Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Nico Baron
Review left May 03 2026
Review
Great value and smooth transaction - transparency with the card values that resulted in a lower payment (fine with me) and easy to use the curated listing service. Even if I messed up 'The List' cards - CC team was able to remedy those mixups and correct the associated values.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
Great value and smooth transaction - transparency with the card values that resulted in a lower payment (fine with me) and easy to use the curated listing service. Even if I messed up 'The List' cards - CC team was able to remedy those mixups and correct the associated values.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
This is the 3rd time I've used them, been beyond impressed each time.
Robert Rose
Review left May 03 2026
Review
Great easy process and awesome way to get rid of excess bulk. Had an ACH issue where my bank refused the transaction and returned the payment. Nathaniel was awesome about the whole process and found an alternative way to make the transaction.
Great easy process and awesome way to get rid of excess bulk. Had an ACH issue where my bank refused the transaction and returned the payment. Nathaniel was awesome about the whole process and found an alternative way to make the transaction.
Avery
Review left May 03 2026
Review
Easy to deal with as they always are this service is always easy for selling cards
Easy to deal with as they always are this service is always easy for selling cards
Leif
Review left May 02 2026
Review
I like you guys, because everything is spelled out before. People see what is required before selling to you. The terms are right there no guessing games. No bullshit. Fast payment once delivery report is appoved. Contact is open quick, any concerns taken care of. These guys are trustworthy.
I like you guys, because everything is spelled out before. People see what is required before selling to you. The terms are right there no guessing games. No bullshit. Fast payment once delivery report is appoved. Contact is open quick, any concerns taken care of. These guys are trustworthy.
Aaron C
Review left May 02 2026
Review
Submitted my collection as I am getting out of the game and struggled to get decent offers locally. A friend recommended me CC so I said what the heck I’ll give it a shot. Ended up getting a great/fair offer on my collection in about a week from when it was shipped/received. I’d definitely go through with them again in the future!
Submitted my collection as I am getting out of the game and struggled to get decent offers locally. A friend recommended me CC so I said what the heck I’ll give it a shot. Ended up getting a great/fair offer on my collection in about a week from when it was shipped/received. I’d definitely go through with them again in the future!
Nick Shively
Review left May 02 2026
Review
Was able to get a decent amount for a few thousand cards that I was likely never to sort through. The price was definitely worth the convenience for me!
Was able to get a decent amount for a few thousand cards that I was likely never to sort through. The price was definitely worth the convenience for me!
Lisa H
Review left May 02 2026
Shipment processed Feb 11 2026
Review
I was extremely impressed with the clear instructions and continuous communication. I even had some questions about my quote and they were able
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
I was extremely impressed with the clear instructions and continuous communication. I even had some questions about my quote and they were able
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
To answer very detailed to make sure I was comfortable with the discrepancy between my data and their quote. I would highly
Recommend this service.
Ryan Rutledge
Review left May 01 2026
Review
I was kept informed throughout the entire process.
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
I was kept informed throughout the entire process.
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
Given a fair estimate.
Accepted the offer then the money was in my account the next day.
10/10
Bob
Review left May 01 2026
Review
The whole process is super simple and easy to do, especially with all the import file formats they support. My only suggestion is they should have a page outlining how cards are graded as stuff i viewed as all near mint was graded lightly played. Would still recommend to friends though!
The whole process is super simple and easy to do, especially with all the import file formats they support. My only suggestion is they should have a page outlining how cards are graded as stuff i viewed as all near mint was graded lightly played. Would still recommend to friends though!
Huy
Review left May 01 2026
Review
Third time selling. CC made it easy and simple. Will sale more soon.
Third time selling. CC made it easy and simple. Will sale more soon.
Curtis Petty
Review left May 01 2026
Review
Easy to ship, step by step updates. I will absolutely use Card Conduit again! Thank you so much!
Easy to ship, step by step updates. I will absolutely use Card Conduit again! Thank you so much!
Josiah Liljekvist
Review left Apr 30 2026
Review
Process was easy, customer service was great, and overall great value. Payment was quick, will definitely use again
Process was easy, customer service was great, and overall great value. Payment was quick, will definitely use again
Breno Raffa
Review left Apr 30 2026
Review
Liked the process, no issues at all. Very good, thanks Card Conduit team!
Liked the process, no issues at all. Very good, thanks Card Conduit team!
Michael Vavrek
Review left Apr 30 2026
Shipment processed Apr 16 2026
Review
Honestly, very easy to go through the collection and upload the cards you want to sell. Always seem to have a fair assessment and the check comes pretty fast. can't go wrong!
Honestly, very easy to go through the collection and upload the cards you want to sell. Always seem to have a fair assessment and the check comes pretty fast. can't go wrong!
Jason Clapp
Review left Apr 29 2026
Review
I often find myself with a large amount of $1-3 dollar cards that are difficult to sell on an online platform like Ebay or Facebook Marketplace. I wanted a cheap and semi-quick way to get some value back on my duplicates without having to sift through every single card one by one. Card Conduits auto
...
Read more
I often find myself with a large amount of $1-3 dollar cards that are difficult to sell on an online platform like Ebay or Facebook Marketplace. I wanted a cheap and semi-quick way to get some value back on my duplicates without having to sift through every single card one by one. Card Conduits automated sifting service accurately recorded every card I sent in, even though they do factor in a chance for errors. I didn't calculate the exact value of every card but I was pleasantly surprised by the value of the entire trade-in. The only complaint I would have is the processing time. The website says it should be processed within 2 weeks of receipt, and in my case I waited a little bit longer than that. I imagine this is just an issue for Card Conduit receiving more orders than they have scanners. I would hope that they invest in more of these machines/employees as their demand continues to increase.
seth
Review left Apr 29 2026
Review
these guys make the whole process a breeze. i felt i got good value for my cards and payment was processed quickly. would not hesitate to work with again!
these guys make the whole process a breeze. i felt i got good value for my cards and payment was processed quickly. would not hesitate to work with again!
Chris Scott
Review left Apr 29 2026
Review
Very easy to deal with, payment was issued fairly quickly after the order was finalized. Thank You
Very easy to deal with, payment was issued fairly quickly after the order was finalized. Thank You
Kunle Adelakun
Review left Apr 29 2026
Review
The process was very smooth and I was very happy with the results. The best part was that I ran into issues with payment and the customer service was quick to resolve the issue. I wouldn't choose any other way to sell my cards in the future.
The process was very smooth and I was very happy with the results. The best part was that I ran into issues with payment and the customer service was quick to resolve the issue. I wouldn't choose any other way to sell my cards in the future.
Kenn
Review left Apr 29 2026
Review
I have used card conduit several times at this point, their timeline has been spot on each time and I’ve felt the condition grades have always been pretty spot on.
I have used card conduit several times at this point, their timeline has been spot on each time and I’ve felt the condition grades have always been pretty spot on.
Kris Custer
Review left Apr 28 2026
Review
Everything went as advertised. I was able to curate a list of my cards and mailed them in. It didn’t take long to receive my offer via email and a check in the mail.
Everything went as advertised. I was able to curate a list of my cards and mailed them in. It didn’t take long to receive my offer via email and a check in the mail.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).