Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5634)
Georgie The Magic Man
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Apr 04 2025
$2,749.29
payout, $144.70
fees
Review
Thank you very much, Card Conduit! This was a very fair transaction, just like the last one.
Thank you very much, Card Conduit! This was a very fair transaction, just like the last one.
Dustyn Pruitt
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Apr 04 2025
Review
I disagree with some quality ratings but everything went well.
I disagree with some quality ratings but everything went well.
Steven Williams
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
If you have a large collection to sell, this is the service to use. The time I saved by being able to send in over 1,300 cards and not needing to sort them was huge. The process is very transparent and has step by step instructions. I highly recommend this to anyone with a large collection they are trying to move.
If you have a large collection to sell, this is the service to use. The time I saved by being able to send in over 1,300 cards and not needing to sort them was huge. The process is very transparent and has step by step instructions. I highly recommend this to anyone with a large collection they are trying to move.
Joe R
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
This was my second time using this awesome service. The team is always communicative and transparent about what to do and at what point of the process they are at. I was nervous to participate initially, but after an excellent first AND second experience, I can confidently say this will be my go to
...
Read more
This was my second time using this awesome service. The team is always communicative and transparent about what to do and at what point of the process they are at. I was nervous to participate initially, but after an excellent first AND second experience, I can confidently say this will be my go to avenue to shed some layers of my never ending stacks of cards. Thank you CardConduit!
Creighton
Review left Apr 04 2025
Shipment processed Mar 26 2025
Review
Exactly as advertised...easy to use and fair payments, delivered fast...everything you want in a card trade
Exactly as advertised...easy to use and fair payments, delivered fast...everything you want in a card trade
Tyler Redding
Review left Apr 04 2025
Review
The process was fairly simple and fast. Stayed in contact throughout each step of the process.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
The process was fairly simple and fast. Stayed in contact throughout each step of the process.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
I was a bit bummed at the card value total. I scanned the collection beforehand to get an idea of what it was worth and it came out quite a bit lower than I anticipated.
Overall, I'd recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to sell in a timely manner.
Reese Irwin
Review left Apr 03 2025
Shipment processed Mar 22 2025
Review
The process was quick and easy, and I feel great about the results.
The process was quick and easy, and I feel great about the results.
Matt
Review left Apr 03 2025
Shipment processed Mar 22 2025
Review
Working through getting rid of my cards as I buy a house. Card Conduit made it as easy as it possibly could be.
Working through getting rid of my cards as I buy a house. Card Conduit made it as easy as it possibly could be.
Hiram Carter
Review left Apr 03 2025
Review
Easy process to ship. Extremely helpful staff. Quick process even with complications.
Easy process to ship. Extremely helpful staff. Quick process even with complications.
Justin
Review left Apr 03 2025
Review
Process is super easy adding cards and seeing prices along with transparency about how much CC takes out of the amounts. fees are super low for the sorted service and i’d highly recommend going through the hassle of sorting your shipment to reduce your fees by a huge margin. Communication was quic
...
Read more
Process is super easy adding cards and seeing prices along with transparency about how much CC takes out of the amounts. fees are super low for the sorted service and i’d highly recommend going through the hassle of sorting your shipment to reduce your fees by a huge margin. Communication was quick and clear after they recieved and reviewed my shipment. Cards i requested returned came back fast and safely packaged. Thanks a ton and i’ll be using you guys again soon
Noah P.
Review left Apr 03 2025
Shipment processed Mar 22 2025
Review
I watched a Jake and Joel video about how to package up my cards and send them away so I did that and Card Conduit finished the rest. I got my cash sooner than expected too. Thank you.
I watched a Jake and Joel video about how to package up my cards and send them away so I did that and Card Conduit finished the rest. I got my cash sooner than expected too. Thank you.
Alex
Review left Apr 03 2025
Shipment processed Mar 25 2025
Review
Always a great experience with CC! Would highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell cards without the hassle of managing everything yourself.
Always a great experience with CC! Would highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell cards without the hassle of managing everything yourself.
Toby Ferguson
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
Very easy process, saved me a lot of time and hassle. Communication was excellent throughout the entire transaction. I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone who is looking to sell cards they no longer want or need.
Very easy process, saved me a lot of time and hassle. Communication was excellent throughout the entire transaction. I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone who is looking to sell cards they no longer want or need.
B H
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
I sold an old stack of slightly valuable cards. The team at CC was quick to review them, kept communication open and clear, and offered me a fair price, which I took. Thanks CC, I'll be doing business with you again.
I sold an old stack of slightly valuable cards. The team at CC was quick to review them, kept communication open and clear, and offered me a fair price, which I took. Thanks CC, I'll be doing business with you again.
Anonymous
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
Process was very easy, infinitely easier than doing the buylisting myself. Cards definitely got marked down more than I would have liked but I think their grading assessment was honest. It is really just a wake up call that sellers like TCGPlayer have much more leeway and don't stick to their own gu
...
Read more
Process was very easy, infinitely easier than doing the buylisting myself. Cards definitely got marked down more than I would have liked but I think their grading assessment was honest. It is really just a wake up call that sellers like TCGPlayer have much more leeway and don't stick to their own guidelines around conditions. If you can stomach that reality I would definitely recommend Card Conduit.
Jesus Diaz Jr
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
I sent my entire binder that I have had for years now with the intention of using these cards to bling out my favorite and first commander deck. I sent the cards and they looked over what the conditions were and agreed to pay me in little less then 1.5 weeks.
I sent my entire binder that I have had for years now with the intention of using these cards to bling out my favorite and first commander deck. I sent the cards and they looked over what the conditions were and agreed to pay me in little less then 1.5 weeks.
Alex Dyvad
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
Easy, quick, convenient, reliable, and a better payout than any other bulk buyer I've seen
Easy, quick, convenient, reliable, and a better payout than any other bulk buyer I've seen
Sam
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
Very easy process, and I honestly had low expectations. I expected hassles and lowball offers. Even a small chance of rug pull. Instead I got prompt service, solid quote, and quick payout. This is a service I have been wanting for years. Good job CC.
Very easy process, and I honestly had low expectations. I expected hassles and lowball offers. Even a small chance of rug pull. Instead I got prompt service, solid quote, and quick payout. This is a service I have been wanting for years. Good job CC.
Michael S Bliss
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
Always the best place to unload MTG Very good Pricing Always Pays What they Quote
Always the best place to unload MTG Very good Pricing Always Pays What they Quote
Cardboard Odysseys
Review left Apr 02 2025
Review
I highly recommend using their tool to look up each individual card because some cards buy prices are extremely low and some are quite good. I would highly advise against just sending in your cards without curating a list. Do the extra work. I got about 73% of what i would have gotten if i were to s
...
Read more
I highly recommend using their tool to look up each individual card because some cards buy prices are extremely low and some are quite good. I would highly advise against just sending in your cards without curating a list. Do the extra work. I got about 73% of what i would have gotten if i were to sell on TCG for the low price at NM value. Of my 361 cards i sent in, they marked 53 LP, 38 MP, 6 HP. I recorded the grades id give each card and they doubled the LP i had recorded quadrupled the number of MP cards. The number of HP cards were accurate but the cards they said were HP were not the ones i had. At the end of the day im overall happy with the service. After seller fees and mailing everything individually and all the time/postage it takes to ship 361 cards this is a killer deal even at lower grading.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).