Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Derek
Review left Sep 29 2025
Review
I have sold cards multiple time and have had a good e patience each time.
I have sold cards multiple time and have had a good e patience each time.
John Mitchell
Review left Sep 29 2025
Review
The process was incredibly easy and I received a lot more money than I thought I would.
The process was incredibly easy and I received a lot more money than I thought I would.
Reagan
Review left Sep 28 2025
Review
Process was super easy and quick! The pay out was fair also
Process was super easy and quick! The pay out was fair also
Edward
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
I sent them a large box of largely unsorted cards. Within a week or so I received a fair evaluation and payment. Many of my cards were graded NM which surprised me. I would use them again.
I sent them a large box of largely unsorted cards. Within a week or so I received a fair evaluation and payment. Many of my cards were graded NM which surprised me. I would use them again.
David Ding
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
I felt like I received good value on the cards that I was selling.
I felt like I received good value on the cards that I was selling.
Cale
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
I had been meaning to sell off some of my cards for a year or two, but I was always hesitant to start, given the perceived hassle of individual card selling, either to buy lists or online tcg marketplaces. Card conduit is a game changer for this. They were fast, graded my cards accurately, and paid
...
Read more
I had been meaning to sell off some of my cards for a year or two, but I was always hesitant to start, given the perceived hassle of individual card selling, either to buy lists or online tcg marketplaces. Card conduit is a game changer for this. They were fast, graded my cards accurately, and paid me a fair price. I will definitely use their services in the future - and I think you should too, so long as you’re ok with not getting “retail” price for your cards. To me, the convenience and hassle-free nature of the card conduit process more than makes up the difference.
John Brett Linton
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
Nobody better than you! Thank you for fast and professional service.
Nobody better than you! Thank you for fast and professional service.
Michael Durnberger
Review left Sep 27 2025
Review
All I had to do was gather my cards that were just sitting in binders anyway, and mail them off. The payment was more than I anticipated and everything was handled super professionally and communication was clear and pleasant. The whole experience was better than I had hoped
All I had to do was gather my cards that were just sitting in binders anyway, and mail them off. The payment was more than I anticipated and everything was handled super professionally and communication was clear and pleasant. The whole experience was better than I had hoped
Trever Phillips
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I always like how easy it is to just send cards and you guys sort through price them and pay good reasonable amounts. Than you for always being fair and definitely will be sending more cards in the future!
I always like how easy it is to just send cards and you guys sort through price them and pay good reasonable amounts. Than you for always being fair and definitely will be sending more cards in the future!
Kyle K
Review left Sep 26 2025
Shipment processed Aug 20 2025
Review
I found the process and customer service incredibly easy/helpful. Not only was the support team responsive to my questions, but the process to send my collection was easy. The payment was also very fair!
I found the process and customer service incredibly easy/helpful. Not only was the support team responsive to my questions, but the process to send my collection was easy. The payment was also very fair!
Ryan Gano Jr.
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
Everything from choosing which cards to send, to shipping them off, to Card Conduit finishing everything on their end and payment was super smooth!
Everything from choosing which cards to send, to shipping them off, to Card Conduit finishing everything on their end and payment was super smooth!
Dolan king
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I had no issues sending my sorted order in and got paid out in about 2 weeks. All steps of the process were easily communicated
I had no issues sending my sorted order in and got paid out in about 2 weeks. All steps of the process were easily communicated
Ryan
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
It was easy and painless………………………?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.??.
It was easy and painless………………………?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.??.
Cody McCarty
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
Everything about the process was fluid and it was easy to get a guesstimate of how much I would receive. Would recommend this service to anyone who has an excessive amount of cards collecting dust.
Everything about the process was fluid and it was easy to get a guesstimate of how much I would receive. Would recommend this service to anyone who has an excessive amount of cards collecting dust.
Vincent Pascoe
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I've used Card Conduit twice now and they where amazing, The custumer suport was great comunications and really went above and beyond to help me out. They also take some cards that no one else will buylist, overall great experience.
I've used Card Conduit twice now and they where amazing, The custumer suport was great comunications and really went above and beyond to help me out. They also take some cards that no one else will buylist, overall great experience.
Eric Augherton
Review left Sep 26 2025
Review
I am very satisfied with the simplicity and effectiveness that Card Conduit provides! I loved their hard work the first time and I appreciate them for doing this so well again a second time! Expect me to come back again in the near future :)
I am very satisfied with the simplicity and effectiveness that Card Conduit provides! I loved their hard work the first time and I appreciate them for doing this so well again a second time! Expect me to come back again in the near future :)
Dan
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
Process was easy, and I think the pricing was very fair. Will be creating another shipment soon!
Process was easy, and I think the pricing was very fair. Will be creating another shipment soon!
Campbell
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
The team responds quickly, is thorough and communicates well. I was surprised by how much i got back. I would recommend Card Conduit to any one looking to sell cards!
The team responds quickly, is thorough and communicates well. I was surprised by how much i got back. I would recommend Card Conduit to any one looking to sell cards!
Cory
Review left Sep 25 2025
Shipment processed Sep 13 2025
Review
Card Conduit has revolutionized the way card collectors can evaluate, liquidate, and evolve our collections. The process was simple, user friendly, and had options for each step of the process that allowed customization for my personal goals. After prepping and sending the shipment, CC was communicative and helpful from evaluation to payment.
Card Conduit has revolutionized the way card collectors can evaluate, liquidate, and evolve our collections. The process was simple, user friendly, and had options for each step of the process that allowed customization for my personal goals. After prepping and sending the shipment, CC was communicative and helpful from evaluation to payment.
Doug
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
The process to record and trade in my cards was really easy I thought. I also thought I got a pretty decent price for what I traded in. I really appreciated the detailed breakdown of the quality and amount that I would be getting for my cards before the final step.
The only negative part of this ... Read more
The only negative part of this ... Read more
The process to record and trade in my cards was really easy I thought. I also thought I got a pretty decent price for what I traded in. I really appreciated the detailed breakdown of the quality and amount that I would be getting for my cards before the final step.
The only negative part of this whole experience is the time it took for the payment to actually arrive. For whatever reason USPS took the letter on the longest path possible to get to me. Then when it finally did get here was delivered to a neighbors home who was out of town. So I had to do some extra work to get my local USPS worker to track down the letter.
The team at Card Conduit was able to help track the letter at least and we could see the long path it took and that it was supposedly delivered.
Overall a great experience and would definitly recommend the service to anyone who is interested.
The only negative part of this whole experience is the time it took for the payment to actually arrive. For whatever reason USPS took the letter on the longest path possible to get to me. Then when it finally did get here was delivered to a neighbors home who was out of town. So I had to do some extra work to get my local USPS worker to track down the letter.
The team at Card Conduit was able to help track the letter at least and we could see the long path it took and that it was supposedly delivered.
Overall a great experience and would definitly recommend the service to anyone who is interested.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).