Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5633)
Eric Wiltsie
Review left Jul 10 2025
Review
This was my third shipment through CC. Process has always been extremely easy and fast, payout was very fair, and I especially like the very thorough report they generate for you. Transparency and integrity are important for me, and CC goes above and beyond in those areas. Will use again for sure!
This was my third shipment through CC. Process has always been extremely easy and fast, payout was very fair, and I especially like the very thorough report they generate for you. Transparency and integrity are important for me, and CC goes above and beyond in those areas. Will use again for sure!
Phillip Dyer
Review left Jul 10 2025
Review
They were prompt and fair, what more could you ask for.
They were prompt and fair, what more could you ask for.
Gabriel Allison
Review left Jul 09 2025
Review
I recently had to go through a very big last minute and they were able to help me sell my collection short notice. Support was very helpful.
I recently had to go through a very big last minute and they were able to help me sell my collection short notice. Support was very helpful.
Robert Braunstein
Review left Jul 09 2025
Review
I had heard the commercials for Card Conduit on the MTG Goldfish podcast and when I made the decision to sell some cards I decided to try Card Conduit's service. I was very easy to use and my only trepidation was how they were going to value the cards I sent. My cards were in very good condition so
...
Read more
I had heard the commercials for Card Conduit on the MTG Goldfish podcast and when I made the decision to sell some cards I decided to try Card Conduit's service. I was very easy to use and my only trepidation was how they were going to value the cards I sent. My cards were in very good condition so I was very pleased and gratified that they gave me a very fair valuation and were quick to send the funds. I intend to use Card Conduit in the future when I sell more of my MTG cards.
Amy
Review left Jul 08 2025
Review
We were able to scan our collection with an Android app and output a csv to load here, so the process was fairly simple to get maximum value for minimum hassle. Faster turnaround than expected.
We were able to scan our collection with an Android app and output a csv to load here, so the process was fairly simple to get maximum value for minimum hassle. Faster turnaround than expected.
Ivan
Review left Jul 08 2025
Shipment processed Jun 28 2025
Review
Process was straightforward. Just follow what the instructions and they'll do the rest of the work.
Process was straightforward. Just follow what the instructions and they'll do the rest of the work.
Jay Maddali
Review left Jul 08 2025
Review
Really easy process with clear instructions. Everything was handled in a reasonable time period. I've already recommended this service to friends who are thinking about unloading some cards in bulk.
Really easy process with clear instructions. Everything was handled in a reasonable time period. I've already recommended this service to friends who are thinking about unloading some cards in bulk.
Cory
Review left Jul 07 2025
Review
Without the time to sell each card individually and mail them myself, Card Conduit allowed me to do it in bulk at a better cash buy list value than other stores that incentivize store credit.
Without the time to sell each card individually and mail them myself, Card Conduit allowed me to do it in bulk at a better cash buy list value than other stores that incentivize store credit.
Jillian Hinzman
Review left Jul 07 2025
Review
I used the sorted service to get rid of some of my foils from my commander decks to help give them a more consistent look. The service was very fair in it's grading of cards, and the payout was about what I expected without the hassle of having to send to multiple buylists.
I used the sorted service to get rid of some of my foils from my commander decks to help give them a more consistent look. The service was very fair in it's grading of cards, and the payout was about what I expected without the hassle of having to send to multiple buylists.
Jillian Hinzman
Review left Jul 07 2025
Review
I used the sorted service to get rid of some of my foils from my commander decks to help give them a more consistent look. The service was very fair in it's grading of cards, and the payout was about what I expected without the hassle of having to send to multiple buylists.
I used the sorted service to get rid of some of my foils from my commander decks to help give them a more consistent look. The service was very fair in it's grading of cards, and the payout was about what I expected without the hassle of having to send to multiple buylists.
Kevin Z
Review left Jul 06 2025
Review
Process was pretty simple to navigate and I am happy with the results overall
Process was pretty simple to navigate and I am happy with the results overall
Kevin Z
Review left Jul 06 2025
Review
Process was pretty simple to navigate and I am happy with the results overall
Process was pretty simple to navigate and I am happy with the results overall
Brett Emerick
Review left Jul 06 2025
Review
I would highly recommend Card Conduit. The process is so easy and they are incredibly transparent. Part of my shipment included a fairly expensive new card, that I had a feeling was going to continue to increase as time went on. However during the process, Card Conduit increased and communicated the
...
Read more
I would highly recommend Card Conduit. The process is so easy and they are incredibly transparent. Part of my shipment included a fairly expensive new card, that I had a feeling was going to continue to increase as time went on. However during the process, Card Conduit increased and communicated the amount they were going to pay out as a result of the increase. While I'm sure the opposite can be true, the transparency and honesty goes a long way. They had every reason to just payout the original amount quoted but did not. That made me a customer for as long as I am in TCG!
LMB
Review left Jul 04 2025
Review
I very much appreciate Card Conduit as a destination for cards I am prepared to part with!
Stellar, swift, communicative service.
Stellar, swift, communicative service.
I very much appreciate Card Conduit as a destination for cards I am prepared to part with!
Stellar, swift, communicative service.
Stellar, swift, communicative service.
Dale
Review left Jul 04 2025
Shipment processed Jun 24 2025
$582.47
payout, $30.66
fees
Review
I appreciate the transparency of the whole process. Like a lot of others who have mentioned it in their reviews, it was kind of rough when the final amount was much less than the initial projection but that's just selling cards. After reviewing the invoice of my cards it all made sense and I was act
...
Read more
I appreciate the transparency of the whole process. Like a lot of others who have mentioned it in their reviews, it was kind of rough when the final amount was much less than the initial projection but that's just selling cards. After reviewing the invoice of my cards it all made sense and I was actually contacted by a representative of the process to see if I had any questions.
The website and interface is well designed too. Overall a solid experience and will definitely be trying the service again with another portion of my collection.
Shout out to Nick A. and Nathaniel B-W!
The website and interface is well designed too. Overall a solid experience and will definitely be trying the service again with another portion of my collection.
Shout out to Nick A. and Nathaniel B-W!
Zeb Hillard
Review left Jul 04 2025
Shipment processed Jul 03 2025
Review
CC really does take all the hassle out of seeking your cards, from a few high value singles to a stack of mid-value things that would just go on a buylist or be tossed in on trades, nice of the worry sticks around when you ship an order to them.
CC really does take all the hassle out of seeking your cards, from a few high value singles to a stack of mid-value things that would just go on a buylist or be tossed in on trades, nice of the worry sticks around when you ship an order to them.
Brandon
Review left Jul 04 2025
Review
Sent Card Conduit a few decent commander decks' worth of cards and came away with the kind of money it would have taken months to make selling them myself. The whole process was transparent and every step of the way I was kept appraised of what to expect. If you're like I was and just want an easy w
...
Read more
Sent Card Conduit a few decent commander decks' worth of cards and came away with the kind of money it would have taken months to make selling them myself. The whole process was transparent and every step of the way I was kept appraised of what to expect. If you're like I was and just want an easy way to offload your collection all at once in exchange for also offloading some of the value, I can't recommend this service highly enough. Could I have squeezed more value out of the collection selling them individually? Of course. How much time and effort would that take? I'm not even gonna bother doing the math, I know this service was worth way more than all that time spent sorting and shipping.
Angel
Review left Jul 03 2025
Review
Sent in some valuable cards and not so valuable cards and got more than I expected. Super easy to send cards in to help get rid of bulk but also make a decent buck, will continue to use their service!
Sent in some valuable cards and not so valuable cards and got more than I expected. Super easy to send cards in to help get rid of bulk but also make a decent buck, will continue to use their service!
Jace Goulart
Review left Jul 03 2025
Review
Great service! Fast grading and payment! Process is easy and website is user friendly.
Great service! Fast grading and payment! Process is easy and website is user friendly.
Jace Goulart
Review left Jul 03 2025
Review
Great service! Fast grading and payment! Process is easy and website is user friendly.
Great service! Fast grading and payment! Process is easy and website is user friendly.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).