Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5855)
Conner
Review left Mar 14 2026
Review
I ended up getting more than I thought I would. I sent in a lot of cards that were just sitting in boxes that I had forgotten about. I knew there were some expensive cards in there so I was expecting around $700. It was easy to get everything set up and shipped and since I did the filter sorting it
...
Read more
I ended up getting more than I thought I would. I sent in a lot of cards that were just sitting in boxes that I had forgotten about. I knew there were some expensive cards in there so I was expecting around $700. It was easy to get everything set up and shipped and since I did the filter sorting it took very little effort on my part, so all in all it was a great experience for me.
Byron
Review left Mar 14 2026
Review
Easy, got a good value, relatively quick, thank you CC
Easy, got a good value, relatively quick, thank you CC
Deli Cards
Review left Mar 13 2026
Review
Card Conduit is the only place I send my cards. This small order included off the wall items like Judge Foils. CC proves that they do fair assessments and the buylist price was better than if I tried to sell myself at enough of a discount to complete a quick sale.
Card Conduit is the only place I send my cards. This small order included off the wall items like Judge Foils. CC proves that they do fair assessments and the buylist price was better than if I tried to sell myself at enough of a discount to complete a quick sale.
Michael Stenger
Review left Mar 13 2026
Review
I had no idea Card Conduit even existed, but I sure am glad I stumbled across them!!! Submitting a box of cards to them saved me hours or days of time and likely earned me hundreds more dollars than I would have earned otherwise! The process was super easy, they communicated me the status along th
...
Read more
I had no idea Card Conduit even existed, but I sure am glad I stumbled across them!!! Submitting a box of cards to them saved me hours or days of time and likely earned me hundreds more dollars than I would have earned otherwise! The process was super easy, they communicated me the status along the way, and the payout was almost instant. I've was surprised at how valuable commons and uncommons were, but their Price Check tool was incredibly helpful in identifying value in a pile of "bulk" sitting in my closet.
Clayton Dansby
Review left Mar 13 2026
Review
No notes, they do an amazing job. I first heard about them through mtggoldfish and are now my go to way to sell cards outside of my l.G.S.
No notes, they do an amazing job. I first heard about them through mtggoldfish and are now my go to way to sell cards outside of my l.G.S.
Jordan
Review left Mar 13 2026
Review
I felt like everything went at a good pace and my cards were graded fairly
I felt like everything went at a good pace and my cards were graded fairly
Jason
Review left Mar 12 2026
Review
Whole process went smoothly, this is the second time I've sent cards in. Took about 3 - 4 weeks from start to finish, card grading was fair and payout was quick once accepted.
Whole process went smoothly, this is the second time I've sent cards in. Took about 3 - 4 weeks from start to finish, card grading was fair and payout was quick once accepted.
Bill Poindexter
Review left Mar 12 2026
Review
I had collected over 3000 cards while working for GameStop -- which I got mostly for free ($5 monthly credit from the GameStop Pro program paid for boosters). So when I stopped working there and decided to sell I had to find a way. Selling them individually would have gotten me a better payout but w
...
Read more
I had collected over 3000 cards while working for GameStop -- which I got mostly for free ($5 monthly credit from the GameStop Pro program paid for boosters). So when I stopped working there and decided to sell I had to find a way. Selling them individually would have gotten me a better payout but would have taken forever. This was so easy especially with the new automated process they have (all I had to do was separate the foils and pack the cards). Start to finish about 2 weeks from shipping to payment hitting my bank.
Recommend this service to everyone.
Recommend this service to everyone.
Ryan S.
Review left Mar 12 2026
Shipment processed Feb 07 2026
Review
Card Conduit made it incredibly easy to sort and sell cards. I felt like the value was as good (and sometimes even better) than I’d get listing the cards myself. The staff at Card Conduit were very responsive and communicated with me directly at each stage of the sale. I’d highly recommend the s
...
Read more
Card Conduit made it incredibly easy to sort and sell cards. I felt like the value was as good (and sometimes even better) than I’d get listing the cards myself. The staff at Card Conduit were very responsive and communicated with me directly at each stage of the sale. I’d highly recommend the service to anyone looking to sell cards quickly, for a good price, and without the hassle of individual listings.
Jack E
Review left Mar 12 2026
Shipment processed Mar 04 2026
Review
The process of packing and shipping the cards to card conduit was much easier than trying to sell them myself. I think the price I got for the auto shifted was fair given that most of the cards have been sitting in my collection untouched for years. It definitely helped me clear out the clutter and make room for new cards.
The process of packing and shipping the cards to card conduit was much easier than trying to sell them myself. I think the price I got for the auto shifted was fair given that most of the cards have been sitting in my collection untouched for years. It definitely helped me clear out the clutter and make room for new cards.
Curtis Hames
Review left Mar 12 2026
Review
Used the auto-sorted service, and it could not have been easier. Very little work on my end to turn cards into cash. Report was thorough, and made it very clear how I was being paid, and for what. Payment was very quick after the report. Impressed with the process.
Used the auto-sorted service, and it could not have been easier. Very little work on my end to turn cards into cash. Report was thorough, and made it very clear how I was being paid, and for what. Payment was very quick after the report. Impressed with the process.
James G
Review left Mar 12 2026
Review
After hearing Card Conduit recommended by Ashlizzle, I checked it out to sell some singles I'd been meaning to buylist. I chose the sorted option and got them all entered and properly sorted myself, which was well worth the time for the low fees.
Orders were processed quickly once they arrived and I received my payout quickly as well. A+ overall.
Orders were processed quickly once they arrived and I received my payout quickly as well. A+ overall.
After hearing Card Conduit recommended by Ashlizzle, I checked it out to sell some singles I'd been meaning to buylist. I chose the sorted option and got them all entered and properly sorted myself, which was well worth the time for the low fees.
Orders were processed quickly once they arrived and I received my payout quickly as well. A+ overall.
Orders were processed quickly once they arrived and I received my payout quickly as well. A+ overall.
Kent Jakubowski
Review left Mar 12 2026
Review
I was most impressed by the card entry system. Magic is a huge card game and they had ways to sort by set and had pictures for every card, so you can make sure you are adding the correct one to your sell list. The payout process was quick and fair.
I was most impressed by the card entry system. Magic is a huge card game and they had ways to sort by set and had pictures for every card, so you can make sure you are adding the correct one to your sell list. The payout process was quick and fair.
Sara Keene
Review left Mar 11 2026
Review
We had a great experience with card conduit. The grading of the cards was what we expected, and it was great getting some extra money for cards that were sitting around in the basement. I would definitely use them again.
We had a great experience with card conduit. The grading of the cards was what we expected, and it was great getting some extra money for cards that were sitting around in the basement. I would definitely use them again.
Matthew
Review left Mar 11 2026
Review
Card Conduit is pretty much the only choice if you've got too many cards to sell and don't want to spend months selling online one card at a time. They were fast, convenient, and I really enjoyed the transparency of their process so I knew exactly how far along they were and when I'd be getting paid
Card Conduit is pretty much the only choice if you've got too many cards to sell and don't want to spend months selling online one card at a time. They were fast, convenient, and I really enjoyed the transparency of their process so I knew exactly how far along they were and when I'd be getting paid
Youki Iimori
Review left Mar 11 2026
Shipment processed Mar 03 2026
$1,088.79
payout, $45.37
fees
Review
Easily sold bulk low to mid value cards to help with some sudden vet bills that came up. 10/10 would recommend.
Easily sold bulk low to mid value cards to help with some sudden vet bills that came up. 10/10 would recommend.
Paul Breedlove
Review left Mar 11 2026
Review
Wonderful communication and overall experience will definitely use this service again!
Wonderful communication and overall experience will definitely use this service again!
Heath
Review left Mar 10 2026
Shipment processed Feb 20 2026
Review
I had some cards I got as a kid and used and played with them for a year or two, and then they sat in a box ever since last month. These guys are straightforward. They were honest about about the condition of the cards and I felt were very fair. All these people complaining about all they didn’t g
...
Read more
I had some cards I got as a kid and used and played with them for a year or two, and then they sat in a box ever since last month. These guys are straightforward. They were honest about about the condition of the cards and I felt were very fair. All these people complaining about all they didn’t give me my money‘s worth. Probably living in the Mom’s basement still. The emails I got weren’t automated or AI, they were personal emails. They kept me up-to-date every step of the way. And gave me my money without any complications. In today’s day and age, it doesn’t get any better than that. I have zero complaints.
Jared s.
Review left Mar 10 2026
Shipment processed Mar 07 2026
Review
My cards were received by Card Conduit on a Thursday and by the following Friday they sent me an invoice for my payment, they kept me informed every step of the way and were open about everything going on, I can't recommend them enough.
My cards were received by Card Conduit on a Thursday and by the following Friday they sent me an invoice for my payment, they kept me informed every step of the way and were open about everything going on, I can't recommend them enough.
Peter Trihas
Review left Mar 10 2026
Review
Easy, clear, concise, and communicative. What more do you need? 10+ shipments and counting :-)
Easy, clear, concise, and communicative. What more do you need? 10+ shipments and counting :-)
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).