Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5644)
Cory
Review left Dec 03 2023
Shipment processed Nov 23 2023
Review
I just tried my first shipment with Card Conduit and was so impressed by the accountability of their process that I’m already building another order with them.
I just tried my first shipment with Card Conduit and was so impressed by the accountability of their process that I’m already building another order with them.
Barry Anderson
Review left Dec 03 2023
Review
This is my second time using the service and I couldn’t be more satisfied. I got great value for the cards I sent in and the whole process was fast and easy. I recommend the service to anyone who’s looking to sell their collection.
This is my second time using the service and I couldn’t be more satisfied. I got great value for the cards I sent in and the whole process was fast and easy. I recommend the service to anyone who’s looking to sell their collection.
Max Luna
Review left Dec 02 2023
Review
The process was easy and I may have gone overboard with packaging up my cards but I heard no complaints from Card Conduit. I definitely will be using this service again. Also after seeing my report, I think I will skip my commons and uncommon next time for processing.
The process was easy and I may have gone overboard with packaging up my cards but I heard no complaints from Card Conduit. I definitely will be using this service again. Also after seeing my report, I think I will skip my commons and uncommon next time for processing.
Ash Meyer
Review left Dec 02 2023
Review
Being able to send my cards off has helped my ability to pay off other things I needed for the holidays. CardConduit is one of the best ways to get cash for your unused cards quickly!
Being able to send my cards off has helped my ability to pay off other things I needed for the holidays. CardConduit is one of the best ways to get cash for your unused cards quickly!
Jacob Kabealo
Review left Dec 01 2023
Review
This was a super great way to easily get some money for cards I wanted to get rid of, no hassle with finding an individual buyer and hoping shipping to them was easy. I love using card conduit to get money for my extra cards!
This was a super great way to easily get some money for cards I wanted to get rid of, no hassle with finding an individual buyer and hoping shipping to them was easy. I love using card conduit to get money for my extra cards!
Dino
Review left Dec 01 2023
Review
Great service as usual. This company is highly professional and provide great communication.
Great service as usual. This company is highly professional and provide great communication.
Sean M
Review left Dec 01 2023
Review
If you have cards that have some value and you take care of your cards, don't send them here. No integrity, they mark down the condition of your cards to where you might get 30% of the value for them. Better to hold on to the higher price cards you own and sell directly to vendors.
If you have cards that have some value and you take care of your cards, don't send them here. No integrity, they mark down the condition of your cards to where you might get 30% of the value for them. Better to hold on to the higher price cards you own and sell directly to vendors.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Dec 01 2023
While we strive to set expectations for all customers ahead of time, there can be times where expectations aren't able to be met. The payout for this Sorted shipment, where the potential value was known ahead of time, was 71% of that potential Near Mint value, which is in line with expectations for the range of conditions received.
Extensive photographic evidence of the wear of the cards was provided, but the customer simply disagreed with the assessments – calling them "a joke".
It can be frustrating when you believe your cards are in great condition, but they don't meet vendor criteria to be assessed as such, as was the case here. At the end of the day, we need to assess the card condition as we receive it, but we always want to reach a satisfactory result for every single customer.
If you are considering our service and are concerned about the grades of your cards, we always recommend requesting a hold for review, which will allow you to get evidence of your grades and provide options in the event we cannot get on the same page regarding the assessment.
Extensive photographic evidence of the wear of the cards was provided, but the customer simply disagreed with the assessments – calling them "a joke".
It can be frustrating when you believe your cards are in great condition, but they don't meet vendor criteria to be assessed as such, as was the case here. At the end of the day, we need to assess the card condition as we receive it, but we always want to reach a satisfactory result for every single customer.
If you are considering our service and are concerned about the grades of your cards, we always recommend requesting a hold for review, which will allow you to get evidence of your grades and provide options in the event we cannot get on the same page regarding the assessment.
While we strive to set expectations for all customers ahead of time, there can be times where expectations aren't able to be met. The payout for this Sorted shipment, where the potential value was known ahead of time, was 71% of that potential Near Mint value, which is in line with expectations for the range of conditions received.
Extensive photographic evidence of the wear of the cards was provided, but the customer simply disagreed with the assessments – calling them "a joke".
It can be frustrating when you believe your cards are in great condition, but they don't meet vendor criteria to be assessed as such, as was the case here. At the end of the day, we need to assess the card condition as we receive it, but we always want to reach a satisfactory result for every single customer.
If you are considering our service and are concerned about the grades of your cards, we always recommend requesting a hold for review, which will allow you to get evidence of your grades and provide options in the event we cannot get on the same page regarding the assessment.
Extensive photographic evidence of the wear of the cards was provided, but the customer simply disagreed with the assessments – calling them "a joke".
It can be frustrating when you believe your cards are in great condition, but they don't meet vendor criteria to be assessed as such, as was the case here. At the end of the day, we need to assess the card condition as we receive it, but we always want to reach a satisfactory result for every single customer.
If you are considering our service and are concerned about the grades of your cards, we always recommend requesting a hold for review, which will allow you to get evidence of your grades and provide options in the event we cannot get on the same page regarding the assessment.
Jaime
Review left Dec 01 2023
Review
After we'd made the difficult decision to sell our collection, Card Conduit made the sale itself amazingly easy. Every step of the process was a pleasant surprise, from the efficiency of the collection estimate tool to the fairness of the card grading to the speed of the payout. We'd recommend this service to anyone.
After we'd made the difficult decision to sell our collection, Card Conduit made the sale itself amazingly easy. Every step of the process was a pleasant surprise, from the efficiency of the collection estimate tool to the fairness of the card grading to the speed of the payout. We'd recommend this service to anyone.
Tim
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
The team was very communicative and helped me setup my order settings in a way that would ensure I got compensated fairly. I liked the service and would recommend it!
The team was very communicative and helped me setup my order settings in a way that would ensure I got compensated fairly. I liked the service and would recommend it!
Zeke Lovette
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
The process was so smooth and easy. The online instructions made it very simple to follow along. I just went to a UPS store and wrote down the shipping number in the box and gave it to the service rep at the counter. A few days later CardConduit sent me an email to update me that they had received m
...
Read more
The process was so smooth and easy. The online instructions made it very simple to follow along. I just went to a UPS store and wrote down the shipping number in the box and gave it to the service rep at the counter. A few days later CardConduit sent me an email to update me that they had received my order and they were appraising all my cards. I received my payment a week later and was very satisfied with the resulting payment.
Thanks CardConduit!
Thanks CardConduit!
Ryan Smith
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
This is a great service. I wanted to sell my entire collection and selling on Facebook took too long and shipping costs ate up a lot of money because I didn't know what I was doing. I got a quote from someone on Facebook who was buying entire collections and card conduit beat it by more than $500.
...
Read more
This is a great service. I wanted to sell my entire collection and selling on Facebook took too long and shipping costs ate up a lot of money because I didn't know what I was doing. I got a quote from someone on Facebook who was buying entire collections and card conduit beat it by more than $500. The value I got from my near mint cards (80% of the 800 cards) was very close to tcglow, and cards rated lower I agreed with. There was a $20 fee for removing sleeves from the cards but I think it was worth it for the peace of mind. I used the price estimator tool on this site before sending my collection in and what I got was very close to the estimate, within $100 iirc. I absolutely would recommend this service if you have taken good care of your cards and they have no visible defects. I've recommended this service to my brother and he's shipped in cards as well. I'd use this again, but I don't really have many cards left.
James Simpson
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
The process for setting up the shipment was very easy. The updates and progress was very steady after they received my package. The grading of the cards was very fair. The payout was more than initially expected and was processed quickly. I will definitely be using this service in the future for sel
...
Read more
The process for setting up the shipment was very easy. The updates and progress was very steady after they received my package. The grading of the cards was very fair. The payout was more than initially expected and was processed quickly. I will definitely be using this service in the future for selling parts of my collection. Overall and excellent experience.
Nicholas Hauber
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
I had a whole bunch of cards sent in because I was moving across states, and they were very helpful in reaching out to me and going into detail about my shipment. You don’t really see that with most places nowadays. Other businesses, take notes. These guys know how to treat a customer well. 10/10, would ship with them again!
I had a whole bunch of cards sent in because I was moving across states, and they were very helpful in reaching out to me and going into detail about my shipment. You don’t really see that with most places nowadays. Other businesses, take notes. These guys know how to treat a customer well. 10/10, would ship with them again!
Chris
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
Amazing response time. Card conduit also bumped my service up to a better rate because I had my shipment organized. Would definitely use this service again.
Amazing response time. Card conduit also bumped my service up to a better rate because I had my shipment organized. Would definitely use this service again.
Eric P.
Review left Nov 29 2023
Review
Just as the title reads. Continuing to go through bulk and using the price checker tool and sent in a bunch of cards and got more than I expected. Sending another one asap.
Just as the title reads. Continuing to go through bulk and using the price checker tool and sent in a bunch of cards and got more than I expected. Sending another one asap.
Dana
Review left Nov 28 2023
Review
That's all I think. I hope I don't find but probably will
That's all I think. I hope I don't find but probably will
Ryan Sun
Review left Nov 28 2023
Review
Super good feedback very helpful. Service was excellent and love every min.
Super good feedback very helpful. Service was excellent and love every min.
Jerry Lou
Review left Nov 28 2023
Review
I liked that it there was a straightforward method to get my cards sold, but doing shipping myself was counterintuitive. Money got from cards was also a bit low for my standards
I liked that it there was a straightforward method to get my cards sold, but doing shipping myself was counterintuitive. Money got from cards was also a bit low for my standards
Jin-Seong Choi
Review left Nov 28 2023
Review
The process was simple. The payout amount was more than I expected. Worth to wait, and make one more shipment. Recommended!
The process was simple. The payout amount was more than I expected. Worth to wait, and make one more shipment. Recommended!
Nick
Review left Nov 27 2023
Review
I've used card conduit several times to sell unwanted cards, and it couldn't be much better than this! The process is fast, easy, and reliable. What's even better is how much better their buylist prices are than other places, including my LGS. I plan to keep using CC in the future.
I've used card conduit several times to sell unwanted cards, and it couldn't be much better than this! The process is fast, easy, and reliable. What's even better is how much better their buylist prices are than other places, including my LGS. I plan to keep using CC in the future.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).