Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5884)
H
Review left Oct 13 2025
Review
Although it took a bit of time, gave a fair payout
Although it took a bit of time, gave a fair payout
Roy
Review left Oct 13 2025
Review
I've buylisted to a lot of places and this was definitely the most seamless.
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot ... Read more
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot ... Read more
I've buylisted to a lot of places and this was definitely the most seamless.
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot on and payment was beyond easy, even after a hiccup that was again not their fault.
If you're on the fence, go for it.
inputting was relatively painless (actually, it's painful - but not their fault. I just don't have the patience to input cards one-by-one), but once that is done, it's smooth sailing.
The grading was pretty spot on and payment was beyond easy, even after a hiccup that was again not their fault.
If you're on the fence, go for it.
chandler
Review left Oct 12 2025
Review
Process was simple and straightforward. I sent in my bulk cards and card Conduit handled the rest. They sent me a detailed sheet of the cards they received and contacted me to confirm I was OK with the results. I will be using the. Again in the future!
Process was simple and straightforward. I sent in my bulk cards and card Conduit handled the rest. They sent me a detailed sheet of the cards they received and contacted me to confirm I was OK with the results. I will be using the. Again in the future!
Alex
Review left Oct 12 2025
Shipment processed Sep 30 2025
$13.53
payout, No
fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
Card Conduit made it super easy to sell my Magic cards. Though I wish I received a higher payout, I feel good that the folks at Card Conduit gave me an honest sale.
Card Conduit made it super easy to sell my Magic cards. Though I wish I received a higher payout, I feel good that the folks at Card Conduit gave me an honest sale.
Ken Mars
Review left Oct 12 2025
Review
The process was easy, and, quite frankly, compared to selling to anyone else, including card shops, or manually trying to sell on eBay or TCGPlayer, etc., these guys are a way better option. They will give you a very fair amount for what you sent in, and it takes an absolute fraction of the time to do it. Highly reccomend them!
The process was easy, and, quite frankly, compared to selling to anyone else, including card shops, or manually trying to sell on eBay or TCGPlayer, etc., these guys are a way better option. They will give you a very fair amount for what you sent in, and it takes an absolute fraction of the time to do it. Highly reccomend them!
AP
Review left Oct 12 2025
Shipment processed Oct 03 2025
Review
A quick, easy, and seamless selling experience as usual!
A quick, easy, and seamless selling experience as usual!
Dylan Harrington
Review left Oct 12 2025
Review
It made it incredibly easy to turn cards into cash, with a full read out to help you understand it all
It made it incredibly easy to turn cards into cash, with a full read out to help you understand it all
Cici
Review left Oct 12 2025
Review
Did a curated order. Super easy to ship. Not a long time to wait on processing. Payment was quickly paid out. The whole process was streamlined and so easy! Will definitely be using this service again.
Did a curated order. Super easy to ship. Not a long time to wait on processing. Payment was quickly paid out. The whole process was streamlined and so easy! Will definitely be using this service again.
Eric W
Review left Oct 11 2025
Review
I found Card Conduit with a random search on google. I am a moderate eBay seller selling about 200 items a year. I had already sold off cards in blocks but when it came to single rares, uncommons and commons that I knew had a better value, I was dreading trying to sell them one at a time on eBay.
...
Read more
I found Card Conduit with a random search on google. I am a moderate eBay seller selling about 200 items a year. I had already sold off cards in blocks but when it came to single rares, uncommons and commons that I knew had a better value, I was dreading trying to sell them one at a time on eBay. I was ecstatic about the prospect of selling to Card Conduit. I found a couple of fair reviews of Card Conduit on Reddit which helped me go into my experience with my eyes open and tempered expectations. Even with tempered expectations I was pleasantly surprised by the final offer they gave me. My cards were not in pristine condition and most of them were from 15+ years ago. I chose the "sorted service" so I only paid 2% commission to Card Conduit compared to eBay's 13%+. I was able to sell 56 cards to Card Conduit and received an average of about $2.06 per card. This was way easier and less stressful than trying to sell them on eBay. I definitely recommend their service. You have nothing to lose as they are very up front with what they are willing to pay. It is an easy way to make sure your cards are in the hands of a company that can hopefully get them into the hands of other MTG players.
Jeremy Champe
Review left Oct 11 2025
Review
I couldn't be happier with Card Conduit so far. Excellent customer service. Transparency. And, most importantly, more than fair payouts.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
I couldn't be happier with Card Conduit so far. Excellent customer service. Transparency. And, most importantly, more than fair payouts.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
Jeremy Champe
Review left Oct 11 2025
Review
I couldn't be happier with Card Conduit so far. Excellent customer service. Transparency. And, most importantly, more than fair payouts.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
I couldn't be happier with Card Conduit so far. Excellent customer service. Transparency. And, most importantly, more than fair payouts.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
R Hill
Review left Oct 11 2025
Review
Super easy, super fast! Using Manabox as a scanner, I set the price to buylist and away I went. A little over 2000 cards (that were projected to be $.60 or greater) later I overnighted what was projected to be a $4900 or so shipment, a week later I was offered a bit over $5800 and was paid a day aft
...
Read more
Super easy, super fast! Using Manabox as a scanner, I set the price to buylist and away I went. A little over 2000 cards (that were projected to be $.60 or greater) later I overnighted what was projected to be a $4900 or so shipment, a week later I was offered a bit over $5800 and was paid a day after accepting the offer. I could not be happier with the processing times or the process.
Charles Thomas
Review left Oct 11 2025
Shipment processed Oct 02 2025
Review
Easy process, great payout...couldn't be more pleased
Easy process, great payout...couldn't be more pleased
Travis Haney
Review left Oct 11 2025
Review
Its a little unreal how easy these guys make it! Ive slowly started liquidating a lot of my collection and these guys are getting me paid every week for it with minimal effort on my end. Customer service is second to none as well (responded within 20 mins of
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
Its a little unreal how easy these guys make it! Ive slowly started liquidating a lot of my collection and these guys are getting me paid every week for it with minimal effort on my end. Customer service is second to none as well (responded within 20 mins of
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
David Lanni
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Quick turnaround and a fair price for the cards. Would sell to them again.
Quick turnaround and a fair price for the cards. Would sell to them again.
Lucas Friedman
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
I love using Card Conduit and will use it again when I have more cards I do not need anymore.
I love using Card Conduit and will use it again when I have more cards I do not need anymore.
Peter Lozano
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Over all I’m very happy with my experience and highly recommend this to people.
Over all I’m very happy with my experience and highly recommend this to people.
JF
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Very happy with the Card Conduit experience! I appreciate how much info is provided. 10/10 would use again!
Very happy with the Card Conduit experience! I appreciate how much info is provided. 10/10 would use again!
David Groulx
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Easy to ship my cards, very happy with the value I received, have already recommended Card Conduit to others.
Easy to ship my cards, very happy with the value I received, have already recommended Card Conduit to others.
Christopher S
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
I had a large Magic the Gathering collection and Card Conduit's card services made the process of selling my cards fast and efficient. The prices provided were more than fair and I appreciate the work they did for me.
I had a large Magic the Gathering collection and Card Conduit's card services made the process of selling my cards fast and efficient. The prices provided were more than fair and I appreciate the work they did for me.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).