Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5882)
Aaron
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
The process is straightforward and easy to follow. Response times are as advertised. The grading for some card conditions was poorer than I had anticipated, but overall the pricing is fair. Best part, I don’t have to sort, individual cards myself because they do all the work and a check arrives in the mail.
The process is straightforward and easy to follow. Response times are as advertised. The grading for some card conditions was poorer than I had anticipated, but overall the pricing is fair. Best part, I don’t have to sort, individual cards myself because they do all the work and a check arrives in the mail.
Conor B
Review left Jul 23 2025
Review
Recently took apart some old commander decks, lots of valuable cards and plenty of random ones that I knew had value but didn't want to individually calculate. Sent it all to Card Conduit, got $3K that week, sent right to my bank account. Thanks for making it so easy!
Recently took apart some old commander decks, lots of valuable cards and plenty of random ones that I knew had value but didn't want to individually calculate. Sent it all to Card Conduit, got $3K that week, sent right to my bank account. Thanks for making it so easy!
Brandon Hubbard
Review left Jul 22 2025
Review
Process is easy as always! Returning customer here, would absolutely recommend to anyone. Best customer service I've had out of any buylist and card buying business!
Process is easy as always! Returning customer here, would absolutely recommend to anyone. Best customer service I've had out of any buylist and card buying business!
Huy
Review left Jul 22 2025
Review
Final Fantasy MTG card. Good pricing. I would recommend service to those who seek to sale bulk MTG. Will do another order soon .
Final Fantasy MTG card. Good pricing. I would recommend service to those who seek to sale bulk MTG. Will do another order soon .
Ryan
Review left Jul 22 2025
Shipment processed Jul 19 2025
Review
I will say that while a couple cards took a bit harsher grade than I expected. Really just the brand new ones not getting near mint sometimes. Overall pleased with the service provided and company.
I will say that while a couple cards took a bit harsher grade than I expected. Really just the brand new ones not getting near mint sometimes. Overall pleased with the service provided and company.
Dylan G.
Review left Jul 21 2025
Review
Great experience, processing was quick and efficient, no issues. Would highly recommend!
Great experience, processing was quick and efficient, no issues. Would highly recommend!
Chuck
Review left Jul 21 2025
Review
The service is easy to use! I figured out the cards that had a decent price and shipped it off! The wait is not long and the instructions were easy to follow! Do recommend!
The service is easy to use! I figured out the cards that had a decent price and shipped it off! The wait is not long and the instructions were easy to follow! Do recommend!
Jason Domenico
Review left Jul 21 2025
Review
It was quite a large order that was worth quite a bit, but everything went smoothly and I was pleased with the results. Having Nick, a rep from the company, personally staying in touch with me made it a more comfortable experience.
It was quite a large order that was worth quite a bit, but everything went smoothly and I was pleased with the results. Having Nick, a rep from the company, personally staying in touch with me made it a more comfortable experience.
Matt
Review left Jul 21 2025
Review
Very easy process to follow. I also appreciated the updates along the way.
Very easy process to follow. I also appreciated the updates along the way.
Robert Moreno
Review left Jul 21 2025
Review
I messed up a shipment label and card conduit received the order and corrected the label for me. It was quickly processed and I got paid in about a week.
I messed up a shipment label and card conduit received the order and corrected the label for me. It was quickly processed and I got paid in about a week.
Max Luna
Review left Jul 21 2025
Review
The process is always easy and the reports gave me all the information I needed to verify my card prices.
The process is always easy and the reports gave me all the information I needed to verify my card prices.
James
Review left Jul 18 2025
Review
I had a deck that I stopped playing with and I was able to sell all of the cards from it in one big bundle using Card Conduit. All I did was list the cards and ship them out. Before you know it I had a check in my mailbox with no hassle or fuss!
I had a deck that I stopped playing with and I was able to sell all of the cards from it in one big bundle using Card Conduit. All I did was list the cards and ship them out. Before you know it I had a check in my mailbox with no hassle or fuss!
Brandon Rath
Review left Jul 17 2025
Review
Easy process every time, fair grading, quick payment. An absolutely streamlined no frills no catch service!
Easy process every time, fair grading, quick payment. An absolutely streamlined no frills no catch service!
Alex
Review left Jul 17 2025
Review
Pretty casual player that really wanted some cards I don't have and wanted to offload some valuable cards I won't use. Card conduit was the easiest way for me to spend minimal time making this "trade". I feel both good about what they paid me and that the hassle of selling elsewhere would not have been worth more money. Would definitely do it again.
Pretty casual player that really wanted some cards I don't have and wanted to offload some valuable cards I won't use. Card conduit was the easiest way for me to spend minimal time making this "trade". I feel both good about what they paid me and that the hassle of selling elsewhere would not have been worth more money. Would definitely do it again.
Paul
Review left Jul 17 2025
Review
Card Conduit yet again made the process quick and painless. I highly recommend you folks.
Card Conduit yet again made the process quick and painless. I highly recommend you folks.
John
Review left Jul 16 2025
Review
I have been shipping cards to this company for a few years now. I can say they are fair and process cards in a timely manner. Hit up the card shop, too!
I have been shipping cards to this company for a few years now. I can say they are fair and process cards in a timely manner. Hit up the card shop, too!
Jeff
Review left Jul 16 2025
Shipment processed Jun 14 2025
Review
The whole process from beginning to end was great. Friendly and very responsive staff. Payment came in very quickly after they received my shipment. I will definitely be returning :)
The whole process from beginning to end was great. Friendly and very responsive staff. Payment came in very quickly after they received my shipment. I will definitely be returning :)
Jeff Scheirer
Review left Jul 16 2025
Review
This process was laid out in steps ahead of time as advertised on the site, it was easy to follow and the team was great and helped me out with questions I had. This is a service I would use again should the need or opportunity arise.
This process was laid out in steps ahead of time as advertised on the site, it was easy to follow and the team was great and helped me out with questions I had. This is a service I would use again should the need or opportunity arise.
Taylor
Review left Jul 16 2025
Review
The team was extremely informative about the condition analysis they did, complete with pictures and explanations. I wish every company I dealt with had this degree of care for the experiences of their clients!
The team was extremely informative about the condition analysis they did, complete with pictures and explanations. I wish every company I dealt with had this degree of care for the experiences of their clients!
jmasoncooper
Review left Jul 16 2025
Review
Everything was easy and smooth. The online process to log the shipment was easy. REMEMBER THAT YOU SHOULD ONLY SHIP 2500 CARDS PER SHIPMENT. Shipped UPS, arrived safely. Remember that the process for a full shipment will take 2-3 weeks to get you paid. But I turned 2500 cards into $900+, so Thanks Card Conduit!
Everything was easy and smooth. The online process to log the shipment was easy. REMEMBER THAT YOU SHOULD ONLY SHIP 2500 CARDS PER SHIPMENT. Shipped UPS, arrived safely. Remember that the process for a full shipment will take 2-3 weeks to get you paid. But I turned 2500 cards into $900+, so Thanks Card Conduit!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).