Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
R.J.
Review left Jun 20 2025
Shipment processed Jun 07 2025
Review
The process was well explained and the step by step manner of actions was easy to understand and commplete. Overalll i would highly recommend this company to others looking to sell their Magic The Gathering cards.
The process was well explained and the step by step manner of actions was easy to understand and commplete. Overalll i would highly recommend this company to others looking to sell their Magic The Gathering cards.
Nate Rumrill
Review left Jun 20 2025
Review
We were able to move a large portion of cards that weren't moving quickly online.
We were able to move a large portion of cards that weren't moving quickly online.
Nick
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
Process was very easy and smooth -- I had already organized my cards so used that option. The guys/girls were highly responsive, even so much as to respond after hours and on weekends. They were transparent and I would absolutely recommend using them and will likely do so again in the future. They are the best and fastest way to sell cards.
Process was very easy and smooth -- I had already organized my cards so used that option. The guys/girls were highly responsive, even so much as to respond after hours and on weekends. They were transparent and I would absolutely recommend using them and will likely do so again in the future. They are the best and fastest way to sell cards.
Heather
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
We recently sent in my son’s Magic: The Gathering cards to Card Conduit, and the entire process was smooth and professional from start to finish. They sorted, priced, and paid out faster than we expected—and the final payout was very fair, even generous. It saved us the hassle of trying to sell
...
Read more
We recently sent in my son’s Magic: The Gathering cards to Card Conduit, and the entire process was smooth and professional from start to finish. They sorted, priced, and paid out faster than we expected—and the final payout was very fair, even generous. It saved us the hassle of trying to sell everything individually, and the transparency throughout the process gave us peace of mind. Excellent service all around. We’ll definitely use them again and recommend them to anyone looking to sell their MTG cards!
Julie
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
Easy process, I did two different shipments and was happy with the payout I received. Much easier to buylisting through my LGS.
Easy process, I did two different shipments and was happy with the payout I received. Much easier to buylisting through my LGS.
Max Luna
Review left Jun 19 2025
Review
This was the biggest payout and I have to agree with the prices I see on the reports. Best service for Magic cards.
This was the biggest payout and I have to agree with the prices I see on the reports. Best service for Magic cards.
Jen
Review left Jun 18 2025
Shipment processed Jun 07 2025
Review
They were timely helpful and direct, I look forward to working with them again.
They were timely helpful and direct, I look forward to working with them again.
Andrew Tardie
Review left Jun 18 2025
Review
Quick and Easy Processing, Hassle Free, Great Value and Friendly Customer Support
Quick and Easy Processing, Hassle Free, Great Value and Friendly Customer Support
Eric S.
Review left Jun 18 2025
Review
This was my third shipment with card conduit and, as always, I got reasonable price estimates for my cards. Payout was quick and easy. I will continue using card conduit to sell cards I don’t need anymore.
This was my third shipment with card conduit and, as always, I got reasonable price estimates for my cards. Payout was quick and easy. I will continue using card conduit to sell cards I don’t need anymore.
Eric S.
Review left Jun 18 2025
Review
I had a lot of secret lair and commander staples to sell. The process was easy to do so and the conditions listed in their report were as expected. This is my second shipment with them and I will continue using Card Conduit when I need to sell cards!
I had a lot of secret lair and commander staples to sell. The process was easy to do so and the conditions listed in their report were as expected. This is my second shipment with them and I will continue using Card Conduit when I need to sell cards!
Nicholas V
Review left Jun 18 2025
Review
The value was excellent for the effort put into it, I will be continuing to use the service. Customer service was also pretty top notch. The transparency and honesty that was involved in handling my order was what really impressed me. Payment was quick also!
The value was excellent for the effort put into it, I will be continuing to use the service. Customer service was also pretty top notch. The transparency and honesty that was involved in handling my order was what really impressed me. Payment was quick also!
Brandon C
Review left Jun 18 2025
Review
I was impressed by the variety of ways to upload a collection, the flexibility with service types (I sorted my cards myself to save on fees, but didn't have to), and great examples to ship cards safely. I got a very fair price for my set of rather aged cards, and customer service was very proactive and helpful. Highly recommend!
I was impressed by the variety of ways to upload a collection, the flexibility with service types (I sorted my cards myself to save on fees, but didn't have to), and great examples to ship cards safely. I got a very fair price for my set of rather aged cards, and customer service was very proactive and helpful. Highly recommend!
Bryce Carpenter
Review left Jun 18 2025
Review
Great service I love it!. So good to have a company that does this
Great service I love it!. So good to have a company that does this
Evan A.
Review left Jun 17 2025
Review
The entire process working with card conduit was extremely easy. Clear and concise instructions on the website made it very clear what was expected from me, and what Card Conduit was responsible for. The communication was phenomenal, with every step sending an email to inform me where they were at in the process.
The entire process working with card conduit was extremely easy. Clear and concise instructions on the website made it very clear what was expected from me, and what Card Conduit was responsible for. The communication was phenomenal, with every step sending an email to inform me where they were at in the process.
Dann Schoenfeld
Review left Jun 15 2025
Shipment processed May 31 2025
Review
Super easy with a great payout. Packed everything up and sent it in, only way it would be easier is if it had more locations to send it too.
Super easy with a great payout. Packed everything up and sent it in, only way it would be easier is if it had more locations to send it too.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 15 2025
Review
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 15 2025
Review
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 15 2025
Review
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 15 2025
Review
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 15 2025
Review
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
Great service for selling cards! Fast and easy, love the option to input your shipping information and tracking on the site.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).