Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5634)
Nick Chaffee
Review left Mar 20 2023
Shipment processed Mar 10 2023
Review
The process was super easy. It gave specific instructions on what you were supposed to do. I would recommend this to a friend!
The process was super easy. It gave specific instructions on what you were supposed to do. I would recommend this to a friend!
Scott Berkhimer
Review left Mar 20 2023
Shipment processed Mar 09 2023
Review
Super easy process from start to finish, great communication, and a fair price for my cards - I'll definitely use the service again.
Super easy process from start to finish, great communication, and a fair price for my cards - I'll definitely use the service again.
Julian
Review left Mar 20 2023
Shipment processed Mar 09 2023
Review
Not a scam, pretty quick support responses. I did the "Sorted" method: shipped 2/28, received 3/3, processed 3/9, paid 3/12. You'd get more money by selling singles on TCGPlayer/eBay, but I opted for this aggregate buylist option because I got to sell everything in one go to the same entity on my ti
...
Read more
Not a scam, pretty quick support responses. I did the "Sorted" method: shipped 2/28, received 3/3, processed 3/9, paid 3/12. You'd get more money by selling singles on TCGPlayer/eBay, but I opted for this aggregate buylist option because I got to sell everything in one go to the same entity on my timeframe, saving a lot of time and headache. I think they assessed prices/conditions fairly. Overall, this service is as advertised, would do again.
Only concern is I don't get how they make money. Perhaps, I'm a minority customer, but they took ~$3.50 out of my ~$200 of proceeds. Even if it took only 15 minutes to process my cards, that's not a lot of margin. Maybe more people don't like to sort the cards and just send in boxes for higher fees, but that's a lot of labor to go through them. I don't know how else they could stay in business unless they have some extra markdown on the proceeds (say the buylist price is $10, then actually sell it for $11 to a vendor's buylist), but it would be unfair of me to speculate as--like I said--prices/conditions assessed by them were fair, service was as advertised. Maybe they have other ideas to monetize in the future.
Only concern is I don't get how they make money. Perhaps, I'm a minority customer, but they took ~$3.50 out of my ~$200 of proceeds. Even if it took only 15 minutes to process my cards, that's not a lot of margin. Maybe more people don't like to sort the cards and just send in boxes for higher fees, but that's a lot of labor to go through them. I don't know how else they could stay in business unless they have some extra markdown on the proceeds (say the buylist price is $10, then actually sell it for $11 to a vendor's buylist), but it would be unfair of me to speculate as--like I said--prices/conditions assessed by them were fair, service was as advertised. Maybe they have other ideas to monetize in the future.
Brad S.
Review left Mar 20 2023
Shipment processed Mar 09 2023
Review
Easy process, think it was 8 days from when CC received my shipment to finalization. I would recommend Card Conduit with confidence.
Easy process, think it was 8 days from when CC received my shipment to finalization. I would recommend Card Conduit with confidence.
Hunter Harrington
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
I got almost all of my expected value from my cards. The customer service team was very kind and professional. I enjoyed my experience with CC.
I got almost all of my expected value from my cards. The customer service team was very kind and professional. I enjoyed my experience with CC.
Bernard
Review left Mar 20 2023
Shipment processed Mar 10 2023
Review
Best store to sell MTG cards on the planet! Super fast payment! Took only a couple of days to grade and they sent my check thru zelle.
Best store to sell MTG cards on the planet! Super fast payment! Took only a couple of days to grade and they sent my check thru zelle.
Great service
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
Easy to sell your cards. Prices are fair. Fast Payment. One thing that i don't like is having to pay a fee to sell my cards. Specially on the sorted package.
One thing that I was not aware is that prices of the submitted cards can drop before the order is fully processed. That caught me by surpri ... Read more
One thing that I was not aware is that prices of the submitted cards can drop before the order is fully processed. That caught me by surpri ... Read more
Easy to sell your cards. Prices are fair. Fast Payment. One thing that i don't like is having to pay a fee to sell my cards. Specially on the sorted package.
One thing that I was not aware is that prices of the submitted cards can drop before the order is fully processed. That caught me by surprise and I did not like that. But if you are ok with that risk then CardConduit continues to be one of the best websites to buylist my MTG cards.
I have done multiple deal with CardConduit so far. And I notice now that the downgrade of the cards has stopped that is +1 in my book. So if you hear the downgrading was an issue in the past that seems to be corrected!
One thing that I was not aware is that prices of the submitted cards can drop before the order is fully processed. That caught me by surprise and I did not like that. But if you are ok with that risk then CardConduit continues to be one of the best websites to buylist my MTG cards.
I have done multiple deal with CardConduit so far. And I notice now that the downgrade of the cards has stopped that is +1 in my book. So if you hear the downgrading was an issue in the past that seems to be corrected!
Mark Parker
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
Easy to follow steps and reasonable pricing. Quick turnaround time as well.
Easy to follow steps and reasonable pricing. Quick turnaround time as well.
nick
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
very impressed, I will almost certainly be using them in the future if my collection ever gets this big again.
very impressed, I will almost certainly be using them in the future if my collection ever gets this big again.
Ashlee
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
Card Conduit was recommended to me & my partner by a good friend. It ended up being the easiest way I could think of to sell some of my mtg collection. The whole process was great (liked being able to see the different value breakdowns for card conditions) & I’d definitely recommend other folks wh
...
Read more
Card Conduit was recommended to me & my partner by a good friend. It ended up being the easiest way I could think of to sell some of my mtg collection. The whole process was great (liked being able to see the different value breakdowns for card conditions) & I’d definitely recommend other folks who have a mountain of cards they need to sell (or even just a handful). Also appreciated the communication & status updates!
Jacob
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
It was super easy to take an evening to sort through my cards, find the most valuable ones, and get them sorted for the shipment. I was dreading the hassle of eventually selling my Magic cards and I'm so thankful that I found Card Conduit to make that process easier and worth my time.
It was super easy to take an evening to sort through my cards, find the most valuable ones, and get them sorted for the shipment. I was dreading the hassle of eventually selling my Magic cards and I'm so thankful that I found Card Conduit to make that process easier and worth my time.
Samuel Arnold
Review left Mar 20 2023
Review
Based on selecting the Sorted Collection option: The process was smooth and simple. I was pleasantly surprised with my experience.
Based on selecting the Sorted Collection option: The process was smooth and simple. I was pleasantly surprised with my experience.
Carson Osborne
Review left Mar 19 2023
Review
Process was easy and at the end of it all they gave me a complete list of the price they paid me for each card and the math for card conduits fee (i submitted 1500 cards). Super transparent and easy process. Will do again.
Process was easy and at the end of it all they gave me a complete list of the price they paid me for each card and the math for card conduits fee (i submitted 1500 cards). Super transparent and easy process. Will do again.
Travis Keshav
Review left Mar 17 2023
Review
This was a large shipment -- hundreds of cards of varying values. Everything went very well. The card conditions exceeded expectations and the payout went very smoothly. I used direct bank processing and had no problems.
This was a large shipment -- hundreds of cards of varying values. Everything went very well. The card conditions exceeded expectations and the payout went very smoothly. I used direct bank processing and had no problems.
Jose Carlos Picado
Review left Mar 17 2023
Shipment processed Mar 13 2023
Review
I had some cards I needed to sell and my brother told me about card conduit. I had a great experience, and I found specially useful to keep track of the status of my package (received, sorting cards, pending payout, etc.) cause it helps to feel at ease during the process. The payout was really close to the estimation. Great experience overall.
I had some cards I needed to sell and my brother told me about card conduit. I had a great experience, and I found specially useful to keep track of the status of my package (received, sorting cards, pending payout, etc.) cause it helps to feel at ease during the process. The payout was really close to the estimation. Great experience overall.
James Yates
Review left Mar 17 2023
Review
From start to finish, the process of selling my collection was simple, fast, and had fantastic follow up. The instructions for sorting and shipping my cards were easy to follow. Afterwards, I was able to follow my order as it progressed through their queue. Following processing, the information I re
...
Read more
From start to finish, the process of selling my collection was simple, fast, and had fantastic follow up. The instructions for sorting and shipping my cards were easy to follow. Afterwards, I was able to follow my order as it progressed through their queue. Following processing, the information I received about my order was staggering in its amount, accuracy, and completeness.
Chris Griffiths
Review left Mar 16 2023
Review
Definitely seemed like good value for me not needing to sort and sell each card individually. Would I recommend this to a friend? I already have and they already shipped their cards in! 10/10
Definitely seemed like good value for me not needing to sort and sell each card individually. Would I recommend this to a friend? I already have and they already shipped their cards in! 10/10
Stephen Beckstead
Review left Mar 16 2023
Review
Sent cards into conduit and they did everything they promised to do which ended in receiving a check for the exact amount they said they would send. I would highly recommend their service.
Sent cards into conduit and they did everything they promised to do which ended in receiving a check for the exact amount they said they would send. I would highly recommend their service.
Jacob
Review left Mar 15 2023
Review
I sent in about 7000 cards to be sorted and figured it would take longer than advertised but within a week they were sorted and I had a full list of what I sent. Had great communication throughout the whole process. Even had a hiccup with the deposit and it was sorted within a couple hours of me emailing them about it. Will definitely use them again.
I sent in about 7000 cards to be sorted and figured it would take longer than advertised but within a week they were sorted and I had a full list of what I sent. Had great communication throughout the whole process. Even had a hiccup with the deposit and it was sorted within a couple hours of me emailing them about it. Will definitely use them again.
M Johnson
Review left Mar 15 2023
Review
I created a list on the TCGplayer app, exported the .csv to Card Conduit and they gave me an estimate. I sent the cards in, and boom money in my account to bling out my commander decks. (Took roughly 2 weeks for entire process, including shipping) Time is money and for the average person, like mysel
...
Read more
I created a list on the TCGplayer app, exported the .csv to Card Conduit and they gave me an estimate. I sent the cards in, and boom money in my account to bling out my commander decks. (Took roughly 2 weeks for entire process, including shipping) Time is money and for the average person, like myself, it's too much of a pain to list all the cards. I will be using Card Conduit again!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).