Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Chalo
Review left Aug 01 2025
Review
Their process is as easy as it could get, and they keep active communication throughout.
Their process is as easy as it could get, and they keep active communication throughout.
Josh reed
Review left Aug 01 2025
Review
The process was so easy. I’ve been sitting on a mound of cards for years and selling them myself was daunting. Card conduit made the process simple and easy. Their communication was great and payout was fast.
The process was so easy. I’ve been sitting on a mound of cards for years and selling them myself was daunting. Card conduit made the process simple and easy. Their communication was great and payout was fast.
Steven Hill
Review left Jul 31 2025
Review
I worked with Nick to grade and review my shipment. It was a very positive experience and I will do it again if I ever come across a bulk of cards that I’m looking to offload.
I worked with Nick to grade and review my shipment. It was a very positive experience and I will do it again if I ever come across a bulk of cards that I’m looking to offload.
David U
Review left Jul 31 2025
Review
Sent a hefty box of $0.50+ cards and definitely recommend that tier of service. The fees were very fair for the volume of cards I sent and the payout was fast and easy.
Sent a hefty box of $0.50+ cards and definitely recommend that tier of service. The fees were very fair for the volume of cards I sent and the payout was fast and easy.
Beng
Review left Jul 31 2025
Review
The selling process was simple and there was good communication when i had questions.
The selling process was simple and there was good communication when i had questions.
Vince Vaughan
Review left Jul 30 2025
Review
I had a great experience with Card Conduit. First, it felt quick to review my cards. I sent in 4 boxes of cards altogether, and each box was graded and I had money for the cards within two weeks of shipment. Additionally, when i did have a challenge, they listened to my concern and explained why t
...
Read more
I had a great experience with Card Conduit. First, it felt quick to review my cards. I sent in 4 boxes of cards altogether, and each box was graded and I had money for the cards within two weeks of shipment. Additionally, when i did have a challenge, they listened to my concern and explained why they made the decisions they did. In short, I felt like I could trust them. And that is the most important thing when I deal with a partner like this.
Steven A
Review left Jul 30 2025
Review
this is my second time selling through card conduit and once again i could not be happier. the process was simple, the valuation was fair, and the service throughout was excellent.
this is my second time selling through card conduit and once again i could not be happier. the process was simple, the valuation was fair, and the service throughout was excellent.
Ryan Calderone
Review left Jul 30 2025
Review
I am very happy with my experience at card conduit! Customer service is on point: the CC representative responsible for my collection was on point and adjusted my collection to the appropriate type to help me maximize my return. Not every company would do that. Many would choose to benefit company g
...
Read more
I am very happy with my experience at card conduit! Customer service is on point: the CC representative responsible for my collection was on point and adjusted my collection to the appropriate type to help me maximize my return. Not every company would do that. Many would choose to benefit company gains at the expense of the customer.
I am happy with the assessment and value of my collection. The whole process was very easy and payment was quick.
I will recommend!
I am happy with the assessment and value of my collection. The whole process was very easy and payment was quick.
I will recommend!
Jack L
Review left Jul 30 2025
Review
First time using Card Conduit and selling old MTG cards I've had stored for decades. The process was well spelled out and clear form their instructions and I used the Sorted service while uploading a my list exported from an app which showed me which cards would qualify.
Process went smoothly an ... Read more
Process went smoothly an ... Read more
First time using Card Conduit and selling old MTG cards I've had stored for decades. The process was well spelled out and clear form their instructions and I used the Sorted service while uploading a my list exported from an app which showed me which cards would qualify.
Process went smoothly and my estimate post-grading assessment was posted. When I had questions they gave detailed answers and included pictures of the cards in question to support their grading assessments. They gave the option to have the cards returned if the estimate did not meet expectations but I agreed to sell after their fair explanations and answers. Payment was prompt and hassle-free via bank ACH transfer.
Overall a good and convenient service that I would use again.
Process went smoothly and my estimate post-grading assessment was posted. When I had questions they gave detailed answers and included pictures of the cards in question to support their grading assessments. They gave the option to have the cards returned if the estimate did not meet expectations but I agreed to sell after their fair explanations and answers. Payment was prompt and hassle-free via bank ACH transfer.
Overall a good and convenient service that I would use again.
Evan
Review left Jul 30 2025
Review
This was definitely the easiest way I could find to sell my cards that was also reliable and trustworthy. With my first shipment I sent to Card Conduit the cases I sent broke in transit and my cards spilled into the packaging. They sent me multiple pictures to show what they found upon opening and w
...
Read more
This was definitely the easiest way I could find to sell my cards that was also reliable and trustworthy. With my first shipment I sent to Card Conduit the cases I sent broke in transit and my cards spilled into the packaging. They sent me multiple pictures to show what they found upon opening and were very forthcoming with what the potential damage to the cards could be and what it would mean to the overall sell price. They also put the payment on hold until I could look over and verify the prices they graded my cards at. I have been very pleased with my interactions with Card Conduit and will continue to use them for my bulk card selling needs.
Ruth
Review left Jul 29 2025
Review
The process of sending my cards was easy and low hassle.
The process of sending my cards was easy and low hassle.
Nick V.
Review left Jul 28 2025
Review
Easy process, fair grading, fast payment, no complaints!
Easy process, fair grading, fast payment, no complaints!
Phillip Dyer
Review left Jul 28 2025
Review
The service has been good other than every order I put in takes longer than the one before it and now this one and I feel the condition of the cards is a little bias as almost all my cards have NEVER been played. I had a Dark Ritual I only got like $40 for. But we will see going forward I still have A LOT of cards
The service has been good other than every order I put in takes longer than the one before it and now this one and I feel the condition of the cards is a little bias as almost all my cards have NEVER been played. I had a Dark Ritual I only got like $40 for. But we will see going forward I still have A LOT of cards
John W Duell
Review left Jul 27 2025
Review
I really like this service and the folks who work here are also very helpful.
I really like this service and the folks who work here are also very helpful.
Phil L
Review left Jul 27 2025
Review
most efficient way to move cards in mass. Used by our store and myself personally
most efficient way to move cards in mass. Used by our store and myself personally
Casey K
Review left Jul 25 2025
Shipment processed Jul 01 2025
Review
Leaving another incredible review, because its always so easy and I love being able to sort my cards for them. Thank you!
Leaving another incredible review, because its always so easy and I love being able to sort my cards for them. Thank you!
Ben
Review left Jul 25 2025
Review
Could not have been easier. With good explanations for everything
Could not have been easier. With good explanations for everything
J G
Review left Jul 25 2025
Shipment processed Jul 17 2025
Review
Card Conduit is easily the best experience I’ve had selling Magic cards online in all my (long) years. Processing was quick, payout was painless, and they have the best web app in the market to support this. The detailed breakdown of my order was great and the personal email about it was an excellent touch.
Card Conduit is easily the best experience I’ve had selling Magic cards online in all my (long) years. Processing was quick, payout was painless, and they have the best web app in the market to support this. The detailed breakdown of my order was great and the personal email about it was an excellent touch.
Dave S
Review left Jul 25 2025
Review
Fast, easy process. Fair pricing for sure. Communicates well and I love the stats breakdown.
Fast, easy process. Fair pricing for sure. Communicates well and I love the stats breakdown.
Luke
Review left Jul 24 2025
Review
The process was very easy and I commend the CC team as they answered honestly and quickly to questions I had for some of the card prices.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG ... Read more
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG ... Read more
The process was very easy and I commend the CC team as they answered honestly and quickly to questions I had for some of the card prices.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG collection, but still I do believe it was a fair payout and the work I did to package and prepare the collection was nearly nothing.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG collection, but still I do believe it was a fair payout and the work I did to package and prepare the collection was nearly nothing.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).