Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5643)
Isaiah Luck
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
Grateful for a service like this. Its tedious work on their end and gives the consumer great reward. This is a service that I would highly recommend to anyone in the MTG community.
Grateful for a service like this. Its tedious work on their end and gives the consumer great reward. This is a service that I would highly recommend to anyone in the MTG community.
Alex N
Review left Nov 11 2024
Review
I had an abundance of Rare/Mythic Magic cards collected over the years, and a lack of time to individually look up, itemize, and ship each card. Card Conduit made it incredibly easy to sell thousands of these cards. The entire process was transparent, and I was provided with a detailed report of eve
...
Read more
I had an abundance of Rare/Mythic Magic cards collected over the years, and a lack of time to individually look up, itemize, and ship each card. Card Conduit made it incredibly easy to sell thousands of these cards. The entire process was transparent, and I was provided with a detailed report of every card that was processed, alongside the price Card Conduit was buying these cards from me at. I think the fee's charged were well worth the convenience.
JZ
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
I did plenty of research before selling my cards, and made sure to triple check things that I wasn’t sure about. The process was easier than I thought it would be. I had a good idea what I had and honestly had lower expectations for what I would get, but ended up getting pretty good value for wha
...
Read more
I did plenty of research before selling my cards, and made sure to triple check things that I wasn’t sure about. The process was easier than I thought it would be. I had a good idea what I had and honestly had lower expectations for what I would get, but ended up getting pretty good value for what I sent in. Took about 2 1/2 weeks for the payout, which I think was very fast. I took time to de sleeve and put all my cards in a collection tracker because I was curious about the total value, which I think was very worth it. Their estimator was a great tool. Very happy with the experience, honestly I’m not sure how they offer such a great service. Very grateful for them.
Alex Takeda
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
Card Conduit is a great way to sell your cards. Fast, easy, and efficient.
Card Conduit is a great way to sell your cards. Fast, easy, and efficient.
John Young
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
I sent the cards, they sent the money. Communicated every step. Will do business with them again.
I sent the cards, they sent the money. Communicated every step. Will do business with them again.
Alex Ciel Vieira
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
I'd heard a lot of good things, so I gave their service a try. I'm very happy with the outcome, and really enjoy that they have different options for how you'd like to sell. Fair prices, quick turnaround, and outstanding communication. A++++
I'd heard a lot of good things, so I gave their service a try. I'm very happy with the outcome, and really enjoy that they have different options for how you'd like to sell. Fair prices, quick turnaround, and outstanding communication. A++++
Thomas Renfro
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
I highly recommend this service for anything particularly valuable and/or easily accessible (think binders and decks). While I feel I could've gotten more by listing everything myself, but not only the convenience of being able to sort, pack, and ship (especially if you're including other shipments
...
Read more
I highly recommend this service for anything particularly valuable and/or easily accessible (think binders and decks). While I feel I could've gotten more by listing everything myself, but not only the convenience of being able to sort, pack, and ship (especially if you're including other shipments under different services in the same box) more than makes up for the time that would be spent listing and shipping individual cards yourself. The fact that I was personally reached out to by Card Conduit was a nice touch and they really went above and beyond in doing so.
Bryan McKendry
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
Having used Card Conduit with several lots of cards I am beyond pleased with the results. With a sprawling, unorganized collection going back to 1993 I had no idea where to start with moving the cards I no longer played with. Their service is straight forward and as advertised. They took my unsorted
...
Read more
Having used Card Conduit with several lots of cards I am beyond pleased with the results. With a sprawling, unorganized collection going back to 1993 I had no idea where to start with moving the cards I no longer played with. Their service is straight forward and as advertised. They took my unsorted cards and quickly turned them into thousands of dollars, finding a lot of value in items I would have mistook as bulk. I will certainly use them again in the future.
Excellent Service
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
The convenience of being able to simply pack and ship this portion of my collection was very nice, and I didn't have to deal with the headache of listing everything myself. Highly recommend this for anyone looking to offload a large amount of cards in a relatively short time frame.
The convenience of being able to simply pack and ship this portion of my collection was very nice, and I didn't have to deal with the headache of listing everything myself. Highly recommend this for anyone looking to offload a large amount of cards in a relatively short time frame.
Trent
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
Did the Sorted Service and they were quick with the processing and getting the report back to me. They were quick to reach out about any issues and get them all settled. Big Recommend
Did the Sorted Service and they were quick with the processing and getting the report back to me. They were quick to reach out about any issues and get them all settled. Big Recommend
Thomas Alvarez
Review left Nov 10 2024
Review
Took 3 weeks to get a payout on a sorted list of 9 cards. Some of the card value literally was cut in half after evaluations without good reasoning. This was the worst service I could have ever imagined for selling my cards, during my time waiting I went to my local Collectable Corner in Illinois an
...
Read more
Took 3 weeks to get a payout on a sorted list of 9 cards. Some of the card value literally was cut in half after evaluations without good reasoning. This was the worst service I could have ever imagined for selling my cards, during my time waiting I went to my local Collectable Corner in Illinois and sold over 200$ worth of cards (double what I sold to card conduit) and I got my money same day and they were actually valued at MINT! (Unlike you guys who values all my minty cards at Moderate Play which was ridiculous. I can provide video evidence of my card quality prior to sending.) would absolutely never recommend this terrible service to anyone! I love playing with Power so I wanted to support them but never again!
Card Conduit Team
Replied Jan 06 2025
The best advice we can provide to those who are considering the service is to contact us if any of your grading is a surprise. The first we had heard that there was any issue with this shipment was when this review was posted, well past any time where we could provide an explanation for the grades or return any items back. We are always willing to have a discussion to get on the same page, and our goal is to conclude every transaction with expectations met or exceeds.
The best advice we can provide to those who are considering the service is to contact us if any of your grading is a surprise. The first we had heard that there was any issue with this shipment was when this review was posted, well past any time where we could provide an explanation for the grades or return any items back. We are always willing to have a discussion to get on the same page, and our goal is to conclude every transaction with expectations met or exceeds.
John B.
Review left Nov 09 2024
Shipment processed Oct 05 2024
Review
This was super easy! I leveraged using Mana Box, exporting my collection and uploading to Card Conduit. Shipping was super easy, communication with everyone was awesome! Great Service! Will be using again!
This was super easy! I leveraged using Mana Box, exporting my collection and uploading to Card Conduit. Shipping was super easy, communication with everyone was awesome! Great Service! Will be using again!
Tucker OBrien
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
Process was clean and easy. I love not having to figure out who to sell cards to; so I love using using their sorted shipment.
Process was clean and easy. I love not having to figure out who to sell cards to; so I love using using their sorted shipment.
Ryan
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
This was a great experience, again. I have used the service multiple times and never been disappointed.
This was a great experience, again. I have used the service multiple times and never been disappointed.
Alejandro Cuellar
Review left Nov 09 2024
Shipment processed Oct 26 2024
Review
This service is great if you don’t want to deal with the hassle of selling everything yourself. It’s by far the easiest way to sell cards that are between 1-5 dollars.
This service is great if you don’t want to deal with the hassle of selling everything yourself. It’s by far the easiest way to sell cards that are between 1-5 dollars.
Andrew Harmon
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
I've used the service twice already and plan on using again in the near future. I also recommend it to all my magic friends. Easy, fair, and no hassle.
I've used the service twice already and plan on using again in the near future. I also recommend it to all my magic friends. Easy, fair, and no hassle.
Matt
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
Process was simple and straightforward. Fee's are reasonable and the not having to sort, sell, and ship your cards on a platform, is great!
Process was simple and straightforward. Fee's are reasonable and the not having to sort, sell, and ship your cards on a platform, is great!
Ben
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
The process was easy and payment came quickly. I felt like they were very fair about the overall grading of my cards. This is the second time I've used Card Conduit and will use them again in the future!
The process was easy and payment came quickly. I felt like they were very fair about the overall grading of my cards. This is the second time I've used Card Conduit and will use them again in the future!
Clint Fish
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
Overall I think the service was great I sold a larger lot of cards so it took a tad longer than anticipated but it went really smoothly. My only complaint was I think some of the cards received a harsher grade than deserved. I do typically keep my cards in very good condition so that is just my only
...
Read more
Overall I think the service was great I sold a larger lot of cards so it took a tad longer than anticipated but it went really smoothly. My only complaint was I think some of the cards received a harsher grade than deserved. I do typically keep my cards in very good condition so that is just my only reservation. But overall I give the service a great review the value was very much well worth it!
Travis Gossner
Review left Nov 09 2024
Review
I really enjoyed the experience and personal touch that was provided, as someone whose often in the past sold to big name retailers doing most of the leg work sorting, protecting, and packaging cards; this all in one convenient service is all one could ask for. I'll be recommending you guys to any f
...
Read more
I really enjoyed the experience and personal touch that was provided, as someone whose often in the past sold to big name retailers doing most of the leg work sorting, protecting, and packaging cards; this all in one convenient service is all one could ask for. I'll be recommending you guys to any friends selling collections, have never had a better experience selling cards before this, thanks again.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).