Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6603)
Jacob Hayes
Review left Jan 20 2025
Review
I really like this service but I have to be more careful with checking the cards. I will most likely use this service again for low value cards and just hold on to the higher value cards until I know the difference from a NM card to a MP card.
I really like this service but I have to be more careful with checking the cards. I will most likely use this service again for low value cards and just hold on to the higher value cards until I know the difference from a NM card to a MP card.
John
Review left Jan 20 2025
Review
I sent some cards in to see how much I would get and was happy with the results. Definitely will be sending more
I sent some cards in to see how much I would get and was happy with the results. Definitely will be sending more
Matthew Zavala
Review left Jan 20 2025
Review
I've used this service several times. They are easy and fast.
Easy and straight to the point review, here.
Easy and straight to the point review, here.
I've used this service several times. They are easy and fast.
Easy and straight to the point review, here.
Easy and straight to the point review, here.
KC
Review left Jan 20 2025
Review
Process was simple and fees were pretty low, Card Conduit also bought some random rares that other buylists weren't taking so the fees in this case made the whole service pretty worth it. Would use again and may try the bulk list as well.
Process was simple and fees were pretty low, Card Conduit also bought some random rares that other buylists weren't taking so the fees in this case made the whole service pretty worth it. Would use again and may try the bulk list as well.
Thomas Colthurst
Review left Jan 18 2025
Review
I sold 1360 cards through Card Conduit, and was extremely happy with the experience. I had never bought or sold cards before, and I didn't have the time to do more than sort my chafe (commons and uncommons) from the rest. The packing instructions were very clear, and I was pleased to get emails at
...
Read more
I sold 1360 cards through Card Conduit, and was extremely happy with the experience. I had never bought or sold cards before, and I didn't have the time to do more than sort my chafe (commons and uncommons) from the rest. The packing instructions were very clear, and I was pleased to get emails at every stage of the process -- shipment created, shipment created, shipment processed, etc.
Two things especially impressed me with what happened next. First, based on the value of my cards, they voluntarily upgraded my shipment to their Curated service, eliminating the per card charge and their overhead percentage from 10% to 5%. Second, when the payment check got lost in the mail, they quickly (as in 4 minutes after I sent my email) sent me the scan history of the letter and then when I asked, they cancelled the check and delivered payment through a direct wire. And those last two things happened over the weekend!
Huge thank you to Card Conduit for the best customer service that I've ever received from any business ever!
Two things especially impressed me with what happened next. First, based on the value of my cards, they voluntarily upgraded my shipment to their Curated service, eliminating the per card charge and their overhead percentage from 10% to 5%. Second, when the payment check got lost in the mail, they quickly (as in 4 minutes after I sent my email) sent me the scan history of the letter and then when I asked, they cancelled the check and delivered payment through a direct wire. And those last two things happened over the weekend!
Huge thank you to Card Conduit for the best customer service that I've ever received from any business ever!
Sean Wills
Review left Jan 17 2025
Review
I used Dragon Shield to meticulously select the cream of the crop from my Magic Card collection---which, I might add, was collected from card packs and NEVER PLAYED WITH. When I was done selecting all the cards $1 and above, I had about $600 worth of cards, which I sent to Card Conduit. In my repor
...
Read more
I used Dragon Shield to meticulously select the cream of the crop from my Magic Card collection---which, I might add, was collected from card packs and NEVER PLAYED WITH. When I was done selecting all the cards $1 and above, I had about $600 worth of cards, which I sent to Card Conduit. In my report from the 'expert,' it was stated that many of the cards were not minted and in 'played' condition, which I don't understand. The $600 plus cards I sent were now around $500, which Card Conduit then took an additional $25 from. I feel like I was scammed.
Card Conduit Team
Replied Jan 17 2025
The maximum possible value for this shipment if everything was NM was $546.81, not $600. Of the 142 cards, 10 were MP, 9 were LP and the rest were NM. As a result, the total assessed value (before fees) was $514.23. The retail value (TCGLow) of these cards at NM was $692.41; as such, the assessed value as graded was 74.27% and the amount paid after fees was 70.55% of the NM retail value. Most folks would view this result as very good, so it is disheartening to hear the customer felt "scammed".
The condition names which include "played" in them are industry terms - they describe the amount and type of wear on a card, and are not suggesting that the wear came from any particular activity, like playing with the cards. We must always grade the cards as they are received, and cannot take into account the history of the cards. If you aren't familiar with grading or are surprised by the grading of the report, contacting us is always the best course of action, as we will always do our best to provide more information and context, with the aim to conclude the transaction in a satisfactory manner.
The condition names which include "played" in them are industry terms - they describe the amount and type of wear on a card, and are not suggesting that the wear came from any particular activity, like playing with the cards. We must always grade the cards as they are received, and cannot take into account the history of the cards. If you aren't familiar with grading or are surprised by the grading of the report, contacting us is always the best course of action, as we will always do our best to provide more information and context, with the aim to conclude the transaction in a satisfactory manner.
The maximum possible value for this shipment if everything was NM was $546.81, not $600. Of the 142 cards, 10 were MP, 9 were LP and the rest were NM. As a result, the total assessed value (before fees) was $514.23. The retail value (TCGLow) of these cards at NM was $692.41; as such, the assessed value as graded was 74.27% and the amount paid after fees was 70.55% of the NM retail value. Most folks would view this result as very good, so it is disheartening to hear the customer felt "scammed".
The condition names which include "played" in them are industry terms - they describe the amount and type of wear on a card, and are not suggesting that the wear came from any particular activity, like playing with the cards. We must always grade the cards as they are received, and cannot take into account the history of the cards. If you aren't familiar with grading or are surprised by the grading of the report, contacting us is always the best course of action, as we will always do our best to provide more information and context, with the aim to conclude the transaction in a satisfactory manner.
The condition names which include "played" in them are industry terms - they describe the amount and type of wear on a card, and are not suggesting that the wear came from any particular activity, like playing with the cards. We must always grade the cards as they are received, and cannot take into account the history of the cards. If you aren't familiar with grading or are surprised by the grading of the report, contacting us is always the best course of action, as we will always do our best to provide more information and context, with the aim to conclude the transaction in a satisfactory manner.
Bob Roudebush
Review left Jan 17 2025
Shipment processed Jan 09 2025
Review
This was my third time using Card Conduit. Everything was processed quickly and I was kept up to date on the status of the order.
This was my third time using Card Conduit. Everything was processed quickly and I was kept up to date on the status of the order.
Marquis
Review left Jan 17 2025
Review
The whole process is super easy! I went with the option of just sending unsorted cards to make it even easier on myself. Even with holidays and some inclement weather, the team worked on my order in a timely manner and were very communicative through the whole process!
The whole process is super easy! I went with the option of just sending unsorted cards to make it even easier on myself. Even with holidays and some inclement weather, the team worked on my order in a timely manner and were very communicative through the whole process!
Alex Vladimir
Review left Jan 16 2025
Shipment processed Jan 09 2025
Review
I love how I was kept informed of where my order was the entire time it was being processed. Very efficient service!
I love how I was kept informed of where my order was the entire time it was being processed. Very efficient service!
Joel
Review left Jan 16 2025
Review
I did not expect to get that much back from my cards but they proved me wrong
I did not expect to get that much back from my cards but they proved me wrong
Nick
Review left Jan 16 2025
Review
If you need money fast then this is the place for you.
If you need money fast then this is the place for you.
Eric
Review left Jan 15 2025
Review
made getting rid of unused cards easy, and able to reinvest in future purchases
made getting rid of unused cards easy, and able to reinvest in future purchases
Trenton Myers
Review left Jan 15 2025
Review
The process was simple and easy. The best way to sell your old cards, hands down. Not only was I pleased with the payout, the customer service was top notch and they made it easy. If I end up selling the rest of my cards, there's nowhere else I'd pick than Card Conduit.
The process was simple and easy. The best way to sell your old cards, hands down. Not only was I pleased with the payout, the customer service was top notch and they made it easy. If I end up selling the rest of my cards, there's nowhere else I'd pick than Card Conduit.
Donnie
Review left Jan 15 2025
Review
Overall the whole process of sending cards for sale is amazing! I had these old MTG cards i have moved from place to place. This time when moving i decided to see if i could sell them! Info on how to ship back cards was great! And it turns out i had $1400 worth of cards laying around! THANK YOU!!
Overall the whole process of sending cards for sale is amazing! I had these old MTG cards i have moved from place to place. This time when moving i decided to see if i could sell them! Info on how to ship back cards was great! And it turns out i had $1400 worth of cards laying around! THANK YOU!!
Deryk Frank
Review left Jan 15 2025
Review
The fact that I could sell my entire collection (apart from my decks) all in one go by shipping them to a single address and got a quick payout via Zelle is insane. Card Conduit is the GOAT fr.
The fact that I could sell my entire collection (apart from my decks) all in one go by shipping them to a single address and got a quick payout via Zelle is insane. Card Conduit is the GOAT fr.
Clay
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
I can't recommend this service highly enough. I found the collection estimate to be fairly accurate for my shipment and the response and payment time as quick as estimated. The updates and customer service were excellent and gave me a lot of confidence in the process. I'm going to use this again in the future and recommend to friends.
I can't recommend this service highly enough. I found the collection estimate to be fairly accurate for my shipment and the response and payment time as quick as estimated. The updates and customer service were excellent and gave me a lot of confidence in the process. I'm going to use this again in the future and recommend to friends.
Alex
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
I was very skeptical at first but the process was super easy. They were fair on the conditions of the cards and they amount they offered was right in line with what I thought I should get. Minimal effort on my end and it didn't take long at all to receive payment. I will be using them in the future to get rid of my higher end bulk.
I was very skeptical at first but the process was super easy. They were fair on the conditions of the cards and they amount they offered was right in line with what I thought I should get. Minimal effort on my end and it didn't take long at all to receive payment. I will be using them in the future to get rid of my higher end bulk.
Zach Boxley
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
I use card kingdom to sell cards, since tcgplayer stopped accepting trade ins. They're pretty slow, so I thought I'd try card conduit. The cards I sent started being verified right away, not a few days later. From the time they got the order of 119 cards until my direct deposit hit, I was only a wee
...
Read more
I use card kingdom to sell cards, since tcgplayer stopped accepting trade ins. They're pretty slow, so I thought I'd try card conduit. The cards I sent started being verified right away, not a few days later. From the time they got the order of 119 cards until my direct deposit hit, I was only a week start to finish. Very happy overall. Thank you, Card Conduit. I'll definitely use you again.
Harrison Howard
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
The whole process was smooth and simple, less than 2 weeks in total! I will definitely be using this service in the future for all my selling needs!
The whole process was smooth and simple, less than 2 weeks in total! I will definitely be using this service in the future for all my selling needs!
Christopher Alanis
Review left Jan 14 2025
Review
Sold cards on here a few times, the last couple gradings were fair, however this order was enough to make me want to look at other options. It was a played set for sure, but the high value cards, like cyclonic rift, were graded unfairly. I feel a bit robbed. Just wanted to let you know I got the sense cards were graded lower to cut costs from this order.
Sold cards on here a few times, the last couple gradings were fair, however this order was enough to make me want to look at other options. It was a played set for sure, but the high value cards, like cyclonic rift, were graded unfairly. I feel a bit robbed. Just wanted to let you know I got the sense cards were graded lower to cut costs from this order.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).