Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Miguel
Review left Aug 05 2022
Shipment processed Jul 01 2022
Review
It was super easy to package all my cards and ship them out. I didn't have to worry about sorting or anything, and I got a report via email that explained everything. Very easy to do business with
It was super easy to package all my cards and ship them out. I didn't have to worry about sorting or anything, and I got a report via email that explained everything. Very easy to do business with
Nicodemic
Review left Aug 05 2022
Review
I couldn't be more satisfied with the service. Everything is A+. Process, communication, payment. 100% recommended. I am in fact sending another package in the following days of this review. Thank you Card Conduit!
I couldn't be more satisfied with the service. Everything is A+. Process, communication, payment. 100% recommended. I am in fact sending another package in the following days of this review. Thank you Card Conduit!
PwnguinMage
Review left Aug 05 2022
Review
I heard about card conduit through the repeated mentionings of it on MTG Goldfish's podcasts and the like, and I decided to give it a go. I had a bunch of rares just laying around from 15+ years of playing that I would never find room for in my commanders decks (and... greedily took apart a few of m
...
Read more
I heard about card conduit through the repeated mentionings of it on MTG Goldfish's podcasts and the like, and I decided to give it a go. I had a bunch of rares just laying around from 15+ years of playing that I would never find room for in my commanders decks (and... greedily took apart a few of my pricy decks I hated playing because they where to strong) and sent them in. The service was excellent, the personal emails I got about my shipment, how they could make things easier, how they explained the hold I could see on paypal for some days was also very welcome. I would very much recommend this service to others, I even sent in more tradable rares once I found out how amazing this was and they should be processed shortly. A very great experience, and yah 5/5 would recommend to others (and have). Only having to unsleeve my bulk rares and ship them in unorganized was very helpful, as I had way to many for me to rare to sort. I am trying the curated shipment next time as well :).
Brandon Martinez
Review left Aug 05 2022
Review
Super easy, Very nice people, totally chill. These guys are killing it every day. I'm recommending this service to everyone at my LGS!
You guys rock!
You guys rock!
Super easy, Very nice people, totally chill. These guys are killing it every day. I'm recommending this service to everyone at my LGS!
You guys rock!
You guys rock!
Adam
Review left Aug 02 2022
Shipment processed Jul 22 2022
Review
Process was easy but value for the cards was a bit misleading. I received about half of the amount I expected from my 3k card lot selling it in bulk. In hindsight I should have sold my valuable cards separately and sent the others in. 5/10
Process was easy but value for the cards was a bit misleading. I received about half of the amount I expected from my 3k card lot selling it in bulk. In hindsight I should have sold my valuable cards separately and sent the others in. 5/10
Josh
Review left Aug 02 2022
Review
Overall the process was very easy. I did two separate shipments; one unsorted and the other sorted. Payout was what I was expecting.
On my sorted and most valuable card shipment, I was slightly disappointed in the condition grading though. Some were graded as MP yet never left a sleeve or even sto ... Read more
On my sorted and most valuable card shipment, I was slightly disappointed in the condition grading though. Some were graded as MP yet never left a sleeve or even sto ... Read more
Overall the process was very easy. I did two separate shipments; one unsorted and the other sorted. Payout was what I was expecting.
On my sorted and most valuable card shipment, I was slightly disappointed in the condition grading though. Some were graded as MP yet never left a sleeve or even storage box and should’ve been scored as LP.
Regardless, I would still recommend to a friend since everything was fairly easy to handle.
On my sorted and most valuable card shipment, I was slightly disappointed in the condition grading though. Some were graded as MP yet never left a sleeve or even storage box and should’ve been scored as LP.
Regardless, I would still recommend to a friend since everything was fairly easy to handle.
Steve
Review left Aug 02 2022
Review
I shipped them a box of rares I had laying around that I hadn’t even looked at… then they sent me a check and a Full breakdown of the cards I sent and how much they gave me for them!? Hands down the easiest way to make some space and turn unused cards in more cash… which I can spend on more cards I guess?
I shipped them a box of rares I had laying around that I hadn’t even looked at… then they sent me a check and a Full breakdown of the cards I sent and how much they gave me for them!? Hands down the easiest way to make some space and turn unused cards in more cash… which I can spend on more cards I guess?
Keith
Review left Aug 02 2022
Review
I did the thing you’re not supposed to do, which is sort the cards beforehand. It took a few weeks, but actually shipping out the finished product and getting paid a little was _very_ easy. Card Conduit does what it says on the tin.
I did the thing you’re not supposed to do, which is sort the cards beforehand. It took a few weeks, but actually shipping out the finished product and getting paid a little was _very_ easy. Card Conduit does what it says on the tin.
Bryan Evans
Review left Aug 02 2022
Review
I thought the process was extremely smooth and I the value was fair. Being able to compare values ahead of time to understand my expectations of what I would be paid to help myself make selling decisions was a great addition. I love this service for being able to trade in the valuable cards I no lon
...
Read more
I thought the process was extremely smooth and I the value was fair. Being able to compare values ahead of time to understand my expectations of what I would be paid to help myself make selling decisions was a great addition. I love this service for being able to trade in the valuable cards I no longer wanted and would recommend this to anyone looking to part with some cards of value.
Paul B
Review left Aug 01 2022
Review
Very easy to follow instructions and getting shipment ready to mail out. I was very nervous about mailing/selling cards but C.C. Was great, excellent communication for every step!
Very easy to follow instructions and getting shipment ready to mail out. I was very nervous about mailing/selling cards but C.C. Was great, excellent communication for every step!
Cameron
Review left Aug 01 2022
Review
Moving a big chunk of my collection was always a daunting thought but Card Conduit made it a breeze. The whole process from start to finish was simple. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. My total value payout was much larger than I expected, the grading is done very fairly in my opinion.
...
Read more
Moving a big chunk of my collection was always a daunting thought but Card Conduit made it a breeze. The whole process from start to finish was simple. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. My total value payout was much larger than I expected, the grading is done very fairly in my opinion. I would recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to sell a big collection in the easiest way possible but also at the best value.
Jason
Review left Jul 31 2022
Shipment processed Jul 27 2022
Review
Secured me close to what I would have made selling singles on other platforms, only Card Conduit did all the work for me. Highly recommended!
Secured me close to what I would have made selling singles on other platforms, only Card Conduit did all the work for me. Highly recommended!
Alex Jenkins
Review left Jul 31 2022
Review
This was the easiest way of selling out of my collection. They took great care of it and graded them correctly! 10/10 would recommend. They stayed in contact with me thr entire time.
This was the easiest way of selling out of my collection. They took great care of it and graded them correctly! 10/10 would recommend. They stayed in contact with me thr entire time.
Josh W.
Review left Jul 31 2022
Review
Experience was what I expected, the email conversation went weird but, other than that, all was good.
Experience was what I expected, the email conversation went weird but, other than that, all was good.
Jerry Tilley
Review left Jul 30 2022
Review
I found Card Conduit to be very easy to use and had zero issues with getting the cards shipped to them. I really only had a couple of issues with the service:
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, n ... Read more
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, n ... Read more
I found Card Conduit to be very easy to use and had zero issues with getting the cards shipped to them. I really only had a couple of issues with the service:
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, never used. When they were graded LP I sent an email and received back photos of very faint, very minuscule “scratches” on the surface of the card. So even if a LGS would grade your card NM if you’ve ever touched it, then go ahead and consider it LP for your dollar value.
2) the timeline. One section of the website meticulously lays out the timeline of when everything will happen and culminates in being roughly 10 days. A second section simply says “TL;DR it’ll take about 2 weeks”. My issue here is win some instances we’re talking about large amounts of money; being vague isn’t a quality I like in businesses that I choose to do business with. If you tell me 14 days and it takes 10 then great; if you tell me 10 and it’s take 14 then we have an issue.
But again, overall I had a good experience with them and now that I have this newfound knowledge I’ll be better prepared to deal with them in the future.
1) they’re incredibly anal. I had a couple of cards that I took directly out of a pack and moved directly into a sleeve; never played, never used. When they were graded LP I sent an email and received back photos of very faint, very minuscule “scratches” on the surface of the card. So even if a LGS would grade your card NM if you’ve ever touched it, then go ahead and consider it LP for your dollar value.
2) the timeline. One section of the website meticulously lays out the timeline of when everything will happen and culminates in being roughly 10 days. A second section simply says “TL;DR it’ll take about 2 weeks”. My issue here is win some instances we’re talking about large amounts of money; being vague isn’t a quality I like in businesses that I choose to do business with. If you tell me 14 days and it takes 10 then great; if you tell me 10 and it’s take 14 then we have an issue.
But again, overall I had a good experience with them and now that I have this newfound knowledge I’ll be better prepared to deal with them in the future.
Joshua Suttle
Review left Jul 30 2022
Review
The process of submitting my cards was very easy. Once my cards had been received Card Conduit was diligent in reporting the status of my order as it was received, sorted, and then bought. They also provided a detailed breakdown of the value of my order. I will definitely use them again in the future.
The process of submitting my cards was very easy. Once my cards had been received Card Conduit was diligent in reporting the status of my order as it was received, sorted, and then bought. They also provided a detailed breakdown of the value of my order. I will definitely use them again in the future.
Uberjam
Review left Jul 30 2022
Review
I sent cards in and they gave me money for them. It is awesome.
I sent cards in and they gave me money for them. It is awesome.
Hunter
Review left Jul 29 2022
Review
Card Conduit was great to get rid of all of the bulk with no issues and fast service, have and will recommend to everyone I know with boxes weighting them down!
Card Conduit was great to get rid of all of the bulk with no issues and fast service, have and will recommend to everyone I know with boxes weighting them down!
Rob
Review left Jul 29 2022
Review
The process was straightforward and the pricing was able to beat out a local offer by a wide margin.
The process was straightforward and the pricing was able to beat out a local offer by a wide margin.
Bernard
Review left Jul 29 2022
Review
I was given a very fair price for my first time using this service. They took all my bulk and provided me a good price for them. It looks like I used the more expensive service but was given a discount once the team realized that I chose the wrong service.
I was given a very fair price for my first time using this service. They took all my bulk and provided me a good price for them. It looks like I used the more expensive service but was given a discount once the team realized that I chose the wrong service.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).