Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6841)
David
Review left Oct 13 2026
Shipment processed Sep 21 2026
Review
The entire process with Card Conduit was quick, efficient, and transparent from start to finish. Their communication was excellent; the pricing and fees were clearly outlined, and the turnaround time was impressive. Everything was straightforward and hassle-free. I highly recommend Card Conduit to a
...
Read more
The entire process with Card Conduit was quick, efficient, and transparent from start to finish. Their communication was excellent; the pricing and fees were clearly outlined, and the turnaround time was impressive. Everything was straightforward and hassle-free. I highly recommend Card Conduit to anyone looking for a reliable and convenient way to sell their Magic cards!
Josh Cunningham
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
Speedy processing and fair card grading! I will continue using Card Conduit when selling my extras!
Speedy processing and fair card grading! I will continue using Card Conduit when selling my extras!
michael
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
Every time I need to sell cards card conduit is the first place I go . I have never had a bad experience. Fast and easy, they are top tier quality when it comes to getting money for mtg cards
Every time I need to sell cards card conduit is the first place I go . I have never had a bad experience. Fast and easy, they are top tier quality when it comes to getting money for mtg cards
stephen Smith
Review left Oct 13 2026
Review
process was easy, pricing was fair, order was done in a timely fashion
process was easy, pricing was fair, order was done in a timely fashion
Kathy K
Review left Oct 12 2026
Review
The process was very easy and transparent. The website is very clear about options, valuations, and gives you plenty of choices of how you want your cards processed, depending on how involved you want to be. I didn't have a lot of cards to send, and I was curious, so I spent some time checking my ca
...
Read more
The process was very easy and transparent. The website is very clear about options, valuations, and gives you plenty of choices of how you want your cards processed, depending on how involved you want to be. I didn't have a lot of cards to send, and I was curious, so I spent some time checking my cards on their card valuation tool so I could get a general idea of what was worthwhile to send. Once I shipped out the cards, it was easy to track where they were in the process. I was happy with the report and the payout. Overall it was a very positive experience.
Derek
Review left Oct 12 2026
Shipment processed Oct 01 2026
Review
I have a large amount of bulk sub $10 rares that I wanted to offload and this was a painless process. I appreciate the service and the user interface. Thank you for existing.
I have a large amount of bulk sub $10 rares that I wanted to offload and this was a painless process. I appreciate the service and the user interface. Thank you for existing.
Jacob Bissonnette
Review left Oct 11 2026
Review
The process was pretty easy. I sent my shipment in a somewhat irregular box and was worried my cards weren’t going to be processed correctly. Communication with the team was consistent and timely throughout the process and they handled my inquiries well. Overall 10/10 would use again if the need arose.
The process was pretty easy. I sent my shipment in a somewhat irregular box and was worried my cards weren’t going to be processed correctly. Communication with the team was consistent and timely throughout the process and they handled my inquiries well. Overall 10/10 would use again if the need arose.
Matthew
Review left Oct 11 2026
Review
I love using cardconduit to sell my mtg cards. I have been using the site for two years and will continue using it in the future.
I love using cardconduit to sell my mtg cards. I have been using the site for two years and will continue using it in the future.
Matthew Daly
Review left Oct 10 2026
Review
The process was easy and it was a great relief to not have to sort a massive amount of cards
The process was easy and it was a great relief to not have to sort a massive amount of cards
Reggie T
Review left Oct 10 2026
Review
Great payout, fair grading and assessment, and had money deposited into my Zelle promptly. So much easier than listing myself.
Great payout, fair grading and assessment, and had money deposited into my Zelle promptly. So much easier than listing myself.
El
Review left Oct 09 2026
Review
I've used Card Conduit to keep my hobby going! Buy packs, crack em, keep what I like, sell the rest back to Card Conduit. Repeat. I usually just wait until I accumulate enough stuff of value to ship out. Thank you for making this so easy!
I've used Card Conduit to keep my hobby going! Buy packs, crack em, keep what I like, sell the rest back to Card Conduit. Repeat. I usually just wait until I accumulate enough stuff of value to ship out. Thank you for making this so easy!
Happy Customer
Review left Oct 09 2026
Review
Easy process. Good value and I am never left disappointed.
Easy process. Good value and I am never left disappointed.
Trevor Wilson
Review left Oct 09 2026
Review
I was skeptical at first but also sick of wasting hours finding buy lists and best prices. I did insure the living snot out of my package but everything went great. The team was really good at communicating each step as they went through the cards. If you do the sorted option I highly recommend sort
...
Read more
I was skeptical at first but also sick of wasting hours finding buy lists and best prices. I did insure the living snot out of my package but everything went great. The team was really good at communicating each step as they went through the cards. If you do the sorted option I highly recommend sorting your cards by set, then seperate foil and non- foil. I scanned everything into mana box and uploaded my list, then had to resort but it saved me a ton in fees. I'll be sending in at least 2 more, I want to try the unsorted services but have a few more cards worth doing a sorted list. I opted to show the stats and payouts so you can see how it works. I have already shared this service with a few pod friends so it's something worth trying.
Bryson
Review left Oct 09 2026
Review
The whole process was easy from uploading my list to shipping and payment receipt.
The whole process was easy from uploading my list to shipping and payment receipt.
Roberto Rodriguez
Review left Oct 09 2026
Shipment processed Oct 08 2026
$933.00
payout, $43.96
fees
Review
This is the 2nd time I have used card conduit, the services are easy, customer support is helpful and the payout is within happy ranges and estimation. Would use again.
This is the 2nd time I have used card conduit, the services are easy, customer support is helpful and the payout is within happy ranges and estimation. Would use again.
Brennan
Review left Oct 09 2026
Review
Was hesitant at first to ship out a box of valuable cards and hope to get paid. However, I received updates throughout the process and a detailed report on the grading and pricing of each card before confirming payout. Once confirmed payout was quick. Since the first transaction I have used Card Conduit multiple times. Great service. Thank you.
Was hesitant at first to ship out a box of valuable cards and hope to get paid. However, I received updates throughout the process and a detailed report on the grading and pricing of each card before confirming payout. Once confirmed payout was quick. Since the first transaction I have used Card Conduit multiple times. Great service. Thank you.
Eric Cella
Review left Oct 08 2026
Review
The process was really streamlined. I wasn't expecting to receive so much value back for my cards so I really appreciate the offer I received. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone that has a lot of cards but not enough time or energy to go through and sell them all. Many thanks Card Conduit!
The process was really streamlined. I wasn't expecting to receive so much value back for my cards so I really appreciate the offer I received. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to anyone that has a lot of cards but not enough time or energy to go through and sell them all. Many thanks Card Conduit!
Nicholas Darr
Review left Oct 08 2026
Review
This was such an easy process and the payment was delivered very quick.
This was such an easy process and the payment was delivered very quick.
Justin McNabb
Review left Oct 07 2026
Review
Have now used them twice to process some old commander decks and it couldn’t be easier. I also like they allow things to be sent in deck boxes to help protect the cards for the next owners
Have now used them twice to process some old commander decks and it couldn’t be easier. I also like they allow things to be sent in deck boxes to help protect the cards for the next owners
John
Review left Oct 07 2026
Review
Simple and straight forward process. Far easier and quicker than listing individuals.
Simple and straight forward process. Far easier and quicker than listing individuals.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).