Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(4357)
Jake Golan
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
3 standout points about my experience and @Nick Anderson:
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the ... Read more
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the ... Read more
3 standout points about my experience and @Nick Anderson:
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the report and personal email from Nick detailed where I gained value or lost value. Also pointing out a counterfeit card that was sold to me.
3. Simple and easy, people could look at their collection and claim, "I could make another 100 or 1000 dollars" without realizing the horrors of selling cards like scammers, haggling, and keeping pace of prices. With the headache of shipping cards. This will be the better solution in the long run for anyone with a collection larger than 500 cards to sell.
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the report and personal email from Nick detailed where I gained value or lost value. Also pointing out a counterfeit card that was sold to me.
3. Simple and easy, people could look at their collection and claim, "I could make another 100 or 1000 dollars" without realizing the horrors of selling cards like scammers, haggling, and keeping pace of prices. With the headache of shipping cards. This will be the better solution in the long run for anyone with a collection larger than 500 cards to sell.
Tovah Donahue
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
I had a very good experience with there team very good communication on there part and very helpful with everything.
I had a very good experience with there team very good communication on there part and very helpful with everything.
Max
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
Perfect experience fast and easy. No issues, far price for cards.
Perfect experience fast and easy. No issues, far price for cards.
Claire W.
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
Card Conduit was excellent in getting everything organized with their card sorting and price check tools to get the best value for my collection (especially during the busy holiday season). I shipped my cards out at the end of November, and received payment in 2 weeks just before the holidays! All w
...
Read more
Card Conduit was excellent in getting everything organized with their card sorting and price check tools to get the best value for my collection (especially during the busy holiday season). I shipped my cards out at the end of November, and received payment in 2 weeks just before the holidays! All while, Nick, with their accommodating updates on not only the shipment progress but also ensuring I was getting the most for the cards! Amazing customer support!
Lee Stansbury
Review left Jan 16 2023
Review
If you go to Card Conduit understanding the fees they charge, you will have no complaints. The evaluation of your cards, prior to shipping, stayed accurate after my shipments got to them and they graded the condition. Obviously collectors want what cards are worth "market value" but if you dont want
...
Read more
If you go to Card Conduit understanding the fees they charge, you will have no complaints. The evaluation of your cards, prior to shipping, stayed accurate after my shipments got to them and they graded the condition. Obviously collectors want what cards are worth "market value" but if you dont want to spend years trying to sell your collection, this is your next best bet.
Adam G
Review left Jan 16 2023
Shipment processed Jan 04 2023
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
The process was so simple and I was able to get almost 5600 cards out of my basement that I was never going to touch again, and I made a nice little profit (more money than the shipping costs were). Customer service reached out to me so many times and walked me through the entire process, so that was great. Highly recommend!
The process was so simple and I was able to get almost 5600 cards out of my basement that I was never going to touch again, and I made a nice little profit (more money than the shipping costs were). Customer service reached out to me so many times and walked me through the entire process, so that was great. Highly recommend!
Deonte
Review left Jan 16 2023
Review
I had a bunch of cards in my collection that I wasn’t using. I knew I could make a few bucks from selling them, but couldn’t find the best way to do it. Other services I’d used in the past had a card limit that I quickly hit (unknowingly), which caused several hours of frustration before givin
...
Read more
I had a bunch of cards in my collection that I wasn’t using. I knew I could make a few bucks from selling them, but couldn’t find the best way to do it. Other services I’d used in the past had a card limit that I quickly hit (unknowingly), which caused several hours of frustration before giving up. I then decided “what the heck—let’s try Card Conduit” since I had heard of them several times on the MTG Goldfish podcast. Using their discount code, and curated sorting option, I was able to easily research, sort, and compile my shipment in ONE sitting in just a couple of hours; finding a detailed list of the expected value, estimated processing time, and a payout scale based on overall conditions once received. I was able to trade on nearly 400 cards for over $1.7K! I could’ve believe how value there was in my excess cards. I was expecting a couple of hundred—maybe even close to one thousand bucks, at the most. Beyond this, the service team was very communicative, thorough, and made sure to reach out during and after the process to offer assistance and answers to questions I may have had. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience and have already recommended CardConduit to several of my friends.
Ben Quiggins
Review left Jan 16 2023
Review
The process was easy, efficient, and everything that I could have asked for
The process was easy, efficient, and everything that I could have asked for
Justin Arnold
Review left Jan 16 2023
Review
I was looking for some way to make a little money back from my card investments, after pulling the cards I wanted or needed from the Boosters I ordered throughout last year. As I am not in a very MTG community, it was difficult to trade or sell off to local card shops, so I was kind of stuck with a
...
Read more
I was looking for some way to make a little money back from my card investments, after pulling the cards I wanted or needed from the Boosters I ordered throughout last year. As I am not in a very MTG community, it was difficult to trade or sell off to local card shops, so I was kind of stuck with a bunch of cards I didn’t really care about. I am thankful there is an online service for this with Card Conduit.
John Cooper
Review left Jan 15 2023
Review
I love working with Card Conduit. I've sold to and through other online vendors before, and Card Conduit takes the cake for ease of use and overall positive vibe.
I love working with Card Conduit. I've sold to and through other online vendors before, and Card Conduit takes the cake for ease of use and overall positive vibe.
Joseph Gosizk
Review left Jan 15 2023
Review
Went from shipping out to having the money in my pocket in under 2 weeks. If you're willing to put in a little effort sorting the chaff it's the best way to offload cards
Went from shipping out to having the money in my pocket in under 2 weeks. If you're willing to put in a little effort sorting the chaff it's the best way to offload cards
Michael McClaran
Review left Jan 15 2023
Review
This is a great service with great communication and really lets you know what’s going on every step of the way. They are very efficient and fair and the process from start to finish is quite fast.
However, after doing multiple shipments with them my only dislike is this: it seems when you hav ... Read more
However, after doing multiple shipments with them my only dislike is this: it seems when you hav ... Read more
This is a great service with great communication and really lets you know what’s going on every step of the way. They are very efficient and fair and the process from start to finish is quite fast.
However, after doing multiple shipments with them my only dislike is this: it seems when you have really high value cards they are downshifted in condition so it’s not so high of a cost. My last example was Urza from modern horizons. I bought a booster pack and it was my foil retro rare. I never played it, put it into a sleeve, then into a binder, and then when I decided to sell it was the first time I had done anything with it. And believe me I pack these shipments with cardboard storage boxes, bubble wrap, extra packing, because I want the best bang for my buck. And it really seems like they get downshifted a lot. Maybe I’m paranoid but when mid prices for a card show a lot higher, you tend to get your hopes up.
That being said, otherwise this service is amazing. This company is amazing and I’m glad they exist.
That’s why it only gets 4/5 stars.
However, after doing multiple shipments with them my only dislike is this: it seems when you have really high value cards they are downshifted in condition so it’s not so high of a cost. My last example was Urza from modern horizons. I bought a booster pack and it was my foil retro rare. I never played it, put it into a sleeve, then into a binder, and then when I decided to sell it was the first time I had done anything with it. And believe me I pack these shipments with cardboard storage boxes, bubble wrap, extra packing, because I want the best bang for my buck. And it really seems like they get downshifted a lot. Maybe I’m paranoid but when mid prices for a card show a lot higher, you tend to get your hopes up.
That being said, otherwise this service is amazing. This company is amazing and I’m glad they exist.
That’s why it only gets 4/5 stars.
Ben
Review left Jan 14 2023
Review
Super EZ. I used to sell on TCG. Dealing with all the many many orders and TCG's cut this is so much better.
Super EZ. I used to sell on TCG. Dealing with all the many many orders and TCG's cut this is so much better.
Gerardo Lopez
Review left Jan 13 2023
Shipment processed Dec 29 2022
Review
Process was smooth and everything was really detailed, would use again.
Process was smooth and everything was really detailed, would use again.
Andrew
Review left Jan 12 2023
Review
This was a great way to get old cards taken care of. Everything felt efficient and was easy to understand and simple. I especially appreciated the fast communication when I had questions. Will be using this business again in the future and will definitely recommend to fellow MTG players.
This was a great way to get old cards taken care of. Everything felt efficient and was easy to understand and simple. I especially appreciated the fast communication when I had questions. Will be using this business again in the future and will definitely recommend to fellow MTG players.
Andy
Review left Jan 12 2023
Shipment processed Jan 09 2023
Review
Easy process of sending in the cards and detailed report after the processing was completed. Would recommended card conduit!
Easy process of sending in the cards and detailed report after the processing was completed. Would recommended card conduit!
Marcus Brothers
Review left Jan 11 2023
Review
Figuring out how to ship them was hard if you have a lot of cards but this service in my mind is the best bang for your buck when piecing out a collection. I could not have made the same amount of money by doing it myself if you figure in time for sorting, shipping, and listing on other sites to sel
...
Read more
Figuring out how to ship them was hard if you have a lot of cards but this service in my mind is the best bang for your buck when piecing out a collection. I could not have made the same amount of money by doing it myself if you figure in time for sorting, shipping, and listing on other sites to sell. Great service and would recommend if you have cards worth something and not bulk. Will use again in the future.
Arielle
Review left Jan 11 2023
Review
I really wasn't sure what to expect. I had a large box of Magic cards that I had not used for too many years, so I took a chance. It was easy, fast, and so worth it. I'm so happy that I chose card conduit. They were exactly what they described. Any issues in the process were immediately communicated
...
Read more
I really wasn't sure what to expect. I had a large box of Magic cards that I had not used for too many years, so I took a chance. It was easy, fast, and so worth it. I'm so happy that I chose card conduit. They were exactly what they described. Any issues in the process were immediately communicated, and the resulting spreadsheet was just an added bonus. I have recommended them to several people already. I definitely appreciate and endorse Card Conduit.
JOHN
Review left Jan 11 2023
Shipment processed Dec 08 2022
Review
EASY,FAST,RELIABLE.
WILL DEFINETLY USE AGAIN FOR SURE!
WILL DEFINETLY USE AGAIN FOR SURE!
EASY,FAST,RELIABLE.
WILL DEFINETLY USE AGAIN FOR SURE!
WILL DEFINETLY USE AGAIN FOR SURE!
Bob
Review left Jan 10 2023
Review
Easy process, great prices, quick payment, couldn't ask for more
Easy process, great prices, quick payment, couldn't ask for more
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).