Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(6842)
John Linton
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
I have used this service several times and I have never been disappointed. Customer service is beyond reproach. If you are in the market for selling your magic cards, look no further, this is the BEST COMPANY PERIOD!
I have used this service several times and I have never been disappointed. Customer service is beyond reproach. If you are in the market for selling your magic cards, look no further, this is the BEST COMPANY PERIOD!
Fernando Fernandez
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
Sent in two orders, one sorted, the other auto-sifted. I'm very pleased with the handling of both orders. They worked through them quickly, the grading was fair, payout was fast and the fees were very reasonable. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit if you want to sell your collection.
Sent in two orders, one sorted, the other auto-sifted. I'm very pleased with the handling of both orders. They worked through them quickly, the grading was fair, payout was fast and the fees were very reasonable. I would highly recommend using Card Conduit if you want to sell your collection.
Kevin Sanders
Review left Jul 18 2026
Review
You guys did a great job! I have no complaints. Thank you all!
You guys did a great job! I have no complaints. Thank you all!
Owen
Review left Jul 17 2026
Review
Fast payment, fair and detailed grading, and customer support always keeps me in the loop
Fast payment, fair and detailed grading, and customer support always keeps me in the loop
William
Review left Jul 17 2026
Shipment processed Jul 07 2026
$249.05
payout, $5.08
fees
Review
I chose to pre-sort my cards which felt like a good deal. I received lots of communication through emails about timelines and where my cards were which was really convenient.
I chose to pre-sort my cards which felt like a good deal. I received lots of communication through emails about timelines and where my cards were which was really convenient.
Garrett Lee
Review left Jul 17 2026
Review
Sent in about 12000 cards using the Auto-Sift option. I was very pleased with the level of tracking and transparency during every step of this process. I would highly reccomend for anyone seeking to consolidate and turn bulk into cash!
Sent in about 12000 cards using the Auto-Sift option. I was very pleased with the level of tracking and transparency during every step of this process. I would highly reccomend for anyone seeking to consolidate and turn bulk into cash!
Wes
Review left Jul 17 2026
Review
The whole process is easy to follow and saved me a lot of headaches if I were to sell my cards individually. Fair payout as well. I'd recommend their service.
The whole process is easy to follow and saved me a lot of headaches if I were to sell my cards individually. Fair payout as well. I'd recommend their service.
Daniel B
Review left Jul 16 2026
Shipment processed Jul 14 2026
Review
Very professional business and I am very grateful to have a trustworthy service like this to send my cards to
Very professional business and I am very grateful to have a trustworthy service like this to send my cards to
Matthew
Review left Jul 16 2026
Shipment processed Jul 07 2026
Review
Honestly the hardest part was just trying to separate the cards from foil and non foil. Other than that, it was not difficult to get everything prepared and sent. Would totally do it again when my bulk gets to be too much.
Honestly the hardest part was just trying to separate the cards from foil and non foil. Other than that, it was not difficult to get everything prepared and sent. Would totally do it again when my bulk gets to be too much.
Tyler
Review left Jul 16 2026
Review
This is my 3rd or 4th time selling cards to Card Conduit and it was as smooth and easy as always. Process was easy and I got my money fast. Always suggest these guys.
This is my 3rd or 4th time selling cards to Card Conduit and it was as smooth and easy as always. Process was easy and I got my money fast. Always suggest these guys.
Clayton
Review left Jul 16 2026
Review
This was an easy and quick process to ship my cards, and get money deposited in my bank!
This was an easy and quick process to ship my cards, and get money deposited in my bank!
Deli Cards
Review left Jul 16 2026
Review
You can see the stats, this was a small number of spendy played cards. CC was the fastest way to capitalize on the current pre-modern hype without stuffing a single envelope. I don't totally agree with the conditioning, but it's either exactly what I expected or within a grade.
You can see the stats, this was a small number of spendy played cards. CC was the fastest way to capitalize on the current pre-modern hype without stuffing a single envelope. I don't totally agree with the conditioning, but it's either exactly what I expected or within a grade.
Frederick J Balsley
Review left Jul 15 2026
Review
10th shipment or so for me, and I have been nothing but pleased.
It's important to understand first, that your cards are probably not worth what you think they are.
If you feel like you're getting screwed, it's most likely because you aren't very good with economics.
90% of these cards are w ... Read more
It's important to understand first, that your cards are probably not worth what you think they are.
If you feel like you're getting screwed, it's most likely because you aren't very good with economics.
90% of these cards are w ... Read more
10th shipment or so for me, and I have been nothing but pleased.
It's important to understand first, that your cards are probably not worth what you think they are.
If you feel like you're getting screwed, it's most likely because you aren't very good with economics.
90% of these cards are worthless, truly. And it's an immense amount of work, EVEN with a card sorter!
So to be able to snag a couple hundred from my collection, very easily, without talking to anyone and with very low fees! You know I am jumping at the chance!
In fact, we are so confident with Card Conduit that my buddy and I started operating a business based mainly around them. We only make a couple hundred a month so far, but we only work like 4 hours a month, sooooooo yea.
Time is worth more than anything else, and Card Conduit helps me get my time back without having to spend EVEN MORE TIME scanning and scouring through goblin toilet paper :)
It's important to understand first, that your cards are probably not worth what you think they are.
If you feel like you're getting screwed, it's most likely because you aren't very good with economics.
90% of these cards are worthless, truly. And it's an immense amount of work, EVEN with a card sorter!
So to be able to snag a couple hundred from my collection, very easily, without talking to anyone and with very low fees! You know I am jumping at the chance!
In fact, we are so confident with Card Conduit that my buddy and I started operating a business based mainly around them. We only make a couple hundred a month so far, but we only work like 4 hours a month, sooooooo yea.
Time is worth more than anything else, and Card Conduit helps me get my time back without having to spend EVEN MORE TIME scanning and scouring through goblin toilet paper :)
Drake T
Review left Jul 15 2026
Review
Not my first shipment, but each time I've shipped to CC, they've handled it in a timely fashion, and have given me a far better price than other outlets/retailers would have
Not my first shipment, but each time I've shipped to CC, they've handled it in a timely fashion, and have given me a far better price than other outlets/retailers would have
Eric Augherton
Review left Jul 15 2026
Review
I've been using Card Conduit for multiple shipments now and I'm satisfied with every transaction! The pricing feels fair for the work they do and the value being processed. I can't recommend this card service enough! :)
I've been using Card Conduit for multiple shipments now and I'm satisfied with every transaction! The pricing feels fair for the work they do and the value being processed. I can't recommend this card service enough! :)
Devin
Review left Jul 14 2026
Review
I decided to sell my MTG collection and Card Conduit made it easy to sell what I had left over. Great customer service, very fast processing time, and fair value. Great experience overall.
I decided to sell my MTG collection and Card Conduit made it easy to sell what I had left over. Great customer service, very fast processing time, and fair value. Great experience overall.
Jason S
Review left Jul 14 2026
Review
Saved me time and put $ straight in my account. Very Easy transaction as always!
Saved me time and put $ straight in my account. Very Easy transaction as always!
leonora sternbach
Review left Jul 13 2026
Review
smooth, frictionless transaction process as it always is
smooth, frictionless transaction process as it always is
James C
Review left Jul 13 2026
Review
Sent in a few jewel cases of cards to clear out some older stock for formats I wasn't playing any longer. Process was smooth and card grading seemed accurate based on the age and wear of most of the cards based on my personal assessment, so overall I'm happy with the process and fees for the service.
Sent in a few jewel cases of cards to clear out some older stock for formats I wasn't playing any longer. Process was smooth and card grading seemed accurate based on the age and wear of most of the cards based on my personal assessment, so overall I'm happy with the process and fees for the service.
Survive
Review left Jul 13 2026
Review
Turn around was faster than expected. CC was fair with the card grading and didn't say a bunch of my pack fresh cards were "lightly played". Easy to deal with fair company unlike some other buy list sites. Will do business with them again!
Turn around was faster than expected. CC was fair with the card grading and didn't say a bunch of my pack fresh cards were "lightly played". Easy to deal with fair company unlike some other buy list sites. Will do business with them again!
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).