Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6084)
Matthew Graham
Review left Apr 29 2025
Review
The process is straightforward, the payout is great, and the detailed breakdown in the end was my favorite part. I've got another shipment inbound lol.
The process is straightforward, the payout is great, and the detailed breakdown in the end was my favorite part. I've got another shipment inbound lol.
Adam C
Review left Apr 29 2025
Shipment processed Apr 19 2025
$3,117.32
payout, $164.07
fees
Review
I did the Curated option for my shipment and it was well worth it. Card Conduit worked quickly, had great communication, and gave me much better value than I expected to receive. Would heartily recommend to anyone looking to move their collection.
I did the Curated option for my shipment and it was well worth it. Card Conduit worked quickly, had great communication, and gave me much better value than I expected to receive. Would heartily recommend to anyone looking to move their collection.
Joseph
Review left Apr 29 2025
Review
Easy process in general. Good instructions. Would recommend
Easy process in general. Good instructions. Would recommend
Nick P
Review left Apr 29 2025
Review
I needed to cash out some of my collection - I was impressed with the process. One of the cards I intended to sell was speculated to be unbanned in EDH, and I went to sell it 3 weeks before the announcement.
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went ... Read more
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went ... Read more
I needed to cash out some of my collection - I was impressed with the process. One of the cards I intended to sell was speculated to be unbanned in EDH, and I went to sell it 3 weeks before the announcement.
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went from $550 to $450 right after the anounvement that my card was NOT unbanned.
They gave me the price of my list, and the price they offered for that card in particular was ridiculous: 20% of its original estimated value.
I felt pretty betrayed, so I reached out, and not only did customer service inform me of why the price change occured (their prices are based directly on market value), they offered a better deal (70%) and offered to send it back no questions asked.
I loved the transparency, the experience went well - if a bit more lengthy than I'd like.
The processing time stretched out, and I watched as the estimated value of my order went from $550 to $450 right after the anounvement that my card was NOT unbanned.
They gave me the price of my list, and the price they offered for that card in particular was ridiculous: 20% of its original estimated value.
I felt pretty betrayed, so I reached out, and not only did customer service inform me of why the price change occured (their prices are based directly on market value), they offered a better deal (70%) and offered to send it back no questions asked.
I loved the transparency, the experience went well - if a bit more lengthy than I'd like.
Prajit Deb
Review left Apr 29 2025
Shipment processed Apr 25 2025
Review
I am a returning customer and have always received fantastic communication, support, and service from the Card Conduit Team, particularly from Nathaniel and Nick. Highly recommend.
I am a returning customer and have always received fantastic communication, support, and service from the Card Conduit Team, particularly from Nathaniel and Nick. Highly recommend.
Daniel
Review left Apr 27 2025
Review
The process was easy, automated, timely, and as advertised.
The process was easy, automated, timely, and as advertised.
Tyler B
Review left Apr 26 2025
Review
Very easy process, great customer service, and still competitive rates on top of all that. If your looking to offload some or all of your collection, you can't go wrong with Card Conduit.
Very easy process, great customer service, and still competitive rates on top of all that. If your looking to offload some or all of your collection, you can't go wrong with Card Conduit.
Anthony McClellan
Review left Apr 25 2025
Review
Love the business model. They are incentivised to get top dollar for your cards since their payout is a percentage of the total. The itemized report shows which cards were poor condition and how much they pay for each specific card. Very easy and fair way to sell your MTG cards.
Love the business model. They are incentivised to get top dollar for your cards since their payout is a percentage of the total. The itemized report shows which cards were poor condition and how much they pay for each specific card. Very easy and fair way to sell your MTG cards.
Random Customer
Review left Apr 25 2025
Shipment processed Apr 24 2025
Review
Would recommend this service - great pricing, quick turnaround, easy payment with Zelle.
Would recommend this service - great pricing, quick turnaround, easy payment with Zelle.
Steven McDougall
Review left Apr 25 2025
Shipment processed Apr 12 2025
Review
The process was incredibly easy and had a lot of support from the Card Conduit team. Even in looking into a question about a grading decision, there was collaboration and understanding. Very fair and fast payout once the shipment was received. Will definitely recommend! Thank you!
The process was incredibly easy and had a lot of support from the Card Conduit team. Even in looking into a question about a grading decision, there was collaboration and understanding. Very fair and fast payout once the shipment was received. Will definitely recommend! Thank you!
Ryan Reed
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
Thank You! Always easy to deal with. Will continue to use this service
Thank You! Always easy to deal with. Will continue to use this service
Jared
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
Card Conduit offered detailed instructions and an unbelievably simple interface to create a pipeline from shipping to payout! Their appraisals were fair and included a personal touch every step of the way. I highly recommend this service to anyone interested in selling Magic: The Gathering cards, an
...
Read more
Card Conduit offered detailed instructions and an unbelievably simple interface to create a pipeline from shipping to payout! Their appraisals were fair and included a personal touch every step of the way. I highly recommend this service to anyone interested in selling Magic: The Gathering cards, and I personally look forward to doing business with them again!
LMB
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
Swift processing and fair pricing, I truly appreciate Card Conduit!
Swift processing and fair pricing, I truly appreciate Card Conduit!
Casey K
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
Prices are always close to accurate and swift to pay. Can't recommend card conduit enough!
Prices are always close to accurate and swift to pay. Can't recommend card conduit enough!
Kyle
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
Great value for my cards. Love these guys. Will definitely use them again!
Great value for my cards. Love these guys. Will definitely use them again!
Ryan V
Review left Apr 24 2025
Shipment processed Mar 20 2025
Review
I would highly recommend this service to anyone interested. I found some of the initial menus and organization to be a little convoluted at times, but still an overall pleasant experience with avtive communication from the team and updates as to the current status of their service and payment.
I would highly recommend this service to anyone interested. I found some of the initial menus and organization to be a little convoluted at times, but still an overall pleasant experience with avtive communication from the team and updates as to the current status of their service and payment.
Tim Law
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
Such a. Great process makes things easy for the value thank you
Such a. Great process makes things easy for the value thank you
Jason
Review left Apr 24 2025
Review
The process was easy and transparent - I essentially got the payout the calculator promised. We had some issues with shipping (not CC's fault) and some resulting communication delays (which does fall on them) but they were quick to act once the issue was noticed and provided personalized support and
...
Read more
The process was easy and transparent - I essentially got the payout the calculator promised. We had some issues with shipping (not CC's fault) and some resulting communication delays (which does fall on them) but they were quick to act once the issue was noticed and provided personalized support and photos of the packaging and damage. Thankfully little to nothing affected the cards and payout was quick.
Dan P
Review left Apr 23 2025
Review
Very well designed and thoughtful process. Would and have recommended to friends and family.
Very well designed and thoughtful process. Would and have recommended to friends and family.
Antonio
Review left Apr 23 2025
Shipment processed Apr 12 2025
Review
Dealing with CC was fast and easy. Best online card selling experience I have dealt with.
Dealing with CC was fast and easy. Best online card selling experience I have dealt with.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).