Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
Ant Best
Review left Aug 13 2026
Very Pleased
Review
I submitted well over 3,000 cards, majority of which rares and mythics of some value, and based on some of the reviews I'd seen prior to submission, I was very nervous, particularly about the grading complaints...
Fortunately, this was NOT my experience at all. Of the thousands of cards, a very low percentage came back MP/HP/DMG and the ones that did seem legitimate to me as they were generally older print runs or foils that likely weren't sleeved beforehand - only one was of $10+ value and was an old foil that warranted the condition.
I felt the condition grading was fair, and just like everyone that has had complaints claims, I am meticulous with my cards and 90% go straight from pack to sleeve if warranted, and I feel that CC was respectful of the conditions and graded fairly.
As far as the payout, I had a ballpark expectation but not a firm one; I had sent in so many cards that there was no way I was going to try and sort them to save a couple % on fees and felt the 5% blanket for the auto-sift service was plenty fair, considering the tedious work it saved me on the front-end. I had prepared myself to receive a lower number based on some negative reviews, and was absolutely fretting what declining the sale and requesting them returned to resell on my own would look like, but was overall very pleased with the return upon review, and once I went through it and decided to accept the sale, I had the funds in my account within 24 hours. Couldn't have asked for a smoother process.
TL/DR: Used auto-sift service to sell over 3k cards, process from shipping to payout was incredibly smooth and transparent, grading was perfectly fair, contrary to some other reviews out there, and payout was fair and smooth.
If you want to maximize your margins, you can always sell them on your own, but if simplicity and time are factors for you, I can confidently recommend the service.
Would definitely use again
Fortunately, this was NOT my experience at all. Of the thousands of cards, a very low percentage came back MP/HP/DMG and the ones that did seem legitimate to me as they were generally older print runs or foils that likely weren't sleeved beforehand - only one was of $10+ value and was an old foil that warranted the condition.
I felt the condition grading was fair, and just like everyone that has had complaints claims, I am meticulous with my cards and 90% go straight from pack to sleeve if warranted, and I feel that CC was respectful of the conditions and graded fairly.
As far as the payout, I had a ballpark expectation but not a firm one; I had sent in so many cards that there was no way I was going to try and sort them to save a couple % on fees and felt the 5% blanket for the auto-sift service was plenty fair, considering the tedious work it saved me on the front-end. I had prepared myself to receive a lower number based on some negative reviews, and was absolutely fretting what declining the sale and requesting them returned to resell on my own would look like, but was overall very pleased with the return upon review, and once I went through it and decided to accept the sale, I had the funds in my account within 24 hours. Couldn't have asked for a smoother process.
TL/DR: Used auto-sift service to sell over 3k cards, process from shipping to payout was incredibly smooth and transparent, grading was perfectly fair, contrary to some other reviews out there, and payout was fair and smooth.
If you want to maximize your margins, you can always sell them on your own, but if simplicity and time are factors for you, I can confidently recommend the service.
Would definitely use again
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).