Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

I looked at every avenue to sell my cards and it seemed like selling them online was the highest paying route unless I were to personally sell them myself thru TCG Player or something, which would be A LOT of work. When I compared online selling sites, (Card Conduit, Card Kingdom, and Star City Games to name a few) I noticed Card Conduit just genuinely quoted me several hundred more for my cards. It was also the easiest to input my collection. I was worried I would get nowhere near what they quoted as that was assuming all NM quality, which I knew I had a good chunk of it being near NM, but definitely some older cards that had seen some play over the years. But they delivered, My original quote was for ~$3700 (assuming all NM) and they had offered me $3500 for it. I even went through their grades and all of them were completely fair. All MP / HP graded cards were older ones that I remember having a bit of wear. I shipped them about 700 cards, it was a little weird at first that it was saying 500 cards max per order (the stats are for first 500 cards), but its honestly not that bad considering it will split your cards for you and you just have to make a 2nd order. You can have both orders in the same box with a divider. This isn't Card Conduit's fault obviously, but it was pretty expensive to ship my box of cards to them. But I did make them load it up with bubble wrap and all sorts of stuff, and also do fragile shipment. The cost was in the $60-$70 range to do all that. I definitely could have saved some by just fully packing it myself probably. But all this did was reassure myself that if I sold my collection individually thru TCG Player, I'd probably be spending a lot more than I realize on shipping every single order. So if you want a quick and painless way to sell your collection, Card Conduit is straight up the best way. They're the most fair on their prices and their grading. Give em a shot, you won't regret it!