Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
Joshua
Review left Jun 13 2025
Shipment processed Jun 04 2025
Review
Just had to pack up my cards and put them in a box, card conduit took care of the rest. Would recommend.
Just had to pack up my cards and put them in a box, card conduit took care of the rest. Would recommend.
Brandon
Review left Jun 13 2025
Shipment processed Jun 10 2025
Review
Excellent experience, very good communication. They were open, treated me with respect, and they clearly value honesty and customer service. I am a very happy customer and will absolutely use this service again and recommend all my friends!
Excellent experience, very good communication. They were open, treated me with respect, and they clearly value honesty and customer service. I am a very happy customer and will absolutely use this service again and recommend all my friends!
Casey Knepley
Review left Jun 13 2025
Review
Card Conduit is so smooth and easy, and has really helped me downsize my collection months and months in a row. Will always recommend!
Card Conduit is so smooth and easy, and has really helped me downsize my collection months and months in a row. Will always recommend!
Timo
Review left Jun 12 2025
Shipment processed Jun 04 2025
Review
Look it’s this simple: you can do all the work yourself and spread the money you earn across an uncertain timeline to maximize your returns. For me, I was ready to sell my whole collection and just walk away with one lump sum. They are running a business here, not trying to do you any favors. Eith
...
Read more
Look it’s this simple: you can do all the work yourself and spread the money you earn across an uncertain timeline to maximize your returns. For me, I was ready to sell my whole collection and just walk away with one lump sum. They are running a business here, not trying to do you any favors. Either be happy with the ease of process and sell them your cards for what they deem the worth to be, or do it yourself. It was fast and professional, and I’m not going to try to argue about the value or grading for this many cards. I do recommend doing a minor pre sort to get as much worthless bulk out as possible. I didn’t have the time or desire to do it myself, so I highly recommend CC. They were helpful and professional at every interaction I had with them.
Jason StMary
Review left Jun 12 2025
Review
I have used Card Conduit Several times and will continue to do so. Great service!
I have used Card Conduit Several times and will continue to do so. Great service!
Tay A.
Review left Jun 12 2025
Review
I was recommended Card Conduit by a friend and after some hemming and hawing, decided to try them out to sell some of my more valuable, but less used, singles. I did a sorted order and packed and shipped the sorted cards as instructed and I got excellent return, only two of my cards had dings for sl
...
Read more
I was recommended Card Conduit by a friend and after some hemming and hawing, decided to try them out to sell some of my more valuable, but less used, singles. I did a sorted order and packed and shipped the sorted cards as instructed and I got excellent return, only two of my cards had dings for slight wear, so I really got the value out of the cards I sold. The personal communication by Nick Anderson was particularly awesome, I really felt like I was being taken care of and my time and cards valued. Will definitely be submitting another sell order in the coming weeks!
Kevin Jay
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
This was my second time selling my MtG cards with Card Conduit. Once again, their valuation was fair, their payment was speedy, and I am looking forward to using their service many times in the future!
This was my second time selling my MtG cards with Card Conduit. Once again, their valuation was fair, their payment was speedy, and I am looking forward to using their service many times in the future!
David Lanni
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
The shipping process was simple and I got exactly what was quoted. This is not my first time selling to Card Conduit and it won't be my last.
The shipping process was simple and I got exactly what was quoted. This is not my first time selling to Card Conduit and it won't be my last.
Sam E.
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
I chose to sort the cards myself. There were 104 cards. Card Conduit's tools made this pretty simple. The grading was fair and I appreciate the final report and the transparency throughout the process. Thank you!
I chose to sort the cards myself. There were 104 cards. Card Conduit's tools made this pretty simple. The grading was fair and I appreciate the final report and the transparency throughout the process. Thank you!
Nick B.
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
I highly recommend Card Conduit. Their tools, communication, and speed are unparalleled.
I highly recommend Card Conduit. Their tools, communication, and speed are unparalleled.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
Love that you can track and see all the steps for your orders. Cards were evaluated fast and payout was timely.
Love that you can track and see all the steps for your orders. Cards were evaluated fast and payout was timely.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
Love that you can track and see all the steps for your orders. Cards were evaluated fast and payout was timely.
Love that you can track and see all the steps for your orders. Cards were evaluated fast and payout was timely.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jun 11 2025
Review
Love that you can track and see all the steps for your orders. Cards were evaluated fast and payout was timely.
Love that you can track and see all the steps for your orders. Cards were evaluated fast and payout was timely.
Rebecca
Review left Jun 10 2025
Shipment processed May 28 2025
Review
Getting rid of a beloved collection is hard but these guys helped ease the pain! Quick to respond to questions; honest with advice and the best course of action; fair grading and valuation. I even got a little more money than I expected without having to mess around with local shops or individual li
...
Read more
Getting rid of a beloved collection is hard but these guys helped ease the pain! Quick to respond to questions; honest with advice and the best course of action; fair grading and valuation. I even got a little more money than I expected without having to mess around with local shops or individual listings. Would definitely recommend and would use again, if I had any cards left!
Garrett Payne
Review left Jun 10 2025
Review
Card Conduit made the process of selling my unwanted cards a smooth, convenient process. I sold them high and medium value cards and agreed with all the grades they assigned them. Payment was handled quickly and was more than expected!!! I highly recommend their services to anyone looking to downsiz
...
Read more
Card Conduit made the process of selling my unwanted cards a smooth, convenient process. I sold them high and medium value cards and agreed with all the grades they assigned them. Payment was handled quickly and was more than expected!!! I highly recommend their services to anyone looking to downsize their collection or sell unused for cards for more valuable singles.
D Chaves
Review left Jun 10 2025
Review
Very Solid Experience. I wanted to trade in some cards and wanted cash instead of store credit which is usually my go to option. Card Conduit seemed like the best option for a payout this large. I could send everything in one go.
I did worry based on reviews I read on Reddit or online. I did see ... Read more
I did worry based on reviews I read on Reddit or online. I did see ... Read more
Very Solid Experience. I wanted to trade in some cards and wanted cash instead of store credit which is usually my go to option. Card Conduit seemed like the best option for a payout this large. I could send everything in one go.
I did worry based on reviews I read on Reddit or online. I did see some positivity on reviews from this website as well as YouTubers but I took that with a grain of salt because those channels seemed to be sponsored.
Anyways I was expecting possibly the worst which thankfully this platform did layout. If you were to have every near mint compared to if everything was graded poorly. I also did decide to take pics of my cards in case I challenge any thing I felt may have been misgraded.
I was pleasantly surprised and felt the amount they offered was fair and went through with it.
I would use this service again. I believe though I would always recommend individuals to take pictures of their cards just so you have something for yourself if you don’t agree and to select the option to pause the transaction before payment so you can look at the details of the their grading.
Very solid experience I would recommend to people.
I did worry based on reviews I read on Reddit or online. I did see some positivity on reviews from this website as well as YouTubers but I took that with a grain of salt because those channels seemed to be sponsored.
Anyways I was expecting possibly the worst which thankfully this platform did layout. If you were to have every near mint compared to if everything was graded poorly. I also did decide to take pics of my cards in case I challenge any thing I felt may have been misgraded.
I was pleasantly surprised and felt the amount they offered was fair and went through with it.
I would use this service again. I believe though I would always recommend individuals to take pictures of their cards just so you have something for yourself if you don’t agree and to select the option to pause the transaction before payment so you can look at the details of the their grading.
Very solid experience I would recommend to people.
Andrew Tardie
Review left Jun 09 2025
Review
Hassle Free Process, Quick Payment, Friendly Customer Service, Highly Recommend
Hassle Free Process, Quick Payment, Friendly Customer Service, Highly Recommend
Cody Lee Fussell
Review left Jun 09 2025
Review
got a good value for my cards i sent in. It was simple and while i might make more by selling these individual cards this process was so simple and efficient that im selling the rest of my collection here. Thanks guys for the wonderful service.
got a good value for my cards i sent in. It was simple and while i might make more by selling these individual cards this process was so simple and efficient that im selling the rest of my collection here. Thanks guys for the wonderful service.
Nick Burger
Review left Jun 08 2025
Review
Super simple process as always. Fast payout, fair and accurate pricing.
Super simple process as always. Fast payout, fair and accurate pricing.
Benjamin Clark
Review left Jun 07 2025
Shipment processed May 29 2025
Review
Very easy and quick to mail in and process, once the shipment was processed, payment was made promptly.
Very easy and quick to mail in and process, once the shipment was processed, payment was made promptly.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).