Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5884)
Taylor Shirley
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
I really liked how easy it was to liquidate cards into cash. The process was simple and easy to figure out. I would recommend this to anyone and everyone who wan’s to seek their cards without all the hassle.
I really liked how easy it was to liquidate cards into cash. The process was simple and easy to figure out. I would recommend this to anyone and everyone who wan’s to seek their cards without all the hassle.
Kash
Review left Dec 10 2025
Review
I wasn't sure what to expect. But the experience was super. You get a report after the card is received and processed. The report was accurate and price was fairly reflecting market value. It is a better deal than selling at a local store by far; I know since I compared pricing.
I highly recommend.
I highly recommend.
I wasn't sure what to expect. But the experience was super. You get a report after the card is received and processed. The report was accurate and price was fairly reflecting market value. It is a better deal than selling at a local store by far; I know since I compared pricing.
I highly recommend.
I highly recommend.
Ryan Sebacher
Review left Dec 09 2025
Shipment processed Nov 08 2025
Review
Simple process, fair grading, cut they take is also fair in my opinion. Fast, responsive customer service. Good company.
Simple process, fair grading, cut they take is also fair in my opinion. Fast, responsive customer service. Good company.
Josh
Review left Dec 09 2025
Review
This was my first shipment with Card conduit and I’m impressed.
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
This was my first shipment with Card conduit and I’m impressed.
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
For my sorted shipment, I uploaded my CSV from ManaBox, they gave me a buy list based on my cards, I organized and shipped, then boom payment received.
Got a fantastic offer on the value of my cards compared to cards shops and other services. Highly recommend
Hayley Greenstone
Review left Dec 09 2025
Shipment processed Nov 27 2025
Review
The process was easy and simple, got good value for my cards and is overall worth doing whenever I have some spare cards to sell
The process was easy and simple, got good value for my cards and is overall worth doing whenever I have some spare cards to sell
Brad HG
Review left Dec 09 2025
Review
Great experience from beginning to end. Will use again
Great experience from beginning to end. Will use again
Mitch Jahnke
Review left Dec 09 2025
Shipment processed Dec 06 2025
Review
Was a great experience all around. Will for sure be using this service again in the future!
Was a great experience all around. Will for sure be using this service again in the future!
Larisa Ann Muller
Review left Dec 09 2025
Review
Taking the tike to sort through my cards for the curated option is so worth it. This last shipment I got more than I was expecting for my cards, and its nice to have a place to sell the lower value cards along with higher value all bundled together without having to worry about individual buyers or
...
Read more
Taking the tike to sort through my cards for the curated option is so worth it. This last shipment I got more than I was expecting for my cards, and its nice to have a place to sell the lower value cards along with higher value all bundled together without having to worry about individual buyers or shipping to a bunch of places over and over as cards are bought one by one. They communicate through the whole process, and are very accommodating for larger collections. And both times I've used this service this year the payment was promp and on time. I will always use Card Conduit if I need to sell again in the future.
Tim
Review left Dec 08 2025
Review
Thank you for processing my order - will do business again
Thank you for processing my order - will do business again
Scott
Review left Dec 07 2025
Review
This is my second major experience selling cards through Card Conduit, as a friend asked me to help get her card collection sold. The staff was helpful and accommodating, even of a larger-than-normal shipment. That was simple in a time that was otherwise somewhat stressful, and the efforts are always appreciated. My thanks to everyone involved.
This is my second major experience selling cards through Card Conduit, as a friend asked me to help get her card collection sold. The staff was helpful and accommodating, even of a larger-than-normal shipment. That was simple in a time that was otherwise somewhat stressful, and the efforts are always appreciated. My thanks to everyone involved.
Logan
Review left Dec 06 2025
Shipment processed Nov 27 2025
$1,987.72
payout, $40.57
fees
Review
Seriously love these guys, don't sleep if you need to move a large amount of cards at once. I don't think they can be beat and the process is always easy!
I'm queuing up another shipment as we speak :)
I'm queuing up another shipment as we speak :)
Seriously love these guys, don't sleep if you need to move a large amount of cards at once. I don't think they can be beat and the process is always easy!
I'm queuing up another shipment as we speak :)
I'm queuing up another shipment as we speak :)
Swiss
Review left Dec 06 2025
Review
I have used Card Conduit for several submissions now and I always feel like I get a great deal. They are professional with replying to emails and are very prompt with their updates. I will continue to use them and promote their services!
I have used Card Conduit for several submissions now and I always feel like I get a great deal. They are professional with replying to emails and are very prompt with their updates. I will continue to use them and promote their services!
Ryan
Review left Dec 06 2025
Review
I looked around for a bit as I had over 1000 cards to sell, I really didn't want to try to sell them in singles. Highly recommended, they were fast, efficient and respectful of the collection. I'm sure I'll want to sell more cards in the future and they will all be going to Card Conduit when the time comes. Great service.
I looked around for a bit as I had over 1000 cards to sell, I really didn't want to try to sell them in singles. Highly recommended, they were fast, efficient and respectful of the collection. I'm sure I'll want to sell more cards in the future and they will all be going to Card Conduit when the time comes. Great service.
Joshua Cunningham
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
Great Service! Will definitely use CC again in the future!
Great Service! Will definitely use CC again in the future!
Phil S.
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
I did a fair amount of legwork so I could get the curated option but overall, the service was wonderful and I was happy with the payment. I was able to lower my collection of a lot of cards.
I did a fair amount of legwork so I could get the curated option but overall, the service was wonderful and I was happy with the payment. I was able to lower my collection of a lot of cards.
Adam Moates
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
This was my first time using card conduit. I did send some cards I thought had decent to high value but those were not evaluated as such. I have to say that the grading process is a little tough cause some of my cards came straight out of a pack and were not graded NM. But as a whole, they make it s
...
Read more
This was my first time using card conduit. I did send some cards I thought had decent to high value but those were not evaluated as such. I have to say that the grading process is a little tough cause some of my cards came straight out of a pack and were not graded NM. But as a whole, they make it simple to get cash for cards. I will be using them again because I have a lot of cards and this was just to see how it all works. I just hope next time some of the values are a bit higher
Aaron K.
Review left Dec 05 2025
Review
Looking up cards was extremely easy, the requested sorting for my cards made perfect sense. All communication was quick, courteous, and transparent. The assessment was fair and explained. It was a great experience and I believe I will be comfortable to sell to CardConduit in the future.
Looking up cards was extremely easy, the requested sorting for my cards made perfect sense. All communication was quick, courteous, and transparent. The assessment was fair and explained. It was a great experience and I believe I will be comfortable to sell to CardConduit in the future.
Travis Pryor
Review left Dec 04 2025
Shipment processed Dec 04 2025
Review
Easy and great service . They get your card done in a timely manner and your money to you quickly as well.
Easy and great service . They get your card done in a timely manner and your money to you quickly as well.
Sebastian
Review left Dec 04 2025
Review
I first used Card Conduit in 2023 and was very pleased with the results. Now it’s 2025 and I just completed my third shipment.
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling ca ... Read more
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling ca ... Read more
I first used Card Conduit in 2023 and was very pleased with the results. Now it’s 2025 and I just completed my third shipment.
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling cards. Customer service is friendly and everything is reasonably fast.
If you use them I highly recommend you unsleeve all the cards you’re shipping first. It’s a little extra work on your part but it’s worth it.
I love how easy they make it to downsize my collection and trim what not actually using, without having to go through the hassle of individually listing and selling cards. Customer service is friendly and everything is reasonably fast.
If you use them I highly recommend you unsleeve all the cards you’re shipping first. It’s a little extra work on your part but it’s worth it.
Connor Cranston
Review left Dec 04 2025
Review
Everything was as easy as could be. The team communicated with me every step of the way, and I loved the little stats review they give once the order is fully processed. 100% satisfied with my experience.
Everything was as easy as could be. The team communicated with me every step of the way, and I loved the little stats review they give once the order is fully processed. 100% satisfied with my experience.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).