Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Zachary Lincoln
Review left Oct 17 2022
Review
The overall process was great! I think one thing that happens with Magic players is that they value their cards more than they should be, so even with a promotional code, I received less for my cards than I thought was appropriate for condition. The process for payment, despite sending a small shipm
...
Read more
The overall process was great! I think one thing that happens with Magic players is that they value their cards more than they should be, so even with a promotional code, I received less for my cards than I thought was appropriate for condition. The process for payment, despite sending a small shipment of 9 cards, in an organized fashion, was a bit longer than I anticipated. All that to say their fees were incredibly fair and I had an overall positive experience. I think with the cost of shipping, sending them large collections may lose quite a bit of value, but for small collections I think it's really smooth.
Michael Jardine
Review left Oct 14 2022
Review
Overall pretty good, the UI for sorting could be a bit better I think. Disappointed that my more valuable cards were downgraded to lp but that's really more the fault of wizards foiling process. This is basically the same process as selling to any individual buyer like cardkingdom- at the cost of
...
Read more
Overall pretty good, the UI for sorting could be a bit better I think. Disappointed that my more valuable cards were downgraded to lp but that's really more the fault of wizards foiling process. This is basically the same process as selling to any individual buyer like cardkingdom- at the cost of slightly more time between shipment and payment you get more money
Michael McClaran
Review left Oct 02 2022
Review
I find that cardconduit is a great website when I want to sell cards from my collection. They are a fast easy service. They have great communication and I do like their step by step updates while they are processing. Their payout is fair and arrives in a reasonable fashion. So far they are a good co
...
Read more
I find that cardconduit is a great website when I want to sell cards from my collection. They are a fast easy service. They have great communication and I do like their step by step updates while they are processing. Their payout is fair and arrives in a reasonable fashion. So far they are a good company to work with and I feel they are fair.
However, I have one major complaint. When I send in high value foils and/or high value cards and let me stress to you, when I open these cards…. I have opened a booster pack and immediately put any card I know is worth money into a sleeve and then put it into a binder, I don’t even play with them…. They seem to grade it as “played” to drop the value by half. I’ve had 3 shipments now and it’s been a pattern. I had a foil Ragavan that I opened and they said it was played. Even though it hadn’t been shuffled once. So that’s my only real complaint.
All and all, cardconduit is a good company with good employees that work hard. And I appreciate that they exist and make this easier for anyone trying to sell their cards in an orderly and efficient manner.
I would recommend this service.
However, I have one major complaint. When I send in high value foils and/or high value cards and let me stress to you, when I open these cards…. I have opened a booster pack and immediately put any card I know is worth money into a sleeve and then put it into a binder, I don’t even play with them…. They seem to grade it as “played” to drop the value by half. I’ve had 3 shipments now and it’s been a pattern. I had a foil Ragavan that I opened and they said it was played. Even though it hadn’t been shuffled once. So that’s my only real complaint.
All and all, cardconduit is a good company with good employees that work hard. And I appreciate that they exist and make this easier for anyone trying to sell their cards in an orderly and efficient manner.
I would recommend this service.
Travis Keshav
Review left Sep 28 2022
Review
I liked the process much better than selling things on EBay. It was very easy to create a structured list and to send in the items. However, I had some concerns or surprises with the grading; many cards that I had bought in near-mint condition were graded at lightly-played and moderately-played condition. Overall, I will probably use the service again.
I liked the process much better than selling things on EBay. It was very easy to create a structured list and to send in the items. However, I had some concerns or surprises with the grading; many cards that I had bought in near-mint condition were graded at lightly-played and moderately-played condition. Overall, I will probably use the service again.
Paul J DeMasi
Review left Sep 27 2022
Review
I was nervous sending so much value across country, but they were great about keeping me informed. Their bulk card policy was worded a bit weird but overall they were very transparent about everything. I'd definitely use this again.
I was nervous sending so much value across country, but they were great about keeping me informed. Their bulk card policy was worded a bit weird but overall they were very transparent about everything. I'd definitely use this again.
John Collini
Review left Sep 25 2022
Review
This is a fantastic service if you had lots of mid-tier cards you'd like to unload. The fee just completely outweighs the cost of shipping to many different buylists and he headache of figuring it out. They were speedy considering just how many cards I sent in! I would have liked better explanation
...
Read more
This is a fantastic service if you had lots of mid-tier cards you'd like to unload. The fee just completely outweighs the cost of shipping to many different buylists and he headache of figuring it out. They were speedy considering just how many cards I sent in! I would have liked better explanation for the process of for the different shipment styles. I went through a ton of work organizing my list of cards for sorted, only to discover I need to send in the card in *their* order, which just added way too much work, and I downgraded to curated. Had I known ahead of time, would have done it different. If you know *exactly* how your shipment will work, this is a fantastic service
Daniel
Review left Sep 23 2022
Review
Fair price, simple process. Great way to sell your extra bulk rares
Fair price, simple process. Great way to sell your extra bulk rares
Nathan Bailey
Review left Sep 09 2022
Review
The whole process was quick and easy. Communication with them nice and courteous.
The whole process was quick and easy. Communication with them nice and courteous.
Trevor M
Review left Sep 07 2022
Shipment processed Aug 27 2022
Review
The process was a bit of work but it really did save me a lot of time and that is the reason I used them.
They are a lot tougher on grading than I thought they would be. Many cards were downgraded and from the images I have, they were not that condition. Many I agreed with but there was a section ... Read more
They are a lot tougher on grading than I thought they would be. Many cards were downgraded and from the images I have, they were not that condition. Many I agreed with but there was a section ... Read more
The process was a bit of work but it really did save me a lot of time and that is the reason I used them.
They are a lot tougher on grading than I thought they would be. Many cards were downgraded and from the images I have, they were not that condition. Many I agreed with but there was a section where I questioned their grading. In the end, the payout was a bit lower than I expected (and I considered it low to begin with).
I would recommend if you have reserve list cards to sell them individually and then everything else, send to card conduit.
They are a lot tougher on grading than I thought they would be. Many cards were downgraded and from the images I have, they were not that condition. Many I agreed with but there was a section where I questioned their grading. In the end, the payout was a bit lower than I expected (and I considered it low to begin with).
I would recommend if you have reserve list cards to sell them individually and then everything else, send to card conduit.
Markus
Review left Sep 01 2022
Review
The value I received was fair but it took almost a month before getting payment. I understand there is a reason for it but perhaps they could invest in making the process faster.
The value I received was fair but it took almost a month before getting payment. I understand there is a reason for it but perhaps they could invest in making the process faster.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Sep 02 2022
We do our best to set timing expectations for customers throughout our site; when we won't be able to meet the "norm", we will always let customers know as soon as we are aware. In this case, the Shipment was Mailed on 8/15, arrived to us 8/19, was processed on 8/25, and was paid on 8/28. So, the time between shipment and payment was under two weeks. This falls well within our described timeframes, and should be within expectations for anyone considering the service.
We do our best to set timing expectations for customers throughout our site; when we won't be able to meet the "norm", we will always let customers know as soon as we are aware. In this case, the Shipment was Mailed on 8/15, arrived to us 8/19, was processed on 8/25, and was paid on 8/28. So, the time between shipment and payment was under two weeks. This falls well within our described timeframes, and should be within expectations for anyone considering the service.
Neal D Connolly
Review left Aug 08 2022
Review
I sent a pretty low value collection of cards. Between 10 cents and a dollar. They were able to quickly process a set of about a thousand cards and give me 42 dollars. Which is understandable given the effort of selling.
I sent a pretty low value collection of cards. Between 10 cents and a dollar. They were able to quickly process a set of about a thousand cards and give me 42 dollars. Which is understandable given the effort of selling.
Josh W.
Review left Jul 31 2022
Review
Experience was what I expected, the email conversation went weird but, other than that, all was good.
Experience was what I expected, the email conversation went weird but, other than that, all was good.
Jerry Tilley
Review left Jul 30 2022
Review
I found Card Conduit to be very easy to use and had zero issues with getting the cards shipped to them. I really only had a couple of issues with the service:
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, n ... Read more
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, n ... Read more
I found Card Conduit to be very easy to use and had zero issues with getting the cards shipped to them. I really only had a couple of issues with the service:
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, never used. When they were graded LP I sent an email and received back photos of very faint, very minuscule “scratches” on the surface of the card. So even if a LGS would grade your card NM if you’ve ever touched it, then go ahead and consider it LP for your dollar value.
2) the timeline. One section of the website meticulously lays out the timeline of when everything will happen and culminates in being roughly 10 days. A second section simply says “TL;DR it’ll take about 2 weeks”. My issue here is win some instances we’re talking about large amounts of money; being vague isn’t a quality I like in businesses that I choose to do business with. If you tell me 14 days and it takes 10 then great; if you tell me 10 and it’s take 14 then we have an issue.
But again, overall I had a good experience with them and now that I have this newfound knowledge I’ll be better prepared to deal with them in the future.
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, never used. When they were graded LP I sent an email and received back photos of very faint, very minuscule “scratches” on the surface of the card. So even if a LGS would grade your card NM if you’ve ever touched it, then go ahead and consider it LP for your dollar value.
2) the timeline. One section of the website meticulously lays out the timeline of when everything will happen and culminates in being roughly 10 days. A second section simply says “TL;DR it’ll take about 2 weeks”. My issue here is win some instances we’re talking about large amounts of money; being vague isn’t a quality I like in businesses that I choose to do business with. If you tell me 14 days and it takes 10 then great; if you tell me 10 and it’s take 14 then we have an issue.
But again, overall I had a good experience with them and now that I have this newfound knowledge I’ll be better prepared to deal with them in the future.
Shawn Michael Briggs
Review left Jul 10 2022
Review
I chose the curated option as I only had 100 or so cards to send, it was quite easy to do and I definitely got my money's worth. The only thing that was a minor issue is that it took them a few days to collect my package and during that time Double Masters was being spoiled and quite a few cards I s
...
Read more
I chose the curated option as I only had 100 or so cards to send, it was quite easy to do and I definitely got my money's worth. The only thing that was a minor issue is that it took them a few days to collect my package and during that time Double Masters was being spoiled and quite a few cards I sent in were confirmed for reprints dropping their prices. Otherwise I would definitely use this service again.
Olivier ferlay
Review left Jun 01 2022
Review
The response and explanation was clear and fast and very good follow through . Mostly it was what I was expecting, except for my foreign cards that were taken as bulk but it was mentioned in the small print and did not see it. So mostly personal mistake on my part .
The response and explanation was clear and fast and very good follow through . Mostly it was what I was expecting, except for my foreign cards that were taken as bulk but it was mentioned in the small print and did not see it. So mostly personal mistake on my part .
David
Review left May 23 2022
Review
1st time using card conduit, overall good and easy to use. From TCGplayer app said the value was 2200 and I received 1300 which is not bad. The issue I had is with the grading of the cards. Some of my cars I have never played with or handle a lot and the were graded lightly played or worse.
1st time using card conduit, overall good and easy to use. From TCGplayer app said the value was 2200 and I received 1300 which is not bad. The issue I had is with the grading of the cards. Some of my cars I have never played with or handle a lot and the were graded lightly played or worse.
Boris
Review left May 16 2022
Shipment processed Apr 09 2022
Review
Pros:
Well defined process and helpful FAQs for every step. Good communication along the way. Will do curated shipment again if I ever have more MTG cards to sell.
Con:
Most of the cards in my collection were never played. I mostly collected, building only 2-3 decks from a few sets. Storage con ... Read more
Well defined process and helpful FAQs for every step. Good communication along the way. Will do curated shipment again if I ever have more MTG cards to sell.
Con:
Most of the cards in my collection were never played. I mostly collected, building only 2-3 decks from a few sets. Storage con ... Read more
Pros:
Well defined process and helpful FAQs for every step. Good communication along the way. Will do curated shipment again if I ever have more MTG cards to sell.
Con:
Most of the cards in my collection were never played. I mostly collected, building only 2-3 decks from a few sets. Storage condition were pretty good as well. How did every third card or so ended up knocked down by one or two condition levels is beyond my comprehension. Lowering curated shipment value by 10% from estimates did not upset me very much. After all it was an estimate. But downgrading a lot of cards to "bulk" made the regular shipment almost pointless.
Well defined process and helpful FAQs for every step. Good communication along the way. Will do curated shipment again if I ever have more MTG cards to sell.
Con:
Most of the cards in my collection were never played. I mostly collected, building only 2-3 decks from a few sets. Storage condition were pretty good as well. How did every third card or so ended up knocked down by one or two condition levels is beyond my comprehension. Lowering curated shipment value by 10% from estimates did not upset me very much. After all it was an estimate. But downgrading a lot of cards to "bulk" made the regular shipment almost pointless.
Card Conduit Team
Replied May 16 2022
Sorry you were unhappy with some of our grading. Unfortunately, even cards that have never been played can experience wear and tear, often from shifting around inside sleeves. Even cards from a freshly opened pack can be less than near mint, whether from rough handling in transit or quality issues at wizards. We can only grade according to our vendor partners standards and the condition of the card when it arrives to us.
Sorry you were unhappy with some of our grading. Unfortunately, even cards that have never been played can experience wear and tear, often from shifting around inside sleeves. Even cards from a freshly opened pack can be less than near mint, whether from rough handling in transit or quality issues at wizards. We can only grade according to our vendor partners standards and the condition of the card when it arrives to us.
Cai Paivarinta
Review left May 15 2022
Review
The whole process was very easy and Card Conduit provided good value to me.
The whole process was very easy and Card Conduit provided good value to me.
Alberto Mejias
Review left May 07 2022
Review
Awesome service that provides you with cash for your cards.
Takes a long time though. Another downside is all my foils were rated "Lightly Played" even though they all went straight from pack to sleeves. Probably because of curling but these NM foils came to me like that.
Overall a great service that I would use again, but I wouldnt send foils.
Takes a long time though. Another downside is all my foils were rated "Lightly Played" even though they all went straight from pack to sleeves. Probably because of curling but these NM foils came to me like that.
Overall a great service that I would use again, but I wouldnt send foils.
Awesome service that provides you with cash for your cards.
Takes a long time though. Another downside is all my foils were rated "Lightly Played" even though they all went straight from pack to sleeves. Probably because of curling but these NM foils came to me like that.
Overall a great service that I would use again, but I wouldnt send foils.
Takes a long time though. Another downside is all my foils were rated "Lightly Played" even though they all went straight from pack to sleeves. Probably because of curling but these NM foils came to me like that.
Overall a great service that I would use again, but I wouldnt send foils.
Michael McClaran
Review left Apr 18 2022
Review
I would recommend this service to others. Sometimes it is hard to get rid of bulk cards rare or otherwise and cardconduit makes it simple. So far direct deposit was the way to go in the payment method for me. They sort through cards at a decent rate and they have great communication. Their emails ar
...
Read more
I would recommend this service to others. Sometimes it is hard to get rid of bulk cards rare or otherwise and cardconduit makes it simple. So far direct deposit was the way to go in the payment method for me. They sort through cards at a decent rate and they have great communication. Their emails are timely and their service is awesome.
My only disappointment is this: they don’t always grade cards in fair ways. For example several of my shipments are near mint cards that went straight from a pack into a binder or storage container and never used (and I mean NEVER used). And they would grade them as lightly played or some play.
From a personal standpoint it’s irritating and I feel like I’m missing out on some value, however they seem to be fair on all other things.
So your mileage may vary.
My only disappointment is this: they don’t always grade cards in fair ways. For example several of my shipments are near mint cards that went straight from a pack into a binder or storage container and never used (and I mean NEVER used). And they would grade them as lightly played or some play.
From a personal standpoint it’s irritating and I feel like I’m missing out on some value, however they seem to be fair on all other things.
So your mileage may vary.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Apr 18 2022
It's always disappointing when a customer doesn't have an exemplary experience. That said - most of the markdowns were due to foils, which have been notorious (and well documented) as having very poor quality control and being opened with scratching and clouding straight out of the pack.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
It's always disappointing when a customer doesn't have an exemplary experience. That said - most of the markdowns were due to foils, which have been notorious (and well documented) as having very poor quality control and being opened with scratching and clouding straight out of the pack.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).