Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Sean D. English
Review left May 07 2026
Review
Truly knocked it out of the park. Very fair grading on my collections thus far, and swift payment with no fuss. Without a doubt, one of the best services out there.
Truly knocked it out of the park. Very fair grading on my collections thus far, and swift payment with no fuss. Without a doubt, one of the best services out there.
Robert
Review left May 07 2026
Review
Good value for your cards and very easy to work with.
Good value for your cards and very easy to work with.
Aiden
Review left May 06 2026
Review
Team is always solid, and I loved the new autosort. Finally was able to liquidate a massive collection without having to break my back sorting each card
Team is always solid, and I loved the new autosort. Finally was able to liquidate a massive collection without having to break my back sorting each card
Ty
Review left May 06 2026
Review
The process was simple and easy. Payment was quick. They also returned a couple cards for me which I great appreciated.
The process was simple and easy. Payment was quick. They also returned a couple cards for me which I great appreciated.
Zachary VanCurine
Review left May 06 2026
Review
Easy good value and excited to be able to sell my cards
Easy good value and excited to be able to sell my cards
Drew
Review left May 06 2026
Review
Easy to use service with updates every step of the way. I recommend it!
Easy to use service with updates every step of the way. I recommend it!
John Detsikas
Review left May 06 2026
Review
Card conduit provided clear instructions and advice for sending a larger order (over 7000 cards) for auto sorting and grading. I was impressed that they then went through and individually graded cards and checked for authenticity. Be aware that sending orders of that size can be quite expensive (whi
...
Read more
Card conduit provided clear instructions and advice for sending a larger order (over 7000 cards) for auto sorting and grading. I was impressed that they then went through and individually graded cards and checked for authenticity. Be aware that sending orders of that size can be quite expensive (which is out of card conduit’s hands) but ultimately I found it to be well worth the price of shipping!
Kess
Review left May 06 2026
Shipment processed Apr 27 2026
Review
I sent in my cards for sale and was given an estimated date for completion. On the date I received my card summary and the transaction moved exactly as expected. Fast and efficient
I sent in my cards for sale and was given an estimated date for completion. On the date I received my card summary and the transaction moved exactly as expected. Fast and efficient
Jonathan L
Review left May 06 2026
Review
I've done three different shipments with these guys, and it's been great every time. They're fair with pricing, and fast with the sorting and payment. I'm glad to have this option and not having to worry about sorting and selling all these on my own.
I've done three different shipments with these guys, and it's been great every time. They're fair with pricing, and fast with the sorting and payment. I'm glad to have this option and not having to worry about sorting and selling all these on my own.
John Paulus
Review left May 06 2026
Review
Impressed with the speed and response time, lost roughly $3k on my trade in which was a hard pill to swallow but satisfied with everything else.
Impressed with the speed and response time, lost roughly $3k on my trade in which was a hard pill to swallow but satisfied with everything else.
Josh
Review left May 06 2026
Review
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving payment, and I got full transparency throughout the process. At the end of the process, I got a thorough analysis of the cards
...
Read more
I had gotten a lot of recommendations for Card Conduit from many different places, and CC did not disappoint. It was about 2 weeks between sending my shipment and receiving payment, and I got full transparency throughout the process. At the end of the process, I got a thorough analysis of the cards I had sent with comprehensive breakdowns on the prices, conditions, and overall statistics. I'm happy with the value that I got - though if I weren't, the shipment was under a 48 hour hold and ready to be returned. Looking forward to using this service again the next time I need to cash in some cardboard.
Drew Carlson
Review left May 06 2026
Review
I had a couple friends use this service and they were right…it’s a great value and very easy to use. I was updated throughout the process and I thought my payout was extremely fair. Will I use Card Conduit again…absolutely!
I had a couple friends use this service and they were right…it’s a great value and very easy to use. I was updated throughout the process and I thought my payout was extremely fair. Will I use Card Conduit again…absolutely!
Tyler H
Review left May 05 2026
Review
I came away super happy tbh! The return amount I got was much higher than I expected to get back & multiple people I’ve told were also impressed! I was sad to see so many cards go; but I needed the money & they kind of saved me!
I came away super happy tbh! The return amount I got was much higher than I expected to get back & multiple people I’ve told were also impressed! I was sad to see so many cards go; but I needed the money & they kind of saved me!
Kyle S
Review left May 05 2026
Review
Made a lot more money with a few thousand cards than I would in store credit. Great service.
Made a lot more money with a few thousand cards than I would in store credit. Great service.
mARCUS
Review left May 05 2026
Review
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
mARCUS
Review left May 05 2026
Review
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
great prices... will always sell to them.. thank you
Phil
Review left May 04 2026
Review
Stress and complication are a big issue for me. Cardconduit removed all that entirely. I recommend them to everyone who even jokes about selling some of their collection. I will be using them again for sure.
Stress and complication are a big issue for me. Cardconduit removed all that entirely. I recommend them to everyone who even jokes about selling some of their collection. I will be using them again for sure.
Mitch Jahnke
Review left May 04 2026
Review
Will continue to use when I plan on selling cards.
Will continue to use when I plan on selling cards.
Taylor Myers
Review left May 04 2026
Review
Straight forward process with concise instructions. Works really nice with moxfield and importing lists from there. Have already sent off a second shipment of cards, and will probably use again down the road!
Straight forward process with concise instructions. Works really nice with moxfield and importing lists from there. Have already sent off a second shipment of cards, and will probably use again down the road!
Blaine John Schultz
Review left May 03 2026
Review
This was just so easy. I mailed my cards with sleeves, and they took care of it. Grading was spot on and payment was fast and secure. I would recommended this company to anyone. Have been in MTG since 1993 and this is a service I would use anytime to selling. I did not have many cards the first time
...
Read more
This was just so easy. I mailed my cards with sleeves, and they took care of it. Grading was spot on and payment was fast and secure. I would recommended this company to anyone. Have been in MTG since 1993 and this is a service I would use anytime to selling. I did not have many cards the first time, but I am already on my second shipment. 100% trust. Great service. Thank you all so much, I appreciate it.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).