Chat with us

Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service

(2710)
Michael Bremer
Review left Nov 02 2022
Shipment processed Oct 22 2022
$1,024.95 payout, $48.29 fees

Review

Got a great value on my cards, process was very easy and grading was generous
Got a great value on my cards, process was very easy and grading was generous
Rolando Lemus
Review left Oct 25 2022
Shipment processed Oct 20 2022
$971.43 payout, $17.80 fees

Review

Not only was this easy it was stress free and every step was updated in a timely fashion any time I had a question I got a response and my worries were answered clearly and professionally. I sent a relatively big lot for my first order and even so the turn around time was about a business week which ... Read more
Not only was this easy it was stress free and every step was updated in a timely fashion any time I had a question I got a response and my worries were answered clearly and professionally. I sent a relatively big lot for my first order and even so the turn around time was about a business week which is way better then expected 10/10 would recommend to ANYONE with extra singles you've no idea what to do with
Craig
Review left Aug 29 2022
Shipment processed Aug 18 2022
$2,043.51 payout, $37.46 fees

Review

I decided to try out the service per a friend's recommendation. The fee structure seems very fair and I really enjoyed that it was adjustable based on how much work I was willing to put in. I had read ahead of time that the grading can be a bit harsh but appreciated that they provided estimates of t ... Read more
I decided to try out the service per a friend's recommendation. The fee structure seems very fair and I really enjoyed that it was adjustable based on how much work I was willing to put in. I had read ahead of time that the grading can be a bit harsh but appreciated that they provided estimates of the collection at each tier. My personal expectation had been that I'd land right between the LP and MP estimates (guessed the cards would be 50/50) - and that was exactly where I ended up for payout in the end. Realistically had I listed the cards myself I would have knocked them all down a grade anyways to cover myself anyways. Being able to save the time, headache, and cost of listing, packaging, and shipping almost 300 cards was more than worth the fees to me. Will definitely use this service again in the future.
Nic
Review left Aug 16 2022
Shipment processed Aug 03 2022
$3,007.21 payout, $158.27 fees

Review

By far the best experience I’ve had selling cards. Fast, Easy and good communication.
By far the best experience I’ve had selling cards. Fast, Easy and good communication.
Michael Beauchemin
Review left Aug 09 2022
Shipment processed Aug 04 2022
$5,272.93 payout, $248.46 fees

Review

CARD CONDUIT is legit !!!!
I had roughly give or take 45 sets of Magic cards.I looked everywhere and without putting in an overabundance of work was not able to find a place to give me the value that I wanted for my collection. I stumbled across Card Conduit online...I was apprehensive about maili ... Read more
CARD CONDUIT is legit !!!!
I had roughly give or take 45 sets of Magic cards.I looked everywhere and without putting in an overabundance of work was not able to find a place to give me the value that I wanted for my collection. I stumbled across Card Conduit online...I was apprehensive about mailing out rares and mythics to a place I knew nothing about.
After reading reviews and getting more info I decided to mail them my cards and they turned my cards into cash....I couldn't be happier with the service they provide.As I type this I have 4 more shipments headed their way....I highly recommend them as they communicate well and process shipments quickly....As you guys know it takes time to sort through Magic cards and these guys take the legwork out and do it for you ! Not only that... they provide you with a spreadsheet with the card values and highlights of the transaction. So glad I used them....GREAT EXPERIENCE.
Bryan H Lonn
Review left Aug 05 2022
Shipment processed Jul 13 2022
$378.38 payout, $19.91 fees

Review

I have used Card Conduit several times now and they are not only trustworthy with your cards but give you the best deal possible with your Magic the Gathering collections. I have several jobs and do not have time to sell my MTG cards on my own and used their service to help reduce my massive collection. Thanks Card Conduit!
I have used Card Conduit several times now and they are not only trustworthy with your cards but give you the best deal possible with your Magic the Gathering collections. I have several jobs and do not have time to sell my MTG cards on my own and used their service to help reduce my massive collection. Thanks Card Conduit!
Michael Jardine
Review left Jun 18 2022
Shipment processed May 14 2022
$2,375.54 payout, $111.93 fees

Review

I took the curated option which I can definitely recommend. You do have to dig through your cards and pull out the ones that meet the price point but that's still less work than actually buylisting and finding the best deal yourself. Instead , I can rest easy knowing cardconduit found the best deal for me.
I took the curated option which I can definitely recommend. You do have to dig through your cards and pull out the ones that meet the price point but that's still less work than actually buylisting and finding the best deal yourself. Instead , I can rest easy knowing cardconduit found the best deal for me.
Greg
Review left May 25 2022
Shipment processed May 14 2022
$5,156.07 payout, $242.95 fees

Review

Simple, clear, fair, and thorough. I had information about every step. Never felt in the dark, felt like there was real time put into my order specifically. I could never have made the money I made on my own, given that stamps, envelopes, and top loaders don’t just appear in my house.
Simple, clear, fair, and thorough. I had information about every step. Never felt in the dark, felt like there was real time put into my order specifically. I could never have made the money I made on my own, given that stamps, envelopes, and top loaders don’t just appear in my house.
DR
Review left May 23 2022
Shipment processed May 07 2022
$4,757.60 payout, $224.18 fees

Review

I am INSANELY impressed with their services. I got a whole lot more than what I initially thought and customer service was both professional and honest. I was super nervous shipping my prized collection across the country for grading but now that I've done it once, I wouldn't hesitate to use Card Conduit again!
I am INSANELY impressed with their services. I got a whole lot more than what I initially thought and customer service was both professional and honest. I was super nervous shipping my prized collection across the country for grading but now that I've done it once, I wouldn't hesitate to use Card Conduit again!
Tom
Review left May 18 2022
Shipment processed Apr 13 2022
$910.26 payout, $42.89 fees

Review

I was a pleasantly pleased with the fairness, and quickness of their process. Like many people who have played magic for 20+ years, I have way too many cards. I also don't have the time or desire to individually list cards. Card Conduit did it for me in an efficient manner. You get updates ... Read more
I was a pleasantly pleased with the fairness, and quickness of their process. Like many people who have played magic for 20+ years, I have way too many cards. I also don't have the time or desire to individually list cards. Card Conduit did it for me in an efficient manner. You get updates all along the way, so you know exactly where they are in the process. I was so pleased, that so far, I have completed 4 shipments with them.
Peter miller
Review left May 17 2022
Shipment processed May 10 2022
$499.89 payout, $26.31 fees

Review

Easy. seriously EXCELLENT communication. Like the best every step of the way. Fair grading and easy process. HIGHLY recommended.
Easy. seriously EXCELLENT communication. Like the best every step of the way. Fair grading and easy process. HIGHLY recommended.
Dan
Review left May 11 2022
Shipment processed Apr 15 2022
$665.82 payout, $31.37 fees

Review

I've held on to some old cards from ages ago and never had the time to file through them all and sell them. When the opportunity to have someone else do it for me came, I was all about that. After a few hours of scanning in cards, I was able to put together two shipments (one cultivated, one not). I ... Read more
I've held on to some old cards from ages ago and never had the time to file through them all and sell them. When the opportunity to have someone else do it for me came, I was all about that. After a few hours of scanning in cards, I was able to put together two shipments (one cultivated, one not). It was made extra easy because I was able to send both in the same package, properly labelled. I was nervous about sending over $500 worth of cards in the mail, but once it arrived, Card Conduit kept me up to date on everything that was happening with the collections. They were quick and efficient and in the end I feel 100% that I made more selling to them than my time was worth doing it myself. Thank you, Card Conduit, for your business!
Jared
Review left May 09 2022
Shipment processed Apr 26 2022
$2,494.97 payout, $131.31 fees

Review

I was looking to sell my Magic collection for a while and thankfully found out about Card Conduit via Reddit. This site and service is great! I’m very satisfied with the amount I received for the bulk of my collection, and Card Conduit was very transparent throughout the entire process. I will def ... Read more
I was looking to sell my Magic collection for a while and thankfully found out about Card Conduit via Reddit. This site and service is great! I’m very satisfied with the amount I received for the bulk of my collection, and Card Conduit was very transparent throughout the entire process. I will definitely recommend these guys to all my Magic friends and family.
Jay Natale
Review left May 07 2022
Shipment processed Apr 26 2022
$2,120.51 payout, $99.92 fees

Review

Super simple and stress free. Only company I trust
Super simple and stress free. Only company I trust
Joe Rico
Review left May 06 2022
Shipment processed Apr 13 2022
$27,326.23 payout, $1,287.62 fees

Review

I never really collected Magic Cards; I played the game. But I am so much into the limited format that I did accumulate a lot of cards. I did get some of the Power Nine when I made a brief foray into what was then called Type One Constructed (a format that was basically anything not Standard). Wh ... Read more
I never really collected Magic Cards; I played the game. But I am so much into the limited format that I did accumulate a lot of cards. I did get some of the Power Nine when I made a brief foray into what was then called Type One Constructed (a format that was basically anything not Standard). When I wanted to sell them, I had no idea what they were worth. I had sold them on my own. I would have overpriced them and upset potential buyers. Card Conduit priced them efficiently, accurately and quickly moved them. Very satisfied.
John
Review left Apr 28 2022
Shipment processed Apr 16 2022
$1,099.74 payout, $57.88 fees

Review

Everything about the process was amazing. The communication with the company was great from start to finish, all cards were graded fairly and quickly and payment was very quick as well. I really couldn’t have asked for a better experience, card conduit is a truly great service!
Everything about the process was amazing. The communication with the company was great from start to finish, all cards were graded fairly and quickly and payment was very quick as well. I really couldn’t have asked for a better experience, card conduit is a truly great service!
Jaden Fowers
Review left Apr 21 2022
Shipment processed Apr 09 2022
$650.11 payout, $116.15 fees

Review

Would definitely recommend if trying to get rid of a big collection! Quick and easy process, and I got the highest payout I’ve gotten from any other sites
Would definitely recommend if trying to get rid of a big collection! Quick and easy process, and I got the highest payout I’ve gotten from any other sites
Ben Eddings
Review left Apr 19 2022
Shipment processed Apr 06 2022
$2,416.23 payout, $127.17 fees

Review

Amazing service, communication, and team of people! I couldn't be more impressed with the level of communication, speed of processing, and ease of the process! I will be using Card Conduit in the future and highly recommend!
Amazing service, communication, and team of people! I couldn't be more impressed with the level of communication, speed of processing, and ease of the process! I will be using Card Conduit in the future and highly recommend!
William O
Review left Apr 19 2022
Shipment processed Mar 19 2022
$16,000.29 payout, $842.12 fees

Review

This place is top notch, they delivered on all expectations. I sent over my pride and Joy, a large collection. They processed it and had me paid in the time frame quoted.

Thanks again!
This place is top notch, they delivered on all expectations. I sent over my pride and Joy, a large collection. They processed it and had me paid in the time frame quoted.

Thanks again!
Logan
Review left Apr 18 2022
Shipment processed Mar 29 2022
$912.85 payout, $43.01 fees

Review

Got great value for all my cards. Best prices I have seen for buylisting especially for cash. Customer service was responsive and answered all my questions really quickly.
Got great value for all my cards. Best prices I have seen for buylisting especially for cash. Customer service was responsive and answered all my questions really quickly.
1 2 3 4 5
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every previous customer to leave a review. Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page. We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).