Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6073)
Aaron
Review left Nov 03 2025
Shipment processed Oct 29 2025
Review
I've done 3 shipments to Card Conduit, all with the sorted service.
Pros: Easy. Very easy. Add the cards, sort them, ship them, get paid. Zelle payout option is wildly convenient. Payout values are much better for some cards than any other place I normally sell or buylist.
Cons: The grading is ... Read more
Pros: Easy. Very easy. Add the cards, sort them, ship them, get paid. Zelle payout option is wildly convenient. Payout values are much better for some cards than any other place I normally sell or buylist.
Cons: The grading is ... Read more
I've done 3 shipments to Card Conduit, all with the sorted service.
Pros: Easy. Very easy. Add the cards, sort them, ship them, get paid. Zelle payout option is wildly convenient. Payout values are much better for some cards than any other place I normally sell or buylist.
Cons: The grading is quite strict. Don't expect to get the NM value for everything you send, even for pack fresh cards. I was definitely surprised at some of the grades my cards received and it makes me hesitant to send higher value cards, even if their list price is higher than other options (because you won't get that NM list price).
I am excited to try their standard shipment service.
Pros: Easy. Very easy. Add the cards, sort them, ship them, get paid. Zelle payout option is wildly convenient. Payout values are much better for some cards than any other place I normally sell or buylist.
Cons: The grading is quite strict. Don't expect to get the NM value for everything you send, even for pack fresh cards. I was definitely surprised at some of the grades my cards received and it makes me hesitant to send higher value cards, even if their list price is higher than other options (because you won't get that NM list price).
I am excited to try their standard shipment service.
Tim
Review left Oct 29 2025
Shipment processed Oct 17 2025
Review
Very easy to work with. Card grading felt a little critical but they were able to provide an explanation and photos when I asked. Corrected some issues quickly with great communication. Was helping a friend with their collection and will return for my collection down the line.
Very easy to work with. Card grading felt a little critical but they were able to provide an explanation and photos when I asked. Corrected some issues quickly with great communication. Was helping a friend with their collection and will return for my collection down the line.
Vincent Marianelli
Review left Oct 28 2025
Review
Yes the process was easy. Nick was very helpful with a lengthy email response to my questions. I was disappointed with the high shipping costs in my area, which was not covered by CardConduit. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell magic cards!
Yes the process was easy. Nick was very helpful with a lengthy email response to my questions. I was disappointed with the high shipping costs in my area, which was not covered by CardConduit. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell magic cards!
William
Review left Oct 10 2025
Review
First time selling to CC, very thorough and straightforward transaction, payout wise wasn't as much as I thought considering some cards were graded less than NM, but overall good service and would use it again.
First time selling to CC, very thorough and straightforward transaction, payout wise wasn't as much as I thought considering some cards were graded less than NM, but overall good service and would use it again.
David
Review left Oct 04 2025
Review
The process was straight forward. It took some time to do it, but not bad. The only complaint is Card Conduit doesn’t seem super up to date on changing market prices
The process was straight forward. It took some time to do it, but not bad. The only complaint is Card Conduit doesn’t seem super up to date on changing market prices
Jared Geuther
Review left Sep 25 2025
Review
Was an easy process to get my cards sold. 4 day turnaround on their site wasn't correct though, it took almost 7 days. Will definitely sell to them again.
Was an easy process to get my cards sold. 4 day turnaround on their site wasn't correct though, it took almost 7 days. Will definitely sell to them again.
Danny
Review left Sep 13 2025
Review
The process was easy. Of course I wanted a little more for my vintage cards, but I'm happy knowing that someone will have the opportunity to appreciate my old cards that were just sitting around.
The process was easy. Of course I wanted a little more for my vintage cards, but I'm happy knowing that someone will have the opportunity to appreciate my old cards that were just sitting around.
Hugh Jan
Review left Sep 11 2025
Review
Not bad to test it out, might use again in future. I sell on TCGplayer (which is the conditioning guide they use) and have to say they under graded a bunch of cards. NM on all the cheap cards and MP on the more expensive cards. For what it is it's fast and good way to get rid of cards quickly that might sit in inventory for 2-6+ months if I sold myself.
Not bad to test it out, might use again in future. I sell on TCGplayer (which is the conditioning guide they use) and have to say they under graded a bunch of cards. NM on all the cheap cards and MP on the more expensive cards. For what it is it's fast and good way to get rid of cards quickly that might sit in inventory for 2-6+ months if I sold myself.
Nathanial Bennett
Review left Sep 10 2025
Review
Easy process, quick payment. I've used other card selling platforms and this was by far the easiest and highest paying.
Easy process, quick payment. I've used other card selling platforms and this was by far the easiest and highest paying.
Wrandy Little
Review left Aug 31 2025
Review
For it’s taking longer to process the order and your company has been taking more out of the pay outs,and besides that it’s alright to help with selling your cards
For it’s taking longer to process the order and your company has been taking more out of the pay outs,and besides that it’s alright to help with selling your cards
Dominic Baker
Review left Aug 18 2025
Review
can't complain ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
can't complain ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
Genesis Hopper
Review left Aug 15 2025
Shipment processed Jul 23 2025
Review
The process was easy, with correspondence being mostly on time.
The process was easy, with correspondence being mostly on time.
James O
Review left Aug 10 2025
Review
The process was pretty simple. I had some old cards that I'd found in the basement from... a billion years ago. Back when we carried around decks rubberbanded in a plastic bag, back when we hard riffle shuffled them. Back when they were for play, rather than for collection. Sleeves were a thing that
...
Read more
The process was pretty simple. I had some old cards that I'd found in the basement from... a billion years ago. Back when we carried around decks rubberbanded in a plastic bag, back when we hard riffle shuffled them. Back when they were for play, rather than for collection. Sleeves were a thing that people did to decks containing cards they'd bought to win games with and pubstomp.
So my cards weren't in an overall great condition. They'd been in a basement forever. Still, some of them were in fair shape, I'd say. Of the ones I decided to turn in, Card Conduit gave me a fair shake on them. Once they were there, the review process went smoothly and even though I had some trouble with screwing up my OWN payment info, support was there to help and figure it out with me. <3
So my cards weren't in an overall great condition. They'd been in a basement forever. Still, some of them were in fair shape, I'd say. Of the ones I decided to turn in, Card Conduit gave me a fair shake on them. Once they were there, the review process went smoothly and even though I had some trouble with screwing up my OWN payment info, support was there to help and figure it out with me. <3
Luke
Review left Jul 24 2025
Review
The process was very easy and I commend the CC team as they answered honestly and quickly to questions I had for some of the card prices.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG ... Read more
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG ... Read more
The process was very easy and I commend the CC team as they answered honestly and quickly to questions I had for some of the card prices.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG collection, but still I do believe it was a fair payout and the work I did to package and prepare the collection was nearly nothing.
Overall the process was easy and convenient. I was a slight bit disappointed in the final payout amount as the collection represented a large portion of my MTG collection, but still I do believe it was a fair payout and the work I did to package and prepare the collection was nearly nothing.
John W Duell
Review left Jul 13 2025
Review
I would recommend this service to a friend for sure.
I would recommend this service to a friend for sure.
Jonathan Martin
Review left Jul 01 2025
Review
As the title states overall happy. If I had the time I would have reached out about the damaged cards. In understand the lightly to moderately played cards they marked but per their standards I don't think I sent damaged cards. I packaged my cards with my extra care but who knows maybe something happened in transit
As the title states overall happy. If I had the time I would have reached out about the damaged cards. In understand the lightly to moderately played cards they marked but per their standards I don't think I sent damaged cards. I packaged my cards with my extra care but who knows maybe something happened in transit
Amanda Osborne
Review left Jul 01 2025
Review
The process was easy, the communication was great and the timing was good.
The process was easy, the communication was great and the timing was good.
Hunter Gunnells
Review left Jun 28 2025
Review
Easy process, while my cards weren't all graded in the condition I thought they were in; I'm not a professional in that regard by any means. That said I wasn't going to use those cards anyway so better to offload them and get something for them. I would recommend.
Easy process, while my cards weren't all graded in the condition I thought they were in; I'm not a professional in that regard by any means. That said I wasn't going to use those cards anyway so better to offload them and get something for them. I would recommend.
Patrick laRue
Review left Jun 24 2025
Review
Fast and easy and price is ok not may others that do it.
Fast and easy and price is ok not may others that do it.
Quick
Review left Jun 10 2025
Review
Prices is easy, just take your time to sort your cards . Some of the high dollar cards get graded as LP , but I guess I’m a bit off on my grading . Overall quick, easy and hassle free
Prices is easy, just take your time to sort your cards . Some of the high dollar cards get graded as LP , but I guess I’m a bit off on my grading . Overall quick, easy and hassle free
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).