Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5627)
Sean R
Review left Jan 17 2026
Review
There's a bit of a curve to the process, it's a little daunting if you're shipping a big supply. The team seemed very happy to assist with the process however. I sent in a very sizeable order and received as much as expected. I could have received more if I went with a higher processing part of my o
...
Read more
There's a bit of a curve to the process, it's a little daunting if you're shipping a big supply. The team seemed very happy to assist with the process however. I sent in a very sizeable order and received as much as expected. I could have received more if I went with a higher processing part of my own, but the convenience and to get back a sizeable chunk was very appreciated. They even bumped my order from the lowest tier (which I selected for convenience sake) to the mid tier due to the quality of my cards.
Overall, extremely impressed with the customer service and overall process.
However, I will strongly caution to take them at their word about rejected cards. Card Conduit does not seem to send them back automatically. I sent some high value non-english cards which were not included in the shipment write up. They were returned to me, but it was not automatic, it was done after I inquired about them. I appreciate that the rejected cards were returned, but take their terms seriously when they indicate no foreign language cards.
Once again, great service, I'm happy it exists, and I will likely use again.
Overall, extremely impressed with the customer service and overall process.
However, I will strongly caution to take them at their word about rejected cards. Card Conduit does not seem to send them back automatically. I sent some high value non-english cards which were not included in the shipment write up. They were returned to me, but it was not automatic, it was done after I inquired about them. I appreciate that the rejected cards were returned, but take their terms seriously when they indicate no foreign language cards.
Once again, great service, I'm happy it exists, and I will likely use again.
Chris B
Review left Jan 17 2026
Review
Easy, and speedy. I've done over 10k worth of cards over several shipments. Pretty fast turn around, once cards are inventoried... payment is super fast. I'll be back.
Easy, and speedy. I've done over 10k worth of cards over several shipments. Pretty fast turn around, once cards are inventoried... payment is super fast. I'll be back.
Justin
Review left Jan 17 2026
Review
Use a sorted shipment, trust me. The little extra work to order the cards is worth the 60+% discount on fees compared to the other shipment options
Use a sorted shipment, trust me. The little extra work to order the cards is worth the 60+% discount on fees compared to the other shipment options
Ian W
Review left Jan 17 2026
Review
Quick, simple, great way to offload bulk. Fair grading system, and all in all just an absolutely fantastic experience. Will use again.
Quick, simple, great way to offload bulk. Fair grading system, and all in all just an absolutely fantastic experience. Will use again.
Paul Chapin
Review left Jan 17 2026
Review
Girlfriend shipped without tracking...I emailed right away and let Nick or Nathaniel know...they told me they would jeep an eye out for it. After a month thought it was a lost cause, then I get an email stating my shipment had arrived. I was so relieved...I NEVER ship without tracking and insuran
...
Read more
Girlfriend shipped without tracking...I emailed right away and let Nick or Nathaniel know...they told me they would jeep an eye out for it. After a month thought it was a lost cause, then I get an email stating my shipment had arrived. I was so relieved...I NEVER ship without tracking and insurance...and never sending girlfriend to do something I should have done myself (don't blame her at all!!!! 100% my bad).
John Boyer
Review left Jan 16 2026
Review
This is my 3rd shipmentthrough CC and once again, another 10/10 experience. Can't recommend Card Conduit enough.
This is my 3rd shipmentthrough CC and once again, another 10/10 experience. Can't recommend Card Conduit enough.
Kevin Fish
Review left Jan 16 2026
Review
Overall a simple and convenient way to liquidate my unwanted cards.
Overall a simple and convenient way to liquidate my unwanted cards.
Juan Ceballo
Review left Jan 15 2026
Review
the process was pretty easy, they provide quite clear instructions on the website and made things smooth for sending out my cards. I felt it was priced fairly and kept me updated during the process, including informing me about the delay due to the holiday. overall easy and good experience would definitely plan on using again on next selling order
the process was pretty easy, they provide quite clear instructions on the website and made things smooth for sending out my cards. I felt it was priced fairly and kept me updated during the process, including informing me about the delay due to the holiday. overall easy and good experience would definitely plan on using again on next selling order
Brian H
Review left Jan 15 2026
Shipment processed Dec 19 2025
$1,269.22
payout, $46.03
fees
Review
I would 100% recommend this service to anyone thinking of cleaning out old unused cards. Couldn't be easier, just package up everything and ship!
I would 100% recommend this service to anyone thinking of cleaning out old unused cards. Couldn't be easier, just package up everything and ship!
Susanna Vandenplas
Review left Jan 15 2026
Review
I will definitely recommend Cardconduit to my friends. It was easy, timely and I am satisfied with the payout. Far easier than having to sell them myself.
I will definitely recommend Cardconduit to my friends. It was easy, timely and I am satisfied with the payout. Far easier than having to sell them myself.
Shaen
Review left Jan 15 2026
Review
The process was smooth and I have already got another shipment planned.
The process was smooth and I have already got another shipment planned.
Devon (AngryBaldMan)
Review left Jan 15 2026
Review
Consider me a believer in Card Conduit now. I was hesitant to use the service initially because I figured there was no way they could pay out decently and I just "knew" they would undervalue all of my cards but in hindsight I consider it very fair. Sure there are one or two cards I could make an arg
...
Read more
Consider me a believer in Card Conduit now. I was hesitant to use the service initially because I figured there was no way they could pay out decently and I just "knew" they would undervalue all of my cards but in hindsight I consider it very fair. Sure there are one or two cards I could make an argument to say they're in better condition than assessed but there were just as many that got the opposite treatment i.e. I got a higher payout than I should have and this really was limited to <1% of the cards. I also figured "Ok they must devalue the expensive cards and offset it with the cheaper cards" but if you check my submission I don't think that's true either.
I don't know how they do it, but it's a great service and I'd use it again. 10/10
Oh and Nick was awesome, I really appreciate the help!
I don't know how they do it, but it's a great service and I'd use it again. 10/10
Oh and Nick was awesome, I really appreciate the help!
Corey shover.
Review left Jan 14 2026
Review
Sent in about 1000 cards. They were very close to what I estimated based on 70 or so percent of market value. Fees were very responsible. I could have tried to list them all on tcg and sold each over the course of months and made literally 1000 trips to the post office but when you say it out loud i
...
Read more
Sent in about 1000 cards. They were very close to what I estimated based on 70 or so percent of market value. Fees were very responsible. I could have tried to list them all on tcg and sold each over the course of months and made literally 1000 trips to the post office but when you say it out loud its sounds insane.
This is a legit and very responsible service that really makes the whole thing much easier. Just do it.
This is a legit and very responsible service that really makes the whole thing much easier. Just do it.
Sean Rodden
Review left Jan 14 2026
Shipment processed Jan 13 2026
Review
I’ve done a couple orders now with card conduit, and I’ve had a great experience every time. Just ship cards and wait and they do the rest. The prices they always give me are fair and I will continue using them anytime I choose to move off some of my cards!!!!!
I’ve done a couple orders now with card conduit, and I’ve had a great experience every time. Just ship cards and wait and they do the rest. The prices they always give me are fair and I will continue using them anytime I choose to move off some of my cards!!!!!
Gabriel Teixeira
Review left Jan 14 2026
Shipment processed Jan 03 2026
Review
These guys are awesome. They make the process as straightforward as possible and their support team is always quick to answer, should you have any questions or concerns. Card Conduit is without a doubt the best place to sell your cards.
These guys are awesome. They make the process as straightforward as possible and their support team is always quick to answer, should you have any questions or concerns. Card Conduit is without a doubt the best place to sell your cards.
Isaiah
Review left Jan 13 2026
Review
Needed money for classes. Sorted and sent everything, got the money no hassle.
Would recommend
Would recommend
Needed money for classes. Sorted and sent everything, got the money no hassle.
Would recommend
Would recommend
Travis
Review left Jan 13 2026
Review
Super easy process and happy with the speed and updates of everything. Couldn't recommend more
Super easy process and happy with the speed and updates of everything. Couldn't recommend more
Barry Patterson
Review left Jan 13 2026
Review
I have used these guys numerous times and after Kingdom has just wasted my time with their new guys, I have only used Conduit with great results and has answered any question I have. Thanks!
I have used these guys numerous times and after Kingdom has just wasted my time with their new guys, I have only used Conduit with great results and has answered any question I have. Thanks!
Nathan G
Review left Jan 12 2026
Review
Truly the best place to sell your cards without the headache. I’ve utilized Card Conduit several times and each time the exceed expectations!
Truly the best place to sell your cards without the headache. I’ve utilized Card Conduit several times and each time the exceed expectations!
Omar
Review left Jan 12 2026
Review
I shipped my double cards I had that were Nm quality,within a week and half they were already done processing everything and payout was easy. I was happy
I shipped my double cards I had that were Nm quality,within a week and half they were already done processing everything and payout was easy. I was happy
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).