Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

1,862 cards total, 4 separate sorted shipments.

I want to start by saying their service is exceptional! Those who value time will appreciate this service. The grading was on par with what I believe my card conditions are, and my friends and I know how subjective I am when it comes to condition. I had 1 damaged card in the shipment, and they nailed it. Hailey was also very helpful over email and gave me clear explanations whenever I had questions.
I was initially hesitant to send my cards in because of reviews saying they tend to downgrade conditions. That was not my experience at all, especially because I know my cards intimately.

A WARNING for submitters: after your cards have been graded and processed, if you want more than 15 cards returned (around 90 in my case), it is a show stopper. They will not grant the request and would rather send the entire shipment back. I had explained that the majority of my list was on one spreadsheet, but that was disregarded. I asked if there was a limit on returns and was told via email that there is a 15-card limit. I wish I had known about this beforehand, as I could not find that information on their webpage.
It does sadden me that I could not get my childhood cards back. I still can't wrap my head around why they can't remove requested cards from a sorted list that I sorted, but would instead ship the entire order back so I can remove them and then resubmit everything for the entire process again. Maybe it's a tedious process...I don't know.
Regardless, I decided to let it go and move on. Someone else will enjoy my nice vintage foils, and I'm glad of that.

Thank you, Card Conduit, for responding to me during the issue. I hope in the future you can develop a system that allows more than 15 cards to be removed from a sorted list.

TL;DR: Great service, fair grading, and Hailey was very helpful. Just know that if you want more than 15 cards returned, forget about it.