Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6305)
Brandon Bee
Review left Jun 11 2026
Review
I sent over 3,000 cards to cardconduit. I was a little hesitant with the process just based on the volume and getting the best price for my cards. Everything was simple and effective. I was blown away by the report of my order and how everything was so detailed based on the data. I feel that I got t
...
Read more
I sent over 3,000 cards to cardconduit. I was a little hesitant with the process just based on the volume and getting the best price for my cards. Everything was simple and effective. I was blown away by the report of my order and how everything was so detailed based on the data. I feel that I got the best offer based on the current market. Would definitely use again.
Christian
Review left Jun 11 2026
Review
Super easy, used the service thrice now. Good stuff.
Super easy, used the service thrice now. Good stuff.
Adam Vilanova-Goldstein
Review left Jun 11 2026
Review
Not gonna lie, I was having massive anxiety the entire time. This was the first time I had ever sold this quantity of cards and to ship thousands of dollars worth of cardboard was incredibly nerve racking. But everything went super smoothly. I didn't have to organize anything. Just securely pack
...
Read more
Not gonna lie, I was having massive anxiety the entire time. This was the first time I had ever sold this quantity of cards and to ship thousands of dollars worth of cardboard was incredibly nerve racking. But everything went super smoothly. I didn't have to organize anything. Just securely packaged everything and sent it off. The processing and payment took less time than the shipping. It was a great experience and I'd do it again!
Steven w
Review left Jun 11 2026
Review
Whenever you have cards that make it seem like a hassle to unload through multiple vendors, Card Conduit is the go to solution. Their prices are fair, the process is seamless, and great turnaround with up front transparency. Always a smooth process whenever I have stuff to buylist out.
Whenever you have cards that make it seem like a hassle to unload through multiple vendors, Card Conduit is the go to solution. Their prices are fair, the process is seamless, and great turnaround with up front transparency. Always a smooth process whenever I have stuff to buylist out.
Owen Winbun
Review left Jun 10 2026
Review
It was super easy to send out all the cards! Glad to use card conduit!
It was super easy to send out all the cards! Glad to use card conduit!
Sean Larsen
Review left Jun 10 2026
Review
Instead of pre-sorting, I tried a box full of >.50 cards - worked great!
Instead of pre-sorting, I tried a box full of >.50 cards - worked great!
Evin Rosenthal
Review left Jun 10 2026
Review
I mailed everything in, and after a few weeks they had my order finished with. Fair payout too.
I mailed everything in, and after a few weeks they had my order finished with. Fair payout too.
Michael
Review left Jun 10 2026
Review
I was very pleased with how Card Conduit was able to help me turn my unused Magic cards into ready cash. There was an e-mail from the person who looked over my cards with some information and feedback about the condition of some of my older cards- I really appreciated that personal touch. Overall,
...
Read more
I was very pleased with how Card Conduit was able to help me turn my unused Magic cards into ready cash. There was an e-mail from the person who looked over my cards with some information and feedback about the condition of some of my older cards- I really appreciated that personal touch. Overall, it was such a positive and easy process that I sent another batch of cards to Card Conduit a couple of days later.
Dustin Jones
Review left Jun 10 2026
Review
Team was fast and helpful! I would recommend this service for anyone looking to get a some bang for their bulk.
Team was fast and helpful! I would recommend this service for anyone looking to get a some bang for their bulk.
Derron C
Review left Jun 10 2026
Review
The process was extremely simple and even with small mistakes on my end as a first time submitter, Card Conduit honored the deal and made thing super simple. Communication was fantastic and the overall value was great! Will definitely be a returning customer. Thank you!
The process was extremely simple and even with small mistakes on my end as a first time submitter, Card Conduit honored the deal and made thing super simple. Communication was fantastic and the overall value was great! Will definitely be a returning customer. Thank you!
Justin
Review left Jun 09 2026
Review
Smooth and easy. I even screwed up a bunch of cards (wrong sets, foil vs. non-foil (don't ask)) and CC handled it and didn't make fun of me. And, I deserved to be made fun of.
Thank you!
Thank you!
Smooth and easy. I even screwed up a bunch of cards (wrong sets, foil vs. non-foil (don't ask)) and CC handled it and didn't make fun of me. And, I deserved to be made fun of.
Thank you!
Thank you!
Sam
Review left Jun 09 2026
Shipment processed May 30 2026
Review
I was skeptical about mailing my valuable MtG cards to some random website. But a buddy who had done so assured me they were good. He was right. Very quick turnaround. Fair valuing. I would do business with them again if I had any more cards left to sell. Very solid.
I was skeptical about mailing my valuable MtG cards to some random website. But a buddy who had done so assured me they were good. He was right. Very quick turnaround. Fair valuing. I would do business with them again if I had any more cards left to sell. Very solid.
Mark G
Review left Jun 09 2026
Shipment processed May 21 2026
Review
The process was simple, I sent in my collection and they found cards that I'd forgotten I had.
The process was simple, I sent in my collection and they found cards that I'd forgotten I had.
Sean
Review left Jun 08 2026
Review
Process was easy, payment was more than fair, and payment was seamless. Always a good experience
Process was easy, payment was more than fair, and payment was seamless. Always a good experience
Dan
Review left Jun 07 2026
Review
Shipping and payout process was clear and easy. When I had a question about packing details, support told me what I needed to know. The dashboard showing me where my submission was in the whole process left few questions to answer. Would definitely recommend!
Shipping and payout process was clear and easy. When I had a question about packing details, support told me what I needed to know. The dashboard showing me where my submission was in the whole process left few questions to answer. Would definitely recommend!
Nick M
Review left Jun 07 2026
Review
The value was fair, the process super easy, and they were helpful all along the way. There's a point where a card you don't want or need is worth something, but not enough to sell it online as a single. And what if no one buys it and you need that cash? I love my LGS, but if I'm not looking for cred
...
Read more
The value was fair, the process super easy, and they were helpful all along the way. There's a point where a card you don't want or need is worth something, but not enough to sell it online as a single. And what if no one buys it and you need that cash? I love my LGS, but if I'm not looking for credit on a stack of cards worth between 5 and 15 dollars, I'm looking for Card Conduit.
Dale
Review left Jun 06 2026
Review
Super easy process! I went the sorted route because it's kind of therapeutic to sort them out as a final sendoff. My order sat in an intake queue for a day or two but once it was my packages turn it was done that same day!
Would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to thin down t ... Read more
Would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to thin down t ... Read more
Super easy process! I went the sorted route because it's kind of therapeutic to sort them out as a final sendoff. My order sat in an intake queue for a day or two but once it was my packages turn it was done that same day!
Would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to thin down their collection or offload a few cards but don't want the hassle of working with TCGplayer.
Would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone who wants to thin down their collection or offload a few cards but don't want the hassle of working with TCGplayer.
Mike
Review left Jun 06 2026
Review
Card Conduit made an the often tedious process of selling surplus MTG cards feel painless! They were professional throughout the transaction and offered me a fair price for my cards. I will be using their service again in the future!
Card Conduit made an the often tedious process of selling surplus MTG cards feel painless! They were professional throughout the transaction and offered me a fair price for my cards. I will be using their service again in the future!
Jason smith
Review left Jun 06 2026
Review
Will 100% use again. Worked great for my bulk. Had 2500 cards of trash that turned into 1000$ cash
Will 100% use again. Worked great for my bulk. Had 2500 cards of trash that turned into 1000$ cash
Frederick J Balsley
Review left Jun 06 2026
Review
Process is always very easy, and they pay very fast!
Never any issues and this is my third or fourth shipment!
They're so good, my buddy and I are building a business model around them!
Never any issues and this is my third or fourth shipment!
They're so good, my buddy and I are building a business model around them!
Process is always very easy, and they pay very fast!
Never any issues and this is my third or fourth shipment!
They're so good, my buddy and I are building a business model around them!
Never any issues and this is my third or fourth shipment!
They're so good, my buddy and I are building a business model around them!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).