Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5644)
Jason
Review left Sep 01 2024
Shipment processed Aug 22 2024
Review
I’m a returning user. Always an efficient process.
I’m a returning user. Always an efficient process.
Leo Libigs
Review left Sep 01 2024
Review
Amazing service! Was my first time using an online retailer to buy my cards. Process was super easy and laid out nicely. Would highly recommend to other people!
Amazing service! Was my first time using an online retailer to buy my cards. Process was super easy and laid out nicely. Would highly recommend to other people!
Matthew A Trover
Review left Aug 31 2024
Review
The process was easy and it was great getting all the money for the cards at once the only gripe I have is the rating of the cards. I had several foil cards in the selection that were obviously damaged and were rated as moderately played yet I had cards that went straight from the booster pack to st
...
Read more
The process was easy and it was great getting all the money for the cards at once the only gripe I have is the rating of the cards. I had several foil cards in the selection that were obviously damaged and were rated as moderately played yet I had cards that went straight from the booster pack to storage that had never even been used that were also rated moderately played, so I guess 20 years in storage just equals moderately played.
Dustin
Review left Aug 31 2024
Review
I used the sorted service and got a great value for the cards. The process was easy and the communication for where in the process my cards were was fantastic. The service was prompt and did not take very long to get payment. Would (and have!) recommend to friends for selling bulk cards!
I used the sorted service and got a great value for the cards. The process was easy and the communication for where in the process my cards were was fantastic. The service was prompt and did not take very long to get payment. Would (and have!) recommend to friends for selling bulk cards!
Zach
Review left Aug 31 2024
Shipment processed Jul 27 2024
Review
Curated shipment went well, fees were quite low for this type of transaction, and I received about as much as I would have expected, if not a bit more. Process was easy and smooth from start to finish. Would highly recommend.
Curated shipment went well, fees were quite low for this type of transaction, and I received about as much as I would have expected, if not a bit more. Process was easy and smooth from start to finish. Would highly recommend.
River North
Review left Aug 31 2024
Shipment processed Jul 27 2024
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
Process was great, I misunderstood the point of the service but they were kind enough to let me have a payout for my bulk commons so long as I didn’t repeat the mistake. Very kind people, and my order was handled quite fast for the amount of bulk I had.
Process was great, I misunderstood the point of the service but they were kind enough to let me have a payout for my bulk commons so long as I didn’t repeat the mistake. Very kind people, and my order was handled quite fast for the amount of bulk I had.
Kevin
Review left Aug 30 2024
Shipment processed Aug 20 2024
Review
I choose the sorted service and overall it was easy. The report they gave was detailed and I received my money quickly once the sorting was complete. There was also great communication throughout each step. Thanks.
I choose the sorted service and overall it was easy. The report they gave was detailed and I received my money quickly once the sorting was complete. There was also great communication throughout each step. Thanks.
Dylan
Review left Aug 30 2024
Review
The process was easy, the communication was great, and I got compensated sufficiently for my cards (large order over 2000 cards).
Highly recommended
Highly recommended
The process was easy, the communication was great, and I got compensated sufficiently for my cards (large order over 2000 cards).
Highly recommended
Highly recommended
Patrick cox
Review left Aug 30 2024
Shipment processed Aug 28 2024
Review
Always gives fair amounts for cards in a great time frame
Always gives fair amounts for cards in a great time frame
C West
Review left Aug 30 2024
Shipment processed Aug 24 2024
Review
I'm a frequent a flier at this point. Love this service
I'm a frequent a flier at this point. Love this service
Philip D
Review left Aug 29 2024
Review
While a good portion of my order was older foils, the grades were much harsher than any other buylists I’ve ever used. My payout was nearly half of what I was expecting, when usually grading is only 20% difference. Will definitely not be using again
While a good portion of my order was older foils, the grades were much harsher than any other buylists I’ve ever used. My payout was nearly half of what I was expecting, when usually grading is only 20% difference. Will definitely not be using again
Card Conduit Team
Replied Aug 29 2024
We can definitely understand being frustrated when the grades you receive are not what you were expecting. We must grade the cards in the condition they are received, but are always willing to provide context and support for the grades received - and we encourage you to reach out to us if you are surprised.
Older foils in particular have a high premium for Near Mint because they are much harder to find decades later. We always recommend inspecting cards prior to sending them in - but critically - to do so without sleeves / binder pages that hide certain types of wear (scratching, clouding) very common with foils. This helps prevent surprises when it comes to grades.
If you are concerned about potential grading differences, you can always request that your shipment be held for review - which will allow us to easily provide you more information and context about the grades. Even if you haven't made that request, we will still do our best to provide additional information about grades in order to get on the same page - but you need to reach out to us in order to make that happen.
Older foils in particular have a high premium for Near Mint because they are much harder to find decades later. We always recommend inspecting cards prior to sending them in - but critically - to do so without sleeves / binder pages that hide certain types of wear (scratching, clouding) very common with foils. This helps prevent surprises when it comes to grades.
If you are concerned about potential grading differences, you can always request that your shipment be held for review - which will allow us to easily provide you more information and context about the grades. Even if you haven't made that request, we will still do our best to provide additional information about grades in order to get on the same page - but you need to reach out to us in order to make that happen.
We can definitely understand being frustrated when the grades you receive are not what you were expecting. We must grade the cards in the condition they are received, but are always willing to provide context and support for the grades received - and we encourage you to reach out to us if you are surprised.
Older foils in particular have a high premium for Near Mint because they are much harder to find decades later. We always recommend inspecting cards prior to sending them in - but critically - to do so without sleeves / binder pages that hide certain types of wear (scratching, clouding) very common with foils. This helps prevent surprises when it comes to grades.
If you are concerned about potential grading differences, you can always request that your shipment be held for review - which will allow us to easily provide you more information and context about the grades. Even if you haven't made that request, we will still do our best to provide additional information about grades in order to get on the same page - but you need to reach out to us in order to make that happen.
Older foils in particular have a high premium for Near Mint because they are much harder to find decades later. We always recommend inspecting cards prior to sending them in - but critically - to do so without sleeves / binder pages that hide certain types of wear (scratching, clouding) very common with foils. This helps prevent surprises when it comes to grades.
If you are concerned about potential grading differences, you can always request that your shipment be held for review - which will allow us to easily provide you more information and context about the grades. Even if you haven't made that request, we will still do our best to provide additional information about grades in order to get on the same page - but you need to reach out to us in order to make that happen.
Michael Barile
Review left Aug 29 2024
Review
Much better than TCGplayer! Heard about this service on the MTG Goldfish podcast and it did not disappoint ;-)
Much better than TCGplayer! Heard about this service on the MTG Goldfish podcast and it did not disappoint ;-)
Mat
Review left Aug 29 2024
Review
The whole process was clean, clear, and very well communicated. After shipping the status page kept me updated with each step of progress. And when I had questions I got a friendly answer promptly: it was an excellent experience the whole way through
The whole process was clean, clear, and very well communicated. After shipping the status page kept me updated with each step of progress. And when I had questions I got a friendly answer promptly: it was an excellent experience the whole way through
Andy Saelee
Review left Aug 29 2024
Shipment processed Aug 15 2024
Review
Easy, and convenient. Nick kept in touch via email, letting me know constantly of the process. I really appreciated that, a constant line of communication.
Easy, and convenient. Nick kept in touch via email, letting me know constantly of the process. I really appreciated that, a constant line of communication.
Ulysses Huichapa
Review left Aug 29 2024
Review
Great and speedy service. I highly recommend this service to any player looking to sell their collection or simply just sell for extra cash.
Great and speedy service. I highly recommend this service to any player looking to sell their collection or simply just sell for extra cash.
Ulysses Huichapa
Review left Aug 29 2024
Review
Great and speedy service. I highly recommend this service.
Great and speedy service. I highly recommend this service.
Brendan
Review left Aug 28 2024
Review
I'm a former Modern player and had put off selling my decks and my collection of all the relevant Modern lands (fetchlands, shocklands, etc) from not wanting to deal with the hassle of individual sellers and listings. Card Conduit allowed me to quickly and easily send a pre-sorted shipment for a low
...
Read more
I'm a former Modern player and had put off selling my decks and my collection of all the relevant Modern lands (fetchlands, shocklands, etc) from not wanting to deal with the hassle of individual sellers and listings. Card Conduit allowed me to quickly and easily send a pre-sorted shipment for a low fee (along with a separate non-sorted assortment for a higher, but still low, fee for some other odds and ends) and sell my cards. Not only was the processing fast, but both from updates on the website and a direct follow up email after everything was said and done, communication about every step was fantastic. Highly recommend!
Brendan
Review left Aug 28 2024
Review
I'm a former Modern player and had put off selling my decks and my collection of all the relevant Modern lands (fetchlands, shocklands, etc) from not wanting to deal with the hassle of individual sellers and listings. Card Conduit allowed me to quickly and easily send a pre-sorted shipment for a low
...
Read more
I'm a former Modern player and had put off selling my decks and my collection of all the relevant Modern lands (fetchlands, shocklands, etc) from not wanting to deal with the hassle of individual sellers and listings. Card Conduit allowed me to quickly and easily send a pre-sorted shipment for a low fee (along with a separate non-sorted assortment for a higher, but still low, fee for some other odds and ends) and sell my cards. Not only was the processing fast, but both from updates on the website and a direct follow up email after everything was said and done, communication about every step was fantastic. Highly recommend!
Christopher McGillick
Review left Aug 28 2024
Review
I sent Card Conduit a collection of 400 cards from my binders and turned it into a payout in less than 7 days. There was only one card that was appraised under a value I was ok selling for, And that one card was quickly and safely returned to me. No questions asked. I used the sorted service, And I
...
Read more
I sent Card Conduit a collection of 400 cards from my binders and turned it into a payout in less than 7 days. There was only one card that was appraised under a value I was ok selling for, And that one card was quickly and safely returned to me. No questions asked. I used the sorted service, And I think that time investment on my part was certainly worth it. I'm now extremely curious about sending lower valued cards using the unsorted service, and I look forward to doing business with card conduit again. Fast Shipment processing, fast payout, quick and easy customer service, and I don't have to deal with private selling or buylisting myself. Pretty fair trade-off, I'm glad I found you guys!
Randy K.
Review left Aug 28 2024
Review
Card Conduit handled my shipment expeditiously and kept me updated the entire time. I truly appreciated the follow-up email after their report was delivered explaining the results!
Card Conduit handled my shipment expeditiously and kept me updated the entire time. I truly appreciated the follow-up email after their report was delivered explaining the results!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).