Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5644)
Frankie Santos
Review left Jan 07 2024
Review
Sorry for the late review. No complaints from me. Everything was super transparent. Once they received my shipment, the process seemed pretty fast and streamlined, even during the holiday season. You could see the progress tracker thingy on the website and on top of that I got a few emails with upda
...
Read more
Sorry for the late review. No complaints from me. Everything was super transparent. Once they received my shipment, the process seemed pretty fast and streamlined, even during the holiday season. You could see the progress tracker thingy on the website and on top of that I got a few emails with updates, stats, and even like a personal assessment of my collection as a whole, shout out Nick Anderson, thank you buddy. I literally just sent random cards in boxes but I guess the nature of the collection and the value they adjusted me to the “curated” service which actually got me a bigger payout. If I could change anything it would be the way I shipped the cards to them, I used UPS because I live close to one. It cost $30 and took a week, I would do something faster next time. I plan on using them again in the future but for a smaller batch of cards. Thanks guys.
Luke Arledge
Review left Jan 07 2024
Review
Process was easy and they let me know about holidays and about when I should expect each part of the process to be finished. Payment was quick.
Process was easy and they let me know about holidays and about when I should expect each part of the process to be finished. Payment was quick.
Mike
Review left Jan 06 2024
Review
This was my first time using Card Conduit, and I had a great experience! I'll be sure to use them again!
This was my first time using Card Conduit, and I had a great experience! I'll be sure to use them again!
Sylvie Johnson
Review left Jan 05 2024
Review
Fourth shipment of cards, these guys are really the best. Forget the other sites out there, CC has your back.
Fourth shipment of cards, these guys are really the best. Forget the other sites out there, CC has your back.
Sylvie Johnson
Review left Jan 05 2024
Review
Never thought I'd be able to unload so many cards I didn't want anymore, let alone get a fair price for them (or any money at all). Thanks CC, you guys are amazing.
Never thought I'd be able to unload so many cards I didn't want anymore, let alone get a fair price for them (or any money at all). Thanks CC, you guys are amazing.
Robert
Review left Jan 05 2024
Review
Process was very quick and well done UI. After shipping was quick and efficient from receiving to payout even right before Christmas, already planning another shipment
Process was very quick and well done UI. After shipping was quick and efficient from receiving to payout even right before Christmas, already planning another shipment
Jasper Arbaugh
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
The process was very easy and intuitive. It was very easy to import a csv of all the cards I was trying to sell from the TCGPlayer scanner. I think the conditions of most cards came back as expected. I had a few cards marked for scratched or foggy foiling even though they recommend you ship them sle
...
Read more
The process was very easy and intuitive. It was very easy to import a csv of all the cards I was trying to sell from the TCGPlayer scanner. I think the conditions of most cards came back as expected. I had a few cards marked for scratched or foggy foiling even though they recommend you ship them sleeveless. But overall just as easy as going to a local game store and I think i received more money overall.
Joe Blank
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
Card Conduit made it very easy to sell cards. They provided amazing service!
Card Conduit made it very easy to sell cards. They provided amazing service!
Alex H
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
I love how efficient and helpful Card Conduit was during the entire submission process. Timely communication (and payout) can be very rare in the TCG world, so Card Conduit blew my expectations away!
I love how efficient and helpful Card Conduit was during the entire submission process. Timely communication (and payout) can be very rare in the TCG world, so Card Conduit blew my expectations away!
Brian Lee
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
I've used cardconduit a few times (maybe this is my fourth) and this was my best ever. They processed my cards and paid out less than a week after I shipped it to them, so that was nice.
I've used cardconduit a few times (maybe this is my fourth) and this was my best ever. They processed my cards and paid out less than a week after I shipped it to them, so that was nice.
Les
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
The process is super easy, I’ve used the service many times and have had no problems whatsoever.
if you’re just looking to make some cash from your cards and don’t have the time or patience to try and sell them individually, the payout is pretty decent. Especially in comparison to some local ... Read more
if you’re just looking to make some cash from your cards and don’t have the time or patience to try and sell them individually, the payout is pretty decent. Especially in comparison to some local ... Read more
The process is super easy, I’ve used the service many times and have had no problems whatsoever.
if you’re just looking to make some cash from your cards and don’t have the time or patience to try and sell them individually, the payout is pretty decent. Especially in comparison to some local card shops cash price for cards.
I highly recommend this service.
if you’re just looking to make some cash from your cards and don’t have the time or patience to try and sell them individually, the payout is pretty decent. Especially in comparison to some local card shops cash price for cards.
I highly recommend this service.
Jim
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
I sent in a lot of cards and got good value with card conduit doing all of the work!
I sent in a lot of cards and got good value with card conduit doing all of the work!
Jonathan W
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
As a collector, I tend to open a lot of packs but never find the time (or energy) to sell all the duplicates and extra cards I have laying around. With Cardconduit, I was able to ship more than 3,500 cards in a single package — the process was super easy to follow, and the customer support is resp
...
Read more
As a collector, I tend to open a lot of packs but never find the time (or energy) to sell all the duplicates and extra cards I have laying around. With Cardconduit, I was able to ship more than 3,500 cards in a single package — the process was super easy to follow, and the customer support is responsive if you have any questions (I had some concerns about how to properly send my package, and had support answer in a couple of hours).
From there, my package was received, processed, and paid out in a matter of days—for more than I expected!
I will use Cardconduit again, and have already recommended it to friends around me :)
From there, my package was received, processed, and paid out in a matter of days—for more than I expected!
I will use Cardconduit again, and have already recommended it to friends around me :)
Treves
Review left Jan 03 2024
Review
Not only was it a quick and easy process they update you every step of the way. Beyond fair grading of cards I wasn’t familiar with the site (I did no reading of my options) they went out of there way to upgrade to what I should have chosen and gave me more money. There is not enough good things to say about card conduit and there team!
Not only was it a quick and easy process they update you every step of the way. Beyond fair grading of cards I wasn’t familiar with the site (I did no reading of my options) they went out of there way to upgrade to what I should have chosen and gave me more money. There is not enough good things to say about card conduit and there team!
Patrick Kline
Review left Jan 02 2024
Review
It was easy and straight forward, no tricks, and they communicated every step. 10/10 would recommend
It was easy and straight forward, no tricks, and they communicated every step. 10/10 would recommend
Scott Swanstrom
Review left Jan 02 2024
Review
Process was smooth, easy, professional, and provided the greatest value for my cards.
Process was smooth, easy, professional, and provided the greatest value for my cards.
Dylan Guidry
Review left Jan 02 2024
Review
Sent my order in just before Christmas and shipment was received and reviewed before new years!
Sent my order in just before Christmas and shipment was received and reviewed before new years!
Peter
Review left Jan 01 2024
Review
I sold a couple hundred old cards via the Sorted service, using the price check tool to classify my collection into the cards that qualified vs. the cards that still made sense to sell via a separate Standard shipment vs. those not worth selling or keeping.
The process was easy; processing was r ... Read more
The process was easy; processing was r ... Read more
I sold a couple hundred old cards via the Sorted service, using the price check tool to classify my collection into the cards that qualified vs. the cards that still made sense to sell via a separate Standard shipment vs. those not worth selling or keeping.
The process was easy; processing was reasonably prompt and payment was quick and painless once everything was graded. I appreciated the corrections made to my own classifications of ambiguous cards, EG "light" vs standard variations for some cards, and the updates as the shipment went through each step.
In general, I thought the service offered fair value for the cards. I am not an experienced judge of card condition, but I did find the condition grading to be strict. Other sources differ in their definitions of eg "heavily played" vs "damaged", and the grades given lined up more with the strictest of those definitions. I don't think the grades were unfair, especially after I compared multiple other sites' descriptions, but I would have appreciated descriptions and even examples of the standards Card Conduit uses. As it was I had my initial expectations somewhat inflated by the more optimistic of those other sites' descriptions.
The process was easy; processing was reasonably prompt and payment was quick and painless once everything was graded. I appreciated the corrections made to my own classifications of ambiguous cards, EG "light" vs standard variations for some cards, and the updates as the shipment went through each step.
In general, I thought the service offered fair value for the cards. I am not an experienced judge of card condition, but I did find the condition grading to be strict. Other sources differ in their definitions of eg "heavily played" vs "damaged", and the grades given lined up more with the strictest of those definitions. I don't think the grades were unfair, especially after I compared multiple other sites' descriptions, but I would have appreciated descriptions and even examples of the standards Card Conduit uses. As it was I had my initial expectations somewhat inflated by the more optimistic of those other sites' descriptions.
Mitch
Review left Jan 01 2024
Review
The process was very easy to follow and everything went smoothly. I have no complaints about my experience. Just read thoroughly and follow all handling instructions, and Card Conduit handles the rest!
The process was very easy to follow and everything went smoothly. I have no complaints about my experience. Just read thoroughly and follow all handling instructions, and Card Conduit handles the rest!
Paul Schmidt
Review left Jan 01 2024
Review
I would assume most people who use this service would be worried about their grading system and if you will be getting your value for your cards. Sure you can make more individually selling cards on other sites, but as a comprehensive service for either large sorted collections or bulk you will be g
...
Read more
I would assume most people who use this service would be worried about their grading system and if you will be getting your value for your cards. Sure you can make more individually selling cards on other sites, but as a comprehensive service for either large sorted collections or bulk you will be getting good value. You receive e-mails through every step of the process as well as Nick being incredibly quick at responding to any concerns or questions you have. Been wanting a service like this for a while and Card Conduit was able to provide.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).