Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5871)
Andy
Review left Nov 24 2023
Shipment processed Nov 21 2023
Review
Sort, pack, ship, and then wait. It's that easy. The value sometimes fluctuates (lower or higher) but just have that expectation going in
Sort, pack, ship, and then wait. It's that easy. The value sometimes fluctuates (lower or higher) but just have that expectation going in
Christina DeMarco
Review left Nov 23 2023
Review
I would recommend. Always get paid fairly and swiftly.
I would recommend. Always get paid fairly and swiftly.
Kevin Daley
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
The process went smoothly and quickly. The payout was reasonable. I would recommend.
The process went smoothly and quickly. The payout was reasonable. I would recommend.
Michael Aymond
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
The whole process is easy and you always know what step your shipment is at during the process. Great customer service, would recommend.
The whole process is easy and you always know what step your shipment is at during the process. Great customer service, would recommend.
Kyle St Hilaire
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
Process was easy to setup and they communicated everything clearly. Great customer service and a perfect efficient way to sell your magic cards. It’s nice to get a full report on your cards and a detailed explanation on why they are priced the way they are. I have some more cards to send and will definitely use them again!
Process was easy to setup and they communicated everything clearly. Great customer service and a perfect efficient way to sell your magic cards. It’s nice to get a full report on your cards and a detailed explanation on why they are priced the way they are. I have some more cards to send and will definitely use them again!
zak
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
very easy to get most of a cards value with minimum effort!
very easy to get most of a cards value with minimum effort!
Nico Baron
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
Really impressed with how it all went using CardConduit! I combed through my whole collection pulling cards that were of value using CK as a base (bad idea) and sent them all over for review. CC did their thing and adjusted my submission based on the overall impression, my take home was nearly doubl
...
Read more
Really impressed with how it all went using CardConduit! I combed through my whole collection pulling cards that were of value using CK as a base (bad idea) and sent them all over for review. CC did their thing and adjusted my submission based on the overall impression, my take home was nearly double what I had anticipated and the service was absolutely stellar. Nick and team were great, would definitely recommend (already have to a bunch of folks) and will be using again when the time is right!
Kayleigh
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
I would absolutely recommend CardConduit to anyone looking to sell their Magic cards!
The service was fantastic! I sent in a shipment incorrectly labeled as a 'bulk' shipment, and they upgraded me to a 'curated' shipment without delay. This change reduced the processing cost and saved me a couple ... Read more
The service was fantastic! I sent in a shipment incorrectly labeled as a 'bulk' shipment, and they upgraded me to a 'curated' shipment without delay. This change reduced the processing cost and saved me a couple ... Read more
I would absolutely recommend CardConduit to anyone looking to sell their Magic cards!
The service was fantastic! I sent in a shipment incorrectly labeled as a 'bulk' shipment, and they upgraded me to a 'curated' shipment without delay. This change reduced the processing cost and saved me a couple bucks! The payment through PayPal was received exactly as advertised.
Their online card search engine was very easy to use, which allowed me to search through my old Magic decks and gather the cards that were worth more than the processing fee.
All in all, I couldn't have asked for a better experience. Selling your (formerly) prized Sliver deck is an experience you only have once, but if I did it again, I would use CardConduit!
The service was fantastic! I sent in a shipment incorrectly labeled as a 'bulk' shipment, and they upgraded me to a 'curated' shipment without delay. This change reduced the processing cost and saved me a couple bucks! The payment through PayPal was received exactly as advertised.
Their online card search engine was very easy to use, which allowed me to search through my old Magic decks and gather the cards that were worth more than the processing fee.
All in all, I couldn't have asked for a better experience. Selling your (formerly) prized Sliver deck is an experience you only have once, but if I did it again, I would use CardConduit!
Steven
Review left Nov 22 2023
Review
This was my third time using Card Conduit. The process was seamless and transparent as always. I'll continue to send my extra cards to Card Conduit as long as I can!
This was my third time using Card Conduit. The process was seamless and transparent as always. I'll continue to send my extra cards to Card Conduit as long as I can!
Cade Pledger
Review left Nov 21 2023
Review
Will continue to use this service in the future makes things so much easier
Will continue to use this service in the future makes things so much easier
Zeb Hillard
Review left Nov 21 2023
Shipment processed Nov 18 2023
Review
Not only is the turnaround time exceptional given the service provided, Card Conduit constantly provides more bang for your cards than any other buy lister (especially when considering the personal time savings!) I've come across previously.
Not only is the turnaround time exceptional given the service provided, Card Conduit constantly provides more bang for your cards than any other buy lister (especially when considering the personal time savings!) I've come across previously.
William
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
The entire process was extremely easy and very prompt. I had a significant inventory of cards, and they were cataloged quickly and processed for payment. Great communication at every step, and I would happily do business with this company again!
The entire process was extremely easy and very prompt. I had a significant inventory of cards, and they were cataloged quickly and processed for payment. Great communication at every step, and I would happily do business with this company again!
Sean Weese
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
Cataloging the cards I was selling was very easy with the way the site is set up. My collection was processed quickly. I will definitely use them again if I have more cards to sell in the future.
Cataloging the cards I was selling was very easy with the way the site is set up. My collection was processed quickly. I will definitely use them again if I have more cards to sell in the future.
Layne Aldrich
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
I feel like this was a great experience. I used the pre-sorted option, where you sort out all the bulk yourself and put the cards in a certain order when you ship them out. I received what I feel is a very fair value for the cards I submitted and the quality they were in. Much easier than posting to
...
Read more
I feel like this was a great experience. I used the pre-sorted option, where you sort out all the bulk yourself and put the cards in a certain order when you ship them out. I received what I feel is a very fair value for the cards I submitted and the quality they were in. Much easier than posting to eBay/Other self-selling platforms. My one little complaint is that they rejected a Wurmcoil Engine that I sent in? After poking around it seems like the only time they would straight up reject is when it is a counterfeit? Which I apologize I did not realize that was the case if so. But anyways, not a huge deal, sent it a lot of other cards just maybe be a little more upfront with that or something but truly basically a non-issue... Thanks again and keep up the good work!
Josh Santosa
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
The process was very easy and straightforward. The notifications of each step was nice to see during the process. A little disappointed about the grading of the cards, as I believe most of them sent back were NM-LP. Grading seems stricter. Pictures or evidence of grading may be a helpful note in the future if things are marked as MP.
The process was very easy and straightforward. The notifications of each step was nice to see during the process. A little disappointed about the grading of the cards, as I believe most of them sent back were NM-LP. Grading seems stricter. Pictures or evidence of grading may be a helpful note in the future if things are marked as MP.
Preston Mulder
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
Amazing service, great and attentive responses, without a doubt one of the best choices you can make if you are looking to sell your cards. 10/10, big thank you to Nick as well, really appreciate all of your help.
Amazing service, great and attentive responses, without a doubt one of the best choices you can make if you are looking to sell your cards. 10/10, big thank you to Nick as well, really appreciate all of your help.
Justin from PA
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
I wanted to sell my collection and CC seemed like the best option in my specific case. I appreciate their candor in social media and Nathan from customer service was extremely helpful. I had my ACH payment about two weeks after they had received my shipment. Everything went smoothly and I was really
...
Read more
I wanted to sell my collection and CC seemed like the best option in my specific case. I appreciate their candor in social media and Nathan from customer service was extremely helpful. I had my ACH payment about two weeks after they had received my shipment. Everything went smoothly and I was really glad to not have to deal with the hassle of selling so many cards one-by-one.
Justin from PA
Review left Nov 20 2023
Review
I wanted to sell my collection and CC seemed like the best option in my specific case. I appreciate their candor in social media and Nathan from customer service was extremely helpful. I had my ACH payment about two weeks after they had received my shipment. Everything went smoothly and I was really
...
Read more
I wanted to sell my collection and CC seemed like the best option in my specific case. I appreciate their candor in social media and Nathan from customer service was extremely helpful. I had my ACH payment about two weeks after they had received my shipment. Everything went smoothly and I was really glad to not have to deal with the hassle of selling so many cards one-by-one.
Earl C
Review left Nov 19 2023
Shipment processed Nov 17 2023
Review
The process was incredibly easy and the team was fantastic to work with. Their services made the complicated process of selling large quantities Magic cards an absolute breeze, so much so that I'd definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to offload their collection!
The process was incredibly easy and the team was fantastic to work with. Their services made the complicated process of selling large quantities Magic cards an absolute breeze, so much so that I'd definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to offload their collection!
Devin W
Review left Nov 19 2023
Review
From start to finish this was a very smooth and easy way to sell my cards. Updates often so I knew what was going on throughout the whole process. Would recommend.
From start to finish this was a very smooth and easy way to sell my cards. Updates often so I knew what was going on throughout the whole process. Would recommend.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).