Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5873)
Mike deRuiter
Review left Oct 05 2024
Review
Great experience. Easy to input cards, very good feedback on what they saw with the cards fast payment
Great experience. Easy to input cards, very good feedback on what they saw with the cards fast payment
Tony
Review left Oct 05 2024
Review
It was pretty easy and convenient to send the stuff in. The biggest issue was waiting until a standard shipment was available. The wait was also longer than expected and delayed
It was pretty easy and convenient to send the stuff in. The biggest issue was waiting until a standard shipment was available. The wait was also longer than expected and delayed
Rain
Review left Oct 05 2024
Review
I could probably get more per card by selling them individually myself, but there is no guarantee to find a buyer for every card, and the time and energy required makes that whole process a giant headache.
Card Conduit streamlines all of that, and I think that makes it worth it. They reached out ... Read more
Card Conduit streamlines all of that, and I think that makes it worth it. They reached out ... Read more
I could probably get more per card by selling them individually myself, but there is no guarantee to find a buyer for every card, and the time and energy required makes that whole process a giant headache.
Card Conduit streamlines all of that, and I think that makes it worth it. They reached out a couple of times during the process to keep me updated on my status, and answered my questions promptly.
Good value for the service provided, I would recommend them to anyone that wants to sell some cards.
Card Conduit streamlines all of that, and I think that makes it worth it. They reached out a couple of times during the process to keep me updated on my status, and answered my questions promptly.
Good value for the service provided, I would recommend them to anyone that wants to sell some cards.
Sorted shipment
Review left Oct 05 2024
Review
Process was easy. I was a bit hesitant to ship my cards in to an unknown place but they sorted, graded and sent the payout. Only thing is I think a few cards were graded a bit lower than I would have expected. But overall good experience.
Process was easy. I was a bit hesitant to ship my cards in to an unknown place but they sorted, graded and sent the payout. Only thing is I think a few cards were graded a bit lower than I would have expected. But overall good experience.
Travis
Review left Oct 05 2024
Review
Super simple and stress free way to sell cards, with great communication throughout the process. I highly recommend
Super simple and stress free way to sell cards, with great communication throughout the process. I highly recommend
Sylvie Johnson
Review left Oct 05 2024
Review
Always fast, always accurate, always good prices, I never sell anywhere else now.
Always fast, always accurate, always good prices, I never sell anywhere else now.
Brad D.
Review left Oct 05 2024
Shipment processed Sep 24 2024
Review
Easy process, quick turn around. Clear communication and loved how easy it was to check in on the status of the cards I sent in. Awesome experience A+++
Easy process, quick turn around. Clear communication and loved how easy it was to check in on the status of the cards I sent in. Awesome experience A+++
Eric Hattig
Review left Oct 04 2024
Review
The hardest part of the whole process is getting over the fear of sending your collection to people through the mail.
The payout was a bit more than I expected (especially if you factor in personal time on selling cards individually) and the customer service was extremely quick and on point.
I ... Read more
The payout was a bit more than I expected (especially if you factor in personal time on selling cards individually) and the customer service was extremely quick and on point.
I ... Read more
The hardest part of the whole process is getting over the fear of sending your collection to people through the mail.
The payout was a bit more than I expected (especially if you factor in personal time on selling cards individually) and the customer service was extremely quick and on point.
I had asked for an update on payout timeline (I wanted a physical check) at around 7:30 am and one of the staff, Nathaniel, had it tracked and the info back to me within 2 hours (over email, not phone). I wasn’t even expecting a response until that afternoon or later being a holiday weekend.
Absolutely recommended for any sell offs.
The payout was a bit more than I expected (especially if you factor in personal time on selling cards individually) and the customer service was extremely quick and on point.
I had asked for an update on payout timeline (I wanted a physical check) at around 7:30 am and one of the staff, Nathaniel, had it tracked and the info back to me within 2 hours (over email, not phone). I wasn’t even expecting a response until that afternoon or later being a holiday weekend.
Absolutely recommended for any sell offs.
Peter
Review left Oct 04 2024
Review
After doing some searching online for a place to sell some old Magic cards, I opted to go with Card Conduit. I'm very happy I did. I used their Standard Shipment option, but they ended up upgrading me to the Curated Shipment fees based on relatively low volume of cards I sent that were in fairly g
...
Read more
After doing some searching online for a place to sell some old Magic cards, I opted to go with Card Conduit. I'm very happy I did. I used their Standard Shipment option, but they ended up upgrading me to the Curated Shipment fees based on relatively low volume of cards I sent that were in fairly good condition and a little less common. I was very happy with the ease, speed of processing, communication, and payout. I would definitely recommend to others.
Jason StMary
Review left Oct 04 2024
Review
Everything was simple and smooth! Will definitely use this service again
Everything was simple and smooth! Will definitely use this service again
Damion Brown
Review left Oct 04 2024
Review
Easier than I thought it would be to clear out all the MTG cards I just had sitting around.
Easier than I thought it would be to clear out all the MTG cards I just had sitting around.
Daniel Langsdale
Review left Oct 03 2024
Shipment processed Aug 27 2024
Review
I was very pleased with the good level of communication that came from the staff. Both in simple form responses that let me know when cards were received and processed, as well as with prompt and informative answers to more specific questions that I had along the way. When staff illness created a
...
Read more
I was very pleased with the good level of communication that came from the staff. Both in simple form responses that let me know when cards were received and processed, as well as with prompt and informative answers to more specific questions that I had along the way. When staff illness created a delay in processing, I was promptly informed and not left hanging.
The price tools were very helpful in helping me make a decision about how to submit my cards for sale. Taking the time to use them and sort them into three lots really helped to get the most value out of my collection. (One lot for Sorted Service, one for Standard Service, and one for bulk value that ended up being traded to a LGS for store credit) I recommend taking the time to use the tools, they are worth it.
I found the grading of the cards' condition to be strict but fair. Payment was speedy and easy. Overall, a positive experience that I wish was available for other collectible hobbies.
The price tools were very helpful in helping me make a decision about how to submit my cards for sale. Taking the time to use them and sort them into three lots really helped to get the most value out of my collection. (One lot for Sorted Service, one for Standard Service, and one for bulk value that ended up being traded to a LGS for store credit) I recommend taking the time to use the tools, they are worth it.
I found the grading of the cards' condition to be strict but fair. Payment was speedy and easy. Overall, a positive experience that I wish was available for other collectible hobbies.
Eric H
Review left Oct 03 2024
Review
Results were quick, customer service was excellent. Extremely happy with the experience!
Results were quick, customer service was excellent. Extremely happy with the experience!
Eric Holland
Review left Oct 03 2024
Review
good service a little on the slower end of the things but was still great and would use them again
good service a little on the slower end of the things but was still great and would use them again
Sage
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
Had a bunch of cards sitting around and a few that were difficult to sell due to value. Managed to get a fair price with minimal work. Would do again.
Had a bunch of cards sitting around and a few that were difficult to sell due to value. Managed to get a fair price with minimal work. Would do again.
Nicholas Reyes
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
I liked the whole process, very easy. But I would like to know the value of my cards before finalizing everything. I see an estimated total but I got something a lot lower due to conditions of my cards. Or maybe returning cards once I find out the total
I liked the whole process, very easy. But I would like to know the value of my cards before finalizing everything. I see an estimated total but I got something a lot lower due to conditions of my cards. Or maybe returning cards once I find out the total
Patrick Meijer
Review left Oct 02 2024
Shipment processed Sep 14 2024
Review
Highly recommend to avoid all the headache, I did sorted so I knew what kind of payout per card I was getting.
Highly recommend to avoid all the headache, I did sorted so I knew what kind of payout per card I was getting.
David Anderson
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
The turn around time was exactly as quoted, and they were even able to rush a payment so that I could have it before the weekend! They were super quick to respond to any inquiries.
The turn around time was exactly as quoted, and they were even able to rush a payment so that I could have it before the weekend! They were super quick to respond to any inquiries.
Evan
Review left Oct 02 2024
Review
I wasn't sure how exactly to deal with my old collection, so I had put off selling forever. Card Conduit's guidance on how to package up the cards was exceptional. In the end, it turned out I had been too conservative on deciding the service type, so of their own accord, they reclassified me upwards
...
Read more
I wasn't sure how exactly to deal with my old collection, so I had put off selling forever. Card Conduit's guidance on how to package up the cards was exceptional. In the end, it turned out I had been too conservative on deciding the service type, so of their own accord, they reclassified me upwards to the Curated tier. Just a terrific team; would recommend to anyone without hesitation.
Clay
Review left Oct 01 2024
Shipment processed Aug 29 2024
Review
This is a great replacement for the TCGPlayer buy list! And I’m able to sell cards I otherwise would not have been able to sell.
This is a great replacement for the TCGPlayer buy list! And I’m able to sell cards I otherwise would not have been able to sell.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).