Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5861)
Cody
Review left Aug 16 2022
Review
I'm not a fan of throwing out cards when I can, and for me this was a great way to make sure that the cards get back into circulation, even if they aren't all that valuable. Pretty easy to put together and send off!
I'm not a fan of throwing out cards when I can, and for me this was a great way to make sure that the cards get back into circulation, even if they aren't all that valuable. Pretty easy to put together and send off!
Cody King
Review left Aug 16 2022
Shipment processed Aug 12 2022
Review
Have already recommended. Much better than Kingdom.
Have already recommended. Much better than Kingdom.
John
Review left Aug 16 2022
Review
I am happy for they're service, but I had multiple people wanting just a couple of the cards for far more than what they gave me. This makes it easy but I would try another way next time.
I am happy for they're service, but I had multiple people wanting just a couple of the cards for far more than what they gave me. This makes it easy but I would try another way next time.
Jordan Fairburn
Review left Aug 16 2022
Review
Process was super easy, grading is a bit lower than I expected but seems to be par for the course these days for any purchasing site. Staff worked with me and kept me in the loop, so great service there. Will probably sell to again.
Process was super easy, grading is a bit lower than I expected but seems to be par for the course these days for any purchasing site. Staff worked with me and kept me in the loop, so great service there. Will probably sell to again.
Dave W
Review left Aug 16 2022
Review
Having not played Magic for the better part of 2 decades, I got boxes of cards when my parents moved. CardConduit was a simple way for someone out of the game to easily, and securely, sell old cards. I would highly recommend this group for those unable/unwilling/uneducated to re-immerse themselves w
...
Read more
Having not played Magic for the better part of 2 decades, I got boxes of cards when my parents moved. CardConduit was a simple way for someone out of the game to easily, and securely, sell old cards. I would highly recommend this group for those unable/unwilling/uneducated to re-immerse themselves with all the various places to sell cards.
Thanks for the great service!
Thanks for the great service!
Landon
Review left Aug 16 2022
Shipment processed Aug 05 2022
Review
Easy, would recommend to anyone looking to offload their cards. Hassle free
Easy, would recommend to anyone looking to offload their cards. Hassle free
Nic
Review left Aug 16 2022
Review
By far the best experience I’ve had selling cards. Fast, Easy and good communication.
By far the best experience I’ve had selling cards. Fast, Easy and good communication.
Tobias Warner
Review left Aug 15 2022
Review
This could not have gone better, thank you to everyone over at CardConduit!!
This could not have gone better, thank you to everyone over at CardConduit!!
Kurt B
Review left Aug 15 2022
Shipment processed Aug 08 2022
Review
Not only was the process easy, but I was able to get a great price for my cards! The service was great and was updated constantly on the process! Would absolutely recommend if you are looking to sell higher-end sorted cards!
Not only was the process easy, but I was able to get a great price for my cards! The service was great and was updated constantly on the process! Would absolutely recommend if you are looking to sell higher-end sorted cards!
Terry Shafer
Review left Aug 14 2022
Shipment processed Aug 03 2022
Review
Had a great experience with this company. Good communication and quick service. Thanks, definitely recommend.
Had a great experience with this company. Good communication and quick service. Thanks, definitely recommend.
Aaron Little
Review left Aug 14 2022
Shipment processed Aug 03 2022
$457.67
payout, $9.34
fees
Review
The process was easy, the fees were reasonable, and the processing didn’t take long at all. 10/10 recommend. Easiest way to move some of your collection and get a fair value.
The process was easy, the fees were reasonable, and the processing didn’t take long at all. 10/10 recommend. Easiest way to move some of your collection and get a fair value.
Eric
Review left Aug 14 2022
Review
I send in shipments fairly regularly. One of the few times I got more than anticipated. Awesome!
I send in shipments fairly regularly. One of the few times I got more than anticipated. Awesome!
Eric
Review left Aug 14 2022
Review
Super easy, very consistent processing times, reliable. Recommended
Super easy, very consistent processing times, reliable. Recommended
Mac
Review left Aug 12 2022
Review
Went with 1 sorted shipment for the highlights of my collection, and a second standard shipment for the remaining fat I was looking to trim from my collection. The grading process was pretty quick, payout was surprisingly high. Ran into a payment issue totally beyond the control of CC themselves, an
...
Read more
Went with 1 sorted shipment for the highlights of my collection, and a second standard shipment for the remaining fat I was looking to trim from my collection. The grading process was pretty quick, payout was surprisingly high. Ran into a payment issue totally beyond the control of CC themselves, and it was handled in a quickly and with care. I'd use this service again even if the staff wasn't professional and attentive, but it certainly helps that they are.
Juan A
Review left Aug 11 2022
Review
I loved working with these folks! Very simple and easy process. The communication was great and transparent. Would highly recommend.
I loved working with these folks! Very simple and easy process. The communication was great and transparent. Would highly recommend.
Carter
Review left Aug 10 2022
Review
I mailed in my cards and the process was easy. They also helped me avoid some fees by changing my request.
I mailed in my cards and the process was easy. They also helped me avoid some fees by changing my request.
Howie P.
Review left Aug 10 2022
Review
The process was super easy, I went with the curated sorted option. Submitted my list to card conduit. Followed the list, sorted my cards by that list and sent them off. Super easy honestly. Great way to sell, they gave better rates then local card shops as well.
The process was super easy, I went with the curated sorted option. Submitted my list to card conduit. Followed the list, sorted my cards by that list and sent them off. Super easy honestly. Great way to sell, they gave better rates then local card shops as well.
Jack Carlson
Review left Aug 10 2022
Review
Super easy, built in price checker is good feature
Super easy, built in price checker is good feature
Mark McCormick
Review left Aug 09 2022
Review
The process couldn't have been more simply and I was treated fairly with great communication throughout. Got cash sent directly to my bank account. A perfect way to turn cards into cash!
The process couldn't have been more simply and I was treated fairly with great communication throughout. Got cash sent directly to my bank account. A perfect way to turn cards into cash!
Robert Winship
Review left Aug 09 2022
Review
This is the second time I've sent cards to Card Conduit. This time I sent two shipments in one package. The first was curated and sorted (2% fee) and the second was unsorted. I love the interface of the website, especially being able to easily search the buylist price. Additionally, I really appreci
...
Read more
This is the second time I've sent cards to Card Conduit. This time I sent two shipments in one package. The first was curated and sorted (2% fee) and the second was unsorted. I love the interface of the website, especially being able to easily search the buylist price. Additionally, I really appreciate the full breakdown of shipment and processing that CC makes available. The only reason I would sell elsewhere (e.g. local game store) would really only be for quick cash. Otherwise, CC is my hands-down pick for selling Magic cards
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).