Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Gage S.
Review left Mar 06 2022
Review
I used their curated service to sell off a large part of my collection. They have solid step by step guides on how to go through the whole process and keep you updated after you ship the cards. My only regret is not doing this sooner!
I used their curated service to sell off a large part of my collection. They have solid step by step guides on how to go through the whole process and keep you updated after you ship the cards. My only regret is not doing this sooner!
Davis phillips
Review left Mar 04 2022
Review
Process was laid out in instructions clearly and when followed was simple. I was reluctant at fist but this is one service to not cut out the middle man.
Process was laid out in instructions clearly and when followed was simple. I was reluctant at fist but this is one service to not cut out the middle man.
Joshua Hinkley
Review left Mar 02 2022
Review
Was a very simple process, constant communication from card conduit and more money than I would have got selling at an LGS. I did the curated shipment, and while it is less than I would have got if I had sold each card individually, the simplicity made up for that! Highly recommended!
Was a very simple process, constant communication from card conduit and more money than I would have got selling at an LGS. I did the curated shipment, and while it is less than I would have got if I had sold each card individually, the simplicity made up for that! Highly recommended!
Jeffrey
Review left Mar 02 2022
Review
Got paid within a week or two of the cards being shipped. Will use this service again
Got paid within a week or two of the cards being shipped. Will use this service again
Satisfied In St. Louis
Review left Mar 02 2022
Review
There is no better or easier way to sell your collection than Card Conduit. Totally seamless process that had my collection evaluated and paid out so quickly.
There is no better or easier way to sell your collection than Card Conduit. Totally seamless process that had my collection evaluated and paid out so quickly.
Rick B.
Review left Mar 02 2022
Review
As I’ve said in a previous review, the process is very easy, I believe I’m getting the best value for my cards and would(and have)recommend them.
As I’ve said in a previous review, the process is very easy, I believe I’m getting the best value for my cards and would(and have)recommend them.
Joe U
Review left Feb 28 2022
Review
The process of sending my cards over was very simple and low costed, and within the next two weeks I was paid according to market values and the condition of my cards. I was initially quite apprehensive, but was pleasantly surprised that they do pay you the full amount possible.
The process of sending my cards over was very simple and low costed, and within the next two weeks I was paid according to market values and the condition of my cards. I was initially quite apprehensive, but was pleasantly surprised that they do pay you the full amount possible.
Jonah
Review left Feb 28 2022
Review
My friend recommended me this service and it did not disappoint! The website explains the process to you and shows you where to send the cards and tells you all the steps you go through. I would recommend this especially to people selling high dollar cards.
My friend recommended me this service and it did not disappoint! The website explains the process to you and shows you where to send the cards and tells you all the steps you go through. I would recommend this especially to people selling high dollar cards.
Nick C.
Review left Feb 28 2022
Review
I sent a box of mostly unsorted foils and leftovers from Collectors Boosters for which I had no use. The Card Conduit website made the process easy and straightforward. I especially like the breakdown at the end. It is totally worth not having to sort through my cards and compare all the different b
...
Read more
I sent a box of mostly unsorted foils and leftovers from Collectors Boosters for which I had no use. The Card Conduit website made the process easy and straightforward. I especially like the breakdown at the end. It is totally worth not having to sort through my cards and compare all the different buylist websites. Fees are reasonable and I will absolutely be using Card Conduit again!
Eric B.
Review left Feb 27 2022
Review
The process was easy and intuitive. It requires a bit of patience since the whole process from shipping to payment takes ~2 weeks, but totally worth it. I went through my collection and sorted out my mythics and rares and sent them to Card Conduit. The value ended up being about $470 of which I kept
...
Read more
The process was easy and intuitive. It requires a bit of patience since the whole process from shipping to payment takes ~2 weeks, but totally worth it. I went through my collection and sorted out my mythics and rares and sent them to Card Conduit. The value ended up being about $470 of which I kept about $410. TOTALLY worth it considering the HOURS upon HOURS it would have taken me to sell all of those cards individually. They were very friendly and regular in their communication as well. Everything was above-board and the fee was quite reasonable.
Joe B
Review left Feb 27 2022
Review
Super easy to ship, great communication, AMAZING value for my cards. Would absolutely use again.
Super easy to ship, great communication, AMAZING value for my cards. Would absolutely use again.
Chris K.
Review left Feb 25 2022
Review
The team at Card Conduit made selling my cards a completely painless experience. They are professional, courteous and honest-to-a-fault. I can fully and without reservation recommend Card Conduit.
The team at Card Conduit made selling my cards a completely painless experience. They are professional, courteous and honest-to-a-fault. I can fully and without reservation recommend Card Conduit.
Jeremy G.
Review left Feb 24 2022
Review
Definitely satisfied with the experience! Payout was pretty accurate to the estimator, and I averaged about 65-70% of retail. Staff were very responsive to my questions about the process, maybe I was a little more apprehensive than I needed to be, but it almost seemed too easy to be real. ;)
I d ... Read more
I d ... Read more
Definitely satisfied with the experience! Payout was pretty accurate to the estimator, and I averaged about 65-70% of retail. Staff were very responsive to my questions about the process, maybe I was a little more apprehensive than I needed to be, but it almost seemed too easy to be real. ;)
I did the legwork ahead of time to maximize return, and suggest folks do the same (use the collection importer for estimates, remove all cards <$0.50 or so from your shipment) rather than just mailing a box of cards you have laying around. )
Will likely be using it in the future!
I did the legwork ahead of time to maximize return, and suggest folks do the same (use the collection importer for estimates, remove all cards <$0.50 or so from your shipment) rather than just mailing a box of cards you have laying around. )
Will likely be using it in the future!
Eric
Review left Feb 23 2022
Review
Had a lot of old cards, mostly from 90s and early 2000s. Extremely simple and straight forward selling experience.
Had a lot of old cards, mostly from 90s and early 2000s. Extremely simple and straight forward selling experience.
Sean T.
Review left Feb 23 2022
Review
It was easy to send the cards in - they tell you exactly how to do it... and definitely make the whole process of selling the cards seamless. I used another service in the past and they didn't match 3 of the cards and it was kind of a mess. This makes it easy and you get paid well for your cards. I was very happy.
It was easy to send the cards in - they tell you exactly how to do it... and definitely make the whole process of selling the cards seamless. I used another service in the past and they didn't match 3 of the cards and it was kind of a mess. This makes it easy and you get paid well for your cards. I was very happy.
Shaun N
Review left Feb 23 2022
Review
Card Conduit was a fantastic experience from beginning to end. They are upfront on all of their policy’s unlike other vendors you Buylist with and give you accurate prices before you send in your cards.
I had issues at one point and was responded to in minutes with the problem being solved immediately.
I had issues at one point and was responded to in minutes with the problem being solved immediately.
Card Conduit was a fantastic experience from beginning to end. They are upfront on all of their policy’s unlike other vendors you Buylist with and give you accurate prices before you send in your cards.
I had issues at one point and was responded to in minutes with the problem being solved immediately.
I had issues at one point and was responded to in minutes with the problem being solved immediately.
Ira Kroll
Review left Feb 23 2022
Review
Processed in a reasonable amount of time. Gave more money than the local store would have.
Processed in a reasonable amount of time. Gave more money than the local store would have.
Dustin M.
Review left Feb 22 2022
Shipment processed Feb 11 2022
Review
First, I would like to say that Nick is a wonderful customer service agent. He responds quickly to emails and is thorough in his explanations. I recently sent in a shipment of cards with a retail value of ~750 give or take and ended up getting ~500 for it. Could I have got more if I sold them on eBa
...
Read more
First, I would like to say that Nick is a wonderful customer service agent. He responds quickly to emails and is thorough in his explanations. I recently sent in a shipment of cards with a retail value of ~750 give or take and ended up getting ~500 for it. Could I have got more if I sold them on eBay or somewhere individually and waited a month or so? Probably, the answer is yes. However, factoring in the final eBay fees, shipping, and risk of buyers returning stuff, it wouldn't be a significant amount of gain for the time. Basically if your time is worth less to you then I would say go for it and list your stuff individually. But if you are wanting the most reasonable offer for your cards and want a hassle free experience Card Conduit is the way to go.
The only caveat here I would mention is definitely use their card evaluation and collection estimate tools. I can't fault Card Conduit solely here but what I see happens in this industry is a card will be bought and "graded" for less, example you have a NM card they pay you for LP or even a MP card then turn around and sell it for NM price. I see this ALL THE TIME on TCGplayer and almost any other online shop. It's just a fact. So be prepared for your cards to be graded less than what you probably think they ought to be graded. Regardless of this, I was still pleased.
The only caveat here I would mention is definitely use their card evaluation and collection estimate tools. I can't fault Card Conduit solely here but what I see happens in this industry is a card will be bought and "graded" for less, example you have a NM card they pay you for LP or even a MP card then turn around and sell it for NM price. I see this ALL THE TIME on TCGplayer and almost any other online shop. It's just a fact. So be prepared for your cards to be graded less than what you probably think they ought to be graded. Regardless of this, I was still pleased.
Geoff E.
Review left Feb 22 2022
Review
Blew my expectations away. Nick was super helpful in answering my litany of questions and made the submission process a breeze. The return was much higher than I anticipated. I was shocked. Can’t recommend this enough for those looking to unload their collection with minimal effort.
Blew my expectations away. Nick was super helpful in answering my litany of questions and made the submission process a breeze. The return was much higher than I anticipated. I was shocked. Can’t recommend this enough for those looking to unload their collection with minimal effort.
Chet
Review left Feb 20 2022
Review
The guys at CC kept me in the loop every step of the way. Definitely recommend.
The guys at CC kept me in the loop every step of the way. Definitely recommend.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).