Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5644)
Ryan Bernhisel
Review left Sep 18 2024
Review
Super easy, quick and painless! Can't recommend them enough
Super easy, quick and painless! Can't recommend them enough
Alex Omusoru
Review left Sep 18 2024
Shipment processed Sep 05 2024
Review
Overall the process was smooth with the website being clean, simple and easy to use. It was easy to go from estimating my cards into preparing and completing a shipment. With a clear process defined and updates at every stage I felt like I was aware of what was going on the entire time.
The one d ... Read more
The one d ... Read more
Overall the process was smooth with the website being clean, simple and easy to use. It was easy to go from estimating my cards into preparing and completing a shipment. With a clear process defined and updates at every stage I felt like I was aware of what was going on the entire time.
The one downside, or challenge, was that because the process is slow (shipping takes time, processing, grading, etc), it gives the card market a lot of time to shift. And because the CC team doesn’t lock prices upon arrival (or purchase like other buy lists), rather they wait until they finish inventorying, grading, etc, there’s a lot of room for change in your collection value. And for me, it tends to go down most of the time (that’s clearly an anecdotal point but a feeling I wanted to share nonetheless). So the main struggle I had was just the slow process actually affecting the sale value.
The one downside, or challenge, was that because the process is slow (shipping takes time, processing, grading, etc), it gives the card market a lot of time to shift. And because the CC team doesn’t lock prices upon arrival (or purchase like other buy lists), rather they wait until they finish inventorying, grading, etc, there’s a lot of room for change in your collection value. And for me, it tends to go down most of the time (that’s clearly an anecdotal point but a feeling I wanted to share nonetheless). So the main struggle I had was just the slow process actually affecting the sale value.
Chris Giroux
Review left Sep 17 2024
Review
This was my first time using Card Conduit and I was very pleased with the entire process. The process was easy and efficient from start to finish. Card Conduit provided a smooth and seamless system to follow with their shipping directions and up-front advice on how to organize my cards. They were op
...
Read more
This was my first time using Card Conduit and I was very pleased with the entire process. The process was easy and efficient from start to finish. Card Conduit provided a smooth and seamless system to follow with their shipping directions and up-front advice on how to organize my cards. They were open with any delays that they faced, responded quickly when I had any questions, and were very fair and transparent about their payouts. Thanks again for the experience and I would happily use them again in the future!
John B Linton
Review left Sep 17 2024
Review
I was very impressed with the staff and pleased with the result. I will definitely use again. I will also recommend this service to my other magic gamers/collectors. Thank you so much.
I was very impressed with the staff and pleased with the result. I will definitely use again. I will also recommend this service to my other magic gamers/collectors. Thank you so much.
Wrandy Little
Review left Sep 17 2024
Review
It has been a source for helping me sell my cards with a reliable service.
It has been a source for helping me sell my cards with a reliable service.
Jayden
Review left Sep 16 2024
Review
Value was great and came back what I expected. The site's clear instruction helped alot through the process. Will use again.
Value was great and came back what I expected. The site's clear instruction helped alot through the process. Will use again.
Davis
Review left Sep 16 2024
Review
Very communicative, frequent updates and relatively efficient process.
Very communicative, frequent updates and relatively efficient process.
Mike B
Review left Sep 16 2024
Review
Selling these individually on ebay would have taken months and months and these guys had me paid out in less than 2 weeks will little to no work done on my end. They paid a fair price and made my life easy. I had used other companies before I discovered Card Conduit and really wish I would have found them sooner. 5 stars all the way!
Selling these individually on ebay would have taken months and months and these guys had me paid out in less than 2 weeks will little to no work done on my end. They paid a fair price and made my life easy. I had used other companies before I discovered Card Conduit and really wish I would have found them sooner. 5 stars all the way!
Eric
Review left Sep 16 2024
Review
Good value and pain free. I highly recommend sorting the supplement yourself to save money and time.
Good value and pain free. I highly recommend sorting the supplement yourself to save money and time.
Anthony
Review left Sep 16 2024
Review
I have already recommended the service to friends. It was fast and easy, and I got about what I expected money wise.
I have already recommended the service to friends. It was fast and easy, and I got about what I expected money wise.
L1fewater
Review left Sep 16 2024
Review
Card Conduit definitely offers the best bang for your buck for your cards - often, local game stores will give you 50% of the card's worth in cash, or ~60% in store credit. Usually, I'm looking to trade up for certain cards, or make relatively close 1-to-1 trades. Card conduit allows you to get ba
...
Read more
Card Conduit definitely offers the best bang for your buck for your cards - often, local game stores will give you 50% of the card's worth in cash, or ~60% in store credit. Usually, I'm looking to trade up for certain cards, or make relatively close 1-to-1 trades. Card conduit allows you to get back as close as possible to the market price of the value of the card.
The process did take a little long, about 3-4 weeks, and although I probably should've shipped my ~30 card order via a slab in an envelope, I followed the instructions to ship it in a deck box. Because of this, shipping cost was around $18 which did eat away at the overall "profit".
That being said, I will still likely use this service, and will likely elect to send cards via envelope to save on shipping costs.
The process did take a little long, about 3-4 weeks, and although I probably should've shipped my ~30 card order via a slab in an envelope, I followed the instructions to ship it in a deck box. Because of this, shipping cost was around $18 which did eat away at the overall "profit".
That being said, I will still likely use this service, and will likely elect to send cards via envelope to save on shipping costs.
Ed
Review left Sep 15 2024
Shipment processed Sep 05 2024
Review
CardConduit's process is even easier than in the past. They won't take shipments quite as large as before, but their service remains thorough, honest, and truly indispensable for those looking to sell a lot of MTG.
CardConduit's process is even easier than in the past. They won't take shipments quite as large as before, but their service remains thorough, honest, and truly indispensable for those looking to sell a lot of MTG.
Ryan
Review left Sep 15 2024
Review
Made everything super easy and offered the best prices for my cards
Made everything super easy and offered the best prices for my cards
Ian
Review left Sep 15 2024
Shipment processed Aug 07 2024
Review
Fast service helping me offload some cards. Would recommend to anyone in the market for an easy solution to get some money for their cards.
Fast service helping me offload some cards. Would recommend to anyone in the market for an easy solution to get some money for their cards.
Harald
Review left Sep 14 2024
Shipment processed Jun 20 2024
Review
I can highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone who would like to offload their MtG card collection! Nick was great! He answered all of my questions, and helped me to get the most out of my collection.
I can highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone who would like to offload their MtG card collection! Nick was great! He answered all of my questions, and helped me to get the most out of my collection.
Spencer
Review left Sep 14 2024
Review
If you’re looking for an option which is less timely than listing cards individually, card conduit is a great option. Their buy list prices are competitive and they have multiple options for how to process your cards. I’ve sent multiple shipments to them, and they’ve been very communicative throughout each process.
If you’re looking for an option which is less timely than listing cards individually, card conduit is a great option. Their buy list prices are competitive and they have multiple options for how to process your cards. I’ve sent multiple shipments to them, and they’ve been very communicative throughout each process.
Niko Marrocco
Review left Sep 14 2024
Review
Easy to use interface. Quick responses. Replied to my questions with pictures to help me understand.
Easy to use interface. Quick responses. Replied to my questions with pictures to help me understand.
Justin
Review left Sep 14 2024
Review
They provided a simple step-by-step set of instructions to help with the packaging and shipping process and then had my order processed and my direct deposit deposited through the Labor Day weekend, overall a very good experience.
They provided a simple step-by-step set of instructions to help with the packaging and shipping process and then had my order processed and my direct deposit deposited through the Labor Day weekend, overall a very good experience.
Lee S
Review left Sep 13 2024
Review
Ill what I always say, as long as you understand you are selling to a seller that has to make a profit, youll be happy with the outcome. I have yet to have an experience with CC that was a surprise. Honest buyers 100%
Ill what I always say, as long as you understand you are selling to a seller that has to make a profit, youll be happy with the outcome. I have yet to have an experience with CC that was a surprise. Honest buyers 100%
M T
Review left Sep 12 2024
Review
I was pleasantly surprised by Card Conduit. I have never sold Magic cards but have amassed a collection. I mainly played commander. But I had a bit of a collection from Pioneer and Standard. They also helped me with my mistakes in selecting the right set for each card. I was new to that but they wer
...
Read more
I was pleasantly surprised by Card Conduit. I have never sold Magic cards but have amassed a collection. I mainly played commander. But I had a bit of a collection from Pioneer and Standard. They also helped me with my mistakes in selecting the right set for each card. I was new to that but they were extremely accommodating. I would recommend Card Conduit to anyone seeking this kind of service!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).