Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
Walt
Review left May 24 2025
Review
I was a little worried about how my cards would be graded, but overall, I think Card Conduit was more than fair. They were very fast and communicated well. I have already sent them an additional shipment, and I will certainly send more in the future!
I was a little worried about how my cards would be graded, but overall, I think Card Conduit was more than fair. They were very fast and communicated well. I have already sent them an additional shipment, and I will certainly send more in the future!
Seth
Review left May 24 2025
Review
Process was easy, value was great, and the return was faster than expected. I was very pleased with the service and will use it in the future as well as recommend it highly to anyone else looking for a similar service. Thank you!
Process was easy, value was great, and the return was faster than expected. I was very pleased with the service and will use it in the future as well as recommend it highly to anyone else looking for a similar service. Thank you!
Jonathan M.
Review left May 24 2025
Review
I began my journey with card conduit, knowing that the buy list often accounts for 50% of the standard value of what you pay MSRP.
I had also done research to find out how much I would get for my cards if I sold them independently, and the time and shipping involved would not account for the con ... Read more
I had also done research to find out how much I would get for my cards if I sold them independently, and the time and shipping involved would not account for the con ... Read more
I began my journey with card conduit, knowing that the buy list often accounts for 50% of the standard value of what you pay MSRP.
I had also done research to find out how much I would get for my cards if I sold them independently, and the time and shipping involved would not account for the convenience that card conduit offers. Simply put, it would take too much time and too much extra money, and it would not be worth it. Luckily, hard conduit is proactive about the communication on their website.
Knowing this, and having a variety of quality for the cards that I submitted, the team was proactive and letting me know that there were some losses in value from what I had submitted. They proactively reached out to me and gave me an option to review the order prior to submitting it for payment.
Because the amount was small and the cards well used, I agreed to the terms that they had given, accounting the lines on the sheet for what their assessed value was and how it compared to the new mint prices listed on the website.
I agreed to the terms, and the payment was sent quickly! Five stars for accurate condition updates, proactive communication, my confirmation of their analysis, and the prompt payment following the service! Highly recommend!
I had also done research to find out how much I would get for my cards if I sold them independently, and the time and shipping involved would not account for the convenience that card conduit offers. Simply put, it would take too much time and too much extra money, and it would not be worth it. Luckily, hard conduit is proactive about the communication on their website.
Knowing this, and having a variety of quality for the cards that I submitted, the team was proactive and letting me know that there were some losses in value from what I had submitted. They proactively reached out to me and gave me an option to review the order prior to submitting it for payment.
Because the amount was small and the cards well used, I agreed to the terms that they had given, accounting the lines on the sheet for what their assessed value was and how it compared to the new mint prices listed on the website.
I agreed to the terms, and the payment was sent quickly! Five stars for accurate condition updates, proactive communication, my confirmation of their analysis, and the prompt payment following the service! Highly recommend!
Jeff Mongon
Review left May 24 2025
Review
Process was easy. No issues at all and got paid pretty quickly. Overall great experience.
Process was easy. No issues at all and got paid pretty quickly. Overall great experience.
Alex Hamilton
Review left May 24 2025
Review
The process was easy and well explained. There were no issues at any point. I will happily use this service again.
The process was easy and well explained. There were no issues at any point. I will happily use this service again.
Travis
Review left May 23 2025
Review
Both times Ive sent in now my order is processed and money is transfered in the 5 business day time frame! I've also been happily surprised at the payout I've received back for my cards! Shooting to try and send some in at least every couple weeks! I sell cards on other platforms and this takes away
...
Read more
Both times Ive sent in now my order is processed and money is transfered in the 5 business day time frame! I've also been happily surprised at the payout I've received back for my cards! Shooting to try and send some in at least every couple weeks! I sell cards on other platforms and this takes away a lot of the stress associated with packages making it to people and interacting with people in general! Thanks so much again!
Jeremy
Review left May 23 2025
Review
This was a major time-saver. I simply dealeeved my cards, made sure it wasn’t all bulk, counted totals, and packed them securely in fat-pack/bundle type boxes to be shipped out to CardConduit. I had an idea of what I thought a low end payment for the cards after assessment and fees would be in o
...
Read more
This was a major time-saver. I simply dealeeved my cards, made sure it wasn’t all bulk, counted totals, and packed them securely in fat-pack/bundle type boxes to be shipped out to CardConduit. I had an idea of what I thought a low end payment for the cards after assessment and fees would be in order to determine if the service was worth it or not. I have 15 years of selling on other sites, and have a pretty decent gauge for sale batches. I was pleasantly surprised when my processing ended up being about $150 more than what I estimated. Obviously I can’t promise every user will have the same outcome as I did, but I checked the detailed report they supplied and felt that all prices were more than reasonable, especially considering the time they saved me. My sale was 1150 cards total. Seeing that slightly higher sell value, saving the trouble of listing one by one via other options, and the general ease of selling and tracking makes this a no brainer for me in the future. I would suggest their services to anyone looking to save time and still have a fair outcome. Highly recommended. I’ll 100% be back with more batches to sell in the future.
Geoff
Review left May 23 2025
Review
As always this is one of the best card selling services, they make it easy to either throw your cards in a bow or do a quick sorting to help them. And only a few days later you get clear results and they'll reach out if they have any concerns about your shipment, fantastic customer service.
As always this is one of the best card selling services, they make it easy to either throw your cards in a bow or do a quick sorting to help them. And only a few days later you get clear results and they'll reach out if they have any concerns about your shipment, fantastic customer service.
Jason Ohashi
Review left May 23 2025
Shipment processed Apr 19 2025
Review
Fair value for the condition of cards submitted, quick turnaround for inspection and payment for cards.
Fair value for the condition of cards submitted, quick turnaround for inspection and payment for cards.
Brenden Griffith
Review left May 22 2025
Review
Nice and easy! Made clearing out my collection fast!
Nice and easy! Made clearing out my collection fast!
Alex Clarke
Review left May 22 2025
Review
This was my first time using Card Conduit and I found it way to use, fast, and provided a good value for my cards. I will likely use this service again in the future
This was my first time using Card Conduit and I found it way to use, fast, and provided a good value for my cards. I will likely use this service again in the future
Casey Knepley
Review left May 22 2025
Review
Another easy and simple process with card conduit. Thank you!!
Another easy and simple process with card conduit. Thank you!!
Brendan
Review left May 22 2025
Shipment processed Apr 19 2025
Review
It was easy to use. All I had to do was pack up my cards and send them and I got more value then I was expecting!
It was easy to use. All I had to do was pack up my cards and send them and I got more value then I was expecting!
Ian
Review left May 22 2025
Review
Everything about the experience was amazing and would highly recommend to anyone looking to nor have to curate all your cards yourself and get a fair market value for your collections.
Everything about the experience was amazing and would highly recommend to anyone looking to nor have to curate all your cards yourself and get a fair market value for your collections.
Jeremy Witkowski
Review left May 22 2025
Review
The process was easy with exceptional responses from support staff. They gave a fair evaluation of the cards value with a helpful readout going over the value of the cards. It was overall an easy process which I would highly recommend to anyone looking to sell cards.
The process was easy with exceptional responses from support staff. They gave a fair evaluation of the cards value with a helpful readout going over the value of the cards. It was overall an easy process which I would highly recommend to anyone looking to sell cards.
John Hagen
Review left May 22 2025
Review
Only needing to do minimal sorting on my own and get nearly 1/3rd more value than expected from my shipment was well worth it.
Keep your cards in good condition and card conduit will get you great value for your cards if you're in the market to sell. 10/10 would recommend.
Keep your cards in good condition and card conduit will get you great value for your cards if you're in the market to sell. 10/10 would recommend.
Only needing to do minimal sorting on my own and get nearly 1/3rd more value than expected from my shipment was well worth it.
Keep your cards in good condition and card conduit will get you great value for your cards if you're in the market to sell. 10/10 would recommend.
Keep your cards in good condition and card conduit will get you great value for your cards if you're in the market to sell. 10/10 would recommend.
Will
Review left May 22 2025
Review
The whole process was a breeze. I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to offload their extra Magic cards all in one shot. The processing time was very quick once they received my shipment, I got a fair payout, and their fees are very reasonable. Highly recommend!
The whole process was a breeze. I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking to offload their extra Magic cards all in one shot. The processing time was very quick once they received my shipment, I got a fair payout, and their fees are very reasonable. Highly recommend!
Cory Crooks
Review left May 21 2025
Review
Easy, friendly, helpful
Much appreciated and very much needed.
Much appreciated and very much needed.
Easy, friendly, helpful
Much appreciated and very much needed.
Much appreciated and very much needed.
Ryan
Review left May 21 2025
Review
Fast process, quick payout, love everything about this service!
Fast process, quick payout, love everything about this service!
Joe R
Review left May 21 2025
Review
The process was easy. I feel like the value was graded fairly. I would certainly recommend this service to anyone interested in looking to get rid of some of their collection. To anyone reading this, DO NOT HESITATE! Card Conduit provides a stellar service. I have used them 3 times now at this point.
The process was easy. I feel like the value was graded fairly. I would certainly recommend this service to anyone interested in looking to get rid of some of their collection. To anyone reading this, DO NOT HESITATE! Card Conduit provides a stellar service. I have used them 3 times now at this point.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).