Customer Reviews
of our Magic collection selling service
(5634)
Adam
Review left Jan 25 2023
Review
Easy process on my end, just sent in a bunch of random cards I had.
Can tell from the report my next batch I should go through them all with a scanner to prevent sending “junk” cards.
Can tell from the report my next batch I should go through them all with a scanner to prevent sending “junk” cards.
Easy process on my end, just sent in a bunch of random cards I had.
Can tell from the report my next batch I should go through them all with a scanner to prevent sending “junk” cards.
Can tell from the report my next batch I should go through them all with a scanner to prevent sending “junk” cards.
Cyrus
Review left Jan 24 2023
Shipment processed Dec 27 2022
$304.21
payout, $5.58
fees
Review
Process was solid and easy enough - payout was fair! Could be a bit faster in processing.
Process was solid and easy enough - payout was fair! Could be a bit faster in processing.
Justin
Review left Jan 24 2023
Shipment processed Jan 21 2023
$1,622.11
payout, $85.37
fees
Review
It was as simple as could be and I received about what I expected, actually a little more. Of all the options to sell your cards this is the best value for the amount of time it takes.
It was as simple as could be and I received about what I expected, actually a little more. Of all the options to sell your cards this is the best value for the amount of time it takes.
Douglas Fitzpatrick
Review left Jan 24 2023
Shipment processed Jan 13 2023
$1,268.32
payout, $66.75
fees
Review
The process was very easy to follow and understand. My cards were sitting in boxes for twenty years collecting dust and I saw an ad for Card conduit and was like wow what a great business model. I was a bit skeptical at first but let me assure you it's the real deal. I sorted through my cards use
...
Read more
The process was very easy to follow and understand. My cards were sitting in boxes for twenty years collecting dust and I saw an ad for Card conduit and was like wow what a great business model. I was a bit skeptical at first but let me assure you it's the real deal. I sorted through my cards used their price check tool and mailed my cards. Payment was prompt and fair. I will highly recommend Card Conduit to all my old Magic friends. Thank You Card Conduit
Makael Bishop
Review left Jan 24 2023
Review
It's always fast and easy to use CardConduit, and I'll keep using it whenever I have cards i don't play anymore.
It's always fast and easy to use CardConduit, and I'll keep using it whenever I have cards i don't play anymore.
W.H.
Review left Jan 23 2023
Review
It was a pretty straightforward and easy process. I entered a CSV file of my deckbox and it churned out a list of cards that they'd accept and I sorted them to mail the next day. The only I was nervous about was that the buylist prices would fluctuate so the payout amount would change during transit
...
Read more
It was a pretty straightforward and easy process. I entered a CSV file of my deckbox and it churned out a list of cards that they'd accept and I sorted them to mail the next day. The only I was nervous about was that the buylist prices would fluctuate so the payout amount would change during transit until it's processed. Once processed, I got my payment pretty quickly. Overall I would recommend to a friend.
Andy Ni
Review left Jan 23 2023
Shipment processed Jan 11 2023
Review
No sorting needed, just ship! Card Conduit paid out fairly and the reports are always interesting to read
No sorting needed, just ship! Card Conduit paid out fairly and the reports are always interesting to read
Omar A
Review left Jan 23 2023
Review
I will definitely Use their services again. It’s much better than individually selling cards. Thank you
I will definitely Use their services again. It’s much better than individually selling cards. Thank you
Jesse J.
Review left Jan 23 2023
Review
Pleasantly surprised that the process was as easy as they described it, there was clear communication the entire time and it didn't take long! Next time I'll definitely use the more do-it-yourself options but not having to sort, scan, or upload inventory lists was very much worth it. Thanks to the team at CardConduit!
Pleasantly surprised that the process was as easy as they described it, there was clear communication the entire time and it didn't take long! Next time I'll definitely use the more do-it-yourself options but not having to sort, scan, or upload inventory lists was very much worth it. Thanks to the team at CardConduit!
Daniel
Review left Jan 23 2023
Review
I've done four shipments to Card Conduit so far. I compared what they were paying out with some other online vendors, and the curated service gave me the best money for my time.
I've also done the bulk sort, for a few thousand cards that I didn't have the time to go through, and was pleasantly surprised.
I've also done the bulk sort, for a few thousand cards that I didn't have the time to go through, and was pleasantly surprised.
I've done four shipments to Card Conduit so far. I compared what they were paying out with some other online vendors, and the curated service gave me the best money for my time.
I've also done the bulk sort, for a few thousand cards that I didn't have the time to go through, and was pleasantly surprised.
I've also done the bulk sort, for a few thousand cards that I didn't have the time to go through, and was pleasantly surprised.
Tim S
Review left Jan 22 2023
Shipment processed Jan 11 2023
$45.65
payout, No
fees
*Fees were waived during a special promotion.
Review
I recently sent them a bunch of cards, and the process could not have been easier. They were fast, great communicators, and gave me what the cards were worth. I’ve now sent two more orders to them and will continue as long as I’m finding magic cards in my closet, this is such an improved way to get rid of unneeded cards, eBay is gone forever!
I recently sent them a bunch of cards, and the process could not have been easier. They were fast, great communicators, and gave me what the cards were worth. I’ve now sent two more orders to them and will continue as long as I’m finding magic cards in my closet, this is such an improved way to get rid of unneeded cards, eBay is gone forever!
James Gray
Review left Jan 20 2023
Shipment processed Jan 09 2023
Review
They have a wide range of cards on their buylist, and they gave me a higher amount than any other online card shop/marketplace. They were transparent on fees, condition of cards, and dollar amount of each individual card.
They have a wide range of cards on their buylist, and they gave me a higher amount than any other online card shop/marketplace. They were transparent on fees, condition of cards, and dollar amount of each individual card.
Joe
Review left Jan 20 2023
Shipment processed Dec 27 2022
Review
The selling of my magic cards went smoothly and quickly. As always Card Conduit offers the best selling value and experience!
The selling of my magic cards went smoothly and quickly. As always Card Conduit offers the best selling value and experience!
WC
Review left Jan 19 2023
Review
Easiest way to get liquid on cards you'd spend an eternity buylisting or selling on ebay. Thank goodness for card conduit
Easiest way to get liquid on cards you'd spend an eternity buylisting or selling on ebay. Thank goodness for card conduit
Daniel
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
This was by far the easiest time I’ve had selling cards online and the amount ended up being a lot more than I expected, compared to other services I had used before.
This was by far the easiest time I’ve had selling cards online and the amount ended up being a lot more than I expected, compared to other services I had used before.
Anthony Gilman
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
This is my second time using card conduit and I can honestly say that they do a great job, I get a very good amount of cash value out of my cards from them (twice what my LGS was willing to give me) and I can only hope that everyone uses their service to support a great company!
This is my second time using card conduit and I can honestly say that they do a great job, I get a very good amount of cash value out of my cards from them (twice what my LGS was willing to give me) and I can only hope that everyone uses their service to support a great company!
Michael
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
Wanted to sell some of my cards for a big city trip and this was such a good way to do it. Super easy and awesome, they gave great instructions on how to pack my cards and even upgraded me to curated list cause of the quality of my cards.
Wanted to sell some of my cards for a big city trip and this was such a good way to do it. Super easy and awesome, they gave great instructions on how to pack my cards and even upgraded me to curated list cause of the quality of my cards.
Corben Decker
Review left Jan 18 2023
Shipment processed Jan 07 2023
Review
The process worked well despite the holiday breaking things up a bit. Most of the big value cards were assessed well. Some of the medium to lower values weren't great but the sorting is a service they provide.
The process worked well despite the holiday breaking things up a bit. Most of the big value cards were assessed well. Some of the medium to lower values weren't great but the sorting is a service they provide.
Jake Golan
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
3 standout points about my experience and @Nick Anderson:
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the ... Read more
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the ... Read more
3 standout points about my experience and @Nick Anderson:
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the report and personal email from Nick detailed where I gained value or lost value. Also pointing out a counterfeit card that was sold to me.
3. Simple and easy, people could look at their collection and claim, "I could make another 100 or 1000 dollars" without realizing the horrors of selling cards like scammers, haggling, and keeping pace of prices. With the headache of shipping cards. This will be the better solution in the long run for anyone with a collection larger than 500 cards to sell.
1. My collection average was above 5 dollars and they converted me to the higher tier for less fees. I didn't read the fee's and the requirements so that was a pleasant surprise that they didn't need to do.
2. Well communicative, both the report and personal email from Nick detailed where I gained value or lost value. Also pointing out a counterfeit card that was sold to me.
3. Simple and easy, people could look at their collection and claim, "I could make another 100 or 1000 dollars" without realizing the horrors of selling cards like scammers, haggling, and keeping pace of prices. With the headache of shipping cards. This will be the better solution in the long run for anyone with a collection larger than 500 cards to sell.
Tovah Donahue
Review left Jan 18 2023
Review
I had a very good experience with there team very good communication on there part and very helpful with everything.
I had a very good experience with there team very good communication on there part and very helpful with everything.
We launched our reviews feature in January 2021, and invited every
previous customer to leave a review.
Reviewers have the option to omit their payout/fee amounts and shipment highlights page.
We publish all reviews, unedited, but may post a response in certain cases. We may need to remove a
review if it's offensive (profanity, etc).