Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5634)
Joseph Smith
Review left May 06 2025
Review
I was able to do local drop off. Communication with Nick was great. I sold most of my collection. Almost everything graded out better than I expected. Was a great experience
I was able to do local drop off. Communication with Nick was great. I sold most of my collection. Almost everything graded out better than I expected. Was a great experience
Matt
Review left May 06 2025
Review
Process was smooth and payout was fast! I did the pre-sorted service, and start to finish, it took about a week and a half between shipping it to them and when I got paid. Highly recommended!
Process was smooth and payout was fast! I did the pre-sorted service, and start to finish, it took about a week and a half between shipping it to them and when I got paid. Highly recommended!
Ashley
Review left May 06 2025
Review
Anytime I stumble across cards of value that I personally won't need, they are the 1st place I think of. They are super reliable, extremely communicative, and very fair pricing. I do not have a lot of extra time and what time I do have I would rather spend playing than selling. This is such a great resource and I am glad they exist!
Anytime I stumble across cards of value that I personally won't need, they are the 1st place I think of. They are super reliable, extremely communicative, and very fair pricing. I do not have a lot of extra time and what time I do have I would rather spend playing than selling. This is such a great resource and I am glad they exist!
WX
Review left May 06 2025
Review
I'm a very casual MTG player who just needs to sell off cards from prereleases. TCGPlayer's buylist was my go-to before but with that closed I gave Card Conduit a try. The core experience is the same, but the overall UX and communication throughout the process is much improved. The fees for self-sor
...
Read more
I'm a very casual MTG player who just needs to sell off cards from prereleases. TCGPlayer's buylist was my go-to before but with that closed I gave Card Conduit a try. The core experience is the same, but the overall UX and communication throughout the process is much improved. The fees for self-sorted, which is the same as the TCGPlayer buylist experience, are very minimal and seem fair for the service of not having to go and try to part out cards to a bunch of different buylists, which I don't have the volume or patience for. Will definitely use this service again in the future.
Robert Allen II
Review left May 05 2025
Review
A painless process, executed with transparency and promptly paid out. Have already recommended the service to multiple friends.
Only issue I have is the price checker is a bit capricious. What is curated-service-eligible one day May be a 3 cent bulk card the next.
Only issue I have is the price checker is a bit capricious. What is curated-service-eligible one day May be a 3 cent bulk card the next.
A painless process, executed with transparency and promptly paid out. Have already recommended the service to multiple friends.
Only issue I have is the price checker is a bit capricious. What is curated-service-eligible one day May be a 3 cent bulk card the next.
Only issue I have is the price checker is a bit capricious. What is curated-service-eligible one day May be a 3 cent bulk card the next.
Nick Z
Review left May 04 2025
Review
They make this a way of making fast and easy cash. If you are hurting for money and have cards you don't use why not sell them. I was hesitant about using card conduit at first but now I am 100% on board. They not only give you a reasonable amount for your cards they also reach out to you to tell y
...
Read more
They make this a way of making fast and easy cash. If you are hurting for money and have cards you don't use why not sell them. I was hesitant about using card conduit at first but now I am 100% on board. They not only give you a reasonable amount for your cards they also reach out to you to tell you if a card was not in good condition and why it wasn't in good condition. They treat all their customers as individuals.
Kaitlin
Review left May 04 2025
Shipment processed Apr 24 2025
$457.49
payout, $24.08
fees
Review
I would absolutely recommend this service to anyone looking to offload some of their cards. The process was quick and the website updated with the order's status every step of the way. Nick was also incredibly helpful and followed up to let me know that he upgraded my cards to the curated service so I would have to pay fewer fees!
I would absolutely recommend this service to anyone looking to offload some of their cards. The process was quick and the website updated with the order's status every step of the way. Nick was also incredibly helpful and followed up to let me know that he upgraded my cards to the curated service so I would have to pay fewer fees!
Nick
Review left May 03 2025
Review
I didn't have a very big or expensive shipment, but I still got customer service I would expect if I had. Great experience!
I didn't have a very big or expensive shipment, but I still got customer service I would expect if I had. Great experience!
Delmer Holton
Review left May 03 2025
Review
Easy process. Fast pay..........................................
Easy process. Fast pay..........................................
Eric
Review left May 03 2025
Review
They were great from shipment to payment. I got a fair price and personal contact.
They were great from shipment to payment. I got a fair price and personal contact.
Andrew Tardie
Review left May 02 2025
Review
Quick, Hassel Free, Good Value, Friendly Customer Support, Highly Recommend
Quick, Hassel Free, Good Value, Friendly Customer Support, Highly Recommend
Eric
Review left May 02 2025
Review
Third time using Card Conduit and I am compelled to leave a review to call out what a fantastic, thoughtfully designed process this is. Super streamlined and informative, highly impressed each time. Thank you!
Third time using Card Conduit and I am compelled to leave a review to call out what a fantastic, thoughtfully designed process this is. Super streamlined and informative, highly impressed each time. Thank you!
Artur
Review left May 02 2025
Review
The process was easy and communication from the staff was good.
The process was easy and communication from the staff was good.
Kurt Peterson
Review left May 02 2025
Review
The service was really great. The import tool makes everything way easier if you already have your cards stored in something like Delver lens. I plan to use the service in the future when I want to sell another large chunk of cards.
The service was really great. The import tool makes everything way easier if you already have your cards stored in something like Delver lens. I plan to use the service in the future when I want to sell another large chunk of cards.
Tom S
Review left May 02 2025
Shipment processed Apr 18 2025
Review
I sold over my 30 year collection to Card Conduit over the past month. Their service was excellent and it certainly was easier than one card at a time. Thanks Nathaniel
I sold over my 30 year collection to Card Conduit over the past month. Their service was excellent and it certainly was easier than one card at a time. Thanks Nathaniel
I Rivera
Review left May 02 2025
Shipment processed Apr 22 2025
Review
3rd processing submittal with company. Very easy and fair exchange. Money was direct deposited into my account with no issues. Will do business again.
3rd processing submittal with company. Very easy and fair exchange. Money was direct deposited into my account with no issues. Will do business again.
Chezarae Ramone Gholson
Review left May 02 2025
Review
Best place to ever sell my magic the Gathering cards took less than a week. These are cards I got for free do its all profit!
Best place to ever sell my magic the Gathering cards took less than a week. These are cards I got for free do its all profit!
Georgie The Magic Man
Review left May 01 2025
Review
Thank you, yet again! You all keep going the extra mile and I really appreciate all of the work that goes into this process. Strongly recommend using this service.
Thank you, yet again! You all keep going the extra mile and I really appreciate all of the work that goes into this process. Strongly recommend using this service.
Heather B
Review left May 01 2025
Review
What an awesome service - all I had to do was sort the cards in order, pack, and ship. A little bit of extra work but I didn’t mind at all. The only thing that took the longest was ensuring that all cards being sent were from the correct release set (which is something Manabox can have a hard time with). Overall would highly recommend CardConduit!!
What an awesome service - all I had to do was sort the cards in order, pack, and ship. A little bit of extra work but I didn’t mind at all. The only thing that took the longest was ensuring that all cards being sent were from the correct release set (which is something Manabox can have a hard time with). Overall would highly recommend CardConduit!!
Gabriel Ferbeyre
Review left May 01 2025
Shipment processed Apr 23 2025
Review
Excellent service. The hardest part was separating the cards on my own but you guys provide a service to avoid that. Fast and easy shipping, turn around time was amazing and the value was spot on.
Excellent service. The hardest part was separating the cards on my own but you guys provide a service to avoid that. Fast and easy shipping, turn around time was amazing and the value was spot on.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).