Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5873)
Eric Sotack
Review left Feb 06 2025
Review
The process was easy to do, it was very easy to export my cards from moxfield into card conduit. Payment was quick upon receiving cards and the fee was very reasonable.
I was a little disappointed with the evaluation of the condition of my cards (most were secret lairs that I had sleeved immediat ... Read more
I was a little disappointed with the evaluation of the condition of my cards (most were secret lairs that I had sleeved immediat ... Read more
The process was easy to do, it was very easy to export my cards from moxfield into card conduit. Payment was quick upon receiving cards and the fee was very reasonable.
I was a little disappointed with the evaluation of the condition of my cards (most were secret lairs that I had sleeved immediately) but I understand that foils are more vulnerable to damage like clouding that can lower their condition.
Overall, I think the payout was a fair amount and I would use the service again!
I was a little disappointed with the evaluation of the condition of my cards (most were secret lairs that I had sleeved immediately) but I understand that foils are more vulnerable to damage like clouding that can lower their condition.
Overall, I think the payout was a fair amount and I would use the service again!
Mike C
Review left Feb 06 2025
Review
Fast and easy processing with no hassle. Good value for the card collection.
Fast and easy processing with no hassle. Good value for the card collection.
Benjamin Welcome
Review left Feb 06 2025
Shipment processed Jan 29 2025
Review
First couple times I sent cards the percentage was closer to 70% of the value. The last couple packages sent best I received was 40% value. Was super upsetting seller 8$ card for 3$ won't be using again
First couple times I sent cards the percentage was closer to 70% of the value. The last couple packages sent best I received was 40% value. Was super upsetting seller 8$ card for 3$ won't be using again
Card Conduit Team
Replied Feb 09 2025
We had reached out for clarification here, but unfortunately had not received a reply yet.
This shipment was over 1500 cards with an assessed value (before our fees) of 62.3% of NM TCGLow. Other recent shipments include one at 69.85% and another at 71%. It isn't clear where the 40% value cited is coming from. We always encourage anyone with questions or concerns to reach out to us - we'd be happy to discuss and get on the same page!
This shipment was over 1500 cards with an assessed value (before our fees) of 62.3% of NM TCGLow. Other recent shipments include one at 69.85% and another at 71%. It isn't clear where the 40% value cited is coming from. We always encourage anyone with questions or concerns to reach out to us - we'd be happy to discuss and get on the same page!
We had reached out for clarification here, but unfortunately had not received a reply yet.
This shipment was over 1500 cards with an assessed value (before our fees) of 62.3% of NM TCGLow. Other recent shipments include one at 69.85% and another at 71%. It isn't clear where the 40% value cited is coming from. We always encourage anyone with questions or concerns to reach out to us - we'd be happy to discuss and get on the same page!
This shipment was over 1500 cards with an assessed value (before our fees) of 62.3% of NM TCGLow. Other recent shipments include one at 69.85% and another at 71%. It isn't clear where the 40% value cited is coming from. We always encourage anyone with questions or concerns to reach out to us - we'd be happy to discuss and get on the same page!
Matthew Ferris
Review left Feb 06 2025
Review
The process was explained very well in the documentation. The web interface is easy to use. After mailing my cards, I received an email explaining how they judged the cards. They even waived some fees without me asking. I received my payment in a timely manner. Card Conduit was professional. This is how business should be done everywhere. Thank you.
The process was explained very well in the documentation. The web interface is easy to use. After mailing my cards, I received an email explaining how they judged the cards. They even waived some fees without me asking. I received my payment in a timely manner. Card Conduit was professional. This is how business should be done everywhere. Thank you.
R.
Review left Feb 05 2025
Shipment processed Jan 22 2025
$153.36
payout, $3.13
fees
Review
Great service all around, I'll definitely be back to sell some more cards!
Great service all around, I'll definitely be back to sell some more cards!
Patrick Kennedy
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
Overall process is pretty straightforward. Look up your cards and see the value. You get more money if you sort them yourself and hand pick your cards out. Send them in and after a while, you’ll get a message saying what they’ve been graded as and how much you should expect. Ratings for cards we
...
Read more
Overall process is pretty straightforward. Look up your cards and see the value. You get more money if you sort them yourself and hand pick your cards out. Send them in and after a while, you’ll get a message saying what they’ve been graded as and how much you should expect. Ratings for cards were about what I would have expected for the ones I have sent in. Have used this company multiple times and I recommend it to others in person
Clay
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
This is my second shipment with Card Conduit and I could not be happier with the results. The process is quick and easy, and they did a wonderful job of providing updates on where my shipment was at in the process. The payout was very close to the estimate I had and seems more than fair. Thanks!
This is my second shipment with Card Conduit and I could not be happier with the results. The process is quick and easy, and they did a wonderful job of providing updates on where my shipment was at in the process. The payout was very close to the estimate I had and seems more than fair. Thanks!
B G
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
Saved so much time! Great experience especially for hard to sort cards
Saved so much time! Great experience especially for hard to sort cards
Stephen
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
I was given an estimate almost exactly where expected
I was given an estimate almost exactly where expected
Stephen
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
Would recommend. Step by step process was easy to handle and shipment handled swiftly. Payment was as fair as you could expect.
Would recommend. Step by step process was easy to handle and shipment handled swiftly. Payment was as fair as you could expect.
Jesse
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
Sold a number of cards I had picked up from packs. Process was super easy, just picked the sets I had cards for and went down the list. 2% processing fee, even less with a discount code, is a bargain for not having to list and sell these all myself.
Sold a number of cards I had picked up from packs. Process was super easy, just picked the sets I had cards for and went down the list. 2% processing fee, even less with a discount code, is a bargain for not having to list and sell these all myself.
Barry Patterson
Review left Feb 04 2025
Review
Being a new client I have made several errors, they simply ask me kindly to correct it and move on. They have always had quick turnaround and pay shortly after. Couldn't ask for anything more.
Being a new client I have made several errors, they simply ask me kindly to correct it and move on. They have always had quick turnaround and pay shortly after. Couldn't ask for anything more.
William Shelton
Review left Feb 04 2025
Shipment processed Feb 01 2025
Review
I've steadily been sending Card Conduit shipments for the past two months, and I've not been disappointed yet! I always feel very taken care of through the entire process. I am looking forward to sending them a larger section of my bulk at the Standard Service to see if that, too, will be a good fit for me.
I've steadily been sending Card Conduit shipments for the past two months, and I've not been disappointed yet! I always feel very taken care of through the entire process. I am looking forward to sending them a larger section of my bulk at the Standard Service to see if that, too, will be a good fit for me.
Will
Review left Feb 04 2025
Shipment processed Jan 20 2025
Review
This service was so easy and effective. The customer service was also impeccable, they even reached out to make sure I was clear on each step of the process and were there for any issues I might have. Would absolutely use again.
This service was so easy and effective. The customer service was also impeccable, they even reached out to make sure I was clear on each step of the process and were there for any issues I might have. Would absolutely use again.
mY1st1
Review left Feb 03 2025
Review
Way better than I expected. Quick, easy, good value, professional, just amazing all around.
Way better than I expected. Quick, easy, good value, professional, just amazing all around.
Maxime
Review left Feb 02 2025
Review
Excellent team, reliable and professional. Much better than buylisting to a single service. Will use them again in the future.
Excellent team, reliable and professional. Much better than buylisting to a single service. Will use them again in the future.
Andrew
Review left Feb 01 2025
Review
I decided to clean out some 10-15 year old MTG cards and found Card Conduit online. The process was easy: I took out most commons, shipped the rest in one package and in a couple of weeks I received the payout. Card Conduit even changed the pricing from standard to curated for me because they saw that the average card value was high enough.
I decided to clean out some 10-15 year old MTG cards and found Card Conduit online. The process was easy: I took out most commons, shipped the rest in one package and in a couple of weeks I received the payout. Card Conduit even changed the pricing from standard to curated for me because they saw that the average card value was high enough.
Michael
Review left Jan 31 2025
Review
I had a 1,400+ collection of MTG cards I lovingly separated by color, made alphabetical, and created an identical list on the TCG app for a workers convenience at my local game store. Priced roughly around $1,500, I was expecting on the lower end for trade in/cash value. 20% or 30% respectively give
...
Read more
I had a 1,400+ collection of MTG cards I lovingly separated by color, made alphabetical, and created an identical list on the TCG app for a workers convenience at my local game store. Priced roughly around $1,500, I was expecting on the lower end for trade in/cash value. 20% or 30% respectively given as it was 70% bulk. Well to my dismay the stores offered me nothing for cash and only $150 store credit... 24hrs of my time spent purely out of kindness for 10% store credit value. Insulting. After feeling like I've been slapped in the face and had my time wasted I decided to look into doing it online. I have never attempted this before so I was a bit hesitant. For a fraction of the cards I was offered almost 4 times what the stores did, in cash! It was quick and easy with minimal waiting. Will be doing again when the boxes start to overrun! 10/10
Pap3rkat
Review left Jan 31 2025
Review
Had a great interaction with Card Conduit! The process was simple and they walk you through each step of the way. Grading was fair and the report at the end was a nice touch. I will definitely be using this site to buy list cards from now on!
Had a great interaction with Card Conduit! The process was simple and they walk you through each step of the way. Grading was fair and the report at the end was a nice touch. I will definitely be using this site to buy list cards from now on!
Ethan
Review left Jan 31 2025
Review
I offloaded 3000+ of bulk several years ago, and I knew after that 100% positive experience I would be using CC again. I opted for an itemized shipment this time to offload some semi-valuables, and CC did not disappoint. Sharing all my order info to help you and your decision to trust CC with your collection.
I offloaded 3000+ of bulk several years ago, and I knew after that 100% positive experience I would be using CC again. I opted for an itemized shipment this time to offload some semi-valuables, and CC did not disappoint. Sharing all my order info to help you and your decision to trust CC with your collection.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).