Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
Chris Crocker
Review left Nov 09 2023
Review
Customer service and easy of use were 5 stars. Wish I got a little bit more value but it is what it is.
Customer service and easy of use were 5 stars. Wish I got a little bit more value but it is what it is.
nat s
Review left Oct 21 2023
Shipment processed Oct 10 2023
Review
I am not excited about the prices but they cant control the market
I am not excited about the prices but they cant control the market
James
Review left Oct 13 2023
Review
Great customer service, there was an issue with payment and someone was very quick to notify me and correct the issue. Some of my cards were graded lower than expected but overall this was a quick and easy service that I would use again and recommend to others.
Great customer service, there was an issue with payment and someone was very quick to notify me and correct the issue. Some of my cards were graded lower than expected but overall this was a quick and easy service that I would use again and recommend to others.
Cameron Sadler
Review left Oct 11 2023
Review
Sent in a beta forcefield and unlimited bayou, I thought the condition was actually not terrible but they wrote it off as damaged, overall everything is great, super happy, just a little upset on a few grades
Sent in a beta forcefield and unlimited bayou, I thought the condition was actually not terrible but they wrote it off as damaged, overall everything is great, super happy, just a little upset on a few grades
Chris Sartorius
Review left Sep 24 2023
Shipment processed Sep 14 2023
$145.48
payout, No
fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
This was my first time with Card Conduit. The process was simple, and there was confirmation the whole time. Would really only recommend if you have a lot of value cards you're looking to get rid of. This isn't really the best platform for what is considered "bulk" cards. Really enjoyed my first experience. Will be using more wisely in the future for sure.
This was my first time with Card Conduit. The process was simple, and there was confirmation the whole time. Would really only recommend if you have a lot of value cards you're looking to get rid of. This isn't really the best platform for what is considered "bulk" cards. Really enjoyed my first experience. Will be using more wisely in the future for sure.
Jim
Review left Sep 22 2023
Shipment processed Aug 18 2023
$404.97
payout, $8.26
fees
Review
Process was very straight forward! Ordering the cards precisely took a little time, but otherwise very smooth/simple. I got dinged a bit on condition, but it was honestly pretty fair (collection was quite old, and heavily played back in the day).
Process was very straight forward! Ordering the cards precisely took a little time, but otherwise very smooth/simple. I got dinged a bit on condition, but it was honestly pretty fair (collection was quite old, and heavily played back in the day).
Nathan W
Review left Sep 18 2023
Review
I opted to sort and organize the cards myself to cut down on fees and I really appreciated having that option. Overall the experience was relatively fast and very convenient, which were my priorities as I'm exiting the hobby. I would say it took about a week from postage to payout, and I really appr
...
Read more
I opted to sort and organize the cards myself to cut down on fees and I really appreciated having that option. Overall the experience was relatively fast and very convenient, which were my priorities as I'm exiting the hobby. I would say it took about a week from postage to payout, and I really appreciated the peace of mind from the constant communication at each stage of the process. I feel good about the service and have told friends about it, but I'd be remiss if I didn't advise people to temper their expectations. In my experience, players and collectors alike tend to overvalue the condition of their card, but Card Conduit grades cards way more stringently than any physical or online retailer I've ever interacted with. I'm not making a value judgement there, but I think it's important to note for anyone using the service.
Dani
Review left Sep 18 2023
Review
Easy and quick way to get money for cards taking up space on a shelf
Easy and quick way to get money for cards taking up space on a shelf
Ahmad Doleh
Review left Sep 09 2023
Review
Processing was quick and easy. Value was better than anything I would've gotten locally. Issue resolution was quick and cordial. Would recommend to anyone selling their larger collections.
Processing was quick and easy. Value was better than anything I would've gotten locally. Issue resolution was quick and cordial. Would recommend to anyone selling their larger collections.
Bill
Review left Sep 04 2023
Review
Easy to use site, helpful staff and fast payment. Pretty much everything as advertised. Some difference on card conditions, but they are subjective a lot of the time so it is understandable.
Easy to use site, helpful staff and fast payment. Pretty much everything as advertised. Some difference on card conditions, but they are subjective a lot of the time so it is understandable.
John
Review left Aug 20 2023
Shipment processed Aug 09 2023
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
Title says all. Might use this service again if i find that i have more bulk to redistribute.
Title says all. Might use this service again if i find that i have more bulk to redistribute.
Good Stuff
Review left Aug 16 2023
Shipment processed Aug 05 2023
Review
Easy process for you to offload your cards. If you’re short on time or energy they will help you
Easy process for you to offload your cards. If you’re short on time or energy they will help you
Jordan Fairburn
Review left Aug 14 2023
Review
Process was easy, shipped everything already sorted, thought that the value was a bit low but I am happy nonetheless.
Process was easy, shipped everything already sorted, thought that the value was a bit low but I am happy nonetheless.
Jeremy J. Jensen
Review left Aug 01 2023
Review
much better pricing than my LGS which is why i continue to come back.
much better pricing than my LGS which is why i continue to come back.
Brad
Review left Jul 31 2023
Review
I appriciate the pay out is very competitive for doing whole selling. The statistics I thought was a nice touch but may not be necessary. I would for sure reccomend yhe service for people wanting the most money for their cards. I might add a sorted <$1 option too. People like me would like probab
...
Read more
I appriciate the pay out is very competitive for doing whole selling. The statistics I thought was a nice touch but may not be necessary. I would for sure reccomend yhe service for people wanting the most money for their cards. I might add a sorted <$1 option too. People like me would like probably like to sell them in with >$1 cards just to have them out of their collection. We are doing most of the works sorting, but I suppose the set up in your system might me more of a hassle.
Dan
Review left Jul 28 2023
Review
The different tiers and methods of uploading card lists is a little complicated, but the service and payment were fast and easy. Card Conduit has great customer service and realistic pricing. I would definitely recommend them above any other single buylist site.
The different tiers and methods of uploading card lists is a little complicated, but the service and payment were fast and easy. Card Conduit has great customer service and realistic pricing. I would definitely recommend them above any other single buylist site.
Morgan
Review left Jul 26 2023
Review
Got less than expected due to the card condition, but otherwise happy. Wish they had a better way to catalogue cards.
Got less than expected due to the card condition, but otherwise happy. Wish they had a better way to catalogue cards.
Carlos
Review left Jul 05 2023
Review
The process was easy, except the fees charged. Almost feels like your should send less than 500 cards or else you will get heavier fees. Over all quick payment and turn time made sense.
The process was easy, except the fees charged. Almost feels like your should send less than 500 cards or else you will get heavier fees. Over all quick payment and turn time made sense.
Brian Thompson
Review left Jun 21 2023
Review
Easy shipping process overall and better than trying to manage buylists by myself. Pleased with the service and will be using again, would recommend to friends.
Only small complaint is in the quality of cards sent in, not sure how to address it but there was a fair discrepancy between what I expe ... Read more
Only small complaint is in the quality of cards sent in, not sure how to address it but there was a fair discrepancy between what I expe ... Read more
Easy shipping process overall and better than trying to manage buylists by myself. Pleased with the service and will be using again, would recommend to friends.
Only small complaint is in the quality of cards sent in, not sure how to address it but there was a fair discrepancy between what I expected for a payout based on the estimate tool and what the collection was graded at. A guide for how you grade the collections would be greatly appreciated to help avoid the misunderstandings in the future.
Overall very pleased with the service and process.
Only small complaint is in the quality of cards sent in, not sure how to address it but there was a fair discrepancy between what I expected for a payout based on the estimate tool and what the collection was graded at. A guide for how you grade the collections would be greatly appreciated to help avoid the misunderstandings in the future.
Overall very pleased with the service and process.
Adam
Review left Jun 14 2023
Review
Over all a very positive experience. Comminucated frequently and very timely. Only problem were some of the higher value cards had big swings in value from when i checked price, to when made list, to when checked and graded. So if sending high dollar cards be mindfull of sudden changes. Rest of the
...
Read more
Over all a very positive experience. Comminucated frequently and very timely. Only problem were some of the higher value cards had big swings in value from when i checked price, to when made list, to when checked and graded. So if sending high dollar cards be mindfull of sudden changes. Rest of the cards were fine. I still highly reccomend this site and people. Great job and i will send more cards when i need to.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).