Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6318)
Brendan
Review left Aug 13 2024
Review
Everything was simple to get through. Got as much as I expected and way simpler than selling individuals.
Everything was simple to get through. Got as much as I expected and way simpler than selling individuals.
Jake
Review left Aug 13 2024
Review
Overall I recommend card conduit. I would never want to take the time to sell my cards on their own individually. I wish I could include my cards that float around 90 cents on a buylist sine so many of my rares sit around that, but I understand that CC needs to move inventory quickly
Overall I recommend card conduit. I would never want to take the time to sell my cards on their own individually. I wish I could include my cards that float around 90 cents on a buylist sine so many of my rares sit around that, but I understand that CC needs to move inventory quickly
Casey Kelley
Review left Aug 12 2024
Review
These guys were professional top to bottom. I was selling off a small portion of my largelt played or unused cards and din't want to take the time and hassle to do it all manually. I opted into their service and came away from the experience extremely happy. They kept me informed of the process t
...
Read more
These guys were professional top to bottom. I was selling off a small portion of my largelt played or unused cards and din't want to take the time and hassle to do it all manually. I opted into their service and came away from the experience extremely happy. They kept me informed of the process the entire way, helped with any questions or concerns I had and the results were above wehat I had initially expected in value.
I would gladly recommend these folks to anyone who is on the fence or has large collections they don't want to take large amounts of time to hand sell. I very likely may use them again down the road if I decide to downsize my collection once again.
I would gladly recommend these folks to anyone who is on the fence or has large collections they don't want to take large amounts of time to hand sell. I very likely may use them again down the road if I decide to downsize my collection once again.
First buylist trade in
Review left Aug 12 2024
Review
Overall you guys have the best communication of any service I have tried. I felt that final amounts/condition was a bit low BUT since you are paying in USD (versus others who pay with credit) that was a reasonable compromise.
Overall you guys have the best communication of any service I have tried. I felt that final amounts/condition was a bit low BUT since you are paying in USD (versus others who pay with credit) that was a reasonable compromise.
Chuck Staples
Review left Aug 12 2024
Review
I'm truly impressed by Card Conduit's process shown with my first shipment! It seems to be a good system with excellent communications by the team. Prices were very good overall and grading was reasonable. Can't beat this level of convenience; definitely saves some time and effort.
I'm truly impressed by Card Conduit's process shown with my first shipment! It seems to be a good system with excellent communications by the team. Prices were very good overall and grading was reasonable. Can't beat this level of convenience; definitely saves some time and effort.
Joshua Carter
Review left Aug 12 2024
Review
Easiest way to sell an abundance of cards. They constantly communicate and the website does a wonderful job of tracking the progress of your shipment.
Easiest way to sell an abundance of cards. They constantly communicate and the website does a wonderful job of tracking the progress of your shipment.
Corey
Review left Aug 11 2024
Review
Fast and professional the whole way through, highly recommended service
Fast and professional the whole way through, highly recommended service
Jacob
Review left Aug 11 2024
Review
Amazing service, very polite and professional team. Due to the quality of my cards they switched my order over to their curated service so I pay less on the fees. Every step of the process is openly communicated to you and they are very transparent with their practices. Will 1000% being using them i
...
Read more
Amazing service, very polite and professional team. Due to the quality of my cards they switched my order over to their curated service so I pay less on the fees. Every step of the process is openly communicated to you and they are very transparent with their practices. Will 1000% being using them in the future with all my doubles and valuable bulk I no longer need. Thanks guys!
Joseph Fleischmann
Review left Aug 11 2024
Review
I've been using card conduit for over a year now and will never sell anywhere else. It's all just so easy. Send the cards wait 3 to 4 weeks and get your money.
I've been using card conduit for over a year now and will never sell anywhere else. It's all just so easy. Send the cards wait 3 to 4 weeks and get your money.
Leanne
Review left Aug 11 2024
Review
I cannot recommend this service enough. Extremely easy process, I got much more $ than expected and it was a fast payout.
I already have another shipment heading out to them.
I already have another shipment heading out to them.
I cannot recommend this service enough. Extremely easy process, I got much more $ than expected and it was a fast payout.
I already have another shipment heading out to them.
I already have another shipment heading out to them.
Kevin
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
The hardest part about getting my collection evaluated by Nick and the team was packaging over 5700 cards! Their shipping instructions provided some good guidance for that. I used a 5,000 card storage box from BCW (got it from amazon) and probably more tape than I really needed. I was informed immed
...
Read more
The hardest part about getting my collection evaluated by Nick and the team was packaging over 5700 cards! Their shipping instructions provided some good guidance for that. I used a 5,000 card storage box from BCW (got it from amazon) and probably more tape than I really needed. I was informed immediately when it was received and saw updates as it moved through processing. I'm guessing that my collection was a bit bigger than most submitted to them because the processing took about a week longer than their goal (~3 days). Importantly, though, Nick emailed me as soon as they realized processing my collection was going to take longer. He let me know everything was processing well and gave me a deadline for completion. They completed processing by the deadline and updated me promptly. Great service, and they gave a military discount on fees! I would definitely work with them in the future if I still had MTG cards! haha
Scott H.
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
The process of selling my cards was very easy. The conversations with Nick were informative and transparent. Value for the cards I sold was right on par with what was suggested beforehand and honest. Would highly recommend their service to everyone. I understand that everyone's experience will vary but I am happy with how the sale went for me. Thanks guys!
The process of selling my cards was very easy. The conversations with Nick were informative and transparent. Value for the cards I sold was right on par with what was suggested beforehand and honest. Would highly recommend their service to everyone. I understand that everyone's experience will vary but I am happy with how the sale went for me. Thanks guys!
Jonathan McNatt
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
It's so easy to make a list and ship it to them and the value I get is way better than any of my local shops. This is absolutely my preferred method to sell cards. A+
It's so easy to make a list and ship it to them and the value I get is way better than any of my local shops. This is absolutely my preferred method to sell cards. A+
LooksLikeAJobFor
Review left Aug 10 2024
Review
I'm glad this service exist. I'm a little OCD about holding on cards I don't use. With the state of magic I'm constantly updating my current decks for more optimal cards. I use to exchange unused cards at my LGS for store credit but would be lucky to get 20% value from the cards I turned in. First t
...
Read more
I'm glad this service exist. I'm a little OCD about holding on cards I don't use. With the state of magic I'm constantly updating my current decks for more optimal cards. I use to exchange unused cards at my LGS for store credit but would be lucky to get 20% value from the cards I turned in. First time, using card conduit I received way more than I was I expecting. Combine that on top of the excellent customer service. You can email the people directly in charge of operations and they even recommended packages to ensure I get more money. Magic isn't a cheap hobby so make sure you get your money's worth using card conduit!
AC
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
The website / process was pretty simple and easy to figure out. Getting paid was a breeze.
The website / process was pretty simple and easy to figure out. Getting paid was a breeze.
Amitayus
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I've had two experiences with Card Conduit so far, and they have both been fantastic. This service has saved me SO MUCH time in selling those cards that are worth something, but not really worth enough to put them into individual packages. Their communication has always been prompt and courteous. Can't recommend enough!
I've had two experiences with Card Conduit so far, and they have both been fantastic. This service has saved me SO MUCH time in selling those cards that are worth something, but not really worth enough to put them into individual packages. Their communication has always been prompt and courteous. Can't recommend enough!
Anthony
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I have loved using this website to sell my cards; the process is easy and transparent. However, the one risk I will state is the subjective nature of the card review process; when cards sent in are NM or LP, in my perspective, they are dinged and reviewed as MP. My review process is not perfect, but
...
Read more
I have loved using this website to sell my cards; the process is easy and transparent. However, the one risk I will state is the subjective nature of the card review process; when cards sent in are NM or LP, in my perspective, they are dinged and reviewed as MP. My review process is not perfect, but the issue is that certain high-priced cards were selected to be as such and sold at what I would say is still lower than the average price. Overall, understand this site is once again a third-party and you run risks of not selling your cards yourself.
Dillon Tiller
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I’ve put in 2 shipments so far (1 complete, 1 in progress) and the process has been very simple and convenient! The original estimate was only slightly off of what the final payout was and I will definitely be using this service again!
I’ve put in 2 shipments so far (1 complete, 1 in progress) and the process has been very simple and convenient! The original estimate was only slightly off of what the final payout was and I will definitely be using this service again!
Nicholas Bills
Review left Aug 09 2024
Review
I had a few cards I wanted to sell because I didn't really need them for any of my decks anymore, but I don't have an LGS to sell to, so after some research, I settled on Card Conduit as my best option. When I received my initial report, I was a bit confused by two cards that were reported as "damag
...
Read more
I had a few cards I wanted to sell because I didn't really need them for any of my decks anymore, but I don't have an LGS to sell to, so after some research, I settled on Card Conduit as my best option. When I received my initial report, I was a bit confused by two cards that were reported as "damaged," so I asked in the email I received with the report if they could elaborate. Sure enough, within 2 hours of my response, they sent me an explanation with photos to explain their grading. One of the cards had a slight tear that I hadn't noticed before I sent it in, but I am certain was there because that card has seen a lot of play from me, and there were plenty of other imperfections on the card that I was aware of. The other card was unfortunately damaged during shipping, which was unfortunate, but it was my fault for not packing the cards better before I sent them in. My cards were all very "well loved" as one might put it, yet I feel I still got my money's worth, and I agree with the grades they gave my cards 100%. I would absolutely recommend this service to a friend and I will be using Card Conduit again in the future if I ever have more cards I want to get rid of.
SuperSaiyaJon
Review left Aug 08 2024
Review
I cannot express enough how amazing it is - take my cards- mail them in - and get paid out to buy more cards <3
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
I cannot express enough how amazing it is - take my cards- mail them in - and get paid out to buy more cards <3
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
Its a no brainer - ill be a customer for life :)
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).