Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5879)
Kaloyan Zamfirov
Review left May 31 2025
Review
The process was simple and not too difficult if you know how to mess with your card counting app (mtg for me).
The process was simple and not too difficult if you know how to mess with your card counting app (mtg for me).
Ben
Review left May 31 2025
Review
Easy process, fair prices, overall great experience. Would recommend.
Easy process, fair prices, overall great experience. Would recommend.
Neil Q.
Review left May 31 2025
Review
I'm very happy with the overall experience. I did the Curated option and the process was easy from start to finish. It saved me a lot of time selling my collection in one go and receiving good pricing.
I'm very happy with the overall experience. I did the Curated option and the process was easy from start to finish. It saved me a lot of time selling my collection in one go and receiving good pricing.
Jon Derek Wright
Review left May 30 2025
Shipment processed May 21 2025
Review
I am selling a competitive Magic the Gathering collection, so most of the cards are in played condition from years of tourneys. Card Conduit allows me to sell the collection without worrying or arguing about condition and realize the maximum possible value.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
I am selling a competitive Magic the Gathering collection, so most of the cards are in played condition from years of tourneys. Card Conduit allows me to sell the collection without worrying or arguing about condition and realize the maximum possible value.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
Card Conduit is a great professional service.
Nate
Review left May 30 2025
Shipment processed May 22 2025
Review
Good return on time investment. Received payment promptly.
Good return on time investment. Received payment promptly.
Cassandra
Review left May 30 2025
Shipment processed May 22 2025
$488.22
payout, $25.70
fees
Review
The whole process was easy and fairly quick. I actually got more for the cards I sent in than I was expecting to. Nick’s communication was great and I’ll definitely be selling to Card Conduit again.
The whole process was easy and fairly quick. I actually got more for the cards I sent in than I was expecting to. Nick’s communication was great and I’ll definitely be selling to Card Conduit again.
Daniel Bretado
Review left May 30 2025
Review
Thank you for helping me with processing my cards. I'll miss them but they will be in good hands. Sorry I categorized some of my cards incorrectly. I'll be more careful next time.
Thank you for helping me with processing my cards. I'll miss them but they will be in good hands. Sorry I categorized some of my cards incorrectly. I'll be more careful next time.
Michael A
Review left May 29 2025
Review
I love this service so much and have done several submissions. I like the status updates as it’s processed. Not having to sort cards alphabetically is a life saver. Thanks Card Conduit! <3
I love this service so much and have done several submissions. I like the status updates as it’s processed. Not having to sort cards alphabetically is a life saver. Thanks Card Conduit! <3
MTGA PizzaCat
Review left May 29 2025
Review
Went quick and easy. I don't play much paper magic. 100% the best way to go. Great pricing and value. I had an old fat pack of random stuff from the Shards of Alara / Phyrexia days. Thought it may be worth $100-150. Sent me a check for $400+. Will use Card Conduit without a second thought in the fut
...
Read more
Went quick and easy. I don't play much paper magic. 100% the best way to go. Great pricing and value. I had an old fat pack of random stuff from the Shards of Alara / Phyrexia days. Thought it may be worth $100-150. Sent me a check for $400+. Will use Card Conduit without a second thought in the future. Give 'em a chance. It takes a lot for me to bother with a review, but they deserve it.
David A
Review left May 28 2025
Review
I was very hesitant to start sending to CC when I started a few years ago but now it's just part of my way of handling inventory. Thanks CC
I was very hesitant to start sending to CC when I started a few years ago but now it's just part of my way of handling inventory. Thanks CC
David A
Review left May 28 2025
Review
I was very hesitant to start sending to CC when I started a few years ago but now it's just part of my way of handling inventory. Thanks CC
I was very hesitant to start sending to CC when I started a few years ago but now it's just part of my way of handling inventory. Thanks CC
Steven V
Review left May 28 2025
Shipment processed Apr 25 2025
Review
A super easy service that comes with clarity. Thank you!
A super easy service that comes with clarity. Thank you!
Conner Aycock
Review left May 28 2025
Review
These guys kick ass. The process was easy, the team was friendly and easy to contact. 100% will be using again.
These guys kick ass. The process was easy, the team was friendly and easy to contact. 100% will be using again.
will
Review left May 28 2025
Review
Fair grading, quick payout and great communication.
Fair grading, quick payout and great communication.
Bryan
Review left May 28 2025
Review
Very easy and guided process. Very transparent with results and fully lives up to the expectations set.
Very easy and guided process. Very transparent with results and fully lives up to the expectations set.
Eric Augherton
Review left May 27 2025
Review
The whole process was simple, smooth and highly effective! The rates given for my cards were priced fairly and the website gave a clear explanation to how selling cards here worked! This is an A+ service I'd visit again in the near future :)
The whole process was simple, smooth and highly effective! The rates given for my cards were priced fairly and the website gave a clear explanation to how selling cards here worked! This is an A+ service I'd visit again in the near future :)
Jackson Schall
Review left May 27 2025
Review
Once I shipped my package, I didn’t have a single worry from then on! I even got my processing fee lowered for a quality value shipment, so I got an overall larger profit. To get the most value, I had to presort my cards some - to filter out the junk - so it wasn’t quite no work on my part. But,
...
Read more
Once I shipped my package, I didn’t have a single worry from then on! I even got my processing fee lowered for a quality value shipment, so I got an overall larger profit. To get the most value, I had to presort my cards some - to filter out the junk - so it wasn’t quite no work on my part. But, I understand exactly why they do that, and it wasn’t too bad. Overall, very happy with Card Conduit!
James
Review left May 27 2025
Review
Given that Magic cards can't be recycled, due to the layer of plastic, Card Conduit is a great way to reduce a personal collection of cards I no longer need.
Given that Magic cards can't be recycled, due to the layer of plastic, Card Conduit is a great way to reduce a personal collection of cards I no longer need.
Aaron
Review left May 27 2025
Shipment processed May 16 2025
Review
Very straight forward process with amazing customer service every step of the way.
Very straight forward process with amazing customer service every step of the way.
P Mitchell
Review left May 27 2025
Review
The entire process was easy and intuitive. I also really appreciated being able to drop off the cards in person since I am local to the area. I felt very confident I would get as close to the best value I could but at a fraction of the effort required to sell via buy lists all over the area. This wa
...
Read more
The entire process was easy and intuitive. I also really appreciated being able to drop off the cards in person since I am local to the area. I felt very confident I would get as close to the best value I could but at a fraction of the effort required to sell via buy lists all over the area. This was an excellent way to sell unwanted or duplicate cards and get some cash for the upcoming Final Fantasy set. Thanks CC!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).