Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5629)
Travis Haney
Review left Oct 11 2025
Review
Its a little unreal how easy these guys make it! Ive slowly started liquidating a lot of my collection and these guys are getting me paid every week for it with minimal effort on my end. Customer service is second to none as well (responded within 20 mins of
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
Its a little unreal how easy these guys make it! Ive slowly started liquidating a lot of my collection and these guys are getting me paid every week for it with minimal effort on my end. Customer service is second to none as well (responded within 20 mins of
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
me reaching out.) Thank you again!
David Lanni
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Quick turnaround and a fair price for the cards. Would sell to them again.
Quick turnaround and a fair price for the cards. Would sell to them again.
Lucas Friedman
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
I love using Card Conduit and will use it again when I have more cards I do not need anymore.
I love using Card Conduit and will use it again when I have more cards I do not need anymore.
Peter Lozano
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Over all I’m very happy with my experience and highly recommend this to people.
Over all I’m very happy with my experience and highly recommend this to people.
JF
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Very happy with the Card Conduit experience! I appreciate how much info is provided. 10/10 would use again!
Very happy with the Card Conduit experience! I appreciate how much info is provided. 10/10 would use again!
David Groulx
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Easy to ship my cards, very happy with the value I received, have already recommended Card Conduit to others.
Easy to ship my cards, very happy with the value I received, have already recommended Card Conduit to others.
Christopher S
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
I had a large Magic the Gathering collection and Card Conduit's card services made the process of selling my cards fast and efficient. The prices provided were more than fair and I appreciate the work they did for me.
I had a large Magic the Gathering collection and Card Conduit's card services made the process of selling my cards fast and efficient. The prices provided were more than fair and I appreciate the work they did for me.
Mike C
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
Quick turn-around on my card shipment. The process is always easy.
Quick turn-around on my card shipment. The process is always easy.
Jeremy O'Briant
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
I think the process is very simple (other than having to go through my collection!). I have done three shipments through Card Conduit and I've been satisfied with the results so far. I am slightly confused as to the grading process (particularly on the second shipment) as I received about the same p
...
Read more
I think the process is very simple (other than having to go through my collection!). I have done three shipments through Card Conduit and I've been satisfied with the results so far. I am slightly confused as to the grading process (particularly on the second shipment) as I received about the same payout for the third shipment as I did for the second when I know the card quality was a little lower (definitely some more well-played cards) in the third shipment. The percentage I received from the NM condition for each was significantly different. I'm not sure of the grading process but it seems different people grade differently. Other than that, I love selling through Card Conduit and the simplicity compared to selling singles through other sites is unbeatable.
b
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
While I was hesitant, Card Conduit's service and detailed report exceeded my expectations. Their valuations in condition and price were in line with current rates and grading. I would recommend this service!
While I was hesitant, Card Conduit's service and detailed report exceeded my expectations. Their valuations in condition and price were in line with current rates and grading. I would recommend this service!
Tom
Review left Oct 09 2025
Shipment processed Sep 02 2025
Review
The process is easy and the money shows up quick. I have only sent in cards under $80 and the pricing has been very fair. If you want to save time and avoid haggling, these are folks to work with.
The process is easy and the money shows up quick. I have only sent in cards under $80 and the pricing has been very fair. If you want to save time and avoid haggling, these are folks to work with.
Howard
Review left Oct 09 2025
Review
The process was simple and easy. I found out about Card Conduit from a friend who previously used their services. While I'm sad that I had to sell my childhood, it did help out in the long run. From the time it would have taken me to sell these cards individually, card conduit made the process simpl
...
Read more
The process was simple and easy. I found out about Card Conduit from a friend who previously used their services. While I'm sad that I had to sell my childhood, it did help out in the long run. From the time it would have taken me to sell these cards individually, card conduit made the process simple. While I realize a lot of my card were heavily played, I feel that I got a good deal for what the cards went for. It's not easy making this decision to sell your cards, but I can assure you that card conduit makes the process simple. Follow their directions and everything will go smoothly. 10 out of 10, I would use again.
Ethan
Review left Oct 09 2025
Review
The team was accessible, helpful & gave good advice when I had questions about shipping. The site made it easy to understand what to do every step of the way, and the amount of information available in their portal after sending the shipment was perfect - gave me confidence and updates when availabl
...
Read more
The team was accessible, helpful & gave good advice when I had questions about shipping. The site made it easy to understand what to do every step of the way, and the amount of information available in their portal after sending the shipment was perfect - gave me confidence and updates when available.
Very professional and very polished service, respectfully handled at every step!
Very professional and very polished service, respectfully handled at every step!
Andre Gomez
Review left Oct 09 2025
Review
The process is so smooth, The process is so smooth.
The process is so smooth, The process is so smooth.
Jeremy Champe
Review left Oct 09 2025
Review
I couldn't be happier with Card Conduit so far. Excellent customer service. Transparency. And, most importantly, more than fair payouts.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
I couldn't be happier with Card Conduit so far. Excellent customer service. Transparency. And, most importantly, more than fair payouts.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
Gabe A.
Review left Oct 09 2025
Review
This was a really simple process, I sorted my cards, sent them out, they got checked, I even got a report about the conditions of my cards to say why some may have been priced lower than expected.
I'm absolutely going to use this service again!
I'm absolutely going to use this service again!
This was a really simple process, I sorted my cards, sent them out, they got checked, I even got a report about the conditions of my cards to say why some may have been priced lower than expected.
I'm absolutely going to use this service again!
I'm absolutely going to use this service again!
Mark Ross-Lonergan
Review left Oct 08 2025
Review
I've now used card conduit a few times, between the quick turnaround times, the accurate evaluations and in-depth guides to both packing and sorting, I really cant recommend enough. This last time I had need to contact customer service and I was so impressed that I had a human response within minut
...
Read more
I've now used card conduit a few times, between the quick turnaround times, the accurate evaluations and in-depth guides to both packing and sorting, I really cant recommend enough. This last time I had need to contact customer service and I was so impressed that I had a human response within minutes and the issues resolved immediately. This is why I will continue to support and use card conduit!
Zach H.
Review left Oct 08 2025
Review
I had a huge amount of cards that I wanted to sell that had values that were all over the place, and many of them didn't carry a value that warranted listing as singles on a sales website like TCG Player, which is where I usually sell my cards. I shipped the whole lot to Card Conduit and they were I
...
Read more
I had a huge amount of cards that I wanted to sell that had values that were all over the place, and many of them didn't carry a value that warranted listing as singles on a sales website like TCG Player, which is where I usually sell my cards. I shipped the whole lot to Card Conduit and they were INCREDIBLE. They communicated with me every step of the way and I actually got way more for my shipment than I was expecting. 10/10 recommend.
Gail v
Review left Oct 08 2025
Review
Such an easy and pleasant transaction. I didn't know what I was doing and they were very kind and understanding. I definitely recommend using their services
Such an easy and pleasant transaction. I didn't know what I was doing and they were very kind and understanding. I definitely recommend using their services
Chris S
Review left Oct 08 2025
Review
I had a large Magic the Gathering collection and Card Conduit's card services made the process of selling my cards fast and efficient. The prices provided were more than fair and I appreciate the work they did for me.
I had a large Magic the Gathering collection and Card Conduit's card services made the process of selling my cards fast and efficient. The prices provided were more than fair and I appreciate the work they did for me.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).