Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

Normally when people online say it's the best thing every they're exaggerating or being hyperbolic. This is not one of those cases.
My five packages arrived damaged due to negligence on USPS's part. When trying to get the purchased insurance they gave me the run around and didn't end up reimbursing ... Read more

Normally when people online say it's the best thing every they're exaggerating or being hyperbolic. This is not one of those cases.
My five packages arrived damaged due to negligence on USPS's part. When trying to get the purchased insurance they gave me the run around and didn't end up reimbursing me. The person working on my orders took and sent pictures unprompted, asked how I would like to proceed, called me to go over options, and proceeded. He even recommended that I change my order settings so as to get more value for my cards that remained after the damage. Once my orders were done processing, he then further ruined me for other customer service by giving me a discount on the processing fees to help me recoup the shipping costs since USPS wouldn't honor the insurance. I could have asked for better help but I wouldn't have gotten it as this was the best that anyone could have ever done. No one would go wrong when working with them.

Normally when people online say it's the best thing every they're exaggerating or being hyperbolic. This is not one of those cases.
My five packages arrived damaged due to negligence on USPS's part. When trying to get the purchased insurance they gave me the run around and didn't end up reimbursing ... Read more

Normally when people online say it's the best thing every they're exaggerating or being hyperbolic. This is not one of those cases.
My five packages arrived damaged due to negligence on USPS's part. When trying to get the purchased insurance they gave me the run around and didn't end up reimbursing me. The person working on my orders took and sent pictures unprompted, asked how I would like to proceed, called me to go over options, and proceeded. He even recommended that I change my order settings so as to get more value for my cards that remained after the damage. Once my orders were done processing, he then further ruined me for other customer service by giving me a discount on the processing fees to help me recoup the shipping costs since USPS wouldn't honor the insurance. I could have asked for better help but I wouldn't have gotten it as this was the best that anyone could have ever done. No one would go wrong when working with them.

Normally when people online say it's the best thing every they're exaggerating or being hyperbolic. This is not one of those cases.
My five packages arrived damaged due to negligence on USPS's part. When trying to get the purchased insurance they gave me the run around and didn't end up reimbursing ... Read more

Normally when people online say it's the best thing every they're exaggerating or being hyperbolic. This is not one of those cases.
My five packages arrived damaged due to negligence on USPS's part. When trying to get the purchased insurance they gave me the run around and didn't end up reimbursing me. The person working on my orders took and sent pictures unprompted, asked how I would like to proceed, called me to go over options, and proceeded. He even recommended that I change my order settings so as to get more value for my cards that remained after the damage. Once my orders were done processing, he then further ruined me for other customer service by giving me a discount on the processing fees to help me recoup the shipping costs since USPS wouldn't honor the insurance. I could have asked for better help but I wouldn't have gotten it as this was the best that anyone could have ever done. No one would go wrong when working with them.

This service is really helping me to Shape up my collection. The more cards I send here the more organized my collection gets, thanks CC

This service is really helping me to Shape up my collection. The more cards I send here the more organized my collection gets, thanks CC

Service was fast and easy. They answered all the questions I had and gave a nice detail report on all the cards you shipped out. I was very happy with them as I didn’t want to wait months and months selling them
On my own.

Service was fast and easy. They answered all the questions I had and gave a nice detail report on all the cards you shipped out. I was very happy with them as I didn’t want to wait months and months selling them
On my own.

Home run, 5 stars. This process was extremely simple and provided me tracking and info for each step along the way. I was given one on one personal feedback about the cards I sent them and what they’re worth and got a great value without having to post everything on eBay. I recommend Card Conduit to everyone and plan on using them again.

Home run, 5 stars. This process was extremely simple and provided me tracking and info for each step along the way. I was given one on one personal feedback about the cards I sent them and what they’re worth and got a great value without having to post everything on eBay. I recommend Card Conduit to everyone and plan on using them again.

This process was so easy. No dealing with shop owners etc. They handle everything and get me best profit

This process was so easy. No dealing with shop owners etc. They handle everything and get me best profit

I boxed up 4x 400ct boxes into a medium flat rate mailer as suggested in the shipping section. Accidentally included a box i was deck brewing by mistake, and they mailed that box back to me. Super responsive via email and answered all my questions. I'd highly recommend Card Conduit, it was a perfe ... Read more

I boxed up 4x 400ct boxes into a medium flat rate mailer as suggested in the shipping section. Accidentally included a box i was deck brewing by mistake, and they mailed that box back to me. Super responsive via email and answered all my questions. I'd highly recommend Card Conduit, it was a perfect solution for me as i am too busy and would never have been able to buy list and sort these cards myself. I will be sending more boxes shortly

I would highly suggest this service to anyone looking to sell. Great prices, great service, quick payment, and an easy-to-use website.
Every part of this process was made easier by an incredible user interface on the website. Additionally, the customer service was fantastic, with timely replies.
... Read more

I would highly suggest this service to anyone looking to sell. Great prices, great service, quick payment, and an easy-to-use website.
Every part of this process was made easier by an incredible user interface on the website. Additionally, the customer service was fantastic, with timely replies.
There is also an immense amount of transparency as they grade the cards. Card Conduit gave an in-depth report after all the grading is completed with regards to card quality and price.
If I ever have to sell cards in the future, it will be here.

I've sold with CFBs old you-box-we-buy program before, but this knocked it out of the park. Way better prices, and I love the stats pages you get at the end. Definitely going to use this in the future, especially with the option to split between curated/noncurated

I've sold with CFBs old you-box-we-buy program before, but this knocked it out of the park. Way better prices, and I love the stats pages you get at the end. Definitely going to use this in the future, especially with the option to split between curated/noncurated

The process is very easy. Just separate the "wheat" from the "chaff" and send it in.
The amount they paid me for the cards was completely reasonable. I sent in only rares worth less than two dollars and wasn't expecting too much. What I got is more than I would have gotten trying to sell them to a ... Read more

The process is very easy. Just separate the "wheat" from the "chaff" and send it in.
The amount they paid me for the cards was completely reasonable. I sent in only rares worth less than two dollars and wasn't expecting too much. What I got is more than I would have gotten trying to sell them to a local store.
I definitely would recommend this as a way to sell large quantities of cards.

The process was very efficient. I look forward to working with Card Conduit in the future.

The process was very efficient. I look forward to working with Card Conduit in the future.

Easy, Great Value, and Very Fast! Exceeded my expectations!

Easy, Great Value, and Very Fast! Exceeded my expectations!

I chose to do a curated shipment of a smaller quantity to test out the full process and I was more than happy with the communication and payout. Plan on using the service in the future.

I chose to do a curated shipment of a smaller quantity to test out the full process and I was more than happy with the communication and payout. Plan on using the service in the future.

Honestly when I was looking to sell my cards I wasn't expecting too much, I was expecting for people to try to rip me off or to get haggled relentlessly. That's why I'm glad I found Card Conduit. They went above and beyond anything I was expecting, having a great support team and providing me with r ... Read more

Honestly when I was looking to sell my cards I wasn't expecting too much, I was expecting for people to try to rip me off or to get haggled relentlessly. That's why I'm glad I found Card Conduit. They went above and beyond anything I was expecting, having a great support team and providing me with reports about why they were offering me what they did. The reports also help sow trust because you see all the cards you sent on the sheet with their values and conditions. I'd love to say I'd use this service again but I did send what was left of my collection, so instead I'll recommend anyone looking to sell some or all of their cards.

I had learned about CC from a couple of internet searches looking for a way to sell my MTG cards en masse. The idea of selling cards individually online is a daunting task, especially with having to consider grading ahead of time. CC made it a lot easier with their collection estimate tool. Based ... Read more

I had learned about CC from a couple of internet searches looking for a way to sell my MTG cards en masse. The idea of selling cards individually online is a daunting task, especially with having to consider grading ahead of time. CC made it a lot easier with their collection estimate tool. Based on the condition of my cards and the estimate given, I would say it was a very accurate readout, and now I'm several rares and foils lighter with some money in my pockets! Very good service and I definitely recommend it to someone looking to sell.

Pros:
This was by far the fastest and easiest way I've ever sold cards. Payment was in my account in about 7 business days, but you may have a longer wait if you're sending a huge collection. As someone that used to purchase collections and sell them piecemeal on a marketplace, it never made sense ... Read more

Pros:
This was by far the fastest and easiest way I've ever sold cards. Payment was in my account in about 7 business days, but you may have a longer wait if you're sending a huge collection. As someone that used to purchase collections and sell them piecemeal on a marketplace, it never made sense to sell my $2-5 cards after shipping costs, fees, and all the hassle. This service is a no-brainer for anyone selling cheapish bulk staples; for a lot of cards in this range I made more selling through CardConduit than I could have made selling them myself. I can't imagine selling cards worth less than $10 any other way.

Cons:
The main con is that I think this service is mostly designed for curated collections. While I used both the curated and non-curated options, I still went through my collection and picked out cards I knew had at least some value. If you open a case or two of the newest standard set and send in all the commons and uncommons, you're probably not going to have a great result since bulk cards will have negative value.

Neither of these are CardConduit's fault and are just a function buylisting, but there are two things to be aware of:
1. The spread between retail prices and buylist prices can get pretty large on expensive cards. If you sell cards yourself, you can expect roughly 10-15% less than retail plus whatever you spend on shipping. With buylisting you can easily take a 50% haircut. For expensive singles (think $50+ retail), you might be better off selling them yourself.
2. Different stores/buylists have significantly different grading definitions. One particularly large marketplace is pretty loosey goosey with their grades. You can sell some fairly beat up stuff as LP and really beat up stuff as MP (I mean, they allow creases as MP) within their grading scheme. Other places are more strict, so CardConduit has to be more strict than someone selling on that marketplace.

Pros:
This was by far the fastest and easiest way I've ever sold cards. Payment was in my account in about 7 business days, but you may have a longer wait if you're sending a huge collection. As someone that used to purchase collections and sell them piecemeal on a marketplace, it never made sense ... Read more

Pros:
This was by far the fastest and easiest way I've ever sold cards. Payment was in my account in about 7 business days, but you may have a longer wait if you're sending a huge collection. As someone that used to purchase collections and sell them piecemeal on a marketplace, it never made sense to sell my $2-5 cards after shipping costs, fees, and all the hassle. This service is a no-brainer for anyone selling cheapish bulk staples; for a lot of cards in this range I made more selling through CardConduit than I could have made selling them myself. I can't imagine selling cards worth less than $10 any other way.

Cons:
The main con is that I think this service is mostly designed for curated collections. While I used both the curated and non-curated options, I still went through my collection and picked out cards I knew had at least some value. If you open a case or two of the newest standard set and send in all the commons and uncommons, you're probably not going to have a great result since bulk cards will have negative value.

Neither of these are CardConduit's fault and are just a function buylisting, but there are two things to be aware of:
1. The spread between retail prices and buylist prices can get pretty large on expensive cards. If you sell cards yourself, you can expect roughly 10-15% less than retail plus whatever you spend on shipping. With buylisting you can easily take a 50% haircut. For expensive singles (think $50+ retail), you might be better off selling them yourself.
2. Different stores/buylists have significantly different grading definitions. One particularly large marketplace is pretty loosey goosey with their grades. You can sell some fairly beat up stuff as LP and really beat up stuff as MP (I mean, they allow creases as MP) within their grading scheme. Other places are more strict, so CardConduit has to be more strict than someone selling on that marketplace.

I have tried to buylist cards before and it was hassle, this was super smooth and quick. I will probably do it again someday if I choose to downsize my collection more.

I have tried to buylist cards before and it was hassle, this was super smooth and quick. I will probably do it again someday if I choose to downsize my collection more.

Again, super reliable service and extremely convenient.

Again, super reliable service and extremely convenient.