Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
Christian
Review left Apr 28 2026
Review
They graded my cards in a timely manner and were communicative about delays due to shipment issues
They graded my cards in a timely manner and were communicative about delays due to shipment issues
Michael A.
Review left Apr 28 2026
Review
Process was easy like always. I love using this service whenever I have anything lying around I can’t use. Thank you for adding set search, that has been very helpful.
Process was easy like always. I love using this service whenever I have anything lying around I can’t use. Thank you for adding set search, that has been very helpful.
Oliver Huggins
Review left Apr 28 2026
Review
I got the money I was expecting to get; a lot of the 7-10 dollar cards came back in more played conditions (thats my fault for shuffling up a precon with no sleeves) It's great to be able to turn cards that I didn't even know were worth anything and turn them into cards I'll actually play super easi
...
Read more
I got the money I was expecting to get; a lot of the 7-10 dollar cards came back in more played conditions (thats my fault for shuffling up a precon with no sleeves) It's great to be able to turn cards that I didn't even know were worth anything and turn them into cards I'll actually play super easily. The nemesis foil and many others would have been very difficult to list and sell for full value, so I can't recommend CardConduit enough. Hearing from Zander about my collection was super great, and the support team was great (Not that anything went wrong with my shipment). will use CC again.
Chris Arnold
Review left Apr 27 2026
Review
Needed to sell some of my cards to cover a medical bill. Listing and shipping was all there was to it. Awesome company and gave me a good price on my cards.
Needed to sell some of my cards to cover a medical bill. Listing and shipping was all there was to it. Awesome company and gave me a good price on my cards.
Xiaofeng
Review left Apr 27 2026
Review
Process was easy enough and despite slow shipping of USPS, overall experience was smooth.
Process was easy enough and despite slow shipping of USPS, overall experience was smooth.
Scott S
Review left Apr 27 2026
Review
Timely and fair! Always quality service and saves me sorting time that I don't have.
Timely and fair! Always quality service and saves me sorting time that I don't have.
Trevor Presnell
Review left Apr 27 2026
Review
Been a big fan of you all for a while and you never seem to disappoint. Easy organization and a timely payment are hard to beat, and CC always delivers.
Been a big fan of you all for a while and you never seem to disappoint. Easy organization and a timely payment are hard to beat, and CC always delivers.
Dan
Review left Apr 26 2026
Review
I was very pleased with how the entire process went! I will definitely be using CardConduit again in the future. 😃👍🏻👍🏻
I was very pleased with how the entire process went! I will definitely be using CardConduit again in the future. 😃👍🏻👍🏻
Rachel Seeley
Review left Apr 26 2026
Shipment processed Apr 16 2026
Review
Easy to work with and quick payouts <3 Would recommend.
Easy to work with and quick payouts <3 Would recommend.
Seth
Review left Apr 25 2026
Review
Easiest process I've ever experienced selling cards. This will be the only way I offload parts of my collection from now on.
Easiest process I've ever experienced selling cards. This will be the only way I offload parts of my collection from now on.
L
Review left Apr 25 2026
Review
Straightforward, quick turnaround, would recommend.
Straightforward, quick turnaround, would recommend.
Marcus
Review left Apr 24 2026
Review
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
Armando
Review left Apr 24 2026
Review
Only my second time using the service and this time I used had them sort for me.
SO much easier than expected. I will admit that I’m impatient and checked status often, but for what the service offers I think it was more than reasonable.
Hopefully I don’t accumulate as many cards as I had ... Read more
SO much easier than expected. I will admit that I’m impatient and checked status often, but for what the service offers I think it was more than reasonable.
Hopefully I don’t accumulate as many cards as I had ... Read more
Only my second time using the service and this time I used had them sort for me.
SO much easier than expected. I will admit that I’m impatient and checked status often, but for what the service offers I think it was more than reasonable.
Hopefully I don’t accumulate as many cards as I had before again, but if I do, I know where I’m selling them!
10/10 would use again.
SO much easier than expected. I will admit that I’m impatient and checked status often, but for what the service offers I think it was more than reasonable.
Hopefully I don’t accumulate as many cards as I had before again, but if I do, I know where I’m selling them!
10/10 would use again.
Joey B
Review left Apr 24 2026
Shipment processed Apr 15 2026
Review
Super smooth process, and I was super happy with the $$ I got for the cards I sent in!
Super smooth process, and I was super happy with the $$ I got for the cards I sent in!
Jeremiah Colwell
Review left Apr 23 2026
Review
I’ve been impressed by Card Conduit’s staff at every step of the way. They reached out and let me know one of my orders wasn’t gonna net me any value. They let me know I could donate it to a charity. I didn’t even know that was an option. I said yes immediately.
I’ve been impressed by Card Conduit’s staff at every step of the way. They reached out and let me know one of my orders wasn’t gonna net me any value. They let me know I could donate it to a charity. I didn’t even know that was an option. I said yes immediately.
Michael Lebens
Review left Apr 22 2026
Review
Process was super easy, and the support team was very responsive and helpful with my questions throughout.
Process was super easy, and the support team was very responsive and helpful with my questions throughout.
Brad
Review left Apr 22 2026
Review
This was my second time using Card Conduit. Maybe 10-15 cards in this shipment, so fairly small, but well worth it for a couple hours digging through the LGS bulk boxes. I will continue to use Card Conduit! I keep my entire collection meticulously organized in Manabox, so export and uploading to the CC site is very easy!
This was my second time using Card Conduit. Maybe 10-15 cards in this shipment, so fairly small, but well worth it for a couple hours digging through the LGS bulk boxes. I will continue to use Card Conduit! I keep my entire collection meticulously organized in Manabox, so export and uploading to the CC site is very easy!
Nick
Review left Apr 22 2026
Review
At first I was very skeptical to just send me cards in and trust them to do the rest. But it was super easy! My wife and I are moving out of the country so the cards couldn’t come, they made it simple and gave me a fair price.
At first I was very skeptical to just send me cards in and trust them to do the rest. But it was super easy! My wife and I are moving out of the country so the cards couldn’t come, they made it simple and gave me a fair price.
Christian Ralles
Review left Apr 22 2026
Review
I recently was downsizing my magic collection and I asked around card shops in my area the rate they would pay for my collection and most were below 50% cash and I knew I would not be able to take that rate. However, when I priced out my collection with Card Conduit I found they would pay close to 7
...
Read more
I recently was downsizing my magic collection and I asked around card shops in my area the rate they would pay for my collection and most were below 50% cash and I knew I would not be able to take that rate. However, when I priced out my collection with Card Conduit I found they would pay close to 70% cash on my collection if my conditions were all near mint. So I packed up my collection and sent it off. The Whole process is pretty accurate of around 2 weeks to get payment and that was amazing. A majority of my collection was all lightly played and the condition checking was very fair. I got a much better amount of cash for my collection than I would've locally. For that reason Card Conduit is definitely a 10/10 business in terms of pricing, efficiency, and overall process of getting to the payout for my cards. If anyone has an uneasiness for using them I hope my review will help influence them to use Card Conduit to sell their cards!
Emily R
Review left Apr 21 2026
Review
I'd been meaning to sell my husband's cards for a long time and am so glad I stumbled upon this service. They made it very easy and gave lots of options. Would recommend to anyone who wants to sell their cards.
I'd been meaning to sell my husband's cards for a long time and am so glad I stumbled upon this service. They made it very easy and gave lots of options. Would recommend to anyone who wants to sell their cards.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).