Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
Jordan Combs
Review left Dec 29 2022
Review
Getting the hang of the process was difficult at first, but once I did, it was a wonderful experience. The process felt smooth and I appreciated the communication. My only hang up was the grading of cards sent in. I think everyone has a bias for what their cards look like, but some of the grades fel
...
Read more
Getting the hang of the process was difficult at first, but once I did, it was a wonderful experience. The process felt smooth and I appreciated the communication. My only hang up was the grading of cards sent in. I think everyone has a bias for what their cards look like, but some of the grades felt a bit harsh. That being said, the time saved by sending Card Conduit my collection instead of piecing out everything felt great.
Clint H.
Review left Dec 28 2022
Review
The process was really easy from star to finish. I was also pleasantly surprised when someone from card conduit reached out to me during the process to provide updates. Overall, it took even less time than they initially estimated.
The process was really easy from star to finish. I was also pleasantly surprised when someone from card conduit reached out to me during the process to provide updates. Overall, it took even less time than they initially estimated.
Mike
Review left Dec 28 2022
Review
The process was smooth and easy. I just grabbed a whole bunch of cards that wanted to get rid of and I sent them off and I got paid. No it is true that if I have done a little bit more research and time I might get more money out of it but for the amount of time I did spend which was virtually nothi
...
Read more
The process was smooth and easy. I just grabbed a whole bunch of cards that wanted to get rid of and I sent them off and I got paid. No it is true that if I have done a little bit more research and time I might get more money out of it but for the amount of time I did spend which was virtually nothing I got a really good deal. And if I need to do it again, I would gladly use the service again
A E C
Review left Dec 27 2022
Review
Everything about the process from inputting my list of cards, shipping, getting my payment, everything was transparent, fast, and great.
Everything about the process from inputting my list of cards, shipping, getting my payment, everything was transparent, fast, and great.
John B
Review left Dec 27 2022
Review
I used to spend a lot of time comparing all the buylists to get the best deal. I decided to use Card Conduit. Really simple process. Easy instructions to organize and ship. Payment was received promptly with a summary of the card conditions. Great experience, highly recommend. Will keep coming back.
I used to spend a lot of time comparing all the buylists to get the best deal. I decided to use Card Conduit. Really simple process. Easy instructions to organize and ship. Payment was received promptly with a summary of the card conditions. Great experience, highly recommend. Will keep coming back.
Kevin Rhodes
Review left Dec 27 2022
Shipment processed Dec 15 2022
Review
In short, if I had more cards in my collection to sell, I would definitely use Card Conduit again.
In short, if I had more cards in my collection to sell, I would definitely use Card Conduit again.
Mike W
Review left Dec 27 2022
Review
The process was super easy. The communication was great and I got a great value from my cards.
The process was super easy. The communication was great and I got a great value from my cards.
Matt
Review left Dec 26 2022
Review
I found the process to be easy and efficient. The website explains everything you need to do, and communication with the company was good. The final sale report was thorough and gave me plenty of information to know how much my cards were sold for and where all the money went.
I found the process to be easy and efficient. The website explains everything you need to do, and communication with the company was good. The final sale report was thorough and gave me plenty of information to know how much my cards were sold for and where all the money went.
Benjamin
Review left Dec 26 2022
Review
Got good money for my cards. Process was very EZ. best thing is that they don't turn away cards that are not on "the buy list"
Got good money for my cards. Process was very EZ. best thing is that they don't turn away cards that are not on "the buy list"
Cody Wesson
Review left Dec 26 2022
Review
It was an overall great experience. They graded the cards fairly and paid fairly. It was easy and pretty quick. Thanks!
It was an overall great experience. They graded the cards fairly and paid fairly. It was easy and pretty quick. Thanks!
John S.
Review left Dec 26 2022
Review
I had a sizable collection that I wanted to sell but did not have the time to buy list or sell online myself. Card Conduit did a fantastic job of taking care of this for me and were very communicative and transparent throughout the process. I would highly recommend this service and would use again in the future.
I had a sizable collection that I wanted to sell but did not have the time to buy list or sell online myself. Card Conduit did a fantastic job of taking care of this for me and were very communicative and transparent throughout the process. I would highly recommend this service and would use again in the future.
Nik K
Review left Dec 26 2022
Review
Overall, I was very impressed with the quality and level of service I received with my shipment. From walking me through each of the steps, providing continual updates, to getting pretty good value for what I thought was 'just bulk', and overall just an easy solution to work with, I was very impress
...
Read more
Overall, I was very impressed with the quality and level of service I received with my shipment. From walking me through each of the steps, providing continual updates, to getting pretty good value for what I thought was 'just bulk', and overall just an easy solution to work with, I was very impressed.
Definitely make sure to pay attention to what you are sending them, even with the bulk sort and settle option as the .03/card fee can really add up and makes sending actual bulk very inefficient (they even call this out in their FAQ so this is no hidden gotcha or anything). Also, while I didn't send in many cards > $5-$10, the ones I did send in were still lower than if I had buylisted them separately, so just know going in that you may not get the absolute best bang for your buck.
Aside from that, their grading is very fair (I kept a log of what cards I sent in and what grade I thought they would be, with photos just because I was curious to how CC would grade them and though I am no expert, they all came back in the grade I was expecting), payout was quick via ACH, and overall, I highly recommend this to someone with bulk of some value (again, not literal bulk as the fee will ding you) as a quick solution to getting some cash for your cards.
Definitely make sure to pay attention to what you are sending them, even with the bulk sort and settle option as the .03/card fee can really add up and makes sending actual bulk very inefficient (they even call this out in their FAQ so this is no hidden gotcha or anything). Also, while I didn't send in many cards > $5-$10, the ones I did send in were still lower than if I had buylisted them separately, so just know going in that you may not get the absolute best bang for your buck.
Aside from that, their grading is very fair (I kept a log of what cards I sent in and what grade I thought they would be, with photos just because I was curious to how CC would grade them and though I am no expert, they all came back in the grade I was expecting), payout was quick via ACH, and overall, I highly recommend this to someone with bulk of some value (again, not literal bulk as the fee will ding you) as a quick solution to getting some cash for your cards.
Aaron H
Review left Dec 25 2022
Review
Kept me up to date and gave me a fair price on leftover cards :)
Kept me up to date and gave me a fair price on leftover cards :)
Russell Smith
Review left Dec 23 2022
Review
They do what they say they do. Took my cards, payed me money. Simple and efficient.
They do what they say they do. Took my cards, payed me money. Simple and efficient.
John Kyker
Review left Dec 23 2022
Review
Relatively fast turn around, fair grading, and good service.
Relatively fast turn around, fair grading, and good service.
Ken Saldi
Review left Dec 23 2022
Review
The process was very easy and they are extremely reasonable with the way they price and grade cards
The process was very easy and they are extremely reasonable with the way they price and grade cards
Sam Wolf
Review left Dec 23 2022
Review
Easy and fast process. Company reached out to compliment me on my collection. Also, because of the quality of my collection and the fact that I sorted them myself, they dropped their commission from to 10% to 5%, saving me hundreds of dollars. Most companies would not do that, but Card Conduit ca
...
Read more
Easy and fast process. Company reached out to compliment me on my collection. Also, because of the quality of my collection and the fact that I sorted them myself, they dropped their commission from to 10% to 5%, saving me hundreds of dollars. Most companies would not do that, but Card Conduit cares more about putting out a quality service rather than the bottom line. I couldn’t recommend card Conduit more.
Steven Croy
Review left Dec 21 2022
Review
I recently sent my fourth or fifth sell order to Conduit and have finally followed every guideline and questions previously answered.
I expected to get almost exactly what I received this time around and very happy with how quick and easy the process is. The fact that someone is always ready to em ... Read more
I expected to get almost exactly what I received this time around and very happy with how quick and easy the process is. The fact that someone is always ready to em ... Read more
I recently sent my fourth or fifth sell order to Conduit and have finally followed every guideline and questions previously answered.
I expected to get almost exactly what I received this time around and very happy with how quick and easy the process is. The fact that someone is always ready to email me with answers to any questions I may have, is exactly what you want out of service like this.
I will warn potential sellers to check the validity of your cards. Not just the quality but the actual authenticity of the card. This was my first experience getting a card rejected and it is quite embarrassing.
All that being said If you follow the guidelines and send cards worth something in good shape using the "curated" service with direct "zelle" payment, well its an amazing service.
Thanks.
I expected to get almost exactly what I received this time around and very happy with how quick and easy the process is. The fact that someone is always ready to email me with answers to any questions I may have, is exactly what you want out of service like this.
I will warn potential sellers to check the validity of your cards. Not just the quality but the actual authenticity of the card. This was my first experience getting a card rejected and it is quite embarrassing.
All that being said If you follow the guidelines and send cards worth something in good shape using the "curated" service with direct "zelle" payment, well its an amazing service.
Thanks.
Max Mahaffey
Review left Dec 21 2022
Review
I had an absolutely great experience dealing with card conduit! They were prompt and graded my cards fairly! 10/10 would highly recommend!
I had an absolutely great experience dealing with card conduit! They were prompt and graded my cards fairly! 10/10 would highly recommend!
Pat Johnson
Review left Dec 21 2022
Shipment processed Dec 10 2022
Review
I shipped my cards in according to the guidelines. Communication was consistent. Received my offer and got paid. Everything was handled well and I immediately shared the experience with my friends who are also now using their services. Will be back if I ever collect more.
I shipped my cards in according to the guidelines. Communication was consistent. Received my offer and got paid. Everything was handled well and I immediately shared the experience with my friends who are also now using their services. Will be back if I ever collect more.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).