Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5644)
Dan
Review left Aug 18 2024
Review
great experience, got me more money for my cards than i could by myself and with less effort on my part. will definitely be selling with them again
great experience, got me more money for my cards than i could by myself and with less effort on my part. will definitely be selling with them again
Amber
Review left Aug 18 2024
Review
I don't have the time to go through my MTG collection anymore so it has been sitting, basically since Markov's wedding. Card conduit saved me a lot of time and effort that I appreciate as a busy bee and a mom. Nick and his team made sure I was in the loop through the process. When I asked questions
...
Read more
I don't have the time to go through my MTG collection anymore so it has been sitting, basically since Markov's wedding. Card conduit saved me a lot of time and effort that I appreciate as a busy bee and a mom. Nick and his team made sure I was in the loop through the process. When I asked questions I got answers and recommendations right away. When there were delays due to COVID I got notified and they followed through with the revised timeframe commitment. Overall this was a great selling service 5/5. I will be using them again.
Garrett Rudolph
Review left Aug 18 2024
Review
The process was clear and easy. They were super helpful and even were flexible when I messed up part of the order instructions. The buy list pricing was really competitive. This was a test to see how the service was and I will 100% sending thousands more cards in. Amazing!!!!
The process was clear and easy. They were super helpful and even were flexible when I messed up part of the order instructions. The buy list pricing was really competitive. This was a test to see how the service was and I will 100% sending thousands more cards in. Amazing!!!!
Kevin
Review left Aug 18 2024
Review
I got a good deal, and it saved me a lot of hassle. I would use this service again.
I got a good deal, and it saved me a lot of hassle. I would use this service again.
Jason
Review left Aug 18 2024
Review
Easy to use website, great communication, will continue to use website in future.
Easy to use website, great communication, will continue to use website in future.
Abbey Smith
Review left Aug 17 2024
Shipment processed Aug 06 2024
Review
Communication was top notch, kept me updated every step of the way!
Communication was top notch, kept me updated every step of the way!
Mike B
Review left Aug 17 2024
Review
The process was extremely straightforward. I appreciated the updates to my shipment throughout the process. I also felt like the value of my collection was fair, and was actually a little surprised. I will definitely recommend this service to friends.
The process was extremely straightforward. I appreciated the updates to my shipment throughout the process. I also felt like the value of my collection was fair, and was actually a little surprised. I will definitely recommend this service to friends.
Ulysses Huichapa
Review left Aug 17 2024
Review
The process was easy and well organized. A pleasure as always!
The process was easy and well organized. A pleasure as always!
Ulysses Huichapa
Review left Aug 17 2024
Review
The process was easy and well organized. It was a pleasure!
The process was easy and well organized. It was a pleasure!
Ulysses Huichapa
Review left Aug 17 2024
Review
The process was easy and well organized. It was a pleasure!
The process was easy and well organized. It was a pleasure!
Mike Dudash
Review left Aug 17 2024
Review
Card Conduit has great people who run a great company. I would not trust ANY other company with my valuable Magic Cards. The process was smooth, fast with great communication and rare personal attention to my cards. Thanks so much for everything to Nathaniel and crew!
Card Conduit has great people who run a great company. I would not trust ANY other company with my valuable Magic Cards. The process was smooth, fast with great communication and rare personal attention to my cards. Thanks so much for everything to Nathaniel and crew!
Brian
Review left Aug 16 2024
Review
I chose to go the 2% route and had to do some work on my own sorting, but it was totally worth it. I got over $2000 from extra copies of cards that had just been sitting around in my collection. I will for sure use them again.
I chose to go the 2% route and had to do some work on my own sorting, but it was totally worth it. I got over $2000 from extra copies of cards that had just been sitting around in my collection. I will for sure use them again.
Ryan
Review left Aug 16 2024
Review
I heard about card conduit online from a creator and I've been playing magic for a long time but less so recently. I decided to use the curated service and it's was pretty easy and smooth. They kept me updated the whole way and I got a fast easy payout!
I heard about card conduit online from a creator and I've been playing magic for a long time but less so recently. I decided to use the curated service and it's was pretty easy and smooth. They kept me updated the whole way and I got a fast easy payout!
Chase B Bahne
Review left Aug 16 2024
Review
Was orphaned after TCGPlayer closed their buylist -- wasn't aware Card Conduit existed until a friend mentioned it. Fantastic service, quick and easy to use/fair and competitive pricing. 100% my new go to for buylisting cards!
Was orphaned after TCGPlayer closed their buylist -- wasn't aware Card Conduit existed until a friend mentioned it. Fantastic service, quick and easy to use/fair and competitive pricing. 100% my new go to for buylisting cards!
Mike
Review left Aug 16 2024
Review
My second shipment. More cards, lower values. A few hundred cards from a single set, half of which had minimal values. Fair payout. One week to grading from mailing, a week after to get check.
I have already sent in my next shipment.
I have already sent in my next shipment.
My second shipment. More cards, lower values. A few hundred cards from a single set, half of which had minimal values. Fair payout. One week to grading from mailing, a week after to get check.
I have already sent in my next shipment.
I have already sent in my next shipment.
Mike
Review left Aug 16 2024
Review
I sorted my cards. They were all from one set and I used the easy checklist on the site to input. Packed up (this was a trial use) so I sent under 100 cards. They were graded, totaled and an email sent seven days after I mailed. I got the first payment within a week after the grading, second two wee
...
Read more
I sorted my cards. They were all from one set and I used the easy checklist on the site to input. Packed up (this was a trial use) so I sent under 100 cards. They were graded, totaled and an email sent seven days after I mailed. I got the first payment within a week after the grading, second two weeks later. Easy! I am selling as I don't want the task to fall on my daughter....and heck, gives me something to do in my retirement.
Malcolm
Review left Aug 15 2024
Review
The process was very easy, and I got my check within 2 weeks of shipment. When I had questions they answered them fast and responsibly. All in all my experience was MAGICal.
The process was very easy, and I got my check within 2 weeks of shipment. When I had questions they answered them fast and responsibly. All in all my experience was MAGICal.
Mike C
Review left Aug 15 2024
Review
Great value and a very easy process. Great communication.
Great value and a very easy process. Great communication.
Jerahmia
Review left Aug 15 2024
Review
Sending the cards in was super easy and I’ve used this service a handful of times now with no regrets. Very involved staff and greatly helpful
Sending the cards in was super easy and I’ve used this service a handful of times now with no regrets. Very involved staff and greatly helpful
Mike Skipper
Review left Aug 15 2024
Review
I always sell my cards with Card Conduit. They are the leader; professional, and responsive. Thanks Card Conduit.
I always sell my cards with Card Conduit. They are the leader; professional, and responsive. Thanks Card Conduit.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).