Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5856)
Gavin
Review left Aug 31 2022
Review
Perfect place to unload cards that you don’t want to individually value or sell. They grade cards very fairly and truly do the seller a favor with finding the correct buy list price. Highly recommend
Perfect place to unload cards that you don’t want to individually value or sell. They grade cards very fairly and truly do the seller a favor with finding the correct buy list price. Highly recommend
Terry Reynolds
Review left Aug 31 2022
Review
It was an easy process to perform, the type of order was upgraded for me as they felt that it was more appropriate, and the payout was better than I expected.
It was an easy process to perform, the type of order was upgraded for me as they felt that it was more appropriate, and the payout was better than I expected.
Alex Teniente
Review left Aug 31 2022
Review
EZ they tell you exactly what to do! Took about 2 weeks from when I got the tracking info till the money was in my account!
EZ they tell you exactly what to do! Took about 2 weeks from when I got the tracking info till the money was in my account!
Spencer Bennion
Review left Aug 31 2022
Review
Easy to ship, they adapted to me sending 6 large USPS packages quickly by communicating with me, and kept me appraised.
Very nice customer service
Very nice customer service
Easy to ship, they adapted to me sending 6 large USPS packages quickly by communicating with me, and kept me appraised.
Very nice customer service
Very nice customer service
Neal Smothers
Review left Aug 30 2022
Review
This is my second shipment of MTG cards through Card Conduit, and I have to say this is the best service I've ever used. The quick response, fast payments, and fantastic attention to detail are unparalleled. I love the report you get once they've completed buying your cards. A super informative and
...
Read more
This is my second shipment of MTG cards through Card Conduit, and I have to say this is the best service I've ever used. The quick response, fast payments, and fantastic attention to detail are unparalleled. I love the report you get once they've completed buying your cards. A super informative and cool extra feature that shows the love they have for buying/selling cards. Fantastic service; if you were on the fence, don't be this place rocks!!
Jon
Review left Aug 30 2022
Review
I had a lot of questions going into the process of selling my childhood collection, but Nick was very helpful. Although I’m sure I could have made a little bit more by piecing out some of the pricier cards, this was much easier and quicker. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to others.
I had a lot of questions going into the process of selling my childhood collection, but Nick was very helpful. Although I’m sure I could have made a little bit more by piecing out some of the pricier cards, this was much easier and quicker. I would definitely recommend Card Conduit to others.
Daniel O
Review left Aug 30 2022
Review
I would recommend this service to anyone! I buy collections locally quiet regularly. I used other outlets for cards above 5 bucks on low generally. I sent them all my bulk rares and valuable L/C/UC... in a few weeks junk turned into over 500 bucks!
I would recommend this service to anyone! I buy collections locally quiet regularly. I used other outlets for cards above 5 bucks on low generally. I sent them all my bulk rares and valuable L/C/UC... in a few weeks junk turned into over 500 bucks!
Kyle
Review left Aug 30 2022
Shipment processed Jul 22 2022
$3,077.91
payout, $145.03
fees
Review
Reliable, straightforward and fast with competitive pricing. Customer support even optimized the fee package after the appraisal process to maximize my payout. Highly recommended!
Reliable, straightforward and fast with competitive pricing. Customer support even optimized the fee package after the appraisal process to maximize my payout. Highly recommended!
Seth R Christenfeld
Review left Aug 30 2022
Review
Right when my mother was bugging me (okay, for about the twenty-seventh time) to get my old 90s-era Magic cards out of her basement, an ad for Card Conduit came across my Facebook feed. Loath as I am to do anything from a Facebook ad, this one intrigued me, as did the information I found on a quick
...
Read more
Right when my mother was bugging me (okay, for about the twenty-seventh time) to get my old 90s-era Magic cards out of her basement, an ad for Card Conduit came across my Facebook feed. Loath as I am to do anything from a Facebook ad, this one intrigued me, as did the information I found on a quick search. I figured I'd be lucky if anything I had was worth more than a pittance, so it wasn't worth my time to go though it and look up every card, estimate a value, and then make the effort to sell them off, and so I boxed up about half of what I had and sent it off. In about a week or so, I got an email from the folks at CC with the information on what I'd sent them--and it was worth much more than I expected. I received the check about a week after that. The same goes for the second shipment I sent. The entire process was swift and painless, and if you're someone like me--i.e. someone who played Magic for a while, then eventually gave it up and have been letting your old cards collect dust for years--I can't recommend them highly enough.
Seth Christenfeld
Review left Aug 30 2022
Review
Right when my mother was bugging me (okay, for about the twenty-seventh time) to get my old 90s-era Magic cards out of her basement, an ad for Card Conduit came across my Facebook feed. Loath as I am to do anything from a Facebook ad, this one intrigued me, as did the information I found on a quick
...
Read more
Right when my mother was bugging me (okay, for about the twenty-seventh time) to get my old 90s-era Magic cards out of her basement, an ad for Card Conduit came across my Facebook feed. Loath as I am to do anything from a Facebook ad, this one intrigued me, as did the information I found on a quick search. I figured I'd be lucky if anything I had was worth more than a pittance, so it wasn't worth my time to go though it and look up every card, estimate a value, and then make the effort to sell them off, and so I boxed up about half of what I had and sent it off. In about a week or so, I got an email from the folks at CC with the information on what I'd sent them--and it was worth much more than I expected. I received the check about a week after that. The same goes for the second shipment I sent. The entire process was swift and painless, and if you're someone like me--i.e. someone who played Magic for a while, then eventually gave it up and have been letting your old cards collect dust for years--I can't recommend them highly enough.
Garrett
Review left Aug 30 2022
Review
Their website is really easy to navigate, super user friendly, and everyone was quick to answer my questions!
Their website is really easy to navigate, super user friendly, and everyone was quick to answer my questions!
Ryan Bernhisel
Review left Aug 29 2022
Shipment processed Aug 08 2022
Review
Very smooth and easy to work with. Got my results quick and detailed explanation. Will definitely use again!
Very smooth and easy to work with. Got my results quick and detailed explanation. Will definitely use again!
Scott Beachy
Review left Aug 29 2022
Review
If I hadn't found these guys online, I probably would have taken my collection to my lgs for about half of what I got on here. The process was super easy too, and once they received my cards, they send me periodic updates for my order, and even allowed me to change details of my order after they had
...
Read more
If I hadn't found these guys online, I probably would have taken my collection to my lgs for about half of what I got on here. The process was super easy too, and once they received my cards, they send me periodic updates for my order, and even allowed me to change details of my order after they had already received my cards to maximize my payout. I would definitely choose these guys again.
Craig
Review left Aug 29 2022
Review
I decided to try out the service per a friend's recommendation. The fee structure seems very fair and I really enjoyed that it was adjustable based on how much work I was willing to put in. I had read ahead of time that the grading can be a bit harsh but appreciated that they provided estimates of t
...
Read more
I decided to try out the service per a friend's recommendation. The fee structure seems very fair and I really enjoyed that it was adjustable based on how much work I was willing to put in. I had read ahead of time that the grading can be a bit harsh but appreciated that they provided estimates of the collection at each tier. My personal expectation had been that I'd land right between the LP and MP estimates (guessed the cards would be 50/50) - and that was exactly where I ended up for payout in the end. Realistically had I listed the cards myself I would have knocked them all down a grade anyways to cover myself anyways. Being able to save the time, headache, and cost of listing, packaging, and shipping almost 300 cards was more than worth the fees to me. Will definitely use this service again in the future.
Matt Smith
Review left Aug 29 2022
Review
Overall great experience. Saw first from YouTubers who recommended CC. Would absolutely use again.
Simple process, great communication, effectively set up website, fair assessment of card quality and fast payment. Saved me a lot of hassle in doing this individually.
Simple process, great communication, effectively set up website, fair assessment of card quality and fast payment. Saved me a lot of hassle in doing this individually.
Overall great experience. Saw first from YouTubers who recommended CC. Would absolutely use again.
Simple process, great communication, effectively set up website, fair assessment of card quality and fast payment. Saved me a lot of hassle in doing this individually.
Simple process, great communication, effectively set up website, fair assessment of card quality and fast payment. Saved me a lot of hassle in doing this individually.
Paul Brooks
Review left Aug 29 2022
Review
Process was easy. Will continue to do..website is not a confusing experience at all, and is transparent
Process was easy. Will continue to do..website is not a confusing experience at all, and is transparent
Paul Brooks
Review left Aug 29 2022
Review
It's helpful for those who are busy to have people willing to take on the work and take some of the payment
It's helpful for those who are busy to have people willing to take on the work and take some of the payment
Jeremy Champt
Review left Aug 28 2022
Review
Just excellent all around. Good communication with clear expectations. They gave me a great rate for my cards and sent me a nice personal email at the end about my collection. It couldn't have been easier. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit if you are looking for a quick way to sell off a large amount of cards.
Just excellent all around. Good communication with clear expectations. They gave me a great rate for my cards and sent me a nice personal email at the end about my collection. It couldn't have been easier. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit if you are looking for a quick way to sell off a large amount of cards.
Don Perrin
Review left Aug 26 2022
Review
I found this service online and signed up immediately. Their fees are on par or lower than any I’ve seen. I had a boatload of Alpha cards from back in the Lake Geneva Game Guild days and it was time to liquidate. The online tools to evaluate and sort the cards was easy. Ince they arrived, the guys
...
Read more
I found this service online and signed up immediately. Their fees are on par or lower than any I’ve seen. I had a boatload of Alpha cards from back in the Lake Geneva Game Guild days and it was time to liquidate. The online tools to evaluate and sort the cards was easy. Ince they arrived, the guys at Card Conduit quickly assessed the collection and sent me their offer. It was exactly where I thought it should be, so I readily accepted. A week later, and the cash was in my account.
It was simple, no hassle and very fair. Great service and I would highly recommend them.
It was simple, no hassle and very fair. Great service and I would highly recommend them.
Neal Smothers
Review left Aug 26 2022
Review
I was a bit skeptical about sending my initial shipment to a company that I hadn't heard of, but this was one of the best experiences I've ever had. The service was highly professional and speedy, and the level of detail/care taken was above rapport. Anyone who is a bit on the fence, please send you
...
Read more
I was a bit skeptical about sending my initial shipment to a company that I hadn't heard of, but this was one of the best experiences I've ever had. The service was highly professional and speedy, and the level of detail/care taken was above rapport. Anyone who is a bit on the fence, please send your cards to Card Conduit. Their service is excellent, and the fees they charge are so small compared to the work that has to be done cataloging/selling yourself. I have two more orders in the pipeline waiting to be graded, and I'm anxious to see what I get for the rest of my MTG collection. Thanks so much, Card Conduit; it made my life much easier!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).