Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

The service is great. takes a lot of work out of finding and traveling to a vendor. Thanks

The service is great. takes a lot of work out of finding and traveling to a vendor. Thanks

sent many cards, fast easy fair processing quick zelle payment

sent many cards, fast easy fair processing quick zelle payment

Process was fairly quick and easy. I had already sorted the cards I was looking to sell. I do want to try the more unsorted service at some point to see how that goes. Entire process took a bit longer than some of the other large options out there but it was easy and the communication during the process was good. I would use it again

Process was fairly quick and easy. I had already sorted the cards I was looking to sell. I do want to try the more unsorted service at some point to see how that goes. Entire process took a bit longer than some of the other large options out there but it was easy and the communication during the process was good. I would use it again

Yes everything went great! Cards were shipped and I got to see every step of the process almost immediately

Yes everything went great! Cards were shipped and I got to see every step of the process almost immediately

I have now turned in a few shipments, it is the best way to turn a lot of cards into cash with a little effort. The best way is to still buy list cards yourself to lock in prices for the buy list. Im not sure how to change this but there is an gap between doing the buy lists yourself and the sorted ... Read more

I have now turned in a few shipments, it is the best way to turn a lot of cards into cash with a little effort. The best way is to still buy list cards yourself to lock in prices for the buy list. Im not sure how to change this but there is an gap between doing the buy lists yourself and the sorted service at cardconduit. When you sort and buy list yourself, at least you are locking in the price at the time of the deal. Often times I have had wide fluctuations in value between when I pack up the cards and when they get processed. Ive probably lost a few hundred dollars this way over several shipments. In the end, its best for either sending a huge amount of cards and letting them sort it or a the second service where you send them the cards of value.

At this point in time I would not recommend the sorted method as it doesn't offer enough incentive to not just buy list the cards yourself. They might say they have more buy lists they have access too but that might not matter if the card fluctuates in the time you sort, pack and send off for processing.

I chose card conduit to liquidate a majority of my collection over the course of 5 small shipments for a few reasons: Convenience - I'm an extremely busy father of three. And I find it much easier to do things at my own pace, within my own schedule, at my leisure. As opposed to the alternatives (g ... Read more

I chose card conduit to liquidate a majority of my collection over the course of 5 small shipments for a few reasons: Convenience - I'm an extremely busy father of three. And I find it much easier to do things at my own pace, within my own schedule, at my leisure. As opposed to the alternatives (get robbed at LGS, or deal with the TCG marketplace! bleh! no thanks) I do realize I could have min/max'd a bit more value selling them on my own, however, if I take into account how valuable my time is, then it's not even close! Trust- this is a big one for me! Before I decided to sell my collection (bulk yet tbd), I had only done a small amount of business with CC, and each time I felt that I was treated fairly, and with the utmost transparency! They always provide an itemized report of any errors I made during card selection that they corrected, even when the value was in my favor. Which, honestly, is rare in this industry. Communication - they always keep me informed about the ongoing process. Which I really appreciated. A few notes, if I may: Speed - while the shipping time is primarily in my hands, or, I suppose, UPS's hands, I do feel like there is room for improvement on the order processing side of things. I can imagine this length of time fluctuating with seasons (i.e, holidays), but they should strive for some improvement here, depending on the size of the shipment, of course. My shipments ranged anywhere from 100-200 cards and took on the low end 5 days from reception to payment (fair) to 8 days on the high end (less fair)

I just have to comment on how professional this outfit is. The description of the service was spot-on, the tools available before you even create the shipment to price out your cards and identify the ones that don't make the cut, the well-defined process, the expectations set around the process, the ... Read more

I just have to comment on how professional this outfit is. The description of the service was spot-on, the tools available before you even create the shipment to price out your cards and identify the ones that don't make the cut, the well-defined process, the expectations set around the process, the communication throughout the process, and the speed of payment was all top-notch. This was my first time using the company, and I had sent in a wide variety of cards, from a value and condition perspective, to see what happened, and I wasn't disappointed. As far as that goes, the only thing I'd change is that they had a plugin for their estimation tools to the magic scanning apps, so that was less guessing at how much of a difference the buy list price to TCGLow was, for instance, especially since their curated service had a minimum buy list value of .50.

I docked one star because the one unknown as part of shipping is how it is graded, and while I think it was consistent how they graded, in some cases, it was a little harsh. I have a lot of speculation on why that might have been and if there were some things I could have done differently to affect this. But the lower grades had less than a 10% affect on my expectations of the payment based on their estimates at different levels. And that was easily offset by the convenience and speed of the process, so I will definitely use the service again, just exclude really old cards.

I am happy with their speed and processing of my orders. I just would like to now a little more about their grading. I for a fact opened up brand new packs and secret lairs and shipped them, and they still said lightly played. The only handling of the cards was from how I got it from Wizards to the box I sent them in.

I am happy with their speed and processing of my orders. I just would like to now a little more about their grading. I for a fact opened up brand new packs and secret lairs and shipped them, and they still said lightly played. The only handling of the cards was from how I got it from Wizards to the box I sent them in.

I offloaded about 700 cards with sorted service ended up getting about 70% of tcg low so I'm happy with it. Was way easier than selling them all myself. Definitely recommend if you don't want to put in the effort of listing and selling yourself.

I offloaded about 700 cards with sorted service ended up getting about 70% of tcg low so I'm happy with it. Was way easier than selling them all myself. Definitely recommend if you don't want to put in the effort of listing and selling yourself.

Overall I had a positive selling experience. They explained every step clearly and everything went smoothly. I got a little less than I hoped to, less than TCG would pay but TCGplayer no longer buys cards so here we are.

Overall I had a positive selling experience. They explained every step clearly and everything went smoothly. I got a little less than I hoped to, less than TCG would pay but TCGplayer no longer buys cards so here we are.

The process is fast and simple but only expect to get about 60-70% of what is estimated, I had a few high value cards that I expected to be rated as LP-HP but the rest were all pack fresh never played and still got rated as LP and MP as a grade which is pretty insane.

The process is fast and simple but only expect to get about 60-70% of what is estimated, I had a few high value cards that I expected to be rated as LP-HP but the rest were all pack fresh never played and still got rated as LP and MP as a grade which is pretty insane.

I've done 3 shipments to Card Conduit, all with the sorted service.

Pros: Easy. Very easy. Add the cards, sort them, ship them, get paid. Zelle payout option is wildly convenient. Payout values are much better for some cards than any other place I normally sell or buylist.

Cons: The grading is ... Read more

I've done 3 shipments to Card Conduit, all with the sorted service.

Pros: Easy. Very easy. Add the cards, sort them, ship them, get paid. Zelle payout option is wildly convenient. Payout values are much better for some cards than any other place I normally sell or buylist.

Cons: The grading is quite strict. Don't expect to get the NM value for everything you send, even for pack fresh cards. I was definitely surprised at some of the grades my cards received and it makes me hesitant to send higher value cards, even if their list price is higher than other options (because you won't get that NM list price).

I am excited to try their standard shipment service.

Very easy to work with. Card grading felt a little critical but they were able to provide an explanation and photos when I asked. Corrected some issues quickly with great communication. Was helping a friend with their collection and will return for my collection down the line.

Very easy to work with. Card grading felt a little critical but they were able to provide an explanation and photos when I asked. Corrected some issues quickly with great communication. Was helping a friend with their collection and will return for my collection down the line.

Yes the process was easy. Nick was very helpful with a lengthy email response to my questions. I was disappointed with the high shipping costs in my area, which was not covered by CardConduit. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell magic cards!

Yes the process was easy. Nick was very helpful with a lengthy email response to my questions. I was disappointed with the high shipping costs in my area, which was not covered by CardConduit. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell magic cards!

First time selling to CC, very thorough and straightforward transaction, payout wise wasn't as much as I thought considering some cards were graded less than NM, but overall good service and would use it again.

First time selling to CC, very thorough and straightforward transaction, payout wise wasn't as much as I thought considering some cards were graded less than NM, but overall good service and would use it again.

The process was straight forward. It took some time to do it, but not bad. The only complaint is Card Conduit doesn’t seem super up to date on changing market prices

The process was straight forward. It took some time to do it, but not bad. The only complaint is Card Conduit doesn’t seem super up to date on changing market prices

Was an easy process to get my cards sold. 4 day turnaround on their site wasn't correct though, it took almost 7 days. Will definitely sell to them again.

Was an easy process to get my cards sold. 4 day turnaround on their site wasn't correct though, it took almost 7 days. Will definitely sell to them again.

The process was easy. Of course I wanted a little more for my vintage cards, but I'm happy knowing that someone will have the opportunity to appreciate my old cards that were just sitting around.

The process was easy. Of course I wanted a little more for my vintage cards, but I'm happy knowing that someone will have the opportunity to appreciate my old cards that were just sitting around.

Not bad to test it out, might use again in future. I sell on TCGplayer (which is the conditioning guide they use) and have to say they under graded a bunch of cards. NM on all the cheap cards and MP on the more expensive cards. For what it is it's fast and good way to get rid of cards quickly that might sit in inventory for 2-6+ months if I sold myself.

Not bad to test it out, might use again in future. I sell on TCGplayer (which is the conditioning guide they use) and have to say they under graded a bunch of cards. NM on all the cheap cards and MP on the more expensive cards. For what it is it's fast and good way to get rid of cards quickly that might sit in inventory for 2-6+ months if I sold myself.

Easy process, quick payment. I've used other card selling platforms and this was by far the easiest and highest paying.

Easy process, quick payment. I've used other card selling platforms and this was by far the easiest and highest paying.