Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5627)
Lorelei
Review left Feb 05 2026
Review
Card Conduit's standard service is super easy to use!
Card Conduit's standard service is super easy to use!
Jason P
Review left Feb 05 2026
Review
Easy to use service, and received constant updates when moving into different phases. Very pleased with the value that Card Conduit provided
Easy to use service, and received constant updates when moving into different phases. Very pleased with the value that Card Conduit provided
Hc
Review left Feb 05 2026
Shipment processed Jan 21 2026
Review
Easy to work with. Fast and fair! Will be doing mucho business with team.
Easy to work with. Fast and fair! Will be doing mucho business with team.
EJ
Review left Feb 05 2026
Review
Easy process to get through. The team responded quickly and it was clear they were thorough when reviewing the cards.
Easy process to get through. The team responded quickly and it was clear they were thorough when reviewing the cards.
Josh Cunningham
Review left Feb 04 2026
Review
As always, excellent communication throughout the process and fair grading of sent cards.
As always, excellent communication throughout the process and fair grading of sent cards.
Dan Bucci
Review left Feb 04 2026
Review
Card conduit is quickly becoming a favorite source for turning cards into cash! If you have piles and piles of cards from years of playing, it can be challenging to sort through everything and find out wha you have. Card conduit takes care of all of that and makes the process so simple!
Card conduit is quickly becoming a favorite source for turning cards into cash! If you have piles and piles of cards from years of playing, it can be challenging to sort through everything and find out wha you have. Card conduit takes care of all of that and makes the process so simple!
Nate Dilgard
Review left Feb 04 2026
Review
The process to sell my cards was very easy with a quick turn around. I found the payout to be very reasonable.
The process to sell my cards was very easy with a quick turn around. I found the payout to be very reasonable.
Josh
Review left Feb 04 2026
Review
This transaction was super smooth and fair. I highly recommend.
This transaction was super smooth and fair. I highly recommend.
Jenna W.
Review left Feb 04 2026
Shipment processed Jan 17 2026
Review
I will say I was skeptical at first, but I told myself why not? I created an account gathered my cards and started the process. I was very happy to see on the site detailed tips on how to best ship my cards. I followed the process and was able to track the process from start to finish. Payment was p
...
Read more
I will say I was skeptical at first, but I told myself why not? I created an account gathered my cards and started the process. I was very happy to see on the site detailed tips on how to best ship my cards. I followed the process and was able to track the process from start to finish. Payment was processed in a timely manner as promised! Thank you Card Conduit!
Mike fletcher
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
The process was easy and this worked out very well. Will be using again.
The process was easy and this worked out very well. Will be using again.
Denver McIntosh
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
Felt they were fair... Better than fair for some cards. I know what I shipped in wasn't pristine, but I still felt it was a great value. It didn't take long either which was nice!
Felt they were fair... Better than fair for some cards. I know what I shipped in wasn't pristine, but I still felt it was a great value. It didn't take long either which was nice!
Joshua Bruce
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
I recently sold all my loose Magic cards to Card Conduit, and the experience was phenomenal. From start to finish, their team was responsive, professional, and incredibly accommodating. As someone in the customer service and sales industry, I can confidently say this is some of the best service I’
...
Read more
I recently sold all my loose Magic cards to Card Conduit, and the experience was phenomenal. From start to finish, their team was responsive, professional, and incredibly accommodating. As someone in the customer service and sales industry, I can confidently say this is some of the best service I’ve ever experienced. They made what could have been a stressful process seamless and even enjoyable. The best part? This luxury-level service came at a very affordable price. I only wish more companies would take a page out of their book!
Tara
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
This was my first time using the website and I appreciated the step-by-step process outline and ease of adding cards to the buylist. You even get an itemized report at the end - a step up from the oftentimes obfuscated price estimate you get from other buyers. I also received my payout quite quick
...
Read more
This was my first time using the website and I appreciated the step-by-step process outline and ease of adding cards to the buylist. You even get an itemized report at the end - a step up from the oftentimes obfuscated price estimate you get from other buyers. I also received my payout quite quickly.
Nick even reached out and provided some guidance as I had some inauthentic cards in my collection as to how to root those out in the future. I'm currently paring down my collection and if I have more cards I want to sell then I will certainly use this service again.
Nick even reached out and provided some guidance as I had some inauthentic cards in my collection as to how to root those out in the future. I'm currently paring down my collection and if I have more cards I want to sell then I will certainly use this service again.
Cristian Villaran
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
I refuse to elaborate. I will hit this fifty character minimum and move on.
I refuse to elaborate. I will hit this fifty character minimum and move on.
James Fagan
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
I appreciated having the option to organize the cards ahead of time to maintain more of the profit! Would highly recommend this site for folks trying to get money for cards
I appreciated having the option to organize the cards ahead of time to maintain more of the profit! Would highly recommend this site for folks trying to get money for cards
kingjrod
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
this was my first this through with Card Conduit, the process was really straight forward, and when i had questions the comms from the CC team were great. I would highly recommend their service
this was my first this through with Card Conduit, the process was really straight forward, and when i had questions the comms from the CC team were great. I would highly recommend their service
craig
Review left Feb 03 2026
Review
Highly recommend for anyone who has excess cards laying around that they do not use to convert into something they will play with!
Highly recommend for anyone who has excess cards laying around that they do not use to convert into something they will play with!
Jonathan Klaskala
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
Suggest sorting it yourself to save money, fair pricing, really easy and worth it.
Suggest sorting it yourself to save money, fair pricing, really easy and worth it.
Walter
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
the stuck to their timeframe they initially gave me, no delays!
the stuck to their timeframe they initially gave me, no delays!
Cody Bujnowski
Review left Feb 02 2026
Review
The process was easy with lost of direction for what to do and follow ups to guarantee accuracy. I am likely to recommend to others.
The process was easy with lost of direction for what to do and follow ups to guarantee accuracy. I am likely to recommend to others.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).