Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Logan
Review left Apr 18 2022
Review
Got great value for all my cards. Best prices I have seen for buylisting especially for cash. Customer service was responsive and answered all my questions really quickly.
Got great value for all my cards. Best prices I have seen for buylisting especially for cash. Customer service was responsive and answered all my questions really quickly.
Michael McClaran
Review left Apr 18 2022
Review
I would recommend this service to others. Sometimes it is hard to get rid of bulk cards rare or otherwise and cardconduit makes it simple. So far direct deposit was the way to go in the payment method for me. They sort through cards at a decent rate and they have great communication. Their emails ar
...
Read more
I would recommend this service to others. Sometimes it is hard to get rid of bulk cards rare or otherwise and cardconduit makes it simple. So far direct deposit was the way to go in the payment method for me. They sort through cards at a decent rate and they have great communication. Their emails are timely and their service is awesome.
My only disappointment is this: they don’t always grade cards in fair ways. For example several of my shipments are near mint cards that went straight from a pack into a binder or storage container and never used (and I mean NEVER used). And they would grade them as lightly played or some play.
From a personal standpoint it’s irritating and I feel like I’m missing out on some value, however they seem to be fair on all other things.
So your mileage may vary.
My only disappointment is this: they don’t always grade cards in fair ways. For example several of my shipments are near mint cards that went straight from a pack into a binder or storage container and never used (and I mean NEVER used). And they would grade them as lightly played or some play.
From a personal standpoint it’s irritating and I feel like I’m missing out on some value, however they seem to be fair on all other things.
So your mileage may vary.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Apr 18 2022
It's always disappointing when a customer doesn't have an exemplary experience. That said - most of the markdowns were due to foils, which have been notorious (and well documented) as having very poor quality control and being opened with scratching and clouding straight out of the pack.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
It's always disappointing when a customer doesn't have an exemplary experience. That said - most of the markdowns were due to foils, which have been notorious (and well documented) as having very poor quality control and being opened with scratching and clouding straight out of the pack.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
That said, we can only grade per our vendors grading criteria and some of them certainly have more stringent standards than others, but also have higher values for that strict condition criteria.
However, ultimately the value-loss on this shipment from downgrades was 4% due to how our system optimizes shipments/conditions, so our first concern was optimizing the most value regardless of how that worked out with the condition, as long as it aligned with our vendors criteria.
Dorian Hutchison
Review left Apr 17 2022
Review
Was a little nervous about sending a collection out, however Card Conduit was clear about when they receive, processed, and finished assessment of my cards.
Was a little nervous about sending a collection out, however Card Conduit was clear about when they receive, processed, and finished assessment of my cards.
Scotch
Review left Apr 17 2022
Review
I was happy with the quality of the service and the timeframe. Would use again.
I was happy with the quality of the service and the timeframe. Would use again.
David Britt
Review left Apr 16 2022
Shipment processed Apr 05 2022
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
The process was easy enough to complete. The person I was in contact with was super helpful and worked with me on the order. I would recommend this service to any of my friends.
The process was easy enough to complete. The person I was in contact with was super helpful and worked with me on the order. I would recommend this service to any of my friends.
Billy
Review left Apr 16 2022
Review
This service is great. Sold 10+ years worth of a stagnating collection with zero hassle on my end. Fair pricing, too, with no surprises in the final payout amount.
This service is great. Sold 10+ years worth of a stagnating collection with zero hassle on my end. Fair pricing, too, with no surprises in the final payout amount.
Matthew Owen
Review left Apr 12 2022
Review
A convenient, streamlined way to get rid of your collection at an acceptable price.
A convenient, streamlined way to get rid of your collection at an acceptable price.
Jake O
Review left Apr 12 2022
Review
Simple process with timely updates and a solid payout compared to expectations. Always my go to website for selling cards!
Simple process with timely updates and a solid payout compared to expectations. Always my go to website for selling cards!
Samuel Frost
Review left Apr 12 2022
Review
I used to sell my cards on ebay, but card conduit was so easy and transparent that after this, I'm puling the rest off ebay to sell with them
I used to sell my cards on ebay, but card conduit was so easy and transparent that after this, I'm puling the rest off ebay to sell with them
Jacob
Review left Apr 12 2022
Review
Everything went extremely smoothly. Would definitely recommend.
Everything went extremely smoothly. Would definitely recommend.
Kyle
Review left Apr 11 2022
Review
This was incredibly easy, I just shipped about 150 cards that I thought were valued at $4 or more. Card Conduit did all the busy work and made me cash. It was fast better than piecing it out and buy listing it all! 10/10 would recommend.
This was incredibly easy, I just shipped about 150 cards that I thought were valued at $4 or more. Card Conduit did all the busy work and made me cash. It was fast better than piecing it out and buy listing it all! 10/10 would recommend.
Kendell Clarke
Review left Apr 09 2022
Review
I sent in my order with little hassle, the process was made very simple and I got way more value then I was thought I’d get out of my cards as well!
I sent in my order with little hassle, the process was made very simple and I got way more value then I was thought I’d get out of my cards as well!
Spencer Wartner
Review left Apr 09 2022
Review
Easy to use. Just took out the basic lands and sent in everything else. Received about $100 more than I was expecting.
Easy to use. Just took out the basic lands and sent in everything else. Received about $100 more than I was expecting.
Anonymous
Review left Apr 09 2022
Review
The process was smooth and, they kept me aware of the whole process.
The process was smooth and, they kept me aware of the whole process.
Timothy Downing
Review left Apr 09 2022
Shipment processed Mar 26 2022
Review
Very simple process and will absolutely be using this service again as well as recommending it to anyone I know looking to sell their collection or cards.
Very simple process and will absolutely be using this service again as well as recommending it to anyone I know looking to sell their collection or cards.
Adam
Review left Apr 06 2022
Review
During previous shipments with CC I was unfortunately at the whim of the postal service for the worst. Unprompted, my receiving technician reached out to suggest best courses of action, took time out of his day to call me and have a conversation about what happened and what could happen with this sh
...
Read more
During previous shipments with CC I was unfortunately at the whim of the postal service for the worst. Unprompted, my receiving technician reached out to suggest best courses of action, took time out of his day to call me and have a conversation about what happened and what could happen with this shipment, and even adjusted my shipment options to give me a better return at the end. These selfless actions gave me sky high expectations for all interactions going forward. On this shipment, while I was not unfortunate enough to have issues like I did previously, they decided to combine both simultaneous shipments' payments into one, while also notifying me of it before doing this, thereby giving me peace of mind of not losing a transaction and making my books that much cleaner. I will never not advocate for CC and their customer service.
Adam
Review left Apr 06 2022
Review
During previous shipments with CC I was unfortunately at the whim of the postal service for the worst. Unprompted, my receiving technician reached out to suggest best courses of action, took time out of his day to call me and have a conversation about what happened and what could happen with this sh
...
Read more
During previous shipments with CC I was unfortunately at the whim of the postal service for the worst. Unprompted, my receiving technician reached out to suggest best courses of action, took time out of his day to call me and have a conversation about what happened and what could happen with this shipment, and even adjusted my shipment options to give me a better return at the end. These selfless actions gave me sky high expectations for all interactions going forward. On this shipment, while I was not unfortunate enough to have issues like I did previously, they decided to combine both simultaneous shipments' payments into one, while also notifying me of it before doing this, thereby giving me peace of mind of not losing a transaction and making my books that much cleaner. I will never not advocate for CC and their customer service.
alexander fellers
Review left Apr 06 2022
Shipment processed Mar 25 2022
Review
selling my unused cards could not have been easier. the grading and payout was fair, the fees were minimal and my personal interactions with the team were stellar. very pleased with my experience and I would absolutely recommend cardconduit to anyone that needs cards gone and cash fast.
selling my unused cards could not have been easier. the grading and payout was fair, the fees were minimal and my personal interactions with the team were stellar. very pleased with my experience and I would absolutely recommend cardconduit to anyone that needs cards gone and cash fast.
Brandin Lawson
Review left Apr 06 2022
Review
They kept me informed at every step and even sent me photos of my package's arrival after I asked for them. All in all, I would use them again.
They kept me informed at every step and even sent me photos of my package's arrival after I asked for them. All in all, I would use them again.
Max
Review left Apr 05 2022
Review
I have sent cards to Card Conduit multiple times and each time I have been very satisfied with the process. Shipment is easy, processing times are quick, and their payouts are fair. You send a stack of cards, they send you cash. Easy as that.
I have sent cards to Card Conduit multiple times and each time I have been very satisfied with the process. Shipment is easy, processing times are quick, and their payouts are fair. You send a stack of cards, they send you cash. Easy as that.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).