Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5855)
Jacob Dominguez
Review left Feb 26 2026
Review
I was nervous for sure going into selling cards(first time, hasn't been in the MTG scene for long), so I wasn't sure if I'd get even a minutia of the value of the cards. I was more than pleasantly surprised, the trade-off for the fractional fees in exchange for the convenience and piece of mind Card
...
Read more
I was nervous for sure going into selling cards(first time, hasn't been in the MTG scene for long), so I wasn't sure if I'd get even a minutia of the value of the cards. I was more than pleasantly surprised, the trade-off for the fractional fees in exchange for the convenience and piece of mind Card Conduit provides was more than enough for me personally. If I ever want to sell cards again, I'll know where to go.
Chris
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 17 2026
Review
This was too easy. I found a bunch of cards I no longer needed, boxed them up, creeted a shipment, and sent them on their way. Once received they kept me apprised of everything and then sent me a report. Too easy. Highly recommend
This was too easy. I found a bunch of cards I no longer needed, boxed them up, creeted a shipment, and sent them on their way. Once received they kept me apprised of everything and then sent me a report. Too easy. Highly recommend
Jorge Martinez Jr.
Review left Feb 26 2026
Shipment processed Feb 18 2026
Review
Great self service tools and honestly the best way to sell cards your lgs may not buy from you at all or buy at a price well below fair price.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Great self service tools and honestly the best way to sell cards your lgs may not buy from you at all or buy at a price well below fair price.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Highly recommend Card Conduit for anyone looking to thin out a collection.
Mike Ebner
Review left Feb 26 2026
Review
Process is super easy to sell your cards. I use the sort feature to get the bigger discount and it is really easy. The price I got for the cards is fair and much easier and faster than selling them individually on my own. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit!
Process is super easy to sell your cards. I use the sort feature to get the bigger discount and it is really easy. The price I got for the cards is fair and much easier and faster than selling them individually on my own. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit!
Matt
Review left Feb 25 2026
Shipment processed Feb 14 2026
Review
The process from looking up cards to mailing them to CardConduit was supremely easy. You are guided with very detailed steps and instructions throughout the entire flow. Review of my cards and payout was very well documented and communication with the Card Conduit team members was excellent throu
...
Read more
The process from looking up cards to mailing them to CardConduit was supremely easy. You are guided with very detailed steps and instructions throughout the entire flow. Review of my cards and payout was very well documented and communication with the Card Conduit team members was excellent throughout. Highly recommend using Card Conduit to sell your cards!
Jason Hashman
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
I think this was my 4th or 5th transaction with Nate and Nick. Both great guys. Great communication and fair buylist prices. Just ship your cards, and get money in a few weeks. Thanks guys!!
I think this was my 4th or 5th transaction with Nate and Nick. Both great guys. Great communication and fair buylist prices. Just ship your cards, and get money in a few weeks. Thanks guys!!
Emilio J Cherino
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
Navigating the Card Conduit website was very intuitive and easy. The step by step process once an order is started is very easy to follow and execute. I appreciate the packing tips when shipping out your cards as this is sometimes confusing on other sites. I will be using Card Conduit in the future for sure.
Navigating the Card Conduit website was very intuitive and easy. The step by step process once an order is started is very easy to follow and execute. I appreciate the packing tips when shipping out your cards as this is sometimes confusing on other sites. I will be using Card Conduit in the future for sure.
Matt F.
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
I was expecting a little more $ but the fees were a lot less than i expected, so it all evened out. Very reasonable turnaround for how much work they put in. 10/10 recommend all the time
I was expecting a little more $ but the fees were a lot less than i expected, so it all evened out. Very reasonable turnaround for how much work they put in. 10/10 recommend all the time
Nelson Machado
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
I have used Card Conduit for close to 2 years, and their customer service and feedback have been amazing. I have sent close to 20 different orders at this point, and the service has been very beneficial to the hobby and to being able to purchase more products. I believe their prices to be more than
...
Read more
I have used Card Conduit for close to 2 years, and their customer service and feedback have been amazing. I have sent close to 20 different orders at this point, and the service has been very beneficial to the hobby and to being able to purchase more products. I believe their prices to be more than fair because of the ease of the service options they provide. I typically go for the sorted service to get as much bang out of my buck as possible. I see myself using Card Conduit for years!
Nick
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
I went the sorted route. I had no issues what so ever. I was able to find my cards easily. I knew the tentative price, so I was able to decide to send the cards or not. They sent me a list, and put my cards in that exact order. I shipped them out via FedEx flat rate shipping with insurance. It took
...
Read more
I went the sorted route. I had no issues what so ever. I was able to find my cards easily. I knew the tentative price, so I was able to decide to send the cards or not. They sent me a list, and put my cards in that exact order. I shipped them out via FedEx flat rate shipping with insurance. It took a few days (as it should) to get my cards sorted/graded. After I accepted, it took about a day for my funds to go through. It was honestly fairly hassle free. I opted for the doing more work on my end to keep more of my cards' value.
Overall I would say this is a great vehicle if you have some cards you want to offload and put a few dollars in your pocket.
Overall I would say this is a great vehicle if you have some cards you want to offload and put a few dollars in your pocket.
Charley B.
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
I had a great experience! The process went smoothly and payment arrived quickly as advertised. Will use again in the future!
I had a great experience! The process went smoothly and payment arrived quickly as advertised. Will use again in the future!
Mitch
Review left Feb 25 2026
Review
Im not normally a review guy. The service itself was fine, was expecting a little moee but apparently condition was a little strict, but whatever. The real map was the service team. Nathaniel was the most helpful customer service person i maybe ever dealt with. He was in top of my case when I had an
...
Read more
Im not normally a review guy. The service itself was fine, was expecting a little moee but apparently condition was a little strict, but whatever. The real map was the service team. Nathaniel was the most helpful customer service person i maybe ever dealt with. He was in top of my case when I had an issues recovering payment and he reached out MULTIPLE times to confirm I got my payment. 10/10 service.
David Ding
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
For the expedited (2%) service, the processing was very fast and I felt that I got the value of my cards back.
For the expedited (2%) service, the processing was very fast and I felt that I got the value of my cards back.
James
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
The process was very easy and they have a lot of help in the FAQ. I had no issues and the payout for my collection was the best I could find anywhere. Overall I was very happy with this service and will be doing this again.
The process was very easy and they have a lot of help in the FAQ. I had no issues and the payout for my collection was the best I could find anywhere. Overall I was very happy with this service and will be doing this again.
Alfian Poon Yong Sheng
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
Thanks again! Will definitely send more. This one was faster than usual so I was pretty happy
Thanks again! Will definitely send more. This one was faster than usual so I was pretty happy
Matt Smith
Review left Feb 24 2026
Review
Card Conduit it my go-to way to sell unused/unneeded cards. They are fast, communicative, and incredibly easy.
Card Conduit it my go-to way to sell unused/unneeded cards. They are fast, communicative, and incredibly easy.
Jillian
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I had inherited a bunch of cards from my dad and was unsure if they would be worth anything. I was pleasantly surprised at how much I was able to get! The process was easy and they responded to my question super quickly. I would definitely recommend this service.
I had inherited a bunch of cards from my dad and was unsure if they would be worth anything. I was pleasantly surprised at how much I was able to get! The process was easy and they responded to my question super quickly. I would definitely recommend this service.
michael
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I always have a good experience when selling my cards to cardconduit.
I always have a good experience when selling my cards to cardconduit.
Chad
Review left Feb 23 2026
Shipment processed Feb 20 2026
Review
Everything went very smoothly. The sorting was quick and the grading was fair. Highly recommened.
Everything went very smoothly. The sorting was quick and the grading was fair. Highly recommened.
SpellVault
Review left Feb 23 2026
Review
I've been using CC for years now. The new addition of the auto sifting is an amazing process. I'm impressed and excited to use it more in the future!
I've been using CC for years now. The new addition of the auto sifting is an amazing process. I'm impressed and excited to use it more in the future!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).