Customer Reviews

of our Magic collection selling service

Shipping my cards was super easy and customer service was shockingly fast to reply.

Shipping my cards was super easy and customer service was shockingly fast to reply.

Had no issues. Transaction was fast and money was sent quicker than expected.

Had no issues. Transaction was fast and money was sent quicker than expected.

Easy, good value, and affordable shipping. All and all, 10 out of 10.

Easy, good value, and affordable shipping. All and all, 10 out of 10.

Easy and convenient and exactly as advertised -- I packed up my cards and mailed them to Card Conduit, and they did the rest. Love that they offer a direct deposit option to pay me for my cards, and all worked flawlessly.

Easy and convenient and exactly as advertised -- I packed up my cards and mailed them to Card Conduit, and they did the rest. Love that they offer a direct deposit option to pay me for my cards, and all worked flawlessly.

I can't recommend this service enough. I opted for the Sorted Service so there was a little more work involved on my end (though nothing too strenuous). I don't think it was even a full two weeks between me sending my cards and then receiving payment.

Even with the Sorted Service I wouldn't expec ... Read more

I can't recommend this service enough. I opted for the Sorted Service so there was a little more work involved on my end (though nothing too strenuous). I don't think it was even a full two weeks between me sending my cards and then receiving payment.

Even with the Sorted Service I wouldn't expect Card Conduit's fees to be so little in comparison to the payout, but I'm not complaining :)

I will definitely use this service again if I end up with unused cards in the future.

The process was easy. I did the fully curated option and it took a while, but they made it as convenient as possible for what was required. I think that the grading was fair. I honestly got slightly higher than I anticipated based on what I thought the condition was. I would definitely recommend to ... Read more

The process was easy. I did the fully curated option and it took a while, but they made it as convenient as possible for what was required. I think that the grading was fair. I honestly got slightly higher than I anticipated based on what I thought the condition was. I would definitely recommend to anyone who is willing to do the work to sell just top tier cards.

For something like Card Conduit to exist, there needs to be a level of trust. Not only are there expensive physical objects involved, but their condition, which is subjective, greatly affects the value. There are also fees involved, so just piling up all your cards to ship to them is not advisable ... Read more

For something like Card Conduit to exist, there needs to be a level of trust. Not only are there expensive physical objects involved, but their condition, which is subjective, greatly affects the value. There are also fees involved, so just piling up all your cards to ship to them is not advisable. Knowing all this up front, I still tried the service for about 2100 cards.

I sent my shipment in on a Friday and they received it the following Tuesday. Note that the shipments arrive at a postal service center that they have to pick up. Their clock doesn't start until they receive the shipment. So I am starting the timeframe from then.

Their process of sorting, grading, and valuing took until the following Wednesday (so 8 days). But give leeway for the Thanksgiving holiday. They send ACH payments over the weekend. I received my payout, in full, the following Tuesday. From start to money received it took 14 days.

The valuation of the cards made sense. Not what I hoped. But made sense. I do crazy things with Magic the Gathering. Namely playing with the cards. I know. Insane. Thus some of the cards came under mostly played and a few were valued as damaged. They explained why they were graded as such. And it was fair. You need to be realistic with your collection. Not everything will be near-mint.

I am a big proponent of good constant communication. Especially with a process like this that handles large dollar transactions. Card Conduit has some of the best communication I have ever seen. The dashboard follows the process step by step. It gives accurate estimates and the end reports are detailed and informative. I especially like the little touch of giving the top number of cards by artist. On the customer support side, I reached out with some questions. No issues. Just questions. They responded very quickly with good answers.

This service is very good, especially if you use the Curated version. Send what you want, and get money back in no time. I agreed with ALL the grades they gave my cards, and they were transparent through the whole process. I'd highly recommend this service if you're looking to clear some space in your binder!

This service is very good, especially if you use the Curated version. Send what you want, and get money back in no time. I agreed with ALL the grades they gave my cards, and they were transparent through the whole process. I'd highly recommend this service if you're looking to clear some space in your binder!

What can I say that I didn't say last review. I will always sell my cards through Card Conduit. The whole process is amazing and extremely transparent. Love this service!

What can I say that I didn't say last review. I will always sell my cards through Card Conduit. The whole process is amazing and extremely transparent. Love this service!

This is what a buylist should be! I have not had such a seamless and profitable experience selling my cards to Card Conduit was. I cannot imagine ever going anywhere else at this point. Great prices, fair grading, and unbelievable customer service and interaction along the way.

This is what a buylist should be! I have not had such a seamless and profitable experience selling my cards to Card Conduit was. I cannot imagine ever going anywhere else at this point. Great prices, fair grading, and unbelievable customer service and interaction along the way.

This was my fourth shipment to liquidate my collection. The service is fast, fair, and always on time or early. Updates are given the moment they need to address something.

This was my fourth shipment to liquidate my collection. The service is fast, fair, and always on time or early. Updates are given the moment they need to address something.

It was very easy, I did not have to do anything but send initial information and payment method. I always felt like I could contact Card Conduit and overall did not have to do much at all.

It was very easy, I did not have to do anything but send initial information and payment method. I always felt like I could contact Card Conduit and overall did not have to do much at all.

Managed to get help selling bulk as well as high priced cards. Selling higher priced cards I managed to get them sold without much effort, just packaging, sending, and they did the rest with multiple payment options, if you have time to sort or not they have either option available, very helpful an ... Read more

Managed to get help selling bulk as well as high priced cards. Selling higher priced cards I managed to get them sold without much effort, just packaging, sending, and they did the rest with multiple payment options, if you have time to sort or not they have either option available, very helpful and friendly responses with the option to consider final payment price, I will definitely use them again if I come across cards to sell, and yes I am a real customer and made a substantial amount selling both bulk and high priced cards.

The process of getting my shipment set up and sent was super easy, and I got a great price for cards that were otherwise sitting in a closet. Absolutely recommend to anyone wanting their cards gone but not going to waste!

The process of getting my shipment set up and sent was super easy, and I got a great price for cards that were otherwise sitting in a closet. Absolutely recommend to anyone wanting their cards gone but not going to waste!

This was my 1st time selling bulk and Card Conduit made it so easy! I especially loved the Stat breakdown they provide once all is sorted and graded. This was a great experience and I will do it again next time I need to make space.

This was my 1st time selling bulk and Card Conduit made it so easy! I especially loved the Stat breakdown they provide once all is sorted and graded. This was a great experience and I will do it again next time I need to make space.

I first heard of Card Conduit from Playing with Power and I thought why not try it out it to get rid of alot of my bulk stuff. Plus they were able to help me get rid some of the stuff in my trade binder that has been sitting there for a while.

I first heard of Card Conduit from Playing with Power and I thought why not try it out it to get rid of alot of my bulk stuff. Plus they were able to help me get rid some of the stuff in my trade binder that has been sitting there for a while.

Thank you guys so much on doing this for me. You guys were awesome and would definitely use your services again.

Thank you guys so much on doing this for me. You guys were awesome and would definitely use your services again.

Process was as easy as running to the post office. Support reached out (an actual human!) to keep me updated on the process at all times. They even went as far to upgrade my order type to cut down significantly on processing fees because it my order matched that tier. They went above and beyond to get me the most money back.

Process was as easy as running to the post office. Support reached out (an actual human!) to keep me updated on the process at all times. They even went as far to upgrade my order type to cut down significantly on processing fees because it my order matched that tier. They went above and beyond to get me the most money back.

I cannot compare the value proposition of CC versus an alternative, as this was my first experience selling off a chunk of my collection. I will say that I looked at buylisting through Card Kingdom, and that the estimated card valuations were functionally equivalent, but the interface for CC was way ... Read more

I cannot compare the value proposition of CC versus an alternative, as this was my first experience selling off a chunk of my collection. I will say that I looked at buylisting through Card Kingdom, and that the estimated card valuations were functionally equivalent, but the interface for CC was way less hassle. I used DelverLens to scan and inventory my collection then exporting to CSV, which worked well. I did attempt to organize my shipment to cull out bulk beforehand based on DelverLens pricing pulled from TCGPlayer, but found that several hundred cards were classed as bulk by CC's metrics. Finding, removing, then re-sorting the cards was a huge pain, so I ended up just opting to pay the 10% fee. That's the one area that I think CC could really stand to improve on. That, and making the CSV field reqs for export easier to find on the website. Those were minor gripes, though. Communication was excellent. Transparency was great. Expectations were met or exceeded at every step. I will absolutely use the service again.

Very simple process that allows for complete peace of mind; I'll continue to use this service.

Very simple process that allows for complete peace of mind; I'll continue to use this service.