Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

Alex Egertsen
Review left Aug 25 2024
Shipment processed Aug 15 2024
$107.17 payout, $16.53 fees

Review

It felt pretty easy to ship and wait for process time.
It felt pretty easy to ship and wait for process time.
Ryan
Review left Aug 25 2024
Shipment processed Aug 15 2024
$572.51 payout, $51.23 fees

Review

Fairly quick overall, there was a brief COVID delay, but the communicated through that and finished my transaction within the allotted time provided. I would highly recommend.
Fairly quick overall, there was a brief COVID delay, but the communicated through that and finished my transaction within the allotted time provided. I would highly recommend.
Nicholas Ely
Review left Aug 24 2024
Shipment processed Aug 13 2024
$975.76 payout, $19.91 fees

Review

Easy porocess! Fantastic people, even communicated when there was a delay! Really appreciated the experience
Easy porocess! Fantastic people, even communicated when there was a delay! Really appreciated the experience
Matthew Berrey
Review left Aug 24 2024
Shipment processed Aug 17 2024
$3,291.81 payout, $60.34 fees

Review

The process was easy but to be honest I was projected a payout of $4,100 roughlly and ended up getting a payout of $3,200 and some change and I understand that the projected payout is just that "projected" but when I went through my list I made sure to pay extra close attention to the condition when ... Read more
The process was easy but to be honest I was projected a payout of $4,100 roughlly and ended up getting a payout of $3,200 and some change and I understand that the projected payout is just that "projected" but when I went through my list I made sure to pay extra close attention to the condition when I made the list and marked them accordingly to try and get a close to an accurate payout as possible and it ended up being $900 less than projected I wasn't super happy, and it seemed that a lot of the high value cards (even ones that I pulled from a pack and went into a seal sleeve immediately was marked down to HP and even in one case a DMG condition I do find that a little misleading, now at the time of writing this I haven't even gotten my payment yet which Im sure wont have an issues with or anything but I wish they would take pictures of the cards that I mark as NM or LP when they says its HP or DMG so I could see where they got that grading result from. I have been in the MTG community now for over 15 YRS and have been buying and selling cards the whole time and I'm by no means an expert but I would like to say I have a decent understanding of how to grade cards. I would have been happier to have paid a processing fee for them going trough it and them just sent me back the cards vs selling them at the price they gave me, I understand the terms and conditions for when I sent my cards to them but I WONT be using the service in the Future not without taking pitchers of them before hand so I can have a leg to stand on when they grade a card completely different then what I have it as
Joe
Review left Aug 24 2024
Shipment processed Aug 13 2024

Review

I've sold through Card Conduit multiple times, and every time has been incredibly easy. They communicate along the way (even reaching out to explain anything that is out of the ordinary or off-schedule) and always respond quickly. There's no other choice for selling cards, Card Conduit is by far the best option.
I've sold through Card Conduit multiple times, and every time has been incredibly easy. They communicate along the way (even reaching out to explain anything that is out of the ordinary or off-schedule) and always respond quickly. There's no other choice for selling cards, Card Conduit is by far the best option.
Nick Langner
Review left Aug 24 2024
Shipment processed Jul 18 2024

Review

Couldn't have asked for a better bulk card-selling service. Frequent communication throughout the process and clear attention to detail and care for the customer. Definitely made sure I got the best value for my collection. I would absolutely recommend Card Conduit to anyone interested in selling ca ... Read more
Couldn't have asked for a better bulk card-selling service. Frequent communication throughout the process and clear attention to detail and care for the customer. Definitely made sure I got the best value for my collection. I would absolutely recommend Card Conduit to anyone interested in selling cards and will keep them in mind if I ever have more cards to sell!
Nick Montebello
Review left Aug 24 2024
Shipment processed Aug 01 2024
$1,060.85 payout, $55.83 fees

Review

If you’re going to go through effort of making the curated shipment, you might as well go the extra mile and document the shipment as a buylist to pay the lower fees. Had this not been my first shipment I would have done that cause it was pretty much already done.

Grading was fair. The customer service was top notch.
If you’re going to go through effort of making the curated shipment, you might as well go the extra mile and document the shipment as a buylist to pay the lower fees. Had this not been my first shipment I would have done that cause it was pretty much already done.

Grading was fair. The customer service was top notch.
Ashley Bandurraga
Review left Aug 23 2024
Shipment processed Jul 23 2024
$282.27 payout, $5.76 fees

Review

Everything was great! Grading was fair and the payment was FAST! Love this team and this service!
Everything was great! Grading was fair and the payment was FAST! Love this team and this service!
David
Review left Aug 22 2024
Shipment processed Jul 19 2024
$680.46 payout, $12.47 fees

Review

Fast and amazing have used them before and will again
Fast and amazing have used them before and will again
Dan
Review left Aug 22 2024
Shipment processed Jul 19 2024
$114.63 payout, $2.34 fees

Review

Easy process, low fees. Very happy with the process.
Easy process, low fees. Very happy with the process.
Seth
Review left Aug 22 2024
Shipment processed Jul 27 2024
$805.19 payout, $42.38 fees

Review

Simple easy way to sell your magic cards. Their lookup tool is very easy to use to find your cards worth $1 or more and the unsorted shipping is fantastic for selling larger collections! I couldn't recommend Card Conduit more for how simple and easy this is!
Simple easy way to sell your magic cards. Their lookup tool is very easy to use to find your cards worth $1 or more and the unsorted shipping is fantastic for selling larger collections! I couldn't recommend Card Conduit more for how simple and easy this is!
Clinton Hall
Review left Aug 22 2024
Shipment processed Jul 11 2024
$258.01 payout, $161.59 fees

Review

It was almost too easy. I was surprised at how easy. The value was worth it, in my opinion. I got a fair price for my collection. I have recommended this service to a couple of people and would recommend it to others should the opportunity arise. Shout out to Nick! Thank you for all the communicatio ... Read more
It was almost too easy. I was surprised at how easy. The value was worth it, in my opinion. I got a fair price for my collection. I have recommended this service to a couple of people and would recommend it to others should the opportunity arise. Shout out to Nick! Thank you for all the communication you provided and keeping me fully informed about my order. Job well done to all the folks over at Card Conduit.
David
Review left Aug 22 2024
Shipment processed Aug 17 2024

Review

First order I sent was to test waters. This one was a few times bigger and both times I have been very pleased with time, communication, and payments
First order I sent was to test waters. This one was a few times bigger and both times I have been very pleased with time, communication, and payments
Swiss
Review left Aug 21 2024
Shipment processed Aug 06 2024
$566.85 payout, $11.57 fees

Review

My friend suggested I try out Card Conduit and I’m so glad I did! The process was incredibly easy! It didn’t take long at all to submit my sorted list. Shipping was a breeze and the return came sooner than expected! I will definitely be using these guys again!
My friend suggested I try out Card Conduit and I’m so glad I did! The process was incredibly easy! It didn’t take long at all to submit my sorted list. Shipping was a breeze and the return came sooner than expected! I will definitely be using these guys again!
Sierra
Review left Aug 21 2024
Shipment processed Aug 10 2024
$1,356.68 payout, $24.87 fees

Review

I choose to do a sorted shipment to get the lowest fee price and the process of adding the cards was very easy and I added cards over the course of a couple days. My payout was much higher than anywhere else I saw online or if I were to sell the cards to a game store.

They were fair to generous o ... Read more
I choose to do a sorted shipment to get the lowest fee price and the process of adding the cards was very easy and I added cards over the course of a couple days. My payout was much higher than anywhere else I saw online or if I were to sell the cards to a game store.

They were fair to generous on card condition.

I will definitely use this service again.
Tim
Review left Aug 21 2024
Shipment processed Aug 01 2024
$152.51 payout, $24.92 fees

Review

Thank you card conduit! I appreciate the convenient and quality service.
Thank you card conduit! I appreciate the convenient and quality service.
Reginald Eckert
Review left Aug 21 2024
Shipment processed Aug 16 2024
$2,201.44 payout, $116.92 fees

Review

I I like the way you guys do things the price of the prices though I feel that yeah that you go off the The very bare minimum of whatever the market value is I feel like some of the cards some of the really premier cards I feel like I could have got more on but overall I love you guys and I'm going ... Read more
I I like the way you guys do things the price of the prices though I feel that yeah that you go off the The very bare minimum of whatever the market value is I feel like some of the cards some of the really premier cards I feel like I could have got more on but overall I love you guys and I'm going to continue business with you guys I appreciate everything you do you guys are awesome
Camden B.
Review left Aug 21 2024
Shipment processed Aug 10 2024
$1,028.99 payout, $48.48 fees

Review

Made the card selling process a breeze, and helped me save money! These guys are great, customer service is phenomenal. 5/5 would highly recommend.
Made the card selling process a breeze, and helped me save money! These guys are great, customer service is phenomenal. 5/5 would highly recommend.
Conner Guntharp
Review left Aug 21 2024
Shipment processed Aug 10 2024
$459.31 payout, $9.37 fees

Review

The process was easy and simple. They keep me updated as my shipment progress and any delays. Overall was an excellent service and communication. Will use them again in the future.
The process was easy and simple. They keep me updated as my shipment progress and any delays. Overall was an excellent service and communication. Will use them again in the future.
Lance
Review left Aug 20 2024
Shipment processed Aug 10 2024
$1,379.13 payout, $72.59 fees

Review

Everything went fine. I’m the kind of person who says “no complaints” when things go smoothly, and this whole process truly went smoothly.
Everything went fine. I’m the kind of person who says “no complaints” when things go smoothly, and this whole process truly went smoothly.
1 2 ... 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 ... 293 294
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).